AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 9 practice questions
Single Audit Compliance Opinion Decision Tree
Material but nonpervasive noncompliance or possible effects of missing evidence require a qualified major-program compliance opinion. Follow the decision tree for a county's major program, checking evidence before materiality and pervasiveness.
Try one first
Hint
First decide whether the finding requires a modification to the compliance opinion; if so, distinguish pervasiveness (adverse) from a confined material finding (qualified).
Answer C. Under Uniform Guidance, material noncompliance requires a modification to the compliance opinion. When the noncompliance is material but confined to a single requirement and not pervasive, a qualified opinion is appropriate. An adverse opinion is reserved for material and pervasive noncompliance, and a disclaimer applies only when the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence or is unable to form an opinion.
Why not A: Tempting because the misstatement is confined to one requirement and not pervasive; wrong because once the auditor concludes the noncompliance is material, an unmodified opinion is not appropriate, some form of modification (qualified or adverse) is required.
Why not B: Tempting because the finding is material and therefore requires a modified opinion; wrong because an adverse opinion is appropriate only when the material noncompliance is also pervasive to the program as a whole.
Why not D: Tempting if one confuses the severity of a finding with inability to form an opinion; wrong because a disclaimer is issued only when there is a scope limitation or the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence, here the auditor obtained sufficient evidence of actual material noncompliance.
Decide it in order
T1Harbor County has one major program; eligibility is the only issue and a direct and material requirement. Assume any unresolved eligibility evidence gap has material possible effects. Has the auditor obtained sufficient appropriate evidence, including through alternative procedures?
T2Did testing identify noncompliance that is material to the major program?
YesGo to T3NoExpress an unmodified opinion on compliance for the major program. Evidence is sufficient, and no material noncompliance was identified.T3Are the effects of the identified material noncompliance pervasive to the major program?
YesExpress an adverse opinion on compliance for the major program. Describe the material and pervasive eligibility noncompliance in the basis for the adverse opinion.NoExpress a qualified opinion on compliance for the major program. Describe the material but nonpervasive eligibility noncompliance in the basis for the qualified opinion.T4Are the material possible effects of undetected eligibility noncompliance pervasive to the major program?
YesDisclaim an opinion on compliance for the major program. Describe the scope limitation and its material and pervasive possible effects in the basis for the disclaimer.NoExpress a qualified opinion on compliance for the major program. Describe the scope limitation and its material but nonpervasive possible effects in the basis for the qualified opinion.
Key points
- Remember: Material but nonpervasive problems mean qualified, whether you found noncompliance or could not obtain evidence.
- Known noncompliance concerns actual effects; a scope limitation concerns possible effects of undetected noncompliance.
- Describe the noncompliance or scope limitation in the basis for the modified opinion.
How the exam traps you
- Any material noncompliance means an adverse opinion. Use adverse only when known noncompliance is both material and pervasive to the major program.
- Missing evidence always requires a disclaimer. If possible effects are material but not pervasive, qualify for the scope limitation.
- No proven noncompliance means an unmodified opinion. Insufficient evidence can require qualification or a disclaimer based on the possible effects.
Question 2
Hint
Keep GAGAS reporting separate from Uniform Guidance: which framework requires a compliance opinion, and is that opinion entity-wide or program-level?
Answer D. GAGAS reporting in a financial statement audit generally describes the scope and results of testing of compliance and internal control but does not include a general opinion on compliance or an opinion on internal control absent a separate engagement. The Uniform Guidance (2 CFR Part 200) requires the auditor to express an opinion on compliance for each major federal program and to report on internal control over compliance. Therefore both reports are required and they reach different conclusions.
Why not A: Tempting because GAGAS requires reporting on compliance matters, but incorrect: in a financial statement audit under GAGAS the auditor ordinarily reports the scope and results of testing rather than providing a general compliance opinion. Uniform Guidance, not GAGAS, requires program-level compliance opinions.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates may conflate internal control findings with opinion requirements, but incorrect: the Uniform Guidance requires program-level compliance opinions regardless of whether material weaknesses are identified, and the schedule of findings supplements but does not replace the required opinion.
Why not C: Tempting because both engagements address compliance, but incorrect because the Uniform Guidance specifically requires program-level compliance opinions. A single entity-wide opinion would not satisfy the Uniform Guidance reporting requirements.
Question 3
Hint
Decide for each major program separately whether the issue is material noncompliance (affecting opinion severity if pervasive) or a scope limitation (which can require a disclaimer), and keep the internal-control finding distinct from the compliance-opinion determination
Answer A. Under Uniform Guidance the auditor issues program-specific compliance opinions for each major program. Alpha: sufficient evidence was obtained but the material noncompliance was not pervasive, so a qualified (except for) compliance opinion is appropriate and the material weakness in internal control over compliance must be reported. Beta: the pervasive scope limitation with no possible alternative procedures requires a disclaimer of opinion for that program.
Why not B: Tempting because Alpha has both a material weakness and material noncompliance, which might suggest a more severe opinion. Wrong because an adverse compliance opinion requires noncompliance that is both material and pervasive to the program; Alpha's noncompliance is material but not pervasive, so a qualified opinion, not adverse, is appropriate. A material weakness alone does not automatically produce an adverse compliance opinion.
Why not C: Tempting because Beta's pervasive scope limitation could be (incorrectly) seen as compromising the entire single audit. Wrong because Uniform Guidance requires evaluating each major program separately; a disclaimer for Beta does not force a disclaimer for Alpha when sufficient evidence was obtained for Alpha.
Why not D: Tempting because Alpha's material noncompliance suggests a qualified opinion and one might understate the effect of Beta's scope limitation. Wrong because a pervasive scope limitation with no alternative procedures mandates a disclaimer for the affected program, so Beta should be disclaimed rather than qualified.
Question 4
Hint
First decide whether the issue is known noncompliance or a scope limitation (insufficient evidence). If it is a scope limitation, determine whether the possible effects are pervasive to the program before selecting the opinion.
Answer D. The facts describe a scope limitation (insufficient appropriate audit evidence) concerning a direct and material requirement. Under AU-C 935 and Single Audit guidance (2 CFR 200 Subpart F), when the possible effects of a scope limitation are material but not pervasive to the program, a qualified opinion is appropriate. The identified material weakness must be reported in the internal-control report, but a material weakness by itself does not automatically require an adverse compliance opinion.
Why not A: This is tempting because no proven noncompliance was found, but an unmodified opinion is inappropriate when the auditor lacks sufficient appropriate evidence about a direct-and-material requirement. A material scope limitation requires a modification (qualified) when effects are material but not pervasive.
Why not B: This option is tempting because a material weakness is serious, but compliance opinion modifications depend on the effect on compliance or the extent of scope limitations, not solely on an internal-control conclusion. Here the issue is insufficient evidence (a scope limitation) that is material but not pervasive, so an adverse opinion is too severe.
Why not C: This choice overstates the rule: a disclaimer (or inability to form an opinion) is appropriate only when a scope limitation is so pervasive that the auditor cannot form an opinion on the program as a whole. The stem specifies the possible effects are confined to eligibility and not pervasive, so a disclaimer is not required.
Question 5
Hint
Determine opinions at the program level and distinguish 'material' from 'pervasive'; consider whether after‑period correction changes the need to modify the opinion for the audited period.
Answer D. Under Uniform Guidance the auditor issues program‑level opinions. Material noncompliance that is not pervasive to a major program warrants a qualified opinion for that program; an adverse opinion is appropriate only when the noncompliance is pervasive. Program Y, having no material noncompliance, receives an unmodified opinion. Post‑period corrective action does not negate the obligation to modify the opinion for the period in which the noncompliance occurred.
Why not A: Tempting because post‑year‑end remediation might seem to cure the problem. Incorrect because the auditor's opinion covers the audited period; correction after the period does not remove the requirement to modify the Year 1 opinion for material noncompliance that occurred during that period.
Why not B: Tempting because 'disclaimer' is a known auditor response when opinions cannot be formed. Incorrect because a disclaimer addresses a scope limitation or lack of sufficient evidence; the stem states sufficient appropriate evidence was obtained, so the auditor should issue a qualified opinion rather than disclaiming.
Why not C: Tempting because 'material' can be associated with the most severe modification. Incorrect because an adverse opinion is required only when noncompliance is pervasive to the program as a whole; a nonpervasive material finding calls for a qualified opinion for that program, and other unaffected programs remain unmodified.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the reporting objectives: one report addresses fair presentation of the financial statements, and another addresses compliance for major federal programs.
Answer B. The financial statement opinion addresses whether the financial statements are fairly presented; because the auditor concluded the noncompliance did not cause a material misstatement of the financial statements or the SEFA, the financial statement opinion need not be modified. Under Uniform Guidance the auditor issues an opinion on compliance for each major federal program, and identified material noncompliance in a major program requires a modified compliance opinion for that program. The finding should also be included in the required compliance-related reporting (e.g., findings and questioned costs).
Why not A: Tempting because the noncompliance is serious, but the financial statement opinion is only modified when noncompliance causes a material misstatement (or inadequate disclosure) of the financial statements; the stem states it did not.
Why not C: Reporting the finding is required, but disclosure alone does not remove the need to modify a compliance opinion when material noncompliance exists; the compliance opinion must reflect the auditor's conclusion on the major program.
Why not D: A disclaimer is appropriate when the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence (a scope limitation). Here the auditor identified the noncompliance and obtained sufficient evidence, so the appropriate action is to modify the compliance opinion (qualified or adverse), not to disclaim.
Question 7
Hint
First decide whether the auditor has sufficient appropriate evidence (known violation vs. scope limitation). Then decide whether the noncompliance is pervasive to overall compliance or confined to a specific requirement.
Answer B. When an auditor obtains sufficient appropriate evidence and identifies a known material noncompliance that is confined to a single requirement (not pervasive), AICPA compliance‑audit guidance requires a qualified opinion. Here the noncompliance is material to the procurement requirement but not pervasive to the program, and other requirements were complied with in all material respects, so a qualified opinion is appropriate. An adverse opinion is required only if the noncompliance is both material and pervasive; a disclaimer is for scope limitations or lack of independence.
Why not A: Tempting because the noncompliance did not affect every requirement and other requirements were complied with; however, any known material noncompliance prevents an unmodified opinion. An unmodified opinion is only appropriate when there are no known material instances of noncompliance.
Why not C: Tempting because the noncompliance is material and affected a program requirement; however, an adverse opinion is reserved for material noncompliance that is pervasive to overall compliance. Because this material noncompliance is confined to one requirement, an adverse opinion is not appropriate.
Why not D: Tempting if a candidate confuses inability to isolate effects with a scope limitation, but here the auditor obtained sufficient appropriate evidence and identified a known condition. Disclaimers are issued for scope limitations (insufficient evidence) or lack of independence, not for a known, limited material noncompliance.
Question 8
Hint
Separate the compliance opinion from the internal-control-over-compliance reporting, and focus on whether the noncompliance is material, pervasive, or a scope issue.
Answer B. Under Uniform Guidance, material noncompliance that is material but not pervasive results in a qualified opinion on the affected major program's compliance. Material weaknesses in internal control over compliance must be reported in the auditor's report on internal control over compliance, but the auditor does not express an opinion on internal control over compliance. Because the auditor obtained sufficient evidence and there was no scope limitation, neither a disclaimer nor an adverse compliance opinion is appropriate.
Why not A: Tempting because a material weakness and material noncompliance are serious, but the noncompliance was not pervasive, so a qualified, not adverse, opinion on compliance is appropriate. Additionally, Uniform Guidance requires reporting of control deficiencies rather than expressing an opinion on internal control over compliance.
Why not C: This distractor assumes the auditor should mirror the compliance opinion with a control opinion. Under Uniform Guidance the auditor reports material weaknesses in internal control over compliance but does not issue a qualified opinion on internal control over compliance.
Why not D: Although the noncompliance was confined to a single requirement, the stem states the departure was material to the major program's compliance. Material noncompliance prevents issuance of an unmodified compliance opinion; a qualified opinion is required when the condition is material but not pervasive.
Question 9
Hint
Separate two questions: Is this a known noncompliance (a findings issue) or a lack of evidence (a scope issue)? And is the effect confined to one major program or pervasive across programs?
Answer B. Under Uniform Guidance the auditor issues compliance opinions by major program. Because sufficient appropriate evidence was obtained and the noncompliance for Program A is material but not pervasive to that program, a qualified opinion is appropriate for Program A; Program B, having no material noncompliance, receives an unmodified opinion. The auditor also issues the required report on internal control over compliance describing the matters identified but does not express an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control over compliance.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may think a modification must affect the entire compliance opinion. However, under Uniform Guidance opinions are issued by major program, so a modification for one program does not automatically modify the opinion for other major programs. Also, the auditor provides a required report on internal control over compliance but does not express an opinion on its overall effectiveness.
Why not C: This distractor is tempting because 'material' often suggests the most severe modification. However, an adverse opinion is required only when noncompliance is both material and pervasive to the program; the stem states the noncompliance is not pervasive, so a qualified opinion, not an adverse opinion, is appropriate for Program A.
Why not D: This distractor is tempting because disclaimers relate to inability to form a conclusion. But a disclaimer is appropriate only when there is a scope limitation or the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence. The stem states sufficient appropriate evidence was obtained, so the appropriate response is a qualified opinion for Program A rather than a disclaimer.
Common questions
When is a Single Audit compliance opinion qualified?
Qualify for known noncompliance that is material but not pervasive to the major program. Also qualify when insufficient evidence has possible effects that are material but not pervasive.
Does a scope limitation require an adverse compliance opinion?
No. When possible effects are material, a nonpervasive scope limitation requires a qualified opinion; a pervasive scope limitation requires a disclaimer.
When can a major program receive an unmodified compliance opinion?
When the auditor has sufficient appropriate evidence and identifies no material noncompliance. Apply that conclusion to the major program, not the entity as a whole.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reporting on Compliance, worked step by step.
Single Audit Compliance Findings & Opinions | CPA AUD TBS on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reporting on Compliance
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.