AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
GAGAS Findings: What Must the Yellow Book Report Include?
GAGAS findings include significant deficiencies, material weaknesses, and reportable fraud or noncompliance, even without a material financial statement misstatement. Sort alternative grant-payment issues from one agency's financial audit, with no restrictions on public reporting.
Try one first
Hint
Identify which items meet GAGAS thresholds for inclusion in the written report: internal-control items classified as significant deficiency/material weakness, and material instances of noncompliance.
Answer D. Under GAGAS, the written report on internal control and compliance must include internal-control deficiencies that rise to the level of significant deficiencies or material weaknesses and material instances of noncompliance. Here, only the internal-control item is a significant deficiency; the other control deficiency is less severe and the instance of noncompliance is explicitly nonmaterial, so neither meets the GAGAS thresholds for inclusion in the written report (they may, however, be communicated in writing outside the report).
Why not A: This choice may attract candidates who mistakenly believe GAGAS requires reporting every finding in the written report. It is incorrect because GAGAS sets thresholds for inclusion: only significant deficiencies/material weaknesses and material instances of noncompliance must be included; nonmaterial matters should be communicated outside the written report.
Why not B: This is tempting because auditors must communicate control deficiencies in writing, which can lead to thinking all such deficiencies belong in the GAGAS report. It is wrong because GAGAS requires inclusion in the written report only for significant deficiencies or material weaknesses; less severe deficiencies are typically communicated separately (e.g., to management) and are not required in the GAGAS report.
Why not C: This distractor tempts by treating any identified noncompliance as reportable. It fails because GAGAS requires reporting only material instances of noncompliance; the stem specifies the noncompliance is isolated and not material to the financial statements or audit objectives, so it does not meet the 'material instance' threshold.
Sort it
A significant deficiency, material weakness, or reportable fraud or noncompliance meets applicable criteria, including financial statement effects, other significant financial data, significance to audit objectives, and other reporting requirements.
A lesser control deficiency, or noncompliance meeting no report-inclusion criterion; separate communication may still be required.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| A grant-payment approval control is classified as a significant deficiency, not a material weakness. | Required as a GAGAS report findingSignificant deficiencies are reportable. The control problem does not have to reach material-weakness severity. |
| A grant-payment violation causes no material financial statement misstatement, but the auditor concludes it is significant to the audit objectives and warrants reporting. | Required as a GAGAS report findingThe absence of a material financial statement misstatement does not eliminate reporting when the violation meets applicable reporting criteria. |
| A grant-payment filing violation is clearly inconsequential and meets no other reporting requirement. | Not required as a GAGAS report findingNot every grant-agreement violation belongs in the GAGAS report. |
| Missing grant-payment approvals create a material weakness, although the financial statement opinion is unmodified. | Required as a GAGAS report findingA material weakness is reportable regardless of whether the financial statement opinion is unmodified. |
| Management corrects an accounting error in a grant payment; no material misstatement, significant deficiency, or reportable noncompliance remains. | Not required as a GAGAS report findingA corrected error alone is not a required finding when no reportable control or compliance issue remains. |
| A grant-payment violation materially affects financial data significant to the audit objectives, even without a material financial statement misstatement. | Required as a GAGAS report findingThe reporting criteria address material effects on other financial data significant to the audit objectives, not just financial statement misstatements. |
| Governance receives a copy of a management notice about a clearly inconsequential grant-payment violation; no broader reporting requirement applies. | Not required as a GAGAS report findingCopying governance does not turn a clearly inconsequential violation into a required finding. |
| A grant-payment control deficiency merits management attention but is not important enough to merit governance attention; it is less severe than a significant deficiency. | Not required as a GAGAS report findingThe deficiency is below the significant-deficiency threshold and does not otherwise meet GAGAS reporting criteria. |
| A grant-payment violation has a material financial statement effect, but its details appear only in a private management letter. | Required as a GAGAS report findingA private letter cannot replace report inclusion. Use the GAGAS report or a referenced auditor-issued report or schedule. |
| Management cures a grant-payment violation before report issuance, but the auditor concludes the violation still warrants inclusion under the reporting criteria. | Required as a GAGAS report findingCorrection does not erase a violation that still meets the reporting criteria. |
| An isolated late grant-payment filing has no financial statement effect, is insignificant to audit objectives, and meets no other reporting requirement. | Not required as a GAGAS report findingThis violation meets none of the applicable report-inclusion criteria, although separate communication may be appropriate. |
| Grant-payment fraud has a material effect on the financial statements. | Required as a GAGAS report findingFraud with a material financial statement effect crosses the reporting threshold. |
Key points
- Remember: Required GAGAS findings can exist without a material financial statement misstatement.
- An unmodified financial statement opinion does not erase a reportable control or compliance matter.
- A private governance letter does not replace a required report finding.
- Correcting a violation before report issuance does not automatically remove its reporting requirement.
How the exam traps you
- Omitting a significant deficiency because no material weakness exists. Report both severity levels; a significant deficiency already crosses the control-reporting threshold.
- Treating no material misstatement as no reportable noncompliance. Evaluate all applicable reporting criteria, including significance to audit objectives; financial statement misstatement is not the only test.
- Putting required findings only in a private management letter. Include them in the GAGAS report or an auditor-issued report or schedule referenced by it.
Question 2
Hint
First decide which findings meet the GAGAS reporting threshold (significant deficiencies and matters warranting governance attention); then determine what the Yellow Book report must describe and what it expressly does not opine on.
Answer B. When an audit is performed under GAGAS, the auditor issues the financial‑statement report and also issues a GAGAS (Yellow Book) report describing the scope and results of internal‑control and compliance testing; that GAGAS report typically does not express an opinion on internal control or on compliance. Under GAGAS, significant deficiencies and other matters the auditor judges to warrant the attention of those charged with governance (including certain noncompliance even if corrected before issuance) must be reported; clearly inconsequential matters need not be reported. Details may be included in the GAGAS report or provided by reference to an auditor‑issued schedule accompanying the report.
Why not A: Tempting because the financial‑statement opinion is unmodified and the issues are not material to the opinion, but incorrect because audits performed under GAGAS require a separate Yellow Book report that describes the scope and results of internal‑control and compliance testing and reports significant deficiencies and other matters that warrant governance attention.
Why not C: This distractor is appealing if one focuses solely on the financial‑statement opinion, but it is wrong because GAGAS requires reporting of matters that the auditor concludes warrant the attention of those charged with governance; a noncompliance corrected before issuance may still be reportable if the auditor so concludes.
Why not D: Some matters are appropriately communicated to management confidentially, but under GAGAS significant deficiencies and matters warranting governance attention generally must be reported in the GAGAS report (or by reference to an auditor‑issued schedule accompanying that report), not solely in a confidential management letter.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the auditor's GAGAS reporting duties about identified control or compliance findings from the decision to modify the financial statement opinion.
Answer D. Under Government Auditing Standards, auditors performing a financial statement audit must report findings on internal control and compliance matters discovered during the audit even when not engaged to opine on those matters. A significant deficiency is reportable; the GAGAS report should describe the scope and results of testing and explicitly state that no opinion on internal control or compliance is being expressed unless the auditor was engaged to provide one. Therefore the auditor issues the financial statement opinion and a separate or combined GAGAS report that discloses the significant deficiency and the scope of testing.
Why not A: This is tempting because internal control deficiencies reflect control weaknesses, and control issues can affect opinion decisions. It is incorrect because a significant deficiency alone, without a material weakness, a financial statement misstatement, or inability to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence, does not require modifying the financial statement opinion.
Why not B: This is tempting because under GAAS modifications to the financial statement opinion are typically driven by material weaknesses or material misstatements. It is incorrect because GAGAS imposes a separate reporting responsibility to disclose significant deficiencies and to report the scope and results of testing even when no material weakness or material noncompliance exists.
Why not C: This distractor tempts by treating the absence of material findings as a basis for positive assurance. It fails because GAGAS does not permit the auditor to give positive assurance that internal control was effective or that the entity complied with laws unless specifically engaged to provide such opinions; the auditor reports findings and the scope and results of testing instead.
Question 4
Hint
Under the 2018 Yellow Book, reportable findings are limited to fraud, material noncompliance with laws, regulations, contracts, or grant agreements, significant deficiencies, and material weaknesses. Abuse and waste are only possible indicators of those matters, not findings themselves.
Answer A. Under the 2018 Yellow Book, the findings that must be included in the auditor's written GAGAS report on internal control over financial reporting and on compliance and other matters are significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in internal control, instances of fraud, and instances of noncompliance with provisions of laws, regulations, contracts, or grant agreements that have a material effect on the financial statements. Noncompliance with a grant agreement that is material to the financial statements squarely meets this threshold, so it must be reported as a finding. Note an important change from prior guidance: under the 2018 Yellow Book, abuse and waste are no longer reportable findings in their own right. The auditor considers waste and abuse only as possible indicators of fraud, noncompliance, or internal control deficiencies; they are not themselves required report contents.
Why not B: This is tempting because auditors should communicate control weaknesses to management, but the written GAGAS report includes only significant deficiencies and material weaknesses. A lesser deficiency that does not rise to that level is instead communicated in writing to officials of the audited entity and need not be included as a GAGAS finding.
Why not C: Grant-compliance deviations can trigger reporting under Single Audit requirements, but the stem excludes a Single Audit. In a non-Single-Audit GAGAS financial audit, a deviation that is inconsequential and has no material effect on the financial statements does not meet the threshold for a written GAGAS finding.
Why not D: This option is tempting because a GAAP departure was identified, but if management corrected it before the report date and no material misstatement, significant deficiency, or reportable noncompliance remains, there is no remaining matter that meets the GAGAS threshold for inclusion as a finding in the written report.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the internal-control reporting threshold from the compliance reporting threshold, and pay attention to the stated materiality of the grant-agreement violation.
Answer C. Under Government Auditing Standards for a financial statement audit, auditors report significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in internal control over financial reporting. Instances of noncompliance (including violations of contracts or grant agreements) are reported in the GAS report only if they are material to the financial statements. Because the grant-agreement violation is stated to be not material to the financial statements, it need not be included in the GAS report, though separate communication could be appropriate.
Why not A: This applies the compliance threshold correctly but misstates internal-control reporting: GAS requires reporting of significant deficiencies as well as material weaknesses, so the identified significant deficiency should not be excluded.
Why not B: This is tempting because GAS requires broader reporting than a plain GAAS-only audit, but GAS ties reporting of noncompliance to materiality for financial-audit reporting. Not every instance of noncompliance must be included in the GAS report; immaterial violations need not be reported there.
Why not D: This reverses the correct treatment. Significant deficiencies are reportable under GAS internal-control reporting, whereas an immaterial compliance violation need not be included in the GAS report if it is not material to the financial statements.
Question 6
Hint
Distinguish GAGAS 'reportable noncompliance' (issues that warrant governance attention) from matters that affect financial‑statement materiality, and remember what the auditor should state when not engaged to opine on internal control or compliance.
Answer C. Under GAGAS, when performing a financial audit in accordance with GAGAS the auditor should provide written reporting that describes the scope and results of internal control and compliance testing. The auditor should report material weaknesses and any noncompliance the auditor determines warrants the attention of those charged with governance even if it did not cause a material misstatement. Because the auditor was not engaged to express opinions on internal control or compliance, the written GAGAS report should state that no such opinions are expressed.
Why not A: This option is attractive if one assumes only opinion‑affecting matters go into the written GAGAS report, but GAGAS requires that reportable noncompliance warranting governance attention be included in the written GAGAS reporting rather than solely in a management letter.
Why not B: Tempting because it equates reportability with financial‑statement materiality, but under GAGAS 'reportable noncompliance' includes matters the auditor determines warrant governance attention even if they did not cause a material misstatement.
Why not D: Performing GAGAS procedures and identifying reportable matters does not, by itself, require the auditor to issue opinions on internal control or compliance; whether opinions are given depends on the engagement terms, if not engaged to opine, the report should state no opinion is expressed.
Common questions
What findings must be reported under GAGAS?
Report significant deficiencies, material weaknesses, and reportable fraud or noncompliance. Noncompliance can require reporting without a material financial statement misstatement when it is significant to audit objectives or otherwise meets applicable reporting criteria.
Does communicating a matter to governance determine whether it belongs in the GAGAS report?
Not by itself. Apply the reporting criteria; do not omit a violation that warrants report inclusion merely because it caused no material misstatement or was corrected before issuance.
Does an unmodified opinion mean there are no Yellow Book findings?
No. An unmodified financial statement opinion can accompany a GAGAS report that includes a significant deficiency or reportable noncompliance.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reporting Requirements Under Government Accountability Office Government Auditing Standards, worked step by step.
GAGAS and Uniform Guidance Findings | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reporting Requirements Under Government Accountability Office Government Auditing Standards
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.