AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 9 practice questions
What Goes in the Yellow Book Internal Control and Compliance Report?
A Yellow Book financial statement audit reports internal control and compliance testing scope and results, not opinions on either. Sort report statements for a state agency with no reportable findings and no separate opinion engagements.
Try one first
Hint
Think about what GAGAS adds to a regular GAAS financial statement audit, even when the auditor finds nothing that must be reported as a finding.
Answer A. When a financial statement audit is performed under GAGAS, the auditor must report on internal control over financial reporting and on compliance testing by describing the scope of the work and the results even if no reportable findings exist. GAGAS does not require the auditor to express an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control or on compliance in this type of financial statement audit unless a separate engagement explicitly requires such an opinion.
Why not B: Tempting because GAGAS emphasizes controls, but in a standard GAGAS financial statement audit the auditor reports the scope and results of control testing rather than giving an opinion on control effectiveness unless a specific engagement (e.g., an examination of internal control) calls for an opinion.
Why not C: A common mistake is to think reporting is only needed when findings exist. Under GAGAS the auditor still reports on the compliance work performed and its results, even when no reportable noncompliance was found.
Why not D: Report distribution or use restrictions are not a substitute for the GAGAS requirement to report on the scope and results of internal control and compliance testing. A GAGAS financial audit report is not automatically restricted solely because it includes those additional reporting elements.
Sort it
Include the ICFR and compliance work's purpose, scope, results, and no-opinion statement, whether reporting is combined or separate.
When the Yellow Book report is separate, state that the audit also followed GAGAS and refer to that report.
Reject missing scope or results, omitted reporting, and unsupported opinions on controls or compliance.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Describe the ICFR work performed to plan and perform the agency's financial statement audit. | Yellow Book report contentThe report explains the control work's purpose and scope, not an examination of control effectiveness. |
| State that internal control was effective because no reportable findings were identified. | Incorrect reportingNo findings does not support an opinion on control effectiveness. |
| Refer to the separately issued Yellow Book report. | Financial statement reportSeparate issuance requires a reference from the financial statement report to the Yellow Book report. |
| Describe testing of selected provisions of laws, regulations, contracts, and grant agreements. | Yellow Book report contentThis describes the scope of compliance testing performed for the financial statement audit. |
| Report only compliance results because no ICFR deficiencies were identified. | Incorrect reportingThe required reporting covers both ICFR and compliance, even when neither produces reportable findings. |
| State that no matters requiring reporting were identified. | Yellow Book report contentNo reportable findings is the testing result. It does not eliminate the reporting requirement. |
| State that the financial statement audit was also conducted under GAGAS. | Financial statement reportIdentify the auditing standards followed. This statement alone does not replace the required scope-and-results reporting. |
| Describe testing procedures but omit their results. | Incorrect reportingScope alone is incomplete. The report must also describe the results. |
| State that no opinion is expressed on ICFR or compliance. | Yellow Book report contentThe work supported the financial statement audit and was not designed to support opinions on either matter. |
| Include the required Yellow Book scope-and-results section in a combined financial statement report. | Yellow Book report contentCombining the reports is permitted. The required Yellow Book content remains. |
| State that the agency complied with all applicable requirements because testing found no reportable noncompliance. | Incorrect reportingTesting selected provisions without findings does not support an overall compliance opinion. |
| Report no findings but omit the scope of ICFR and compliance testing. | Incorrect reportingResults alone are incomplete. Readers also need the scope of the work performed. |
Key points
- Remember: No findings is a result to report, not permission to skip the report or express an opinion.
- ICFR means internal control over financial reporting; compliance testing covers selected provisions of laws, regulations, contracts, and grant agreements.
- The required reporting may be combined with the financial statement report or issued separately.
How the exam traps you
- No findings means no Yellow Book reporting. Report testing scope and results even when no reportable findings exist.
- Clean test results prove effective controls and full compliance. Report what testing found; state that no opinion is expressed on ICFR or compliance.
- Naming GAGAS is enough when the reports are separate. The financial statement report must also refer to the separate Yellow Book report.
Question 2
Hint
Keep the financial statement opinion separate from GAGAS's separate reporting requirements on internal control and compliance.
Answer C. When an audit is performed under GAGAS, the auditor issues a GAGAS report on internal control and on compliance that describes the scope of testing and the results and discloses reportable findings (such as a material weakness). That report is required even when the auditor issues an unmodified financial statement opinion; the auditor does not express an opinion on internal control or on compliance unless specifically engaged or required to do so.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often (incorrectly) link extra reporting only to a modified financial statement opinion or to material noncompliance. It is wrong because GAGAS requires a report on internal control and compliance that discloses reportable findings regardless of whether the financial statement opinion is modified.
Why not B: This choice tempts by equating the severity of control deficiencies with the basis for the financial statement opinion. It fails because the financial statement opinion is based on whether the statements are materially misstated; a material weakness without a material misstatement does not, by itself, require modifying the financial statement opinion.
Why not D: This distractor is plausible since auditors must communicate findings to management and governance, but it is incorrect because private communication does not replace the GAGAS-required report that discloses reportable findings when the audit is performed under GAGAS.
Question 3
Hint
Consider what GAGAS requires in addition to the financial statement opinion, what the auditor must describe about control and compliance testing, and whether the auditor should express opinions on those topics.
Answer B. GAGAS requires auditors to report on internal control and on compliance in a financial audit even when there are no reportable findings. That report must describe the scope of the auditor's testing and the results, and it must make clear that the auditor is not expressing an opinion on internal control or on compliance; the GAGAS report may be separate from or combined with the financial statement report.
Why not A: Tempting because under a GAAS-only audit a financial statement opinion might appear sufficient; however, when the audit is performed under GAGAS the auditor has additional reporting obligations to describe the scope and results of testing of internal control and compliance even if nothing reportable was found.
Why not C: Tempting because it emphasizes that no reportable noncompliance was found; however, this distractor omits the GAGAS requirement to describe the scope of the auditor's testing and the results. GAGAS does not require issuing a standalone 'no noncompliance' assurance statement as the sole compliance report.
Why not D: Tempting because internal control testing occurs during audits; however, GAGAS does not call for the auditor to express an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control in a financial audit, the report should describe scope and results and explicitly state that no opinion on internal control is being expressed.
Question 4
Hint
Which event actually triggers GAS reporting: performing the audit under GAS, finding reportable issues, or being subject to a single-audit requirement?
Answer D. Under Government Auditing Standards (Yellow Book), when a financial statement audit is performed under GAS the auditor must issue a written report on internal control and on compliance that describes the scope of testing and the results even if no findings exist. The auditor does not express formal opinions on internal control or compliance in that engagement unless separately engaged to perform examinations and render such opinions.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates often associate extra reporting only with the presence of findings. It is wrong because GAS requires the report whenever the audit is performed under those standards, regardless of whether findings were identified.
Why not B: Tempting because Uniform Guidance single audits have their own reporting rules tied to federal awards. It is wrong because GAS reporting is triggered by conducting the audit under Government Auditing Standards and is independent of whether a single audit is required.
Why not C: Tempting because GAS requires testing and reporting on internal control and compliance matters. It is wrong because GAS does not require the auditor to express formal opinions on those matters unless there is a separate examination engagement to do so.
Question 5
Hint
Distinguish the financial-statement opinion from the separate internal control/compliance reporting requirements under GAGAS.
Answer C. When an audit is performed under Government Auditing Standards, the auditor must report internal control and compliance matters. If those communications are issued in a separate GAGAS report, the financial-statement report should note the audit was also done under GAGAS and refer readers to the separate report. The separate GAGAS report describes scope and findings (including significant deficiencies) but ordinarily does not express an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control or on compliance.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates may equate GAGAS reporting only with material weaknesses or reportable noncompliance, but incorrect because when an audit is performed under GAGAS the auditor must communicate required internal control and compliance matters even if the finding is a significant deficiency; such communications can be issued separately but still must be made and referenced.
Why not B: Tempting because no material weaknesses were identified, but wrong because the GAGAS internal control/compliance report is descriptive of scope and findings and does not permit the auditor to render an overall opinion that internal control was effective or that the entity complied with all requirements.
Why not D: Tempting because internal control problems can affect financial reporting, but incorrect: a significant deficiency alone does not require modification of the financial-statement opinion. GAGAS reporting requirements for internal control are separate from the auditor's financial statement opinion, and disclosure in the notes does not eliminate the auditor's obligation to report the finding under GAGAS.
Question 6
Hint
Identify what specifically triggers a GAGAS report and whether that report is intended to provide positive assurance or to describe scope and results.
Answer D. When an audit is performed under GAGAS, the auditor must issue the additional GAGAS report on internal control and compliance regardless of whether findings exist or a Single Audit is required. That report describes the scope and results of testing and does not give positive assurance, it does not opine that controls were effective or that the entity complied in all respects.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates often link GAGAS reporting to findings or Single Audit triggers. It fails because the obligation to issue the GAGAS report is triggered by conducting the audit under GAGAS itself, not by the presence of findings or the Single Audit threshold.
Why not B: Tempting because people may equate the absence of findings with positive assurance. It fails because the GAGAS report summarizes scope and results but does not provide positive assurance that controls were effective or that compliance was absolute simply because no findings were reported.
Why not C: Tempting because state law can impose additional reporting duties and some statutes may demand stronger opinions. It fails because the baseline GAGAS requirement for the additional report arises from performing the audit under GAGAS, not from a separate state-law mandate to opine on internal control (state law could add requirements but does not replace the GAGAS obligation).
Question 7
Hint
Consider what Yellow Book requires in addition to a GAAS financial statement opinion when the auditor performs procedures on internal control and compliance but does not express an opinion on them.
Answer D. Government Auditing Standards require that a Yellow Book financial statement audit include reporting on internal control and on compliance. When the auditor is not required to, and does not, express an opinion on those matters, the Yellow Book report must describe the scope and results of the work performed and expressly state that no opinion is being expressed. The absence of reportable findings does not eliminate this reporting requirement.
Why not A: This choice may appeal because compliance reporting is often prominent, but it is incorrect: Yellow Book reporting for a financial statement audit addresses both internal control over financial reporting and compliance regardless of whether deficiencies or instances of noncompliance were identified; internal control is not reported only when deficiencies exist.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates may think additional reporting is only needed when there are findings. It is wrong because Yellow Book requires reporting on internal control and compliance as part of a Yellow Book financial statement audit even when no reportable deficiencies or instances of noncompliance are identified; the auditor must describe the procedures and results and clarify that no opinion is expressed.
Why not C: This distractor tempts because the auditor performed procedures and found no problems. It fails because a standard Yellow Book report for a financial statement audit does not provide a separate opinion (positive assurance) on internal control effectiveness or overall compliance unless a law or regulation specifically requires an opinion; instead the report should describe the work performed and the results without expressing an opinion.
Question 8
Hint
Distinguish the auditor's GAAS financial-statement opinion from the separate written reporting duties imposed by GAGAS when the audit is conducted under GAGAS.
Answer D. Because the audit was performed in accordance with GAGAS, the auditor must provide written GAGAS reporting on internal control and compliance matters (which may be combined with or separate from the financial statement report). That written report should describe the scope of testing and communicate in writing significant deficiencies and instances of noncompliance that warrant the attention of those charged with governance, even when they are not material to the financial statements. The auditor should not express an opinion on internal control or compliance unless specifically engaged to do so.
Why not A: Incorrect because GAGAS requires that significant deficiencies identified during a GAGAS audit be communicated in writing and that instances of noncompliance that warrant attention be reported; both items can be included in the required written GAGAS report rather than splitting them or treating significant deficiencies as only private communications.
Why not B: Tempting because the financial statement opinion was unmodified, but under GAGAS the auditor is required to communicate in writing significant deficiencies and instances of noncompliance that warrant attention; oral communication alone does not satisfy the GAGAS reporting requirement when the audit is conducted in accordance with GAGAS.
Why not C: This confuses GAAS opinion mechanics with GAGAS reporting obligations. The auditor should not alter the financial statement opinion to present a compliance opinion unless engaged to do so, and GAGAS requires written reporting of significant deficiencies and certain noncompliance rather than relegating them solely to a management letter.
Question 9
Hint
Ask whether GAGAS reporting is triggered only by findings or whether the standards require reporting on the scope and results of certain testing even when no findings exist.
Answer C. GAGAS requires written reporting on internal control over financial reporting and on compliance in connection with a GAGAS financial statement audit even when no reportable findings exist. The GAGAS report must describe the scope of the testing performed and the results, and ordinarily states that the work was not designed to provide, and does not provide, an opinion on internal control or compliance. If the GAGAS report is issued separately, the auditor's financial statement report should refer to it (reports may also be combined when appropriate).
Why not A: Why tempting: It's a common misconception that GAGAS reporting is triggered only when reportable findings exist. Why wrong: GAGAS requires the auditor to report on the scope and results of internal control and compliance work performed during a GAGAS financial audit regardless of whether reportable matters were identified.
Why not B: Why tempting: Candidates may conflate GAGAS reporting with the financial statement opinion and think any limitation of scope requires modifying the opinion. Why wrong: The need to report on internal control and compliance is addressed through the GAGAS report (which may be combined with the FS report); it does not require modifying the financial statement opinion when no reportable matters exist.
Why not D: Why tempting: This reflects the mistaken view that internal control reporting is findings-driven and can be skipped if no deficiencies exist. Why wrong: GAGAS requires reporting that addresses both internal control and compliance, including scope and results of testing, regardless of whether deficiencies were identified, so omitting internal control reporting is incorrect.
Common questions
Is a Yellow Book internal control and compliance report required if there are no findings?
Yes. In the agency's GAGAS financial statement audit, no findings changes the reported results, not the requirement to report testing scope and results.
Does a Yellow Book report give an opinion on internal control or compliance?
Not in this financial statement audit. The agency's testing supports the financial statement audit; it does not support separate ICFR or compliance opinions.
Can the Yellow Book report be combined with the financial statement report?
Yes. If issued separately, the financial statement report should state that the audit also followed GAGAS and refer to the separate report.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reporting Requirements Under Government Accountability Office Government Auditing Standards, worked step by step.
GAGAS and Uniform Guidance Findings | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reporting Requirements Under Government Accountability Office Government Auditing Standards
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.