TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 8 practice questions
Sec. 357(c): Gain When Liabilities Exceed Basis
Sec. 357(c) requires each transferor to recognize the excess of assumed liabilities over that transferor's aggregate adjusted basis. Below: follow Lee's calculation and see how Lee's additional cash contribution eliminates the gain.
Try one first
Hint
Start with the general nonrecognition rule for a qualifying incorporation, then check whether a liability-related exception changes the result.
Answer B. Under Sec. 351 transfers are generally nonrecognition, but Sec. 357(c) requires the transferor to recognize gain to the extent liabilities assumed by the transferee exceed the adjusted basis of the property transferred. Here liabilities assumed ($42,000) exceed basis ($30,000) by $12,000, so Taylor recognizes $12,000 of gain.
Why not A: Tempting because Sec. 351 generally defers gain, but Sec. 357(c) creates an exception when assumed liabilities exceed the property's basis, so recognition may occur.
Why not C: This equals the realized gain (FMV $50,000 minus basis $30,000). Realized gain is not necessarily recognized in a qualifying Sec. 351 exchange; recognized gain here is limited to the excess of liabilities assumed over basis ($12,000).
Why not D: This incorrectly treats the entire assumed liability as recognized. Only the amount by which liabilities assumed exceed the transferred property's basis is recognized under Sec. 357(c), not the full liability amount.
Step by step
- Start with the qualifying exchange
Lee transfers equipment (basis $20,000; FMV $90,000) and unencumbered land (basis $8,000; FMV $25,000) to Pine Corp, which assumes the equipment's $35,000 business liability; Morgan contributes $50,000 cash. Both receive only stock, Sec. 351 otherwise applies, Sec. 357(b) does not apply, and no liability is excluded from Sec. 357(c).
- Separate the transferors
Calculate Lee's excess using only Lee's transferred property and assumed liability. Morgan's $50,000 cash does not enter Lee's calculation.
- Add Lee's adjusted bases
Lee's aggregate adjusted basis is $20,000 + $8,000 = $28,000, including the unencumbered land. The $115,000 total FMV is not the amount used in this test.
- Compute the liability excess
Pine assumes $35,000, exceeding Lee's $28,000 aggregate basis by $7,000. Lee recognizes $7,000 under Sec. 357(c).
- Identify the basis shortfall
Lee needs $7,000 more adjusted basis in the same exchange to match the $35,000 liability. The needed amount is the liability excess, not the equipment's separate $15,000 shortfall.
- Contribute the additional cash
If Lee contributes $7,000 cash in the same exchange and receives no cash, Lee's aggregate basis becomes $35,000. Liabilities now equal basis, so Sec. 357(c) gain is zero.
Key points
- Remember: Combine one transferor's assets, not different transferors' bases.
- High fair market value does not replace adjusted basis in this test.
- Cash contributed adds its dollar amount to the contributing transferor's basis total.
How the exam traps you
- Test only Lee's encumbered equipment and recognize $15,000. Include Lee's $8,000 land basis; the aggregate test produces $7,000.
- Add Morgan's $50,000 cash to Lee's basis and recognize nothing. Morgan's contribution does not increase Lee's transferred basis.
- Compare the $35,000 liability with Lee's $115,000 total FMV and recognize nothing. Use Lee's $28,000 adjusted basis, not FMV.
Question 2
| Parcel | Adjusted Basis | FMV | Liability Assumed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parcel 1 | $20,000 | $80,000 | $50,000 |
| Parcel 2 | $25,000 | $60,000 | $20,000 |
Hint
Start with whether the transfer qualifies under Sec. 351, then ask whether the liability-assumption rule changes the usual nonrecognition result. Be careful whether the comparison is made per asset or in total.
Answer D. Section 351 nonrecognition generally applies when property is transferred to a controlled corporation for stock. However, under Sec. 357(c) the transferor must recognize gain to the extent the corporation's assumed liabilities exceed the transferor's aggregate adjusted basis of the transferred property. Total liabilities = $50,000 + $20,000 = $70,000; total basis = $20,000 + $25,000 = $45,000; excess = $25,000, which is recognized.
Why not A: Tempting because Sec. 351 normally defers gain when only stock is received, but Sec. 357(c) requires recognition to the extent assumed liabilities exceed the transferor's aggregate basis. Because liabilities exceed basis here, some gain is recognized.
Why not B: Incorrect: liabilities assumed are not automatically treated as boot in a Sec. 351 exchange. Only the excess of liabilities over the transferor's aggregate basis is recognized under Sec. 357(c), so the recognized amount here is $25,000, not the full $70,000.
Why not C: This reflects the mistake of comparing liability to basis on an asset-by-asset basis. Sec. 357(c) compares aggregate liabilities assumed to the transferor's aggregate adjusted basis for all transferred property, so the recognized amount is $70,000 - $45,000 = $25,000, not $30,000.
Question 3
Hint
Work in order: (1) test cash received under Sec. 351(b); (2) test whether assumed liabilities exceed the aggregate adjusted basis under Sec. 357(c); then (3) apply Sec. 358(a) to compute the stock basis (start with aggregate transferred basis, subtract cash and liabilities, add recognized gain).
Answer D. Dana recognizes $5,000 for the cash boot under Section 351(b). Because Oak's assumed liabilities ($25,000 + $50,000 = $75,000) exceed the aggregate adjusted basis of the transferred property ($40,000 + $30,000 = $70,000) by $5,000, Dana must also recognize $5,000 under Section 357(c), for total recognized gain of $10,000. Under Section 358(a), the stock basis is computed from the transferor's aggregate basis ($70,000) reduced by cash received and liabilities assumed ($5,000 + $75,000) and increased by recognized gain ($10,000), which yields a $0 basis immediately after the exchange.
Why not A: Tempting because it recognizes only the cash boot under Section 351(b), but it ignores the additional $5,000 recognition triggered by Section 357(c) when assumed liabilities exceed the aggregate adjusted basis; total recognition is $10,000, not $5,000.
Why not B: This treats only the cash boot as recognized and likewise miscalculates basis. It fails to apply Section 357(c)'s liability-excess recognition and the correct Sec. 358(a) basis computation, so both the recognition and basis amounts are incorrect.
Why not C: This option has the correct total recognized gain but miscomputes the stock basis. Under Section 358(a) liabilities assumed reduce the starting basis and the recognized gain is then added back; the arithmetic yields a $0 basis, not $5,000.
Question 4
Hint
Apply two filters: (1) under the stated assumption, who counts as a property transferor for the Section 351 80% control test? (2) compare corporation-assumed liabilities to the transferor's aggregate adjusted basis in property transferred (Section 357(c)).
Answer D. Two separate defects exist. Under the question's stated assumption, North would not count as a property transferor because he would receive stock solely for services, so Lane would own only 70% and the Section 351 80% control test fails. Separately, Section 357(c) requires recognition of gain to the extent liabilities assumed by the corporation exceed the transferor's aggregate adjusted basis in property transferred; here Lane's basis ($90,000 equipment + $20,000 cash = $110,000) is less than the $150,000 liability (the liability is attributable to Lane as the transferor of the encumbered equipment). Option D remedies both defects by adding a property transferor to meet the control test and increasing Lane's transferred basis to eliminate recognition under §357(c).
Why not A: Tempting because assumed bona fide liabilities are not always treated as taxable boot, but this ignores the control test defect: under the question's assumption North's service-only stock does not count, so Section 351 would not apply as planned and the expected nonrecognition relief would not be available.
Why not B: Fixing the 80% control test alone would satisfy Section 351, but it does not eliminate recognition under §357(c): Lane's aggregate adjusted basis transferred would still be $110,000, less than the $150,000 liability, so gain would be recognized to the extent of the excess.
Why not C: Delaying issuance might make Lane the sole initial stock recipient and resolve the control issue, but it does not address the separate §357(c) problem; unless Lane increases his aggregate transferred basis to cover the assumed liability, gain will be recognized to the extent the liability exceeds his basis.
Question 5
Hint
First decide whether the incorporation meets Sec. 351's control requirement. Then separately test whether the assumed liability changes the nonrecognition result.
Answer A. Sec. 351 applies because Jill and Omar were both property transferors, and together they controlled Harbor immediately after the exchange. Cash is property for this purpose, so Omar counts in the control group. Under Sec. 357(c), Jill must recognize gain to the extent the liability assumed ($60,000) exceeds her aggregate adjusted basis in the transferred property ($50,000), so she recognizes $10,000 of gain.
Why not B: This is tempting because it applies the general Sec. 351 rule correctly at first. But it stops too soon. Even when Sec. 351 otherwise applies, Sec. 357(c) requires gain recognition if the liabilities assumed exceed the transferor's aggregate adjusted basis in the property transferred.
Why not C: This distractor targets the common mistake of thinking only noncash assets count as property in a formation. Cash is property for Sec. 351 purposes, so Omar is part of the control group. Because Jill and Omar together owned all Harbor stock immediately after the exchange, the control requirement was met.
Why not D: This is tempting because students often remember that liability relief can trigger gain. But the assumption of liability is not automatically fully taxable or treated as gain equal to the entire debt. Here, absent tax-avoidance issues, Jill recognizes only the excess of liabilities over basis, which is $10,000.
Question 6
Hint
Start with the general Sec. 351 rule, then check whether the assumed liability exceeds the transferor's basis before you compute the stock basis.
Answer B. Although Sec. 351 generally provides nonrecognition, Sec. 357(c) requires Reed to recognize gain to the extent the liability assumed by the corporation exceeds the adjusted basis of the property transferred. The excess is $20,000 ($70,000 mortgage less $50,000 basis), so Reed recognizes $20,000 of gain. Reed's stock basis is computed as basis transferred ($50,000) plus gain recognized ($20,000) minus liability assumed ($70,000) = $0.
Why not A: Tempting because of the general Sec. 351 nonrecognition rule and the carryover-basis idea, but it ignores Sec. 357(c). Because the mortgage assumed exceeds Reed's basis, Reed must recognize $20,000 of gain and the assumed liability reduces the stock basis.
Why not C: This reflects correctly reducing basis for the assumed liability and the idea that basis cannot end up negative, but it fails to apply Sec. 357(c): the $20,000 excess of the liability over Reed's basis is recognized as gain, so Reed does have recognized gain even though the final stock basis is $0.
Why not D: This correctly identifies the Sec. 357(c) gain but incorrectly leaves the stock basis at $50,000 as if the $70,000 liability did not reduce it. The correct basis calculation is $50,000 + $20,000 - $70,000 = $0.
Question 7
Hint
Do the analysis in two steps: first identify who is treated as a property transferor for the Section 351 control test, then determine whether any counted transferor must recognize gain because liabilities assumed exceed adjusted basis under Section 357(c).
Answer B. Stock issued for services is taxable compensation and is not counted toward the Section 351 control test unless the service provider also transfers property of more than a relatively small value. Cruz's $1 cash is a relatively small contribution, so only Allen and Baker are treated as property transferors and they own 80% of the stock immediately after the exchange, satisfying Section 351. Under Section 357(c), Allen must recognize gain to the extent the liabilities assumed exceed his adjusted basis ($30 − $25 = $5); Baker has no recognized gain, and Cruz recognizes ordinary income for the services.
Why not A: This distractor tempts candidates who treat any transfer (including nominal cash or stock issued for services) as property for 351. In fact, stock issued for services is taxable compensation and a $1 cash contribution of relatively small value does not make Cruz a counted property transferor for the control test, so he has ordinary income rather than tax-free 351 treatment.
Why not C: This choice appeals to candidates who conclude 351 fails and therefore all built-in gains are recognized. It is incorrect because Allen and Baker together hold 80% of the stock after the exchange, meeting the Section 351 control requirement, so the large FMV-based gains would not be recognized in that event.
Why not D: This distractor attracts candidates who incorrectly believe liability assumptions never trigger recognition. While liabilities are treated differently for 351 boot analysis, Section 357(c) separately requires a transferor to recognize gain to the extent liabilities assumed exceed the transferor's adjusted basis; Allen's assumed liability exceeds his basis by $5.
Question 8
Hint
Confirm Sec. 351 control, then treat recognition in layers: test cash received under Sec. 351(b) and test whether liabilities assumed exceed the transferor's aggregate adjusted basis under Sec. 357(c); compute aggregate basis and realized gain to check any cap.
Answer D. Under Sec. 351 transfers to a controlled corporation are generally nonrecognition, but Sec. 351(b) requires recognition to the extent cash (boot) is received and Sec. 357(c) requires recognition to the extent liabilities assumed exceed the transferor's aggregate adjusted basis. Lee's aggregate adjusted basis = $20,000 + $8,000 = $28,000; Pine assumed $35,000, so the excess is $7,000; Lee also received $5,000 cash. Recognized gain cannot exceed realized gain; realized gain on the transferred property = ($90,000 + $25,000) - $28,000 = $87,000, so the cap does not bind and Lee recognizes the full $5,000 + $7,000 = $12,000.
Why not A: Tempting because Sec. 351 often results in nonrecognition for transfers to a controlled corporation, but incorrect here because Lee received $5,000 cash (boot) and Pine assumed liabilities in excess of Lee's aggregate basis, both of which can trigger recognition.
Why not B: This reflects recognizing only the cash boot under Sec. 351(b). It is incomplete because Sec. 357(c) also requires recognition to the extent liabilities assumed ($35,000) exceed Lee's aggregate basis ($28,000), producing an additional $7,000 of recognition.
Why not C: This reflects recognizing only the Sec. 357(c) excess-liability amount. It is incomplete because Lee also received $5,000 cash boot, so both amounts are recognized (subject to the realized-gain limit), yielding $12,000 here.
Common questions
Is Sec. 357(c) calculated per asset or per transferor?
Per transferor, using the aggregate adjusted basis of that person's property transferred in the same exchange. Lee includes both the equipment and the unencumbered land.
Can another shareholder's cash contribution prevent Sec. 357(c) gain?
Not for Lee. Morgan's $50,000 contribution does not offset Lee's $7,000 excess because each transferor is tested separately.
How much cash must Lee contribute to avoid Sec. 357(c) gain?
Lee must contribute $7,000 in the same exchange, with no cash received. That raises Lee's aggregate basis from $28,000 to $35,000, matching the liability assumed.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Formation and liquidation of business entities, worked step by step.
Section 351 Formation & Complete Liquidation | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Formation and liquidation of business entities
All Formation and liquidation of business entities practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.