PracticeTCPFree practice exam

TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 6 practice questions

Related-Party Sale: Seller’s Loss Disallowed

A seller cannot deduct a loss on a sale to a related party, even at fair market value. Below: a step-by-step land sale example separates the realized loss from the deductible amount.

The ruleUnder §267(a)(1), a loss on a sale between related parties is disallowed, even if the sale is bona fide and at fair market value.

Try one first

In Year 1, Reed sold investment land to his 100%-owned corporation for $120,000 cash. Reed's adjusted basis in the land was $150,000. Assume the sale was bona fide, the land was a capital asset in Reed's hands, and no other nonrecognition rule applies. How much loss, if any, may Reed deduct on the sale in Year 1?
Hint

First decide whether Reed and the corporation are related parties for loss-disallowance purposes; only then worry about the amount and character of the loss.

Step by step

  1. Read the sale facts

    Lane sells investment land to Pine Corp. for $70,000 cash, its fair market value. Lane’s adjusted basis is $90,000, Lane owns 100% of Pine, and the sale is bona fide with no other special rules.

  2. Confirm the related-party relationship

    An individual and a corporation more than 50% owned by that individual by value are related under §267. Lane’s 100% ownership meets this test.

  3. Calculate the realized loss

    Subtract Lane’s $90,000 adjusted basis from the $70,000 sale proceeds. Lane realizes a $20,000 loss.

  4. Apply the loss disallowance

    Section 267 disallows the entire $20,000 loss. Holding the land for investment does not make that loss deductible.

  5. Reject the fair-value exception

    The $70,000 price equals fair market value, but that fact does not change the answer. A bona fide sale does not override the related-party loss rule.

  6. State the seller’s result

    Lane realizes a $20,000 loss but deducts $0. The loss is disallowed, not deferred for Lane to deduct when Pine later sells.

Key points

  • Remember: A realized loss is not necessarily deductible; §267 blocks the seller’s deduction when the buyer is related.
  • Investment-property status does not rescue a disallowed loss.
  • The seller’s loss is disallowed, not deferred until the buyer resells.

How the exam traps you

  • Deducting the realized loss because the land was investment property. Apply §267 before allowing a capital loss deduction.
  • Treating a bona fide sale at fair market value as an exception. The relationship still disallows the seller’s loss.
  • Saving the loss for the seller to deduct after the buyer resells. The seller’s disallowed loss is not a deferred deduction.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Paige owns 100% of Lark, a C corporation. In Year 1, Paige sold investment stock to Lark for $27,000 cash, which equaled the stock's fair market value on the sale date. Paige's adjusted basis in the stock was $35,000. Assume the stock was a capital asset to Paige and that no other special rule applies. What is the required federal income tax treatment of Paige's Year 1 sale?
Hint

First determine whether Paige and Lark are related parties under the tax loss-disallowance rules. Then decide whether the loss is recognized, deferred, or fully barred.

Question 3

In Year 1, Dana sold investment land to her son for $180,000 in a bona fide sale. Dana's adjusted basis in the land was $230,000, and the sale price equaled the land's fair market value on the sale date. Assume no installment sale issues and no other special rules apply. For federal income tax purposes, which statement is correct regarding Dana's Year 1 tax result?
Hint

Before deciding whether the loss is capital or ordinary, first ask whether a current loss is allowed at all when property is sold within a family.

Question 4

In Year 1, Lee owns 90% of Pine Corporation. Lee sells investment land to Pine for $70,000. Lee's adjusted basis in the land is $100,000. Assume the sale is otherwise bona fide and no other special rules apply. What is the federal income tax effect to Lee from this sale in Year 1?
Hint

Focus first on whether the buyer and seller are related under the tax rules, and then determine what that does to a loss on the sale.

Question 5

Paula owned vacant land for investment. In Year 1, she sold the land to her adult daughter in a bona fide cash sale for $90,000, which was also the land's fair market value. Paula's adjusted basis in the land was $120,000. Assume Paula is not a dealer in real estate and no other special rule applies. Which statement best describes Paula's Year 1 tax treatment from this sale?
Hint

Before deciding whether the loss is capital, ordinary, or disallowed, first determine whether the buyer falls within the tax law's related-party family group.

Question 6

In Year 1, Mason owns 100% of Cedar Corporation. Mason sells land held for investment to Cedar for $180,000. Mason's adjusted basis in the land is $230,000, and Cedar does not assume any liabilities on the property. For Year 1, how much loss may Mason recognize on the sale?
Hint

First decide whether Mason and Cedar are related parties under the tax rules. If they are, ask whether a loss is recognized at all before worrying about capital versus ordinary character.

Drill all 144 Related party transactions questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

How much loss can a seller deduct on a related-party sale?

Lane realizes a $20,000 loss but deducts $0 because Lane owns 100% of Pine, the buyer. Section 267 disallows the loss.

Does selling at fair market value avoid §267?

No. Lane’s bona fide sale at fair market value still produces a disallowed loss because Lane and Pine are related.

Can the seller deduct the disallowed loss when the buyer resells?

No. Lane does not receive a deferred deduction when Pine later sells the land.

Practice TCP like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Related party transactions

All Related party transactions practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.