TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 8 practice questions
C Corporation Bonus vs. Dividend: Compare Total Tax
A C corporation deducts reasonable compensation for actual services, but not dividends; the deduction does not guarantee lower combined tax. Below: compare both payouts from the same pre-tax earnings.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the shareholder's role as owner from the shareholder's role as employee, and focus on which type of payment is deductible by the corporation.
Answer A. A C corporation may deduct reasonable compensation paid for actual services rendered. A cash dividend, however, is a distribution of earnings and is not deductible by the corporation; therefore only the deductible bonus reduces Pine's taxable income.
Why not B: This plays on the idea that payments to owners are always distributions. Here the shareholder is also an employee and the fact pattern states the bonus is reasonable and for services rendered, so the bonus is deductible while the dividend is not.
Why not C: Tempting because both payments involve cash leaving the company, but tax treatment depends on the nature of the payment. Dividends are distributions, not deductible business expenses.
Why not D: Incorrect because corporate tax treatment focuses on the legal character of the payment (compensation vs. distribution), not solely on the recipient's identity. Compensation for services can be deductible even if paid to an owner-employee.
Side by side
| Reasonable bonus | Qualified dividend | |
|---|---|---|
| Pine's same $100,000 of pre-tax earnings | Pay $100,000 to its sole shareholder-employee for actual services. | Pay corporate tax, then distribute all remaining earnings to the same shareholder. |
| Corporate deduction | $100,000; reasonable bonus paid and fully deductible. | $0; dividend is not deductible. |
| Corporate tax at 21% | $0 | $100,000 × 21% = $21,000 |
| Cash paid to shareholder | $100,000 | $100,000 − $21,000 = $79,000 |
| Assumed shareholder tax rate | 37% ordinary income rate | 20% qualified dividend rate |
| Shareholder income tax | $100,000 × 37% = $37,000 | $79,000 × 20% = $15,800 |
| Combined federal income tax | $0 + $37,000 = $37,000 | $21,000 + $15,800 = $36,800 |
| Shareholder cash after all taxes | $63,000 | $63,200; dividend leaves $200 more. |
| Taxes excluded from this comparison | Payroll taxes, NIIT, and state taxes. | Payroll taxes, NIIT, and state taxes. |
Key points
- Remember: a bonus removes the corporate tax layer, but a dividend can still produce lower combined tax.
- Start both choices with Pine's same $100,000 of pre-tax earnings, not the same cash payout.
- The shareholder pays dividend tax only on the $79,000 left after corporate tax.
- The $200 dividend advantage depends on the stated rates and excluded taxes.
How the exam traps you
- Choosing the bonus automatically because it is deductible. Compare $37,000 of combined bonus tax with $36,800 of combined dividend tax.
- Applying the 20% dividend rate to the full $100,000. Subtract $21,000 of corporate tax first; the taxable dividend is $79,000.
- Comparing only the shareholder's 37% and 20% rates. Include Pine's corporate tax in the dividend total.
Question 2
Hint
Which option can produce both a corporate deduction and no immediate taxable income to the shareholder-employee?
Answer C. When provided through a qualifying employer-sponsored group health plan, employer-paid health insurance premiums are generally deductible by a C corporation and excludable from the employee's gross income. That gives Maple a corporate deduction while Jordan receives a current-year tax-free benefit, which is typically more tax-efficient in the current year than taxable wages or nondeductible dividends.
Why not A: Why tempting: A salary bonus is straightforward and reduces corporate taxable income while giving cash to the shareholder-employee. Why wrong: The bonus is taxable compensation to Jordan, so Jordan recognizes ordinary income immediately rather than receiving a tax-free benefit.
Why not B: Why tempting: A dividend provides cash and may be taxed at favorable individual rates. Why wrong: Dividends are not deductible by the corporation, so they do not reduce corporate taxable income and are generally less tax-efficient on a current-year basis than a deductible employer-provided benefit.
Why not D: Why tempting: Many know self-employed taxpayers can deduct health insurance premiums, so this appears to shift the tax burden to the individual. Why wrong: Jordan is an employee of a C corporation, not self-employed for this deduction, and thus cannot claim the self-employed health insurance adjustment in this fact pattern.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which type of cash transfer is deductible by the C corporation, not just which one gets money to the shareholder.
Answer C. A reasonable bonus paid for actual services is generally deductible by a C corporation and reduces corporate taxable income in the year the deduction is allowed. Because the fact pattern states the payment is supported by services and is reasonable, compensation gives Bluebird the best current-year corporate tax benefit.
Why not A: This may look attractive because a return of capital can avoid immediate shareholder-level tax to the extent of basis. But a return of capital is not a corporate expense and does not create a corporate deduction, so it provides no current-year corporate tax benefit.
Why not B: This is tempting because dividends are a common way for a C corporation to transfer cash to shareholders. However, dividends are not deductible by the corporation and therefore do not reduce Bluebird's taxable income.
Why not D: Repaying loan principal is tempting because it transfers cash to the shareholder-lender, but repayment of principal is not deductible by the corporation. Only interest (if deductible) reduces taxable income; principal repayment does not.
Question 4
Hint
Start by asking which choices give Beacon a current-year deduction, then check whether the chosen payment characterization is actually supported by the stated facts.
Answer C. Because a contemporaneous compensation study supports total annual pay up to $380,000, the additional $80,000 is deductible by Beacon as reasonable compensation (Sec. 162). That deduction saves Beacon $80,000 × 21% = $16,800 of corporate tax, while Nora pays $80,000 × 37% = $29,600 of ordinary income tax, for a combined current-year tax cost of $29,600 − $16,800 = $12,800. This combined cost is lower than the dividend alternative and the reasonableness support reduces recharacterization risk.
Why not A: Repayment of bona fide debt can avoid dividend treatment, but the stem explicitly states no bona fide debt exists, so relabeling the payment as loan repayment would not be well supported and would not produce a corporate deduction.
Why not B: A qualified dividend is taxed to Nora at 20%, but dividends are not deductible by the corporation; Beacon would still have borne $80,000 × 21% = $16,800 of corporate tax and Nora would pay $80,000 × 20% = $16,000, yielding a combined current-year tax of $32,800, worse than the deductible bonus.
Why not D: Return of capital treatment applies only to distributions to the extent they exceed earnings and profits; because Beacon has sufficient current E&P, an $80,000 distribution would be treated as a dividend, not a return of capital, and thus would not generate a corporate deduction.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on which type of payment is generally deductible by a C corporation, not just on how value reaches the shareholder.
Answer A. A C corporation may generally deduct reasonable compensation paid for services actually performed (reducing corporate taxable income). Paying Mason an $80,000 year-end bonus that is reasonable for his services would therefore lower Ridge's taxable income. By contrast, nonliquidating shareholder distributions (dividends or distributions treated as dividends) are not deductible, and distributions of appreciated property generally do not produce a corporate deduction and can even trigger corporate gain.
Why not B: This is tempting because dividends move cash to the shareholder, but dividends are not deductible by a C corporation and therefore would not reduce Ridge's taxable income.
Why not C: This may seem appealing because returns of capital can reduce shareholder basis, but when the corporation has sufficient earnings and profits a cash distribution is generally treated as a dividend to that extent and still does not provide a corporate deduction.
Why not D: This may look attractive to move value without paying cash, but nonliquidating distributions of appreciated property generally do not create a corporate deduction and can force the corporation to recognize gain on the distributed property.
Question 6
Hint
Compute total federal tax paid by the corporation plus the shareholder under each alternative separately. For the dividend choice, remember the corporation is taxed before the shareholder receives the distribution.
Answer C. If Orion pays the $100,000 as a deductible bonus, Lane reports $100,000 of ordinary income taxed at 24% = $24,000 and the corporation pays no tax on that amount. If Orion pays no bonus, the corporation pays 21% × $100,000 = $21,000, leaving $79,000 that Lane would receive as a dividend and pay 15% × $79,000 = $11,850. Combined tax under the dividend route is $21,000 + $11,850 = $32,850, so the bonus route saves $32,850 − $24,000 = $8,850.
Why not A: $9,000 is the difference between the shareholder rates applied to the full $100,000 (24% − 15% = 9% of $100,000). It ignores the corporate tax that reduces the cash available for dividends and therefore overstates the actual combined saving.
Why not B: $11,850 equals the shareholder tax on the after‑corporate‑tax dividend ($79,000 × 15%) but omits the corporation's $21,000 tax; it does not compare total combined federal taxes under both alternatives.
Why not D: $21,000 is the corporate tax avoided by deducting the bonus (21% of $100,000). It ignores the shareholder's ordinary‑income tax on the bonus, so it overstates the net combined tax savings.
Question 7
Hint
Ask which choice is a deductible payment for services, rather than a distribution of corporate cash to the owner.
Answer C. A C corporation may deduct reasonable compensation paid for services actually rendered by an employee. Because Lee provides substantial services and the additional $80,000 would be reasonable compensation for Year 1, a year-end bonus is deductible by Harbor and directly reduces its taxable income. The other choices involve distributions or balance-sheet transactions that are not deductible business expenses.
Why not A: A bona fide loan creates a receivable on the corporation's books rather than an expense. While it provides cash to Lee, it is not compensation and does not produce a corporate deduction unless the loan is recharacterized (which is a separate factual inquiry).
Why not B: This is tempting because dividends move cash to the owner, but dividends are paid from after-tax corporate earnings and are not deductible by the corporation. Paying a dividend does not reduce corporate taxable income.
Why not D: Labeling a payment a return of capital does not create a deduction for the corporation. With sufficient earnings and profits, a cash distribution will generally be treated as a dividend to the shareholder and is not deductible by the corporation.
Question 8
Hint
Start by deciding whether the payment is being treated as compensation for services or as a shareholder distribution. That classification drives whether the corporation gets a deduction.
Answer C. A C corporation may deduct reasonable compensation paid for services actually rendered, which reduces corporate taxable income. When the payment is properly characterized as salary, the shareholder-employee reports it as compensation (wage) income rather than as a dividend. Earnings and profits are relevant to distributions but do not convert bona fide wages into dividends.
Why not A: This overgeneralizes that corporate payments are nondeductible. Dividends are nondeductible, but reasonable compensation paid for actual services is generally deductible by the corporation, so the corporation may deduct the $90,000 on these facts.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates often associate payments to shareholders with dividends when earnings and profits exist. However, if the payment is bona fide compensation for services, it is treated as salary to the employee, not a distribution; E&P are relevant to distributions but do not recharacterize wages as dividends.
Why not D: Earnings and profits determine whether a distribution is a dividend, but they do not limit the deduction for reasonable compensation. The corporation's ability to deduct reasonable wages is governed by whether the payment is bona fide compensation, not by the level of E&P.
Common questions
Can a C corporation deduct a bonus paid to its shareholder?
Yes, if it is reasonable compensation for services actually rendered and deduction timing requirements are satisfied. Pine's example assumes the bonus is paid and fully deductible.
How do you calculate combined tax on a C corporation dividend?
Add corporate tax to shareholder tax on the after-corporate-tax dividend. Here, $21,000 + ($79,000 × 20%) = $36,800.
Is a bonus always better than a dividend for a C corporation?
No. Here, the dividend produces $200 less combined federal income tax, despite being nondeductible. The comparison excludes payroll taxes, NIIT, and state taxes.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax planning for C corporations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.