AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 7 practice questions
Yellow Book Compliance Reporting Without an Opinion
In a Yellow Book financial statement audit with no separate compliance opinion engagement or requirement, report compliance testing scope and results without an opinion. Below, follow a state agency's testing through the required no-opinion statement.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on what Government Auditing Standards require in a financial statement audit versus what would require a separate compliance audit opinion.
Answer C. Under Government Auditing Standards, when performing a financial statement audit the auditor reports on compliance by describing the scope of compliance testing and reporting the results, but does not issue a separate opinion on compliance unless a compliance audit was performed. The financial statement audit considers compliance only to the extent it affects the financial statements. Therefore the appropriate approach is to describe testing and results, not to express an overall compliance opinion.
Why not A: Tempting because auditors consider compliance when it affects the financial statements, but that consideration in a financial statement audit does not convert the engagement into a compliance audit and does not justify an overall opinion on compliance.
Why not B: Incorrect because GAGAS requires the auditor to report on compliance testing and its results even if no material noncompliance affecting the financial statements was identified; the auditor should not simply omit compliance reporting.
Why not D: A disclaimer is inappropriate here, the auditor simply does not express an opinion on compliance in a financial statement audit and instead reports the scope and results of compliance testing. The lack of exhaustive testing does not lead to a compliance opinion disclaimer in this context.
Step by step
- Check the engagement scope
An auditor audits a state agency's financial statements under GAAS and Government Auditing Standards (GAGAS). The engagement excludes a separate compliance audit, and no separate compliance opinion is required.
- Describe the compliance testing scope
The auditor tested selected provisions of laws, regulations, contracts, and grant agreements that could directly and materially affect the agency's financial statements. Describe that scope; selected testing does not require a qualified compliance opinion.
- Report the testing results
The tests identified no reportable noncompliance. Report that result; it does not establish that the agency complied with every applicable requirement.
- Explicitly state no opinion
State that the tests were not designed to provide an opinion on compliance and that no such opinion is expressed. Issuing this reporting separately does not turn it into a compliance audit or a compliance opinion.
Key points
- Remember: No reportable noncompliance is a test result, not a compliance opinion.
- A separate Yellow Book report does not mean a separate compliance audit was performed.
- Selected compliance tests do not call for a qualified compliance opinion when no compliance opinion is required.
How the exam traps you
- Treating no reportable noncompliance as grounds for an unmodified compliance opinion. Report the testing result and explicitly state that no compliance opinion is expressed.
- Omitting compliance reporting because the tests found no reportable noncompliance. Report the testing scope and results even when there are no reportable findings.
- Expressing a qualified compliance opinion because only selected provisions were tested. Describe the testing scope. Do not modify an opinion the engagement does not require.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the two frameworks: a GAGAS financial statement audit is not the same as a Uniform Guidance single audit.
Answer C. Under Government Auditing Standards (GAGAS) financial audits, the auditor issues a report on internal control and on compliance and other matters that describes the scope and results of compliance testing but does not express an opinion on compliance. Under the Uniform Guidance single-audit, the auditor issues a compliance report that includes an opinion on whether the auditee complied, in all material respects, with applicable requirements for each major federal program (here, the single major program).
Why not A: This is tempting because no reportable findings were identified, but both frameworks require compliance-related reporting even when there are no reportable findings: GAGAS requires a compliance-and-other-matters report, and the Uniform Guidance single audit requires a compliance opinion for each major program.
Why not B: This applies the wrong reporting form in both cases. A GAGAS financial statement audit generally does not include an opinion on overall compliance; the GAGAS report describes testing results. In a single audit the auditor issues an opinion on compliance for major programs rather than merely providing negative assurance.
Why not D: This is incorrect because GAGAS requires a compliance-related report even when no noncompliance is detected, and the schedule of findings and questioned costs in a single audit supplements but does not replace the auditor's compliance opinion on major programs.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the opinion on the financial statements from the additional reporting required under Government Auditing Standards.
Answer A. Because management corrected the misstatement and the auditor obtained sufficient appropriate evidence that the final statements are fairly stated, the financial-statement opinion is unmodified. Government Auditing Standards require separate reporting of findings (such as a material weakness and a reportable noncompliance), but that report describes the results and does not provide an opinion on internal control or on compliance.
Why not B: This is incorrect because a modified financial-statement opinion is driven by whether the issued financial statements are materially misstated. If the misstatement is corrected before issuance and the final statements are fairly stated, a modification of the FS opinion is not required; the violation is reported under Government Auditing Standards instead.
Why not C: Incorrect, correcting the financial statements does not eliminate the auditor's obligation under Government Auditing Standards to report reportable instances of noncompliance or significant internal-control findings when they meet the reporting criteria.
Why not D: Incorrect because Government Auditing Standards reports on the scope and results of tests of internal control and compliance but generally do not express overall opinions that internal control or compliance were effective; they describe findings and their implications instead.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the report tied to the financial statement audit from the report tied to the major-program compliance audit.
Answer C. This separates the two frameworks: a Uniform Guidance compliance audit requires the auditor to express an opinion on compliance for each major program, while reporting under Government Auditing Standards (in connection with a GAAS financial statement audit) typically describes the scope and results of compliance testing and findings but does not include a separate compliance opinion unless another requirement or the audit objectives specifically call for one.
Why not A: Tempting because evidence may overlap, but the reporting requirements differ: Uniform Guidance requires an opinion for the major program, whereas Government Auditing Standards reporting on compliance in a financial statement audit generally describes testing and findings rather than expressing a compliance opinion.
Why not B: This overgeneralizes the Government Auditing Standards approach. It is incorrect because a Uniform Guidance compliance audit includes an opinion on whether the auditee complied, in all material respects, with applicable requirements for the major program.
Why not D: This reverses the correct roles: Government Auditing Standards reporting ordinarily does not include a compliance opinion unless required, while the Uniform Guidance compliance report includes an opinion on program compliance (and also reports on internal control over compliance where applicable), not in place of the compliance opinion.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what a Government Auditing Standards financial statement audit report does when the auditor was not engaged to opine separately on compliance.
Answer D. When performing a financial statement audit under Government Auditing Standards (the Yellow Book) and the auditor was not engaged to render a separate compliance opinion, the auditor issues the required Government Auditing Standards report describing the scope of compliance testing and the results but does not express an opinion on compliance. If no material instances of noncompliance are identified, the report may state that the tests disclosed no material instances, yet it still stops short of a separate compliance opinion.
Why not A: Incorrect and procedurally misleading: a management certification is not the condition that controls whether the financial statement opinion must be qualified. Compliance reporting under Government Auditing Standards is separate from the financial statement opinion and does not automatically require a qualification in this scenario.
Why not B: Tempting because no findings were identified, but incorrect: unless specifically engaged to opine on compliance, the auditor reports the scope and results of compliance testing under Government Auditing Standards rather than issuing a formal compliance opinion.
Why not C: This relies on the mistaken belief that the financial statement opinion covers legal compliance. Government Auditing Standards require a separate report on compliance and other matters in a Yellow Book engagement, even when no material noncompliance is found.
Question 6
Hint
Remember this is not a Single Audit; decide whether GAGAS requires a compliance opinion or a scope-and-results style report in a GAGAS financial-statement audit.
Answer C. Under GAGAS, a financial-statement audit performed in accordance with Government Auditing Standards requires the auditor to issue a report on internal control and on compliance that describes the scope of compliance testing and reports the results. That GAGAS report summarizes testing and findings (or the absence of reportable noncompliance) but is not an opinion on compliance in the context of a GAGAS financial-statement audit; an opinion on compliance is issued only in a compliance audit (for example, a Single Audit under Uniform Guidance).
Why not A: Tempting because the absence of findings might seem to eliminate further reporting. Incorrect because GAGAS requires the auditor to report the scope of compliance testing and the results even when no reportable noncompliance is identified; omission would fail to satisfy GAGAS reporting requirements.
Why not B: Tempting because a Single Audit (a compliance audit under Uniform Guidance) results in compliance opinions for major programs, so candidates may conflate that requirement with GAGAS. Incorrect because a GAGAS financial-statement audit does not include a separate opinion that the entity complied in all material respects; GAGAS instead requires the scope-and-results style report described in A.
Why not D: Tempting because appending a paragraph to the financial-statement report seems efficient. Incorrect because simply adding a paragraph would omit the required GAGAS description of the scope and results of compliance testing and could misleadingly present a compliance assertion as an opinion; GAGAS reporting requires the scope-and-results report format.
Question 7
Hint
First decide which reporting framework is actually triggered by the facts, and then ask whether that framework calls for an opinion on compliance or only a report on testing and results.
Answer B. Because the engagement is a financial statement audit performed under Government Auditing Standards, the auditor issues the regular financial statement report and the required GAGAS (Yellow Book) report on internal control and compliance that describes the scope of any testing and the results. The city is below the Uniform Guidance single-audit threshold and no separate compliance audit was requested, so no Uniform Guidance opinion on compliance is required. Under GAGAS the auditor reports findings and test results rather than expressing a separate opinion on internal control or compliance.
Why not A: Tempting because GAGAS requires reporting on compliance-related testing, but GAGAS does not require the auditor to issue a separate opinion on compliance in connection with a financial statement audit; it requires a report describing the scope and results of testing.
Why not C: This confuses a Yellow Book financial-statement audit with a Uniform Guidance single audit. A Uniform Guidance compliance report is required only when the single-audit criteria are met (or another specified compliance audit is engaged), which the stem says is not the case.
Why not D: While being below the single-audit threshold means no Uniform Guidance single audit is required, the audit was performed under Government Auditing Standards, which calls for an additional GAGAS report on internal control and compliance testing in connection with the financial statement audit.
Common questions
Does a Yellow Book financial statement audit include a compliance opinion?
Not when no separate compliance opinion is required or included in the engagement. The auditor describes compliance testing scope and results and explicitly states that no opinion on compliance is expressed.
Is Yellow Book compliance reporting required if there are no findings?
Yes. Report the testing scope and the absence of reportable noncompliance, but do not turn that result into an opinion that the agency complied.
Do selected compliance tests require a qualified opinion?
No. When the engagement does not call for a compliance opinion, the auditor describes the selected tests and states that no opinion on compliance is expressed.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reporting on Compliance, worked step by step.
Single Audit Compliance Findings & Opinions | CPA AUD TBS on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reporting on Compliance
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.