PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 6 practice questions

Audit Materiality: Pretax Income vs. Revenue vs. Assets

Choose the overall materiality benchmark that best reflects users' common information needs, not simply the largest or most stable measure. Below: compare pretax income, revenue, and assets when a one-time charge distorts earnings.

The ruleSelect the benchmark most relevant to users' common information needs. When a one-time item distorts current-year earnings, consider normalized earnings, revenue, or assets rather than automatically using reported pretax income.

Try one first

Jordan, CPA, is planning the audit of Northline Co. Northline reported a small pretax loss in Year 2 after several years of near break-even results. The company's primary external users are a bank and major trade creditors, and those users focus heavily on revenue trends and total assets. When establishing overall materiality for the financial statements as a whole, which factor should primarily govern Jordan's choice of an appropriate benchmark?
Hint

Think about who uses the financial statements and which overall measure would matter most to their decisions when earnings are weak or unstable.

Side by side

Pretax incomeRevenueTotal assets
Users' main focusAnnual earnings and income-based covenantsSales trends and operating scaleFinancial position and asset-based measures
Strongest fitProfitable entity with representative earningsRevenue-focused users when earnings are unrepresentativeUsers focused on the balance sheet
Effect of a one-time chargeMay make reported earnings misleading as a benchmarkMay remain representative if revenue is unaffectedAssess whether assets still represent users' focus
Northline exampleA properly recorded plant-closure charge sharply reduces earningsRevenue remains stableAssets remain stable; lenders primarily monitor financial position
Best conclusion for NorthlineDo not default to depressed reported incomeStability alone does not make revenue the best choiceBest aligned with the stated lender focus
Possible alternative to reported incomeNormalized earnings, if relevant to usersRevenue, if users emphasize operating scaleAssets, if users emphasize financial position
If the charge becomes known after planningReconsider whether the original earnings benchmark remains appropriateConsider revenue only if it better reflects users' needsConsider assets given Northline's lender focus

Key points

  • Remember: choose the measure users follow, not the measure that produces your preferred materiality amount.
  • A properly recorded one-time charge can still make reported earnings a poor benchmark.
  • Reassessment does not automatically mean lowering materiality; first reconsider which benchmark represents users' needs.

How the exam traps you

  • Always use reported pretax income for a profit-oriented company. Check whether the one-time charge makes reported earnings unrepresentative.
  • Choose revenue solely because it is stable. Stability helps, but the benchmark must match users' information needs.
  • Keep the original benchmark because it was selected during planning. Reconsider it when new information would have changed the initial determination.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

In planning the audit of Hart Co. for Year 2, the auditor is selecting a benchmark for overall materiality. Hart has stable revenue and total assets from year to year, but Year 2 pretax income is unusually low because of a large one-time lawsuit loss. Which fact is the strongest reason not to base overall materiality primarily on current-year pretax income?
Hint

Ask which fact makes current-year pretax income a poor representation of the company's normal financial size.

Question 3

During planning of the 20X6 audit of Delta Manufacturing, the auditor set overall materiality at $900,000, based on 5% of expected pretax income of $18,000,000; performance materiality was $630,000. Midway through fieldwork, management's near-final results show pretax income of $4,000,000 because of a separately disclosed, nonrecurring plant-closing charge of $12,000,000 that the auditor believes is properly recorded and presented. Revenue, total assets, and core operating margins are otherwise consistent with prior expectations. Delta's primary external users are its bank group (which monitors EBITDA- and working-capital-based covenants) and a private equity owner (which evaluates adjusted operating results excluding the plant-closing charge). Aggregate detected misstatements total $420,000, and no qualitative factor indicates smaller amounts would be material. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate (1) whether the change in reported pretax income requires a reassessment of materiality and (2) which benchmark (reported pretax, normalized earnings, covenant measure, etc.) best reflects user needs.

Question 4

In planning the Year 2 audit of Delta Co., the auditor initially set overall materiality using pretax income as the benchmark. After performing additional planning procedures, the auditor learns that pretax income is unusually low because of a one-time restructuring charge, and Delta's primary external users are lenders who focus heavily on balance sheet measures in debt covenants. Assuming these facts are reliable, what is the primary issue the auditor should address?
Hint

Think about whose needs drive materiality and whether planning judgments can change when new facts emerge.

Question 5

During the Year 2 audit of a nonissuer, the auditor set materiality for the financial statements as a whole at $600,000 based on expected pretax income and set performance materiality at $450,000. Near year-end, actual results changed to a small pretax loss after an unexpected impairment charge. The auditor also learned that the entity is close to violating a lender current-ratio covenant, and a known $220,000 misclassification of long-term debt as current would cause a covenant breach if left uncorrected. Assume no fraud issues or scope limitation exist, and assume the auditor now concludes that the original $600,000 overall materiality is too high given users' likely sensitivity to smaller misstatements. What is the most appropriate consequence for the audit?
Hint

Focus on what happens when facts learned during the audit show that users would care about smaller misstatements than the auditor originally expected.

Question 6

Delta Medical Supply, a closely held company, has unusually volatile pretax income in Year 2 because of a one-time inventory write-down. Its primary external financial statement user is a bank that monitors debt covenants and focuses closely on operating results and cash-generating ability. When setting overall materiality for the audit, which factor should primarily govern the auditor's choice of benchmark?
Hint

Focus on why auditors use a benchmark in the first place: to reflect the financial information most important to expected users of the statements.

Drill all 93 Materiality questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What is the best benchmark for overall audit materiality under AU-C 320?

Use the measure most relevant to users' common information needs. Pretax income, revenue, and total assets are possible benchmarks, not a mandatory ranking.

Should auditors use pretax income when a one-time charge reduces earnings?

Not automatically. Consider whether normalized earnings or another measure better represents users' focus; removing the charge is not always the best answer.

Must auditors change the materiality benchmark during the audit?

Reconsider the benchmark when new information would have changed the planning determination. A distorted earnings figure does not automatically require either retaining or lowering the original amount.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Materiality, worked step by step.

AUD Simulation: AU-C 320 Materiality, Risk Tiers and Caps on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Materiality

All Materiality practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.