TCP · Property Transactions (disposition of assets) · 13 practice questions
§267(d): Gain or Loss on a Related Buyer's Later Sale
Section 267(d) lets a related buyer use the seller's disallowed loss to reduce later gain, but never to create or increase a loss. Below: compare the same land sale with only the resale price changed.
Try one first
Hint
Keep Maya's basis separate from Nora's disallowed loss, and ask whether the later sale produces a gain or a loss.
Answer D. Maya's basis is her cost of $100,000. If she sells for $128,000 she realizes a $28,000 gain, but her recognized gain is reduced to $0 by Nora's previously disallowed $40,000 related‑party loss (the disallowed loss can offset the transferee's recognized gain up to the amount of the gain). If Maya sells for $92,000 she realizes and recognizes an $8,000 loss; the prior disallowed loss cannot increase or create a loss for Maya.
Why not A: This overgeneralizes the related‑party loss rule to mean no subsequent recognition is ever allowed. Only Nora's Year 1 loss was disallowed; Maya's sale to an unrelated buyer can result in recognition of her own loss (or reduction of her gain) under the special offset rule.
Why not B: Tempting because it correctly uses Maya's $100,000 cost basis to compute a $28,000 realized gain and the $8,000 later loss, but it ignores the rule that Nora's disallowed related‑party loss can reduce Maya's recognized gain when Maya later sells to an unrelated buyer.
Why not C: This lures students who think Nora's $40,000 disallowed loss carries over to increase Maya's later loss (8,000 + 40,000 = 48,000). That is incorrect: the prior disallowed loss can only offset Maya's recognized gain on a subsequent sale to an unrelated party, it does not enlarge Maya's loss.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Nora sold investment land to her daughter, Maya, for its $100,000 fair market value. Nora's basis was $140,000, so her $40,000 loss was disallowed under §267. Maya kept the land for investment and later sold it to an unrelated buyer for $120,000. Both sales were bona fide taxable sales. There were no selling expenses, basis adjustments, or other special rules.
Answer: Maya recognizes no gain or loss.
Maya realizes $20,000 gain: $120,000 minus her $100,000 cost. Nora's $40,000 disallowed loss eliminates that gain. The unused $20,000 cannot create a loss or carry forward.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Maya's resale price is $90,000 instead of $120,000.
Answer: Maya recognizes a $10,000 capital loss.
$90,000 minus $100,000 equals a $10,000 loss. Section 267(d) neither eliminates nor increases Maya's own loss.
Change 2Maya's resale price is $160,000 instead of $120,000.
Answer: Maya recognizes a $20,000 capital gain.
Maya realizes $60,000 gain. Subtract Nora's $40,000 disallowed loss to reach $20,000 recognized gain.
Change 3Maya's resale price is $140,000 instead of $120,000.
Answer: Maya recognizes no gain or loss.
Her $40,000 realized gain exactly equals Nora's disallowed loss. This is the upper boundary of the zero-gain range.
Key points
- Remember: The seller's disallowed loss shelters the buyer's gain, not the buyer's loss.
- Maya's basis stays $100,000; Nora's $140,000 basis does not transfer to her.
- Any disallowed loss left after Maya's resale is permanently lost, not a capital loss carryforward.
How the exam traps you
- Using Nora's $140,000 basis to compute Maya's result. Use Maya's $100,000 purchase cost before applying §267(d).
- Reporting Maya's full realized gain without the offset. Reduce positive realized gain by Nora's $40,000 disallowed loss, but stop at zero.
- Subtracting $40,000 even when Maya already has a loss. Recognize Maya's actual loss without increasing it.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer C. Correct. Nora's $40,000 disallowed loss fully offsets Maya's $20,000 realized gain.
Why not A: Incorrect. This is realized gain before applying Nora's disallowed loss.
Why not B: Incorrect. The offset cannot turn Maya's $20,000 gain into a loss.
Why not D: Incorrect. Nora's disallowed loss does not become Maya's deductible loss.
Question 2
Answer A. Correct. Maya's $90,000 proceeds minus her $100,000 cost produce a $10,000 loss.
Why not B: Incorrect. Section 267(d) does not eliminate Maya's separate realized loss.
Why not C: Incorrect. Nora's disallowed loss cannot increase Maya's $10,000 loss.
Why not D: Incorrect. Maya's proceeds are below her cost, so she has a loss.
Question 3
Answer D. Correct. The $60,000 realized gain exceeds Nora's $40,000 disallowed loss by $20,000.
Why not A: Incorrect. This ignores the $40,000 offset for Nora's disallowed loss.
Why not B: Incorrect. The $40,000 offset cannot eliminate all $60,000 of realized gain.
Why not C: Incorrect. This is the offset amount, not Maya's remaining gain.
Question 4
Answer B. Correct. Maya's $40,000 realized gain is exactly offset by Nora's $40,000 disallowed loss.
Why not A: Incorrect. This is realized gain before the §267(d) offset.
Why not C: Incorrect. The offset eliminates gain but does not create a loss.
Why not D: Incorrect. Maya's $100,000 cost is her basis, not her gain.
Question 2
Hint
First compute Park Corp.'s realized gain (amount realized minus basis); then apply the related‑party loss rule (see IRC §267) to determine whether and how the seller's previously disallowed loss affects the purchaser's recognized gain.
Answer C. Under IRC §267, a loss on a sale between related parties is disallowed. If the related‑party purchaser later sells the property to an unrelated person at a gain, the purchaser's recognized gain is reduced by the amount of the seller's previously disallowed loss, but only to the extent of that gain. Here Park Corp.'s realized gain is 170,000 − 120,000 = 50,000; applying the disallowed $40,000 loss reduces Park Corp.'s recognized gain to $10,000, and Park (the original seller) does not separately deduct the $40,000.
Why not A: This is tempting because it suggests the disallowed loss simply becomes deductible to the original seller when the purchaser later sells; however, IRC §267 ties the treatment of the disallowed loss to the purchaser's later disposition rather than allowing the original seller to claim the loss separately in Year 2.
Why not B: This distractor correctly computes Park Corp.'s gain ignoring §267, but it is incorrect because it omits the special related‑party rule that reduces the purchaser's recognized gain by the seller's previously disallowed loss.
Why not D: This mixes two ideas and is incorrect: while Park Corp.'s recognized gain is reduced by the disallowed loss, the statute does not simultaneously permit the original seller to claim that disallowed loss as a separate deduction when the purchaser sells to an unrelated party.
Question 3
Hint
First determine whether half-siblings are related parties for the loss-disallowance rule, then analyze how a previously disallowed loss affects the buyer's later sale at a gain.
Answer C. Half-siblings are related parties for the loss-disallowance rule, so Beth's $20,000 loss on the sale to Carl is disallowed. Carl's realized gain on his later sale is $15,000 ($85,000 − $70,000), but that gain is reduced by the previously disallowed $20,000 loss; the reduction cannot produce a negative amount, so Carl recognizes neither gain nor loss.
Why not A: This ignores the related-party loss rule; although Carl's gross economic gain is $15,000, the transferor's disallowed $20,000 loss must be applied to reduce any later gain on the property.
Why not B: This reflects the error of treating Beth's $90,000 basis as Carl's basis. Carl's basis is his purchase price, $70,000; he did not inherit Beth's basis, and the disallowed loss does not become a carryover basis that would create a loss.
Why not D: This wrongly assumes the disallowed loss transfers to Carl as a deductible loss. The rule only permits the previously disallowed loss to offset any later recognized gain on the property and cannot create a recognized loss for Carl.
Question 4
Hint
Work in two steps: first determine whether Dana and RCo were related at the original sale (apply spouse attribution); then compute RCo's realized gain and compare it to any previously disallowed related-party loss under the related-party resale limitation.
Answer A. Dana is treated as a >50% owner of RCo because Dana directly owned 40% and is treated as owning the spouse's 20%, so Dana's Year 1 $60,000 capital loss on the related-party sale was disallowed. RCo's basis is its purchase price ($260,000), so the Year 2 realized gain is $40,000. Under the related-party resale limitation (IRC Sec. 267(d)), recognized gain on the later unrelated-party sale is limited by the previously disallowed loss; because RCo's $40,000 realized gain does not exceed the $60,000 disallowed loss, RCo recognizes no gain or loss. Any excess of the disallowed loss remains disallowed and does not become a transferee deduction or increase transferee basis.
Why not B: Tempting because it computes RCo's realized gain (300,000 − 260,000) and stops there. It is wrong because it ignores the related-party resale limitation that can eliminate recognition when a previously disallowed related-party loss exceeds the transferee's realized gain.
Why not C: Tempting if one incorrectly assumes RCo 'steps into' Dana's $320,000 basis. In fact, RCo's basis is its cost ($260,000); the disallowed loss does not create a transferee deductible loss.
Why not D: Tempting if one treats Dana's disallowed loss as transferable to RCo as a deduction. That is incorrect: the disallowed loss can reduce recognized gain on a later unrelated sale only up to the amount of that gain and cannot itself become a transferee deduction.
Question 5
Hint
First determine whether the Year 1 loss is allowed. Then analyze whether the buyer's later sale to an unrelated party gets any benefit from that disallowed loss.
Answer D. Because Mason owned more than 50% of Brook, Mason's Year 1 loss on the sale to Brook is disallowed under the related-party loss rules (IRC Sec. 267). Brook's Year 2 realized gain is $20,000 (110,000 amount realized less 90,000 cost), but the related-party disallowed loss reduces Brook's recognized gain to zero because the $20,000 gain is fully absorbed by Mason's previously disallowed $30,000 loss.
Why not A: Tempting if the candidate treats both transactions as independent investment sales. It is wrong because Mason's loss is disallowed on the sale to a corporation he more-than-50%-owns, and that disallowed loss can reduce the purchaser's later recognized gain on a sale to an unrelated party.
Why not B: Tempting because it applies the related-party rule to Mason but stops there. It is incorrect because the previously disallowed $30,000 loss reduces Brook's recognized gain on the subsequent sale to an unrelated party, so Brook would not recognize the full $20,000 gain.
Why not C: Tempting if the candidate mistakenly gives Brook a carryover basis or treats Mason's disallowed loss as creating additional basis for Brook. That is incorrect: Brook's cost basis is the $90,000 purchase price, and the prior disallowed loss does not create a recognized loss on Brook's subsequent sale.
Question 6
Hint
Work this in two steps: determine whether family constructive-ownership makes Apex related to Jordan, then apply the related-party loss and resale interaction to decide who (if anyone) gets the benefit of the prior disallowed loss.
Answer D. Family constructive-ownership rules cause Jordan to be treated as owning his daughter's 20%, making his constructive ownership 60% and the sale a related-party transaction. Under the related-party loss rule, Jordan's $80,000 loss on the Year 1 sale is disallowed. When Apex later sells at a $40,000 gain, that gain is absorbed by the previously disallowed loss, so Apex recognizes no gain and Jordan does not later deduct the remaining $40,000.
Why not A: This is tempting if the candidate looks only at direct ownership. The facts state family constructive-ownership applies, so Jordan is treated as owning an additional 20% and the transaction is between related parties, which triggers the loss disallowance.
Why not B: This correctly notes the initial disallowance and Apex's cost basis, but it fails to apply the related-party resale interaction: Apex's later $40,000 gain is reduced by the transferor's previously disallowed loss, so Apex recognizes no gain in Year 2.
Why not C: This reflects a common misconception that the transferor's disallowed loss is deferred to the transferor. In fact, the transferor does not later deduct the loss; only the transferee may apply the prior disallowed loss to reduce its own recognized gain on a later sale to an unrelated party.
Question 7
Hint
First determine whether the Year 1 sale is between related parties under the tax rules. Then ask how a previously disallowed loss affects the buyer's gain when the buyer later sells to an unrelated party.
Answer A. Because Amber owns more than 50% of Red Corp, the Year 1 sale is a related-party transaction under IRC §267, so Amber's $20,000 realized loss is disallowed. Red's basis is its cost of $70,000, so its realized gain on the Year 2 sale is $25,000. Under §267(d), Red may offset that gain by Amber's previously disallowed $20,000 loss, so Red recognizes only $5,000 of gain.
Why not B: This correctly applies the related-party loss disallowance to Amber but stops short: under §267(d) the buyer (Red) can reduce its later recognized gain by the seller's previously disallowed $20,000 loss, so Red would not recognize the full $25,000.
Why not C: Tempting if the candidate treats the sale as arm's-length. It's wrong because §267 disallows Amber's loss on a sale to a corporation she controls; the seller cannot recognize the $20,000 loss in Year 1.
Why not D: This mixes one correct rule with one incorrect one. Amber cannot both recognize the loss in Year 1 and also have Red benefit from that same disallowed loss; the $5,000 recognized by Red reflects the effect of Amber's loss being disallowed in Year 1 and then applied against Red's later gain.
Question 8
Hint
First decide whether the seller's Year 1 loss is allowed under related‑party rules; then determine Bee's basis (its cost) and whether a disallowed seller loss increases the buyer's basis.
Answer A. Under IRC §267, losses on sales between related parties are disallowed, so Lana's $20,000 realized loss (basis $90,000 − proceeds $70,000) is not deductible in Year 1. Bee's basis is its purchase price ($70,000); when Bee sold the land for $65,000 in Year 2 it recognized a $5,000 loss. A disallowed related‑party loss does not increase the transferee's basis and therefore cannot be used to create or enlarge a transferee's loss.
Why not B: Tempting because it treats the disallowed seller loss as if it 'follows' the property and offsets the buyer's tax outcome. It fails because §267 disallows the seller's loss but does not transfer that loss to increase the buyer's basis; Bee's basis is $70,000, so Bee still realizes a $5,000 loss on the Year 2 sale.
Why not C: Tempting if one incorrectly assumes Bee steps into Lana's $90,000 basis (which would yield a $25,000 loss). It fails because a purchaser's basis is generally the purchase price; the seller's disallowed loss does not transfer to increase the buyer's basis.
Why not D: Tempting because the numeric computations are correct if you ignore related‑party rules. It fails because Lana and Bee are related (Lana owns 100% of Bee), so Lana's $20,000 loss in Year 1 is disallowed under §267 and is not deductible.
Question 9
Hint
Work the transaction in two stages: first decide what happens to the seller's loss, then determine whether the buyer's later gain can be adjusted by that previously disallowed loss.
Answer B. A loss on a sale between siblings is disallowed under the related-party loss rules, so Olivia cannot recognize her $22,000 loss in Year 1. Ethan's basis is his cost of $70,000, so his Year 2 sale produces a $12,000 realized gain; that realized gain is reduced by Olivia's previously disallowed $22,000 loss, but only to the extent of his gain. Therefore Ethan recognizes no gain or loss.
Why not A: This ignores the related-party loss disallowance: a sale between siblings disallows Olivia's loss. Because of that disallowance, Ethan's later gain is subject to reduction by the previously disallowed loss, so he does not necessarily recognize the full $12,000.
Why not C: This correctly disallows Olivia's loss but overlooks the rule that a previously disallowed related-party loss can reduce the buyer's later recognized gain when the buyer sells to an unrelated party; Ethan's $12,000 realized gain is eliminated by Olivia's $22,000 disallowed loss (to the extent of the gain).
Why not D: This incorrectly assumes Ethan takes Olivia's basis (or otherwise applies the disallowed loss to create a loss for Ethan). Ethan's basis is his purchase cost of $70,000, and the disallowed loss can at most reduce his later gain, it cannot convert his later sale into a recognized loss.
Common questions
How much gain does the buyer recognize under §267(d)?
Subtract the seller's previously disallowed loss from the buyer's realized gain, but not below zero. Maya recognizes zero at a $120,000 resale price and $20,000 gain at $160,000.
Does the related buyer use the seller's basis?
No. In this taxable purchase, Maya's basis is her $100,000 cost, not Nora's $140,000 basis.
Can unused related-party loss create a loss or carry forward?
No. At a $120,000 resale price, Maya uses $20,000 of Nora's disallowed loss to eliminate her gain. The remaining $20,000 is permanently lost.
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Related party transactions
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.