TCP · Entity Tax Planning · 7 practice questions
Section 351 Boot: How Much Gain Is Recognized?
In a qualifying Section 351 exchange, recognized gain is the lesser of realized gain or boot received. Below: a worked calculation separating cash boot from an assumed business liability.
Try one first
Hint
First compute realized gain, then apply the Sec. 351 rule that limits recognized gain when boot is received.
Answer A. Under section 351, transfers to a corporation solely for stock are generally nonrecognition transactions. However, when the transferor receives boot (cash), gain is recognized to the extent of the boot but not more than the realized gain. Here realized gain = $120,000 - $70,000 = $50,000, and boot = $20,000, so recognized gain = $20,000.
Why not B: This reflects the incorrect belief that Sec. 351 always defers all gain. Nonrecognition applies only when the transfer is solely for stock; receipt of $20,000 cash (boot) requires recognition up to the amount of the boot.
Why not C: This is the realized gain (FMV minus adjusted basis) but under Sec. 351 recognized gain is limited to the boot received. Because boot is only $20,000, only $20,000 of the $50,000 realized gain is recognized.
Why not D: This confuses the property's adjusted basis with recognized gain. The $70,000 is basis, not the amount of gain recognized; recognized gain is determined by realized gain and limited by boot received.
Worked example
Morgan transfers land worth $150,000 with a $90,000 adjusted basis to newly formed Elm Corp for all its common stock, worth $110,000, and $20,000 cash. Elm assumes a $20,000 business liability with a bona fide business purpose and no tax-avoidance purpose. Morgan owns 100% immediately afterward, performs no services, and receives no other property. The exchange otherwise qualifies under Section 351.
| 1 | Confirm Section 351 qualificationMorgan transfers property and owns 100% of Elm immediately afterward. | Section 351 applies |
| 2 | Calculate total consideration$110,000 stock + $20,000 cash + $20,000 liability assumed | $150,000 |
| 3 | Calculate realized gain$150,000 total consideration - $90,000 adjusted basis | $60,000 |
| 4 | Identify boot$20,000 cash; no other nonstock property is received. Exclude the $20,000 assumed business liability because it has a bona fide business purpose, no tax-avoidance purpose, and does not exceed the $90,000 adjusted basis of the transferred land. | $20,000 |
| 5 | Apply the recognition limitLesser of $60,000 realized gain or $20,000 boot | $20,000 |
Morgan recognizes $20,000 of gain on the exchange.
Check: The land's appreciation is $150,000 - $90,000 = $60,000, more than the $20,000 cash, so cash sets the answer.
Key points
- Owning 100% of the corporation immediately after transferring property satisfies the control requirement here.
- Include the assumed liability in total consideration when calculating realized gain, even though it is not boot here.
- Realized gain measures the total gain; recognized gain is the amount currently taxable.
How the exam traps you
- Recognizing $0 because Section 351 applies. The $20,000 cash is boot and triggers gain up to the realized gain.
- Recognizing the entire $60,000 realized gain. Apply the boot limit after calculating realized gain. Only $20,000 is recognized.
- Adding the assumed liability to cash and recognizing $40,000. Exclude this qualifying business liability from boot. Only the $20,000 cash counts.
Question 2
Hint
First decide whether the §351 control test is satisfied by the property transferors. Then analyze the tax effect separately for boot and for stock issued solely for services.
Answer B. Alice and Ben's transfers qualify under §351 because they transferred property and together controlled more than 80% of Newco immediately after the exchange, so nonrecognition applies except to the extent of boot. Alice's realized gain is $90,000 - $40,000 = $50,000, but she recognizes only $10,000, the cash boot. Ben received only stock for his $30,000 cash contribution and recognizes no gain. Cara received stock solely for legal services, which is compensation taxable as ordinary income equal to the stock's $10,000 FMV.
Why not A: This is tempting because Alice's realized gain is $50,000, but when §351 applies gain is deferred except to the extent of boot; Alice recognized only the $10,000 cash boot. Also Cara received stock for services and that is taxable as compensation, so she does not recognize no income.
Why not C: This option remembers the §351 nonrecognition rule for Alice and Ben but ignores boot, Alice did receive $10,000 cash and must recognize gain to that extent. It also mischaracterizes Cara's receipt of stock for services, which is ordinary compensation, not capital gain.
Why not D: While it correctly treats Alice's boot gain and Cara's service income, it wrongly asserts that Ben recognizes gain. Cash is property eligible for §351, and because Alice and Ben together controlled more than 80% immediately after the exchange, Ben's contribution of cash in exchange for stock is nonrecognition under §351.
Question 3
Hint
First decide whether the overall exchange qualifies for Sec. 351, then separate true boot from items that may affect basis without causing immediate gain.
Answer B. The exchange qualifies under Sec. 351 because Green and Moss transferred property to Pine and immediately controlled the corporation. Green's realized gain is $60,000 (amount realized of $100,000 less basis of $40,000), but recognition is limited to boot received. The $5,000 cash is boot, so Green recognizes $5,000 of gain. Pine's assumption of the $15,000 liability does not cause additional recognition here because the liability does not exceed Green's basis and no tax-avoidance exception applies.
Why not A: This is tempting because Sec. 351 generally provides nonrecognition when transferors control the corporation immediately after the exchange. However, Green also received $5,000 cash, which is boot and triggers recognition up to the amount of boot received.
Why not C: This distractor relies on the mistaken belief that any liability assumed by the corporation is treated as boot. Under current rules, assumed liabilities do not trigger recognition in a Sec. 351 exchange unless a statutory exception applies (for example, liabilities in excess of the transferor's basis), and that exception is expressly ruled out here.
Why not D: This answer double-counts relief from liability as boot on these facts. Only the $5,000 cash is treated as boot for current recognition; the $15,000 liability assumption does not cause additional recognized gain given the facts provided.
Question 4
Hint
First decide whether Sec. 351 applies. Then separate the assumed liability from true boot before computing both recognized gain and stock basis.
Answer B. Section 351 applies because Dana transferred property to a corporation and controlled it immediately after the exchange. Realized gain = FMV (90,000) − basis (55,000) = 35,000; recognized gain is limited to boot received (the $12,000 cash) so Dana recognizes $12,000. For stock basis: start with the transferred basis (55,000), add recognized gain (12,000), and subtract money received and liabilities treated as money received for basis purposes (12,000 cash + 20,000 liability assumed) = 35,000.
Why not A: This incorrectly treats the assumed $20,000 liability as generating additional recognized gain. Under §357(c) liabilities trigger recognized gain only to the extent they exceed the aggregate adjusted basis; here they do not. It also fails to reduce stock basis for the cash and liability treated as money received for basis purposes.
Why not C: This gets recognized gain correct but ignores that liabilities assumed by the corporation are treated as money received for purposes of computing stock basis (they reduce the transferror's basis in the stock), so the stock basis is overstated here.
Why not D: This overapplies the nonrecognition aspect of §351 and ignores the effect of cash boot. Receipt of cash causes recognition of gain up to the lesser of realized gain and boot, so Dana must recognize $12,000; the stock basis calculation shown here is also inconsistent with the correct basis adjustments.
Question 5
Hint
First decide whether the exchange qualifies for Section 351. Then ask whether Jordan received anything other than stock.
Answer D. Section 351 provides nonrecognition for transfers of property to a corporation controlled by the transferor(s), but any cash received is boot and can trigger recognition. Jordan's realized gain is $20,000 (FMV $50,000 minus basis $30,000). Recognized gain is limited to the lesser of realized gain or boot received, so Jordan recognizes $10,000 of gain.
Why not A: This is tempting because Section 351 generally allows nonrecognition for transfers of property for stock when control exists. However, Jordan also received $10,000 cash (boot), and receiving boot causes gain recognition to the extent of the boot received.
Why not B: This misapplies basis and gain/loss concepts. The land has built-in gain (FMV exceeds basis), not a loss, and Section 351 does not produce a loss result on these facts.
Why not C: This treats the exchange as a fully taxable sale and recognizes the entire realized gain. Under Section 351, recognized gain is capped at the amount of boot received, so recognizing the full $20,000 is incorrect.
Question 6
Hint
First decide whether the exchange falls under Sec. 351, then determine whether Nora received anything other than stock.
Answer A. The transfer qualifies under Sec. 351 because property was transferred to a corporation and the transferors were in control immediately after the exchange. Nora's realized gain is $15,000 (55,000 FMV − 40,000 basis). Because she received $5,000 of boot (cash), she must recognize the lesser of the realized gain or the boot received, so recognized gain is $5,000.
Why not B: Tempting because Sec. 351 generally provides nonrecognition for transfers to controlled corporations, but Nora received cash boot. Receipt of boot triggers recognition up to the amount of the boot.
Why not C: $10,000 might be chosen by someone misallocating gain between stock and cash or making an arithmetic error. The realized gain is $15,000, but recognized gain is limited to the boot received ($5,000), so $10,000 is incorrect.
Why not D: This is the full realized gain. In a qualifying Sec. 351 exchange the full realized gain is recognized only if boot received equals or exceeds the realized gain; Nora received only $5,000, so $15,000 is not recognized.
Question 7
Hint
First determine whether the exchange qualifies under Sec. 351, then separate realized gain from recognized gain and decide whether the assumed liability counts as boot.
Answer C. Because the exchange qualifies under §351, Lee generally recognizes no gain except to the extent of boot received. The only boot here is the $15,000 cash (the §357 conditions in the fact pattern mean the liability assumption is not treated as boot). Lee's realized gain on the land is $100,000 − $60,000 = $40,000, so recognized gain is limited to the $15,000 cash boot.
Why not A: This is tempting because §351 normally allows nonrecognition when only stock is received. However Lee received $15,000 cash (boot), so some gain must be recognized to the extent of that boot.
Why not B: This answer results from incorrectly treating both the $15,000 cash and the $10,000 liability assumption as boot (15,000 + 10,000 = 25,000). Under the facts given the liability assumption does not count as boot.
Why not D: This equals Lee's realized gain (FMV − basis). In a qualifying §351 exchange recognized gain is limited to the boot received, not the full realized gain.
Common questions
How do you calculate recognized gain under Section 351 with cash boot?
First calculate realized gain using total consideration minus adjusted basis. Then recognize the lesser of that gain or cash boot: here, the lesser of $60,000 or $20,000.
Does an assumed liability count as boot under Section 351?
Generally, no. Here, the $20,000 liability has a bona fide business purpose, no tax-avoidance purpose, and does not exceed the land's $90,000 adjusted basis, so it triggers no additional gain.
Does owning 100% of the corporation eliminate gain on cash received?
No. Ownership satisfies the control requirement here, but the cash still triggers $20,000 of recognized gain because realized gain exceeds the cash received.
Watch it solved
A full CPA TCP task-based simulation on Formation and liquidation of business entities, worked step by step.
Section 351 Formation & Complete Liquidation | CPA TCP TBS on YouTube
Practice TCP like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Formation and liquidation of business entities
All Formation and liquidation of business entities practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.