PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 8 practice questions

C Corporation Bonus vs. Dividend: Compare Total Tax

A C corporation deducts reasonable compensation for actual services, but not dividends; the deduction does not guarantee lower combined tax. Below: compare both payouts from the same pre-tax earnings.

The ruleReasonable compensation for services actually rendered is deductible; dividends are not. Compare corporate tax plus shareholder tax using the same starting amount of pre-tax corporate earnings.

Try one first

Pine Co., a calendar-year C corporation, expects $300,000 of taxable income before any year-end payment to its sole shareholder, who also works full time for the company. Pine is considering either a $50,000 cash dividend or a $50,000 year-end bonus for services actually rendered. Assume the bonus amount is reasonable, is paid in Year 1, and is otherwise fully deductible. Ignore shareholder-level tax effects and focus only on Pine's federal taxable income. Which statement is most accurate?
Hint

Separate the shareholder's role as owner from the shareholder's role as employee, and focus on which type of payment is deductible by the corporation.

Side by side

Reasonable bonusQualified dividend
Pine's same $100,000 of pre-tax earningsPay $100,000 to its sole shareholder-employee for actual services.Pay corporate tax, then distribute all remaining earnings to the same shareholder.
Corporate deduction$100,000; reasonable bonus paid and fully deductible.$0; dividend is not deductible.
Corporate tax at 21%$0$100,000 × 21% = $21,000
Cash paid to shareholder$100,000$100,000 − $21,000 = $79,000
Assumed shareholder tax rate37% ordinary income rate20% qualified dividend rate
Shareholder income tax$100,000 × 37% = $37,000$79,000 × 20% = $15,800
Combined federal income tax$0 + $37,000 = $37,000$21,000 + $15,800 = $36,800
Shareholder cash after all taxes$63,000$63,200; dividend leaves $200 more.
Taxes excluded from this comparisonPayroll taxes, NIIT, and state taxes.Payroll taxes, NIIT, and state taxes.

Key points

  • Remember: a bonus removes the corporate tax layer, but a dividend can still produce lower combined tax.
  • Start both choices with Pine's same $100,000 of pre-tax earnings, not the same cash payout.
  • The shareholder pays dividend tax only on the $79,000 left after corporate tax.
  • The $200 dividend advantage depends on the stated rates and excluded taxes.

How the exam traps you

  • Choosing the bonus automatically because it is deductible. Compare $37,000 of combined bonus tax with $36,800 of combined dividend tax.
  • Applying the 20% dividend rate to the full $100,000. Subtract $21,000 of corporate tax first; the taxable dividend is $79,000.
  • Comparing only the shareholder's 37% and 20% rates. Include Pine's corporate tax in the dividend total.

7 more, each from a different angle

0 of 7 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Maple Co. is a profitable C corporation wholly owned by Jordan, who works full-time as Maple's president. Maple wants to provide Jordan with an additional $24,000 of current-year economic value. Maple already offers the same insured group health plan to its full-time employees and can add Jordan immediately. Assume Jordan is an eligible employee, the plan otherwise satisfies applicable employee-benefit requirements, and payroll taxes are ignored. Which action generally produces the most favorable current-year federal income tax result for Maple and Jordan?
Hint

Which option can produce both a corporate deduction and no immediate taxable income to the shareholder-employee?

Question 3

Rex owns 100% of Bluebird, a profitable C corporation, and works full time as its president. Bluebird wants to transfer an additional $80,000 of cash to Rex in Year 1. Assume Rex performed services that support this amount, the payment would be reasonable compensation, any shareholder debt is bona fide, and payroll tax effects are ignored. Which choice would generally give Bluebird the best current-year corporate tax benefit?
Hint

Focus on which type of cash transfer is deductible by the C corporation, not just which one gets money to the shareholder.

Question 4

Beacon Corp., a profitable calendar-year C corporation, is wholly owned by Nora, who works full time as its CEO. Before any additional Year 1 payment, Beacon expects $600,000 of taxable income and has sufficient current earnings and profits. Nora already receives a $300,000 annual salary. A contemporaneous compensation study supports total annual compensation up to $380,000 as reasonable for Nora's actual services. Beacon wants to transfer an additional $80,000 cash to Nora before year-end. Assume Beacon is taxed at 21%, Nora's marginal federal rate on ordinary income is 37%, any dividend would be a qualified dividend taxed at 20%, and payroll taxes, NIIT, and state taxes are ignored. There is no bona fide debt from Beacon to Nora. Which choice best minimizes the combined current-year federal income tax burden while remaining well supported under the tax rules?
Hint

Start by asking which choices give Beacon a current-year deduction, then check whether the chosen payment characterization is actually supported by the stated facts.

Question 5

Ridge Co. is a profitable C corporation. Its sole shareholder, Mason, works full-time in the business and performs substantial services. At the end of Year 1, Ridge wants to transfer $80,000 of value to Mason. Assume Ridge has sufficient earnings and profits, Mason has no shareholder loan balance, and any year-end bonus would be reasonable compensation for services actually rendered. For federal income tax purposes only, which action would generally best reduce Ridge's taxable income?
Hint

Focus on which type of payment is generally deductible by a C corporation, not just on how value reaches the shareholder.

Question 6

Orion, a calendar-year C corporation, has $100,000 of Year 1 income before any year-end payment to its sole shareholder-employee, Lane. Orion is deciding between (1) paying Lane a $100,000 year-end cash bonus that would be reasonable compensation and fully deductible by Orion, or (2) paying no bonus and instead distributing all of the resulting after‑corporate‑tax cash as a dividend. Assume Orion has sufficient earnings and profits for dividend treatment. The federal corporate income tax rate is 21%; Lane's marginal federal tax rate is 24% on ordinary income and 15% on qualified dividends. Ignore payroll taxes, NIIT, state taxes, and all other limitations. Compared with paying no bonus and distributing earnings as a dividend, how much combined federal income tax would Orion and Lane save if Orion pays the $100,000 as a deductible bonus?
Hint

Compute total federal tax paid by the corporation plus the shareholder under each alternative separately. For the dividend choice, remember the corporation is taxed before the shareholder receives the distribution.

Question 7

Harbor, Inc. is a profitable C corporation wholly owned by Lee, who works full time managing the business. Harbor wants Lee to receive an additional $80,000 in Year 1. Assume Harbor has sufficient earnings and profits, Lee has already received a base salary, and any additional amount paid as compensation would be reasonable for the services Lee performed in Year 1. Which action would most directly reduce Harbor's Year 1 federal taxable income?
Hint

Ask which choice is a deductible payment for services, rather than a distribution of corporate cash to the owner.

Question 8

Orchid Inc., a calendar-year C corporation, has one shareholder who works full time in the business. At the end of Year 1, Orchid plans to pay the shareholder $90,000 in cash. Assume the amount is reasonable compensation for services actually performed if classified as salary, Orchid has sufficient earnings and profits, and payroll tax effects are ignored. What is the federal income tax effect of paying the $90,000 as salary rather than as a dividend?
Hint

Start by deciding whether the payment is being treated as compensation for services or as a shareholder distribution. That classification drives whether the corporation gets a deduction.

Drill all 104 Tax planning for C corporations questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can a C corporation deduct a bonus paid to its shareholder?

Yes, if it is reasonable compensation for services actually rendered and deduction timing requirements are satisfied. Pine's example assumes the bonus is paid and fully deductible.

How do you calculate combined tax on a C corporation dividend?

Add corporate tax to shareholder tax on the after-corporate-tax dividend. Here, $21,000 + ($79,000 × 20%) = $36,800.

Is a bonus always better than a dividend for a C corporation?

No. Here, the dividend produces $200 less combined federal income tax, despite being nondeductible. The comparison excludes payroll taxes, NIIT, and state taxes.

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Tax planning for C corporations

All Tax planning for C corporations practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.