AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 12 practice questions
When Do You Revise Materiality During an Audit?
Revise materiality when new audit information would have changed the original materiality judgment. Below, compare the same audit with changes to earnings, the reason for the decline, and when the auditor learns about it.
Try one first
Hint
Ask what new fact, if known at the beginning, would have changed the auditor's original materiality judgment.
Answer A. Materiality is established during planning but is not fixed for the engagement. If information learned during the audit would have led the auditor to choose a different materiality amount at the outset (for example, a significant decline in expected pretax income), the auditor should revise materiality and adjust planned procedures and the evaluation of misstatements accordingly.
Why not B: This is tempting because students focus on accumulated misstatements as a trigger, but revising materiality is prompted by changes in circumstances or new information, not solely by whether known misstatements have crossed performance materiality.
Why not C: Management's views or agreement are not the deciding factor: materiality is the auditor's professional judgment and the auditor must revise it when audit evidence indicates the original judgment would have been different.
Why not D: This reflects a common shortcut mistake, planning materiality is a starting point, but auditing standards require the auditor to revise materiality if facts learned during the audit would have changed the original judgment.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Ridgeway, a nonissuer, expects $1 million pretax income. The auditor sets overall materiality at $50,000, using 5% of representative pretax earnings. Users focus on recurring earnings. Midway through fieldwork, reliable results show $200,000 pretax income because of an $800,000 recurring operating decline. Pretax earnings remain representative. What should the auditor do?
Answer: Revise overall materiality now to $10,000. Reconsider performance materiality and whether audit procedures remain sufficient.
The recurring earnings decline would have produced a different amount at planning. Using the scenario's unchanged 5% judgment, $200,000 × 5% = $10,000.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Updated pretax income is $1 million rather than $200,000; there is no operating decline.
Answer: Keep overall materiality at $50,000.
Receiving updated results alone does not trigger revision. These results leave the original benchmark and amount appropriate.
Change 2The $800,000 reduction comes from a nonrecurring loss rather than a recurring operating decline.
Answer: Keep overall materiality at $50,000 using normalized recurring pretax earnings of $1 million.
Users still focus on recurring earnings. Adding back the nonrecurring loss leaves the original earnings basis appropriate; reported income alone does not control.
Change 3The auditor learns of the decline near completion, after most substantive testing, but before issuing the report.
Answer: Still revise overall materiality now to $10,000. Reconsider performance materiality and whether additional procedures are needed.
Late timing does not change the trigger. Completed work must be assessed against the revised materiality; additional procedures are not automatically unnecessary.
Key points
- Remember: Ask whether knowing the new facts at planning would have changed your materiality judgment.
- A lower overall materiality requires reconsidering performance materiality and whether audit procedures remain sufficient.
- The scenario's 5% is an assumed judgment, not a percentage required by AU-C 320.
- An unusual loss does not automatically require lower materiality when recurring earnings remain the appropriate basis.
How the exam traps you
- Keeping overall materiality fixed because it was reasonable at planning. Update the judgment when new information would have changed the original determination.
- Waiting until final evaluation because most testing is complete. Revise now and assess whether completed and planned procedures remain sufficient.
- Automatically applying 5% to reported income after a nonrecurring loss. First decide whether reported income still represents the earnings users focus on.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer B. The recurring earnings basis fell to $200,000; 5% gives $10,000.
Why not A: A reasonable planning judgment must change when new information would have changed the original amount.
Why not C: Changing only performance materiality leaves the inappropriate overall amount unchanged.
Why not D: The auditor should respond when the information becomes known.
Question 2
Answer D. The updated results support the same benchmark and amount selected at planning.
Why not A: Updated information does not itself require a lower amount.
Why not B: Nothing here makes the original earnings benchmark inappropriate.
Why not C: The auditor can assess the new information now; no deferral is needed.
Question 3
Answer A. Recurring earnings remain $1 million and reflect the users' unchanged focus.
Why not B: Reported income does not automatically replace a more representative earnings basis.
Why not C: A nonrecurring loss does not eliminate materiality.
Why not D: The amount remains appropriate because of the facts, not because planning materiality is fixed.
Question 4
Answer C. The trigger still applies, and the auditor must reassess the sufficiency of audit procedures.
Why not A: Completed testing does not prevent a required materiality revision.
Why not B: Avoiding additional work is not a basis for retaining inappropriate overall materiality.
Why not D: Additional procedures may be necessary; the auditor cannot rule them out without assessment.
Question 2
Hint
Think about whether the new facts would have led you to a different planning decision on materiality (benchmark or amount), not just whether later events affect sampling results or the posting of adjustments.
Answer B. Overall materiality should be reconsidered when information obtained during the audit indicates that the auditor's planning judgment would have been different, for example, selecting a different benchmark or amount because lenders now dominate users' needs. The change in earnings profile and covenant sensitivity are the type of new facts that could alter the original materiality determination. That detected misstatements remain below performance materiality does not eliminate the need to reassess the planning judgment.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates commonly view accumulated misstatements as the cue to change planning thresholds. However, performance materiality governs tolerable misstatement for audit procedures and the evaluation of detected misstatements; the controlling trigger for revising overall materiality is whether new information would have led to a different planning decision (benchmark or amount), not merely that aggregate misstatements exceed a procedural threshold.
Why not C: Tempting because a now‑riskier revenue cycle seems to raise its importance and might suggest a revenue‑based benchmark. But assessed risk primarily influences account‑level tolerable misstatement and the nature, timing, and extent of procedures; selecting a financial‑statement‑level benchmark depends on users' information needs and overall financial‑statement considerations, not solely on which cycle has the highest risk.
Why not D: Tempting because if management will correct adjustments before issuance, residual misstatements may be eliminated and less likely to mislead users. But management's expectation to record adjustments does not itself change the auditor's original materiality determination; the key question is whether the newly obtained facts would have led the auditor to a different planning judgment.
Question 3
Hint
Ask whether audit materiality is a one-time planning number or something the auditor revisits when key benchmark information changes.
Answer B. Materiality is not fixed at planning; if information obtained during the audit would have led to a different materiality amount initially, the auditor should revise it. A substantially lower benchmark such as pretax income normally reduces materiality, and the auditor must reassess whether the nature, timing, and extent of planned procedures remain appropriate.
Why not A: Tempting because preliminary materiality is based on estimates at planning, but planning judgments must be updated when significant new information arises. Keeping the original amount despite a materially lower benchmark could leave the audit under-responsive.
Why not C: This plays on incorrect intuition about user reliance. In practice, when a benchmark like pretax income decreases significantly, materiality generally decreases rather than increases; lower materiality typically requires more, not less, persuasive evidence.
Why not D: Incorrect because the auditor should revise materiality during fieldwork if new information indicates the original amount is no longer appropriate. Waiting until the end risks insufficient audit procedures in light of the lower threshold.
Question 4
Hint
Decide whether materiality is a fixed planning number or a judgment that may require updating when the expected benchmark changes materially.
Answer B. AU-C 320 indicates materiality is a matter of professional judgment and may be revised when the auditor becomes aware of information during the audit that would have led to a different amount initially. If overall materiality is revised, performance materiality should be reconsidered and the auditor should reassess the planned nature, timing, and extent of further audit procedures.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often focus on whether detected misstatements have crossed an execution threshold. It is wrong because the need to revise materiality depends on new information that would have changed the original judgment about the benchmark, not solely on whether current misstatements exceed the original performance materiality.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the view that performance materiality is the operational number. It fails because performance materiality is derived from overall materiality; if the change in the benchmark would have produced a different overall amount initially, overall materiality must be reconsidered first.
Why not D: This is tempting because final numbers are more certain. It is incorrect because auditing standards require the auditor to revise judgments when they become aware of information during the audit that would have changed the original decision; deferring could mean using inappropriate thresholds while performing further procedures.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what event causes planning materiality to become outdated, not on whether management has accepted adjustments yet.
Answer D. Planning materiality must be reconsidered when the auditor obtains new information that would have affected the original determination. A significant change in the chosen benchmark (income before tax) during fieldwork is a classic trigger; revising materiality may require changing planned procedures and re-evaluating identified misstatements.
Why not A: Incorrect: planning materiality is not fixed for the entire audit. Auditors are required to reconsider and, if appropriate, revise materiality during the audit when circumstances change, rather than waiting until the opinion is formed.
Why not B: Tempting because uncorrected misstatements affect the final evaluation, but the trigger to reconsider planning materiality is new information that makes the original amount inappropriate, not management's refusal to post adjustments.
Why not C: A candidate might think revision depends on a detected misstatement crossing the numeric threshold, but materiality may need revision when the benchmark changes even before any single misstatement exceeds the original amount.
Question 6
Hint
Ask whether the late-arising information would have changed the auditor's original materiality judgment, not merely whether final earnings turned out lower than expected.
Answer D. Auditing standards require the auditor to revise overall materiality only when information obtained during the audit would have caused a different amount to have been determined initially (see AU-C 320). Here, the decline in reported pretax income stems from a separately presented, unusual flood loss and users continue to focus on recurring operating results, so the normalized pretax-income benchmark remains the most relevant basis. Therefore, a downward revision of overall materiality is not required absent evidence that the new information would have changed the auditor's original judgment.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often assume final reported results automatically replace planning benchmarks. It is wrong because standards do not require automatic recalculation from final results; revision is required only if the late information would have produced a different initial materiality judgment.
Why not B: This choice confuses the concept of a lower materiality threshold for a specific class or disclosure with an automatic requirement. A separate lower amount is required only when smaller misstatements in that area could reasonably influence users, which the facts here do not show.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the idea that unusual items are ignored in analysis. It is incorrect because materiality does not categorically exclude unusual items; the auditor must assess whether the unusual item would have changed the original judgment about what is material to users.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on what should happen when new audit information would have changed the original planning judgment.
Answer A. Materiality is a planning judgment but is not fixed for the remainder of the engagement. If the auditor becomes aware of information during the audit that would have led to a different materiality determination at planning, the auditor should promptly revise materiality and reconsider the nature, timing, and extent of further audit procedures. Revising promptly ensures the audit remains appropriately responsive to the changed circumstances.
Why not B: Tempting because materiality is determined at planning, but incorrect because the standard requires the auditor to revise materiality when new information would have affected the original judgment; it is not irrevocably fixed once fieldwork starts.
Why not C: This confuses the timing of misstatement aggregation with the separate duty to update planning judgments. The trigger here is new information that would change the materiality judgment now, so waiting risks performing inappropriate procedures in the interim.
Why not D: Incorrect because the need to revise materiality depends on the auditor's awareness of information that affects the planning judgment, not on whether management has already recorded an entry. The auditor responds to the economic reality and its impact on materiality.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on the standard's revision trigger: ask what new information matters to the auditor's original materiality judgment, not what seems mechanically easiest to recalculate.
Answer B. AU-C 320 (GAAS) requires the auditor to revise materiality for the financial statements as a whole when information obtained during the audit would have led the auditor to a different materiality judgment at planning. A substantial decline in forecast pretax income is precisely the sort of new information that may change the benchmark or amount chosen initially, so the partner should ask whether the original judgment remains appropriate. The standard emphasizes whether the new facts invalidate the planning judgment, not an automatic formulaic recalculation.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often treat materiality as a mechanical formula tied strictly to current-year results. However, GAAS does not mandate an automatic recomputation whenever actual results differ from forecasts; the trigger is whether the new information would have changed the auditor's original materiality decision.
Why not C: This distractor appeals because auditors sometimes normalize earnings for unusual items. But the fact that an item is properly recorded or nonrecurring does not by itself eliminate the need to reconsider materiality, what matters is whether knowledge of the item at planning would have produced a different materiality determination.
Why not D: Candidates may conflate misstatement evaluation with setting materiality. While the aggregate of identified misstatements affects the nature and extent of further work, revising overall materiality can be triggered by newly obtained financial information even before misstatements reach any threshold.
Common questions
When does AU-C 320 require an auditor to revise materiality?
When information learned during the audit would have led to a different initial materiality determination. In Ridgeway's base case, the recurring earnings decline requires a downward revision now.
Does lower actual income always mean lower audit materiality?
No. In the nonrecurring-loss version, normalized recurring earnings remain $1 million and still reflect users' focus, so the original $50,000 remains appropriate.
Can materiality change after most audit testing is complete?
Yes. Late discovery does not remove the revision requirement. The auditor must also reconsider performance materiality and determine whether additional procedures are needed.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Materiality, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: AU-C 320 Materiality, Risk Tiers and Caps on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Materiality
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.