AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
Single Audit: Material Weakness, Unmodified Compliance Opinion
A material weakness alone does not modify a major program's compliance opinion in a Uniform Guidance single audit. Follow Apex University's cash management finding from expanded testing to an unmodified compliance opinion and a separate control finding.
Try one first
Hint
Decide the compliance opinion first (did the auditor obtain sufficient evidence of compliance?), then consider how internal-control deficiencies must be reported under Uniform Guidance.
Answer D. The compliance opinion is based on whether the auditor obtained sufficient appropriate evidence that the entity complied, in all material respects, with applicable requirements. Because the auditor obtained sufficient evidence after expanded testing, an unmodified compliance opinion is appropriate. Under Uniform Guidance the auditor must report material weaknesses in internal control over compliance but does not express an opinion on those controls.
Why not A: Tempting because severe control problems can prevent forming an opinion. It fails here because the stem states the auditor obtained sufficient appropriate evidence and there was no scope limitation; a disclaimer is appropriate only when the auditor cannot obtain sufficient evidence.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates may assume a material weakness automatically requires a modified opinion. It is wrong because a modification is required only if the auditor concludes noncompliance is material or cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence; a material weakness alone does not force a qualified compliance opinion when testing provides sufficient evidence of compliance.
Why not C: Tempting because additional testing that supports compliance might seem to resolve the issue. It is incorrect because internal-control deficiencies (including material weaknesses) are reportable under Uniform Guidance regardless of whether compliance testing supports an unmodified opinion, and the auditor does not simply omit reporting the deficiency.
Step by step
- Separate compliance from controls
In a Uniform Guidance single audit, the auditor expresses an opinion on compliance for each major program. The auditor does not express an opinion on internal control over compliance.
- Identify the control finding
Apex University has one major federal program and a material weakness in cash management controls. The weakness is a reportable control finding, not proof of material noncompliance.
- Evaluate the compliance evidence
After expanding compliance testing, the auditor obtains sufficient appropriate evidence that Apex complied in all material respects. There is no scope limitation.
- Choose the compliance opinion
Issue an unmodified opinion on compliance for Apex's major program. The material weakness alone does not change that conclusion.
- Report the weakness separately
Report Apex's material weakness in the report on internal control over compliance and the Schedule of Findings and Questioned Costs. State that no opinion is expressed on internal control over compliance.
Key points
- Remember: A material weakness is a control finding, not an automatic reason to modify the compliance opinion.
- Expanded testing can support an unmodified compliance opinion without eliminating the control finding.
- The auditor reports on internal control over compliance but does not express an opinion on it.
How the exam traps you
- Qualifying the compliance opinion solely because a material weakness exists. Base the compliance opinion on compliance evidence, not the control finding alone.
- Omitting the weakness because expanded testing supports compliance. Report it in the internal control report and Schedule of Findings and Questioned Costs.
- Giving an adverse opinion on internal control over compliance. State that no opinion is expressed on internal control over compliance.
Question 2
Hint
Distinguish the requirement to report internal-control findings from the conditions that require modifying a compliance opinion; focus on sufficiency of evidence and materiality of questioned costs.
Answer D. Under the Uniform Guidance (2 C.F.R. Part 200, Subpart F), the auditor's compliance opinion is based on whether sufficient appropriate evidence was obtained and whether any noncompliance is material to the program. A material weakness in internal control over compliance must be reported as a finding, but it does not, by itself, require modifying the compliance opinion. Because the auditor expanded testing, obtained sufficient appropriate evidence, and concluded the known and likely questioned costs were not material, an unmodified compliance opinion is supportable.
Why not A: A disclaimer is issued when the auditor is unable to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence to form an opinion; the stem states the auditor expanded procedures and obtained sufficient evidence, so a disclaimer is not supported by the facts.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often equate internal-control severity with an opinion modification; however, a material weakness must be reported as a finding but does not automatically require a qualified opinion, modification is required only when there is material noncompliance or the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not C: An adverse opinion is appropriate only when the auditor concludes that material noncompliance exists; ineffective controls alone do not establish material noncompliance, and here the auditor performed additional procedures and concluded the questioned costs were not material.
Question 3
Hint
Decide separately (1) what facts would require modifying the compliance opinion and (2) where significant internal-control deficiencies must be reported.
Answer A. Under Uniform Guidance the auditor must express an opinion on whether each major program complied, in all material respects, with applicable requirements. A significant deficiency in internal control over compliance must be reported (in the internal-control report and the schedule of findings and questioned costs) but does not by itself require modification of the compliance opinion; modification is required only for identified material noncompliance or when a scope limitation prevents obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence, neither of which exists here.
Why not B: This is tempting because control problems increase risk of noncompliance, but it fails because a significant deficiency alone is not the threshold for modifying the compliance opinion. The compliance opinion is modified only when actual material noncompliance is identified or when a scope limitation denies sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not C: Candidates may conflate serious control deficiencies with an inability to obtain evidence, making a disclaimer seem plausible. It is incorrect here because the facts state there was no scope limitation or inability to obtain evidence, only a significant deficiency, so a disclaimer is not appropriate.
Why not D: This confuses reporting locations: while GAGAS requires reporting on internal control, Uniform Guidance also requires significant deficiencies to be included in the schedule of findings and questioned costs. Omitting the deficiency from the schedule would not meet Uniform Guidance reporting requirements.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the effect of internal control findings from the effect of actual noncompliance, then ask whether any identified noncompliance is limited or pervasive.
Answer C. Compliance opinions are based on whether the auditee complied in all material respects with applicable requirements for each major program. A material weakness in internal control over compliance must be reported separately but does not by itself require a modified compliance opinion if no material noncompliance exists. Program B had actual noncompliance that was material to the program but limited to one requirement, which warrants a qualified opinion (material but not pervasive).
Why not A: This lures candidates who recall that control deficiencies alone don't modify the compliance opinion, but it overlooks that Program B had material noncompliance. An unmodified opinion is inappropriate for Program B when material noncompliance exists.
Why not B: This is attractive if a student treats a material weakness as automatically affecting the compliance opinion and treats any material noncompliance as pervasive. Program A had no material noncompliance, so its compliance opinion remains unmodified. Program B's noncompliance was material but limited, supporting a qualified, not adverse, opinion.
Why not D: This reverses the correct reasoning for Program A: an adverse compliance opinion requires material and pervasive noncompliance affecting the program's compliance as a whole. The facts show only a material weakness in internal control (no material noncompliance) for Program A, so an adverse compliance opinion is not supported.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on whether the auditor obtained sufficient appropriate evidence and whether the identified noncompliance is material to the major program; internal control weaknesses are reported separately from the compliance opinion.
Answer C. The compliance opinion is determined by whether noncompliance is material to the major program and whether the auditor obtained sufficient appropriate evidence. A material weakness in internal control should be reported as a finding but does not, by itself, require a modified compliance opinion. Because the auditor expanded testing, obtained sufficient evidence, and found only isolated, immaterial ineligible disbursements, an unmodified opinion on compliance is appropriate while the material weakness is reported separately.
Why not A: An adverse opinion is appropriate only when noncompliance is material (and, depending on the circumstances, pervasive) to the major program. Isolated, immaterial instances of ineligible disbursements do not meet that threshold.
Why not B: This distractor is tempting because a material weakness sounds significant. However, a qualified opinion is triggered by material noncompliance (or a scope limitation), not solely by a control weakness when the auditor has obtained sufficient appropriate evidence and any noncompliance is immaterial.
Why not D: A disclaimer is required only when the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence to form an opinion. The facts state the auditor expanded testing and obtained sufficient evidence, so a disclaimer is not supported.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the opinion on compliance from the reporting requirement for internal control over compliance, and focus on the audit period rather than later remediation.
Answer D. The compliance opinion addresses whether the entity complied, in all material respects, with the applicable compliance requirements; the stem states the auditor concluded that it did, so an unmodified compliance opinion is appropriate. A material weakness in internal control over compliance that existed during the audit period should still be reported in the auditor's report on internal control over compliance (and in the schedule of findings), even if management began remediation before report issuance. The auditor may, if appropriate, document the corrective actions taken, but that does not eliminate the requirement to report the weakness that existed during the audit period.
Why not A: This is attractive because 'material weakness' sounds severe, but an adverse opinion on compliance requires evidence of material noncompliance. A material weakness in controls alone does not prove that the entity failed to comply in all material respects if the auditor concluded compliance was achieved.
Why not B: Tempting because remediation occurred before the report, but incorrect: the auditor reports conditions that existed during the audit period. Remediation after the period (but before report issuance) does not automatically remove the obligation to report a material weakness that existed during the audit period.
Why not C: This appeals to the mistaken belief that control weaknesses automatically require a modified compliance opinion. It is wrong because a modification of the compliance opinion is based on the existence of material noncompliance, not merely on the existence of a material weakness in controls when the auditor has sufficient evidence of compliance.
Common questions
Does a single audit include an opinion on internal control over compliance?
No. The auditor expresses an opinion on compliance for each major program and separately reports material weaknesses in internal control over compliance.
Where is a material weakness in internal control over compliance reported?
Report it in the report on internal control over compliance and the Schedule of Findings and Questioned Costs. An unmodified compliance opinion does not eliminate this reporting requirement.
Does a material weakness automatically change the compliance opinion?
The material weakness alone does not change the compliance opinion. Evaluate the compliance evidence separately; report the weakness even when that evidence supports an unmodified opinion.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reporting on Compliance, worked step by step.
Single Audit Compliance Findings & Opinions | CPA AUD TBS on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reporting on Compliance
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.