PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 6 practice questions

C Corporation Reasonable Compensation and Excess Dividends

A C corporation may deduct reasonable compensation for actual services, but excess pay to a shareholder-employee is generally a dividend when earnings and profits are sufficient. Below: a step-by-step example separating a deductible bonus from an excess distribution.

The ruleA C corporation may deduct only reasonable compensation for services actually rendered. Excess compensation paid to a shareholder-employee is generally nondeductible and treated as a dividend to the extent of earnings and profits.

Try one first

North Pine, a calendar-year C corporation, is wholly owned by Lee, who works full-time as its president. At year-end, North Pine has substantial current earnings and profits and wants to transfer an additional $250,000 of cash to Lee. Lee's regular salary for the year (before any year-end bonus) was $100,000. Assume the bonus would be properly authorized and paid in Year 1, Lee performed substantial services during the year, and the only issue is the federal income tax characterization of the payment. In deciding whether the bonus approach can produce a corporate deduction rather than a nondeductible distribution, which factor is most important?
Hint

Focus on the test the tax law uses to allow a corporate deduction for payments to a shareholder who is also an employee, not on which facts determine dividend treatment.

Step by step

  1. Identify the proposed payment

    Maple, a calendar-year C corporation, has paid its sole shareholder-president $220,000 for Year 1 services and wants to pay another $60,000 before year-end. Maple has sufficient current and accumulated earnings and profits; ignore payroll taxes.

  2. Find supported total compensation

    After reviewing comparable executive compensation, Maple's adviser concludes that $240,000 is the maximum reasonable total pay for the services actually performed. This limit covers salary plus any year-end bonus.

  3. Subtract compensation already paid

    The remaining compensation allowance is $240,000 minus $220,000, or $20,000. Maple can support a $20,000 deduction for additional compensation.

  4. Separate the excess

    The proposed $60,000 payment exceeds the remaining $20,000 allowance by $40,000. Paying the entire amount does not eliminate the deduction for the reasonable portion.

  5. Apply dividend treatment

    Because Maple has sufficient earnings and profits, the $40,000 excess is generally a dividend taxable to the shareholder. Maple cannot deduct that dividend.

  6. Check substance, not labels

    The defensible split is a $20,000 deductible bonus and a $40,000 nondeductible dividend. Board approval or reporting the full payment as wages does not make the excess deductible.

Key points

  • Remember: The reasonable compensation limit applies to total annual pay, not just the year-end bonus.
  • Paying the full $60,000 as salary would raise annual compensation to $280,000.
  • Sufficient earnings and profits do not turn the supported $20,000 bonus into a dividend.

How the exam traps you

  • Deducting the full $60,000 because payroll records call it a bonus. Only $20,000 fits within the supported annual compensation limit.
  • Treating the full $60,000 as a dividend because the employee owns the corporation. Shareholder status does not prevent a deduction for reasonable compensation for actual services.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Harbor Corp, a profitable calendar-year C corporation, is wholly owned by Lane, who works full time in the business. Through November 20X6, Lane has already been paid $420,000, and independent salary data support $420,000 as Lane's full reasonable compensation for 20X6. There is no claim of prior-year undercompensation. Harbor has current and accumulated earnings and profits well in excess of $200,000 and wants to transfer an additional $200,000 of cash to Lane before year-end. Assume no loan, redemption, fringe-benefit, or retirement-plan issues. Which year-end tax-planning conclusion is the most appropriate?
Hint

First decide whether the extra payment can still qualify as deductible compensation. Then apply the normal ordering rules for C corporation distributions.

Question 3

Pine, a profitable calendar-year C corporation, is owned equally by Lin and Moss. Lin is Pine's president and works full time for the corporation; Moss is a passive investor and performs no services. Before any year-end payments, Pine expects $400,000 of taxable income and has sufficient earnings and profits. Pine wants to transfer $150,000 of excess cash to Lin without increasing Moss's payout. Lin already receives an annual salary, and Pine's adviser has concluded that no more than $80,000 of additional Year 1 compensation would be reasonable for Lin's actual services. All payments would be made in Year 1. Ignoring payroll tax effects, which conclusion is best supported for federal income tax planning purposes?
Hint

Focus on the line between deductible compensation for services and a nondeductible shareholder distribution. The label on the payment is less important than whether the amount is supportable as reasonable compensation.

Question 4

North Co., a calendar-year C corporation, has one shareholder-employee, Mills. Before any year-end payment, North expects Year 1 taxable income of $40,000 and has sufficient accumulated earnings and profits so that any noncompensation distribution to Mills would be treated as a dividend. Mills has already received $235,000 of salary for Year 1. A contemporaneous independent compensation study supports total reasonable compensation of $275,000 for Mills's Year 1 services. North wants to transfer an additional $70,000 to Mills before year-end. Ignore payroll taxes, state taxes, and shareholder-level rate differences; focus only on corporate-level deductibility and a defensible tax-planning recommendation. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate two ideas: how much additional compensation is still supportable as reasonable, and whether taxable income itself limits the deduction.

Question 5

Maple Manufacturing, a calendar-year C corporation, is wholly owned by Ortiz, who works full time as president. Before any discretionary year-end payment, Maple has already paid Ortiz $220,000 of salary for Year 1 and has sufficient current and accumulated earnings and profits. After reviewing comparable compensation for similar executives, Maple's tax adviser concludes that total Year 1 compensation above $240,000 would likely not be reasonable for the services Ortiz actually performed. Maple wants to transfer an additional $60,000 to Ortiz before year-end. Assume the payment is not intended to be a loan and no other arrangement (such as rent) applies. Which treatment is most defensible for federal income tax purposes?
Hint

Separate the issue into two steps: first determine how much additional compensation is still reasonable, then classify any remaining payment using the earnings-and-profits fact.

Question 6

Maple Manufacturing, a calendar-year C corporation wholly owned by Noor (its full-time CEO), expects $750,000 of taxable income for 20X5 before any year-end payment to Noor. Noor already received a $350,000 salary for 20X5. An independent compensation study indicates total annual compensation of $360,000-$390,000 would be reasonable for comparable services. Maple is considering transferring an additional $200,000 to Noor before year-end and labeling it either a bonus or a dividend. Assume Maple has sufficient current or accumulated earnings and profits, no NOLs, and no payroll/state tax issues. Which statement best identifies the primary federal income tax issue?
Hint

Start by asking what facts determine whether a payment to a shareholder-employee qualifies as deductible compensation by the corporation, rather than focusing first on shareholder distribution rules.

Drill all 104 Tax planning for C corporations questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How do you calculate additional deductible compensation for a C corporation owner?

Subtract compensation already paid from supported total reasonable compensation. Here, $240,000 minus $220,000 leaves $20,000 of additional deductible compensation.

What happens to compensation above the reasonable amount?

The excess is generally nondeductible to the corporation and treated as a dividend to the shareholder to the extent of earnings and profits. Here, the excess is $40,000.

Does board approval make a shareholder bonus deductible?

No. Board approval and payroll reporting do not override the reasonable compensation limit. Calling the full $60,000 a bonus does not support a deduction beyond $20,000.

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Tax planning for C corporations

All Tax planning for C corporations practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.