AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 8 practice questions
Revising Audit Materiality: What to Do Next
When new information changes the original materiality judgment, revise materiality and reassess whether the audit work remains sufficient. Below: a judgment scenario showing why lowering the threshold can require revisiting completed testing.
Try one first
Hint
Ask whether planning materiality is permanent or whether new facts can force the auditor to revisit it.
Answer C. Materiality determined at planning is not fixed; if the auditor obtains information that would have led to a different overall materiality at the time of planning, the auditor should revise the overall amount. The auditor should also reconsider performance materiality and adjust the nature, timing, and extent of planned procedures as necessary.
Why not A: Some candidates believe materiality is reconsidered only at the end of the engagement. In fact, the trigger for revision is new information that affects the original judgment, and the auditor should act on that information as soon as practicable because it can affect ongoing procedures.
Why not B: This is tempting because performance materiality and account-level thresholds are often adjusted during the audit. However, when new information would have changed the original overall materiality judgment, the overall materiality must be revised as well, not just account-level thresholds.
Why not D: This distractor confuses the reason to revise materiality with the presence of identified misstatements. Here the appropriate trigger is new information affecting the benchmark (expected pretax income), so materiality should be revised regardless of whether detected misstatements already exceed the original amount.
What should you do?
The situation
During Nova Co.'s audit, overall materiality was $300,000 and performance materiality was $180,000. After most revenue and inventory testing, an operating decline reduces expected pretax income. Earnings remain the appropriate benchmark, but the auditor concludes overall materiality should now be $150,000. Detected uncorrected misstatements total $100,000. Completed samples used the original thresholds. What should the auditor do next?
Set overall materiality at $150,000; reassess performance materiality, sampling thresholds, and completed and remaining procedures. Document the revision.
Best The revision affects both the evaluation threshold and evidence needed. Lower testing thresholds and perform additional procedures where necessary.
Lower overall materiality to $150,000, but retain performance materiality and all sampling thresholds.
Wrong The original $180,000 performance materiality exceeds revised overall materiality. Testing thresholds cannot simply remain unchanged.
Lower overall materiality to $150,000 and conclude no additional work is needed because misstatements total only $100,000.
Wrong Detected misstatements below revised materiality do not establish that procedures adequately addressed possible undetected misstatements.
Retain overall materiality at $300,000, but lower performance materiality for remaining testing.
Wrong The auditor has concluded that new information changes overall materiality. Adjusting only performance materiality skips the required revision.
Wait until final misstatement evaluation to revise materiality because most testing is complete.
Wrong Revise materiality when the information becomes known. Completed testing is not exempt from reassessment.
Key points
- Remember: A lower threshold can make completed testing insufficient, even when detected misstatements remain below revised materiality.
- Revisit sampling tolerable misstatement when resetting performance materiality.
- Document why materiality changed and how the revision affected audit procedures.
How the exam traps you
- Lower overall materiality but leave performance materiality and sampling thresholds untouched. Reassess the testing thresholds, not just the financial statement threshold.
- Treat $100,000 of detected misstatements below $150,000 as proof that enough testing was performed. Consider undetected misstatements and whether earlier procedures remain sufficient.
- Wait until final misstatement evaluation because most testing is complete. Revise materiality now and assess whether completed work needs additional procedures.
Question 2
Hint
Consider whether planning materiality can change when the auditor learns new information that would have affected the original judgment.
Answer C. Materiality is not fixed at planning; if the auditor obtains information that would have led to a different materiality judgment, the auditor should revise overall materiality. The auditor should also reassess and adjust the planned nature, timing, and extent of procedures to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence. Because a lower materiality means smaller misstatements could be material, more persuasive evidence or expanded testing may be necessary.
Why not A: This is tempting because materiality is first determined during planning, but planning is the starting point, not permanent. New information that would have affected the original judgment requires revising materiality.
Why not B: This distractor confuses the trigger for revising materiality. The need to revise arises from new financial information that changes the benchmark, not from whether misstatements have already been detected.
Why not D: Lower earnings do not justify relaxing audit effort or increasing detection risk. If anything, a lower materiality typically requires the auditor to perform more, not less, persuasive testing.
Question 3
Hint
Separate two issues: the benchmark used for overall materiality and the amount of cushion built into performance materiality for a higher-risk area.
Answer B. When information obtained during the audit would have affected the auditor's original materiality judgment, the auditor should reconsider materiality, but should not automatically adopt a final reported figure that is distorted by an unusual, separately disclosed event if users focus on operating results excluding that event. Because pretax income from continuing operations before the flood loss remains close to expectations, the auditor should reconsider which benchmark best reflects users' focus rather than simply using $1.1 million. In addition, identified misstatements of $140,000 together with recent control deviations in inventory justify considering a lower performance materiality for inventory to reduce the risk that undetected misstatements could aggregate to a material amount.
Why not A: This is tempting because the flood loss is unusual and the $140,000 of misstatements is below overall materiality, but the auditor must reconsider materiality if new information would have changed the original judgment, and increased likelihood of undetected inventory misstatements can justify lowering performance materiality for that area.
Why not C: This is tempting because actual results can trigger a materiality revision, but it is wrong to automatically adopt the distorted $1.1 million when users focus on operating results excluding the unusual loss; also increased risk and identified misstatements can appropriately lead to revising performance materiality for a specific high-risk area.
Why not D: This is tempting because a distorted earnings figure may suggest a non-income benchmark, but the facts support reconsideration of the benchmark rather than an automatic switch to revenues, pretax income before the unusual loss is close to plan and users focus on operating results. Also, performance materiality need not wait until identified misstatements exceed the threshold before being adjusted when risk of undetected misstatements increases.
Question 4
Hint
First decide whether the original profit-based benchmark is still representative; if it is not, use the alternative benchmark most relevant to a retail business and then apply the firm’s guidance for account‑level performance materiality given the inventory risk.
Answer C. Because the profit-based benchmark is no longer representative, the auditor should revise overall materiality using the most relevant alternative benchmark for a retailer (revenue at 1%), yielding $800,000. Inventory has elevated inherent risk, so per the firm's guidance reduce performance materiality for that account to 50% of overall ($400,000) to limit the risk that aggregate inventory misstatements exceed materiality.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates may think planning judgments are fixed, but AU‑C 320 requires revising materiality when information obtained during the audit indicates the original judgment is no longer appropriate. A projected year‑end loss makes the profit benchmark unrepresentative, so failing to revise would be incorrect.
Why not B: Switching benchmarks is reasonable when profit is not representative, but for a retail client revenue is generally the most relevant benchmark to users. Using total assets here is less representative of user concerns for a retailer and would produce an unreasonably small materiality that could drive unnecessary audit work.
Why not D: Although 60-75% is the normal range for performance materiality, inventory is identified as having elevated inherent risk (markdowns/promotions). The firm's guidance calls for reducing performance materiality for such accounts to 50% of overall; using 75% would not sufficiently reduce the risk that aggregate inventory misstatements exceed acceptable limits.
Question 5
Hint
Ask whether materiality is fixed at planning or whether it can change when a key benchmark changes significantly during the audit.
Answer B. Materiality is not fixed at planning; auditors should revise overall materiality if later information would have led to a different amount initially. A substantial decline in the chosen benchmark (pretax income) supports lowering overall materiality, and the auditor should then reconsider the nature, timing, and extent of planned procedures and adjust performance materiality accordingly. Failing to revise could result in insufficient evidence under an outdated threshold.
Why not A: Tempting because initial materiality is based on early estimates, but auditors are expected to update materiality when new information arises that would have changed the original amount; a significant decline in the benchmark makes the original amount inappropriate.
Why not C: This confuses the relationship between overall and performance materiality; performance materiality is derived from overall materiality, and overall materiality itself must be reconsidered when facts change significantly.
Why not D: While final aggregation of misstatements is important, materiality influences planning and performance throughout the audit; waiting until the end could mean procedures were insufficient under an outdated threshold.
Question 6
Hint
Ask whether materiality in an audit is a one-time planning number or a judgment that must be updated when key benchmark information changes.
Answer B. Materiality is not fixed at planning. If the auditor becomes aware of information during the audit that would have resulted in a lower materiality amount initially, the auditor must revise overall materiality and, as applicable, performance materiality. The auditor must then consider whether the audit plan and procedures already performed remain adequate and expand procedures as necessary.
Why not A: Tempting because planning judgments are based on information available at the time, but standards require revision when later information would have changed the original materiality amount; the lower amount affects not only final evaluation but also whether earlier audit work was sufficient.
Why not C: Attractive because it separates planning from execution, but incorrect: performance materiality should be reconsidered when overall materiality changes, and the auditor must reassess the adequacy of procedures already performed even if identified misstatements have not exceeded the prior performance materiality.
Why not D: Misleading because it focuses on cause; the requirement to revise is triggered by information that would have led to a different materiality judgment, regardless of whether the change was due to fraud, error, or a legitimate operating event.
Question 7
Hint
Consider whether facts learned before report issuance would have changed the original planning judgment about materiality and remember which materiality measure determines whether uncorrected misstatements require correction or modification.
Answer A. When information obtained before the report would have affected the original materiality judgment, the auditor must revise materiality. With revised overall materiality of $150,000 and aggregate uncorrected misstatements of $190,000, the auditor should request corrections; if management refuses, the auditor must evaluate and, if appropriate, issue a modified opinion. Performance materiality is for planning, not the reporting threshold for uncorrected misstatements.
Why not B: This distractor confuses performance materiality with the threshold for reporting uncorrected misstatements. Performance materiality guides the nature, timing, and extent of procedures; the decision to request correction or modify the opinion is based on overall materiality (here, the revised overall materiality).
Why not C: Tempting because $190,000 is below the original $200,000 planning materiality, but incorrect: the auditor obtained new information before report issuance that affects the original materiality determination, so materiality must be reassessed and cannot simply remain at the original planning level.
Why not D: Although corrected items reduce misstatement and concentration might influence user impact, concentration in a single account does not eliminate the need to consider the aggregate effect relative to the revised overall materiality. The auditor must address uncorrected misstatements that exceed revised materiality.
Question 8
Hint
Ask whether materiality can change after planning if the auditor learns facts that would have changed the original judgment.
Answer D. Materiality set at planning should be reassessed if the auditor obtains information that would have affected the original judgment. Because lenders' covenant sensitivity and lower reported earnings make users more likely to be influenced by smaller misstatements, the auditor should lower overall materiality and adjust the planned nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures accordingly. This ensures the audit addresses the increased risk that smaller misstatements are relevant to users.
Why not A: Waiting until the end ignores that materiality drives planning and performance of audit procedures. If users are now more sensitive to smaller misstatements, audit procedures should be adjusted during fieldwork rather than deferred.
Why not B: This is tempting because planning decisions feel fixed, but it's incorrect: materiality is not locked in. It should be revised when new information would have led to a different planning judgment, regardless of whether a misstatement has yet been identified.
Why not C: Expanding testing is prudent, but it skips the required first step of revising overall materiality when circumstances change. Limiting additional work only to previously identified high-risk accounts may miss other areas where smaller misstatements are now material.
Common questions
What should an auditor do after lowering overall materiality?
Reconsider performance materiality, sampling tolerable misstatement, and the nature, timing, and extent of procedures. Document the revision and its effect on the audit.
Does lower materiality require redoing completed audit testing?
Not automatically. Reassess whether completed procedures provide sufficient appropriate evidence under the revised thresholds, and perform additional procedures where needed.
Can materiality change if detected misstatements are below the revised amount?
Yes. New information affecting the original materiality judgment triggers revision, not whether detected misstatements exceed a threshold.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Materiality, worked step by step.
AUD Simulation: AU-C 320 Materiality, Risk Tiers and Caps on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Materiality
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.