TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions
Related-Party Sale: Seller’s Loss Disallowed
A seller cannot deduct a loss on a sale to a related party, even at fair market value. Below: a step-by-step land sale example separates the realized loss from the deductible amount.
Try one first
Hint
First decide whether Reed and the corporation are related parties for loss-disallowance purposes; only then worry about the amount and character of the loss.
Answer C. Losses on sales between related parties are disallowed under IRC §267. An individual and that individual's more-than-50%-owned corporation are related, so Reed cannot deduct the $30,000 loss in Year 1, even though the sale was bona fide and for cash.
Why not A: A reasonable mistake because the land was a capital asset, but Section 267 disallows the loss entirely for related-party sales, so character does not rescue the deduction.
Why not B: Tempting if a candidate focuses on the economic loss, but incorrect because the loss is disallowed by the related-party rule. Also, the asset was a capital asset in Reed's hands, not ordinary-income property.
Why not D: This plays on the common belief that disallowed losses are merely suspended. The seller does not later deduct the loss; any later tax effect involves the purchaser's transactions and potential adjustments to the purchaser's gain, not a subsequent deduction by the original seller.
Step by step
- Read the sale facts
Lane sells investment land to Pine Corp. for $70,000 cash, its fair market value. Lane’s adjusted basis is $90,000, Lane owns 100% of Pine, and the sale is bona fide with no other special rules.
- Confirm the related-party relationship
An individual and a corporation more than 50% owned by that individual by value are related under §267. Lane’s 100% ownership meets this test.
- Calculate the realized loss
Subtract Lane’s $90,000 adjusted basis from the $70,000 sale proceeds. Lane realizes a $20,000 loss.
- Apply the loss disallowance
Section 267 disallows the entire $20,000 loss. Holding the land for investment does not make that loss deductible.
- Reject the fair-value exception
The $70,000 price equals fair market value, but that fact does not change the answer. A bona fide sale does not override the related-party loss rule.
- State the seller’s result
Lane realizes a $20,000 loss but deducts $0. The loss is disallowed, not deferred for Lane to deduct when Pine later sells.
Key points
- Remember: A realized loss is not necessarily deductible; §267 blocks the seller’s deduction when the buyer is related.
- Investment-property status does not rescue a disallowed loss.
- The seller’s loss is disallowed, not deferred until the buyer resells.
How the exam traps you
- Deducting the realized loss because the land was investment property. Apply §267 before allowing a capital loss deduction.
- Treating a bona fide sale at fair market value as an exception. The relationship still disallows the seller’s loss.
- Saving the loss for the seller to deduct after the buyer resells. The seller’s disallowed loss is not a deferred deduction.
Question 2
Hint
First determine whether Paige and Lark are related parties under the tax loss-disallowance rules. Then decide whether the loss is recognized, deferred, or fully barred.
Answer B. A loss on a sale or exchange between an individual and a corporation more than 50% owned by that individual is disallowed (see IRC §267). Because Paige owns 100% of Lark, her $8,000 capital loss (35,000 basis − 27,000 amount realized) is not recognized on her Year 1 return; selling at FMV does not prevent the disallowance.
Why not A: This is tempting because the mechanical loss calculation (basis minus amount realized) yields $8,000. However, the related-party loss-disallowance rule overrides the normal loss result for sales between an individual and a corporation the individual owns more than 50% of.
Why not C: Students may recall that later disposition by the buyer can affect related-party issues, but the seller's loss here is disallowed rather than deferred. A later resale by Lark to an unrelated party does not revive Paige's deduction.
Why not D: It's common to see family examples, but the related-party loss rule is broader. It also covers transactions between an individual and a corporation more than 50% owned by that individual, so Paige's loss is disallowed.
Question 3
Hint
Before deciding whether the loss is capital or ordinary, first ask whether a current loss is allowed at all when property is sold within a family.
Answer D. Under IRC Section 267, losses on sales or exchanges between related parties (including a parent and child) are not currently deductible by the seller. Dana realized a $50,000 loss (basis $230,000 − sale $180,000), but that loss is disallowed in Year 1 because the buyer is her son.
Why not A: This is tempting because investment land normally produces a capital gain or loss on sale, but the related-party loss disallowance (IRC §267) prevents Dana from deducting the loss in Year 1 when she sold to her son.
Why not B: This confuses a taxable sale with a gift or nonrecognition transfer. In a purchase, the buyer's basis is generally the purchase price, not a carryover of the seller's basis; the correct issue here is that the seller's loss is disallowed under the related-party rule.
Why not C: A bona fide sale at fair market value does not override the related-party loss rule. Also, even if the loss were allowed, loss on investment land would be capital in character, not ordinary.
Question 4
Hint
Focus first on whether the buyer and seller are related under the tax rules, and then determine what that does to a loss on the sale.
Answer B. Under IRC §267, losses from sales of property between related parties are disallowed. Lee owns 90% of Pine, so Lee and Pine are related parties and the $30,000 loss is disallowed (not deductible) by Lee. Therefore Lee recognizes no loss in Year 1.
Why not A: This is tempting because investment land would ordinarily generate a capital loss on sale. However, the related-party loss disallowance under IRC §267 overrides the normal character analysis here, so Lee cannot recognize the loss.
Why not C: This distractor confuses the buyer's intended use with the seller's deduction. The buyer's future use does not convert the seller's loss to an ordinary deduction; the related-party rule disallows the loss regardless of Pine's intended use.
Why not D: Many students assume a disallowed loss is merely deferred for the seller. Under §267 the seller's loss is disallowed (not deductible) and Lee does not later claim that loss when Pine disposes of the land to an unrelated party.
Question 5
Hint
Before deciding whether the loss is capital, ordinary, or disallowed, first determine whether the buyer falls within the tax law's related-party family group.
Answer C. IRC §267 disallows deductions for losses on sales or exchanges of property between certain related parties, including parent and child. Because Paula sold the land to her daughter, the $30,000 loss is not deductible in Year 1 even though the sale was bona fide and at fair market value. The fact that the land is an investment asset (which would otherwise produce a capital loss) is therefore overridden by the related-party rule.
Why not A: This is tempting because investment land is a capital asset and a sale at a loss would normally produce a capital loss. However, IRC §267 disallows losses on sales between related parties (parent-child), so the capital loss cannot be deducted in Year 1.
Why not B: Some may think that an arm's-length sale should permit recognition of the loss, but the related-party loss disallowance applies regardless of whether the sale was bona fide or at fair market value. Also, investment land would not generate an ordinary loss in these facts.
Why not D: Buyer's basis is generally the purchase price, not the purchase price plus the seller's disallowed loss. While there are limited rules that may affect later recognition if the related buyer disposes of the property to an unrelated party, the disallowed loss is not simply added to the buyer's basis at the time of the related-party sale.
Question 6
Hint
First decide whether Mason and Cedar are related parties under the tax rules. If they are, ask whether a loss is recognized at all before worrying about capital versus ordinary character.
Answer D. Under the related-party loss disallowance (Sec. 267), losses on sales between an individual and a corporation more than 50% owned by that individual are disallowed. Mason owns 100% of Cedar, so his $50,000 realized loss ($180,000 sale proceeds − $230,000 basis) is not recognized in Year 1. Because the loss is disallowed, its character (capital versus ordinary) is irrelevant for recognition.
Why not A: A realistic trap is thinking the loss is merely deferred until the buyer's later sale. That is incorrect: the loss is disallowed to Mason and does not become deductible later when Cedar sells to an unrelated party.
Why not B: Tempting because the land was held for investment and would normally produce a capital loss, but Sec. 267 disallows losses on sales between an individual and a >50%-owned corporation, so Mason cannot recognize a capital loss in Year 1.
Why not C: This appeals to candidates focusing on economic loss or mischaracterizing the asset, but the related-party rules disallow the loss entirely regardless of whether it would be capital or ordinary.
Common questions
How much loss can a seller deduct on a related-party sale?
Lane realizes a $20,000 loss but deducts $0 because Lane owns 100% of Pine, the buyer. Section 267 disallows the loss.
Does selling at fair market value avoid §267?
No. Lane’s bona fide sale at fair market value still produces a disallowed loss because Lane and Pine are related.
Can the seller deduct the disallowed loss when the buyer resells?
No. Lane does not receive a deferred deduction when Pine later sells the land.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Related party transactions
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.