AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 6 practice questions
Audit Materiality: Pretax Income vs. Revenue vs. Assets
Choose the overall materiality benchmark that best reflects users' common information needs, not simply the largest or most stable measure. Below: compare pretax income, revenue, and assets when a one-time charge distorts earnings.
Try one first
Hint
Think about who uses the financial statements and which overall measure would matter most to their decisions when earnings are weak or unstable.
Answer C. Overall materiality should reflect what could reasonably influence the decisions of the financial statement users. The auditor therefore selects a benchmark that best matches the users' common information needs; here, because pretax earnings are small and unstable, measures such as revenue or total assets are likely more appropriate benchmarks than pretax income.
Why not A: Assessed risk affects the nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures, but it is not the primary basis for selecting the overall materiality benchmark, which should reflect users' informational needs.
Why not B: Large balances often attract audit attention, but the largest account balance does not automatically determine the overall materiality benchmark; materiality is driven by what matters to users' decisions.
Why not D: Management's attitude toward adjustments may influence the audit approach but does not govern the auditor's judgment about what is material to users; materiality is an auditor judgment focused on users' decisions.
Side by side
| Pretax income | Revenue | Total assets | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Users' main focus | Annual earnings and income-based covenants | Sales trends and operating scale | Financial position and asset-based measures |
| Strongest fit | Profitable entity with representative earnings | Revenue-focused users when earnings are unrepresentative | Users focused on the balance sheet |
| Effect of a one-time charge | May make reported earnings misleading as a benchmark | May remain representative if revenue is unaffected | Assess whether assets still represent users' focus |
| Northline example | A properly recorded plant-closure charge sharply reduces earnings | Revenue remains stable | Assets remain stable; lenders primarily monitor financial position |
| Best conclusion for Northline | Do not default to depressed reported income | Stability alone does not make revenue the best choice | Best aligned with the stated lender focus |
| Possible alternative to reported income | Normalized earnings, if relevant to users | Revenue, if users emphasize operating scale | Assets, if users emphasize financial position |
| If the charge becomes known after planning | Reconsider whether the original earnings benchmark remains appropriate | Consider revenue only if it better reflects users' needs | Consider assets given Northline's lender focus |
Key points
- Remember: choose the measure users follow, not the measure that produces your preferred materiality amount.
- A properly recorded one-time charge can still make reported earnings a poor benchmark.
- Reassessment does not automatically mean lowering materiality; first reconsider which benchmark represents users' needs.
How the exam traps you
- Always use reported pretax income for a profit-oriented company. Check whether the one-time charge makes reported earnings unrepresentative.
- Choose revenue solely because it is stable. Stability helps, but the benchmark must match users' information needs.
- Keep the original benchmark because it was selected during planning. Reconsider it when new information would have changed the initial determination.
Question 2
Hint
Ask which fact makes current-year pretax income a poor representation of the company's normal financial size.
Answer A. Pretax income is a common benchmark for overall materiality, but it can be misleading when the current-year amount is abnormally low or distorted by a one-time, nonrecurring item. In that circumstance, the auditor should consider a more stable benchmark (for example, revenue or assets) that better represents the entity's normal financial size and the needs of users.
Why not B: Stable revenue and assets support using those measures as alternative benchmarks, but their stability is not itself the reason to avoid pretax income. The key problem is that current-year pretax income is distorted by an unusual loss, so it does not reflect normal operations.
Why not C: Control quality affects audit risk and the nature/timing of procedures, but it does not determine which financial-statement base (income, revenue, or assets) is an appropriate benchmark for overall materiality.
Why not D: A large inventory balance is relevant when designing procedures and setting performance materiality for that account, but it does not by itself make pretax income an inappropriate overall benchmark, an unusual, nonrecurring loss that depresses income does.
Question 3
Hint
Separate (1) whether the change in reported pretax income requires a reassessment of materiality and (2) which benchmark (reported pretax, normalized earnings, covenant measure, etc.) best reflects user needs.
Answer B. AU-C Section 320 requires the auditor to reassess materiality if information obtained during the audit would have led to a different initial determination. The large, disclosed, nonrecurring closing charge substantially changed reported pretax income, so the auditor must reassess materiality. Because the charge is nonrecurring and users focus on covenant- and adjusted-results measures, the auditor should consider a normalized-earnings or other stable benchmark rather than automatically applying 5% to the depressed pretax income.
Why not A: This is tempting because aggregate misstatements are below performance materiality and the charge is properly disclosed, which might suggest no change is needed. It fails because the auditor's obligation to reassess materiality is triggered by new information that would have led to a different planning determination (AU-C 320), not solely by whether current misstatements approach the threshold.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to rote application of the planning formula (apply 5% to final pretax income). It is incorrect because materiality is a matter of professional judgment and a properly disclosed, large nonrecurring item can make reported pretax income a less meaningful benchmark for users; alternative benchmarks (normalized earnings or covenant measures) may be more appropriate.
Why not D: This option is tempting because the facts point to user emphasis on covenants and adjusted results, which could justify a different benchmark. It is wrong because there is no automatic basis to increase materiality; the auditor must reassess and justify the chosen benchmark and level, and the sharp drop in reported pretax income could make smaller misstatements more significant to some users rather than support a higher materiality.
Question 4
Hint
Think about whose needs drive materiality and whether planning judgments can change when new facts emerge.
Answer A. Materiality is a matter of professional judgment and should reflect the common information needs of financial statement users. If pretax income is distorted by a one-time restructuring charge and lenders (who emphasize balance-sheet measures) are the primary users, the auditor should reconsider whether a different benchmark (for example, a balance-sheet measure) is more appropriate. Materiality judgments, including the chosen benchmark, may be revised as the auditor obtains more reliable information during planning.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates sometimes treat planning choices as fixed; however, initial selections are not immutable. If new information shows the original benchmark is no longer appropriate, the auditor should reconsider it.
Why not C: This distractor plays on a partial memory about adjusting performance materiality for audit risk. In fact, both overall materiality and performance materiality can be revised during planning if better information indicates a change is needed.
Why not D: This is attractive to those who think materiality follows management's preference, but materiality is evaluated from the perspective of financial statement users as a group. If lenders' needs are predominant and relevant, they should be considered.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what happens when facts learned during the audit show that users would care about smaller misstatements than the auditor originally expected.
Answer C. Materiality is not fixed after planning; if facts learned during the audit cause the auditor to conclude the original overall materiality was set too high, the auditor must revise overall materiality. That revision typically requires revising performance materiality and may require applying a lower threshold for particular classes, account balances, or disclosures that are especially important to users (for example, items affecting covenant compliance). The auditor must then reconsider whether the audit procedures already performed and those still planned provide sufficient appropriate evidence under the revised thresholds and reevaluate accumulated misstatements.
Why not A: This distractor is operationally appealing, but incorrect because lowering overall materiality can mean prior procedures no longer provide sufficient appropriate evidence and accumulated misstatements must be reconsidered under the revised thresholds. The reassessment is not purely prospective.
Why not B: This is tempting because materiality is set based on planning benchmarks and some items warrant special sensitivity, but the stem states the auditor now concludes the original overall materiality is too high. Retaining the planning materiality is inconsistent with that reassessment; the required action is a broader revision, not a single end-of-audit adjustment for one misstatement.
Why not D: This is tempting for candidates who focus narrowly on quantitative effects on earnings or totals. A misstatement can be material for qualitative reasons, such as its effect on covenant compliance and liquidity presentation; communicating with governance may be appropriate but does not replace revising materiality and reassessing audit procedures.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on why auditors use a benchmark in the first place: to reflect the financial information most important to expected users of the statements.
Answer C. When selecting a benchmark for overall materiality, the auditor should focus on the financial information that is most important to the expected users of the financial statements given the entity's nature and circumstances. Considerations include the users' needs (for example, a lender concerned with operating results and cash-generating ability), and whether pretax income, revenue, or another measure is most relevant. Here, user relevance governs the choice rather than a mechanical rule.
Why not A: Risk assessment influences the nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures and performance materiality, but it does not primarily determine which financial-statement benchmark is most appropriate for overall materiality. Benchmark choice is guided by user relevance.
Why not B: This distractor plays on the belief that more conservative equals better, but materiality is about what would influence users' decisions, not simply minimizing the numerical threshold. Automatically choosing the lowest benchmark can misalign the audit with user needs.
Why not D: Prior-year practice can be a helpful starting point, but consistency is not required if current-year facts or users' needs indicate a different benchmark is more meaningful. The auditor must reassess materiality each period.
Common questions
What is the best benchmark for overall audit materiality under AU-C 320?
Use the measure most relevant to users' common information needs. Pretax income, revenue, and total assets are possible benchmarks, not a mandatory ranking.
Should auditors use pretax income when a one-time charge reduces earnings?
Not automatically. Consider whether normalized earnings or another measure better represents users' focus; removing the charge is not always the best answer.
Must auditors change the materiality benchmark during the audit?
Reconsider the benchmark when new information would have changed the planning determination. A distorted earnings figure does not automatically require either retaining or lowering the original amount.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Materiality, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: AU-C 320 Materiality, Risk Tiers and Caps on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Materiality
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.