REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 6 practice questions
UBTI: Debt-Financed Property Rents and Gains
Acquisition debt brings otherwise excluded real-property rent and investment sale gains into UBTI to the debt-financed extent. Below, follow one museum building from rental to sale and compare the debt-free result.
Try one first
Hint
Start with the general exclusions for rents and capital gains, then consider whether the debt used to acquire the building causes part of those amounts to be treated as UBTI under the debt‑financed rules.
Answer D. Under IRC §§512(b)(3) and 514, income and gains from property that are attributable to acquisition indebtedness are treated as unrelated business taxable income to the debt‑financed extent. Although rents from real property and capital gains are generally excluded from UBTI, the debt‑financed property rules ''pull back'' otherwise excluded rents and disposition gains to the extent they are attributable to acquisition indebtedness that existed while the property was held and at disposition. The museum's facts (debt used to acquire the building, debt outstanding while held and at sale, and no exception) therefore cause both the rents and the gain to be UBTI to the debt‑financed portion.
Why not A: This is tempting because of the basic exclusions for rents and capital gains, but it ignores the specific debt‑financed rules. IRC §§512(b)(3) and 514 provide that amounts attributable to acquisition indebtedness are treated as UBTI, so the exclusion does not apply to the debt‑financed portion.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to the idea that applying sale proceeds to repay debt triggers inclusion. Inclusion is not dependent on how sale proceeds are used; it is based on whether acquisition indebtedness existed and financed the property while it was held, which can cause both rents and gains to be UBTI to the debt‑financed extent.
Why not C: This option confuses dealer/inventory treatment with debt‑financed income. Even though the property was not dealer inventory, the debt‑financed property rules can convert otherwise excluded capital gain into UBTI to the debt‑financed extent.
Step by step
- Read the museum's facts
A section 501(c)(3) museum buys an office building solely for investment, partly with acquisition debt. It leases the building to unrelated tenants in Year 1, provides only customary landlord services, and sells at a gain in Year 2 with the debt still outstanding; no statutory exception applies.
- Start with the normal exclusions
Real-property rent and investment-property sale gains are generally excluded from UBTI. With no acquisition indebtedness at any time, the museum's rent and gain would remain excluded under these facts.
- Identify acquisition indebtedness
The loan financed the building's purchase and remains outstanding during rental and at sale. The building is therefore debt-financed property under these facts.
- Apply the exception to rent
The debt-financed portion of the museum's rental income enters UBTI. Providing only customary landlord services does not override the debt-financed property rule.
- Apply the exception to gain
The debt-financed portion of the sale gain also enters UBTI. Holding the building for investment does not preserve the exclusion for that portion.
- Limit the inclusion
Choose the conclusion that includes both rent and gain only to the debt-financed extent. Acquisition debt defeats complete exclusion, but it does not automatically make the full amounts includible.
Key points
- Remember: Acquisition debt overrides both exclusions, but only the debt-financed portion enters UBTI.
- Customary landlord services do not protect rental income from the acquisition-debt test.
- Tax-exempt status alone does not keep the museum's investment income out of UBTI.
How the exam traps you
- Exclude all rent because the building is real property. Check acquisition indebtedness before applying the normal rent exclusion.
- Exclude the sale gain because the building was held for investment. Apply the debt-financed property rule to the gain too.
- Include all rental income and all gain because acquisition debt exists. Include only the portions attributable to acquisition indebtedness.
Question 2
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| dividends from an investment portfolio | $80,000 |
| rent from an office building it owns; the building was debt-financed for the entire year, average acquisition indebtedness was 25% of average adjusted basis, and the museum provided no services other than customary maintenance | $120,000 |
| regularly selling display advertising in the museum's quarterly magazine distributed to the public | $40,000 |
Hint
Classify each income item separately before combining anything. For the rent, do not stop at the general exclusion for real property.
Answer C. Dividends are generally excluded from UBTI. The $40,000 from regularly sold advertising is unrelated business income and is taken into account. Because the building is debt-financed, the debt-financed portion of the rent (25% of $120,000 = $30,000) is included under the debt-financed income rules, so total gross income taken into account for UBTI is $40,000 + $30,000 = $70,000.
Why not A: This is tempting because dividends and rents from real property are generally excluded, but the debt-financed rules make a portion of the rent includible. With acquisition indebtedness equal to 25% of basis, 25% of the $120,000 rent ($30,000) is included along with the $40,000 advertising income.
Why not B: This overstates the rule. Debt-financed property income is included only to the extent of the debt-financed percentage (based on average acquisition indebtedness relative to basis), not the full rental amount. Here only 25% of the rent ($30,000) is includible.
Why not D: UBTI is determined by the character of the income-producing activity, not by how the proceeds are used. Unrelated advertising income and the debt-financed portion of rental income can be taken into account even when the proceeds support exempt operations.
Question 3
Hint
Identify the statutory exclusions (rent, royalties, donated merchandise, volunteer labor) and then consider whether a special rule, such as unrelated debt‑financed income, converts an otherwise excluded item into UBTI.
Answer C. Rent from real property is generally excluded from UBTI (see IRC §512(b)(3)), but the unrelated debt‑financed income (UDFI) rules in IRC §514 treat the portion of income attributable to acquisition indebtedness as UBTI. Because the office building was purchased with acquisition mortgage debt, the portion of the rental income attributable to that acquisition indebtedness will be treated as UBTI even though only customary landlord services are performed.
Why not A: This is tempting because licensing can resemble commercial exploitation, but true royalty income is excluded from UBTI when the arrangement is a license rather than a services or advertising contract; customary quality‑control approvals typically preserve royalty characterization.
Why not B: Operating a snack bar is ordinarily an unrelated trade or business, but the volunteer‑labor exception excludes income when substantially all of the work is performed without compensation, so these facts point to an exclusion from UBTI.
Why not D: Selling merchandise is commonly UBTI, but the donated‑merchandise exception excludes the proceeds when substantially all items sold were contributions or gifts, making this choice non‑UBTI under the stated facts.
Question 4
Hint
Look for any rental activity where financing of the property could alter the usual exclusion for rent; debt on the property can change the UBTI analysis.
Answer B. Rental income from real property is generally excluded from UBTI, but that exclusion is displaced for unrelated debt-financed income when the property is subject to acquisition indebtedness (see IRC §514). Because the museum's building is subject to acquisition indebtedness and is leased to unrelated tenants, the rental receipts are treated as debt‑financed UBTI. The other activities are either substantially related to the museum's educational mission (catalog sales and seminars) or meet the donated-goods/volunteer exceptions (thrift sale) and therefore do not present the primary UBTI issue.
Why not A: Tempting because sales look commercial, but when merchandise is directly tied to and furthers the museum's educational exhibitions it typically meets the substantial-relation test; income that is substantially related to the exempt purpose is not UBTI.
Why not C: A recurring sale can resemble a trade or business, yet the donated-goods and volunteer exceptions commonly exclude such activity from UBTI when the facts show the goods were donated and the event was substantially staffed by volunteers as stated here.
Why not D: Charges for curator-led seminars are likely to be substantially related to the museum's exempt educational purpose; income that advances the exempt purpose generally is not treated as UBTI.
Question 5
Hint
Start by asking whether rent from real property stays excluded when the property is debt-financed. Then determine whether the debt percentage applies only to income or to both income and deductions.
Answer B. The property is debt-financed, so the rent is treated as debt-financed income to the extent of the debt ratio. Debt ratio = $300,000 / $1,200,000 = 25%; 25% × $200,000 = $50,000 of gross income is debt-financed and 25% × $80,000 = $20,000 of directly connected deductions are allocable to debt-financed income. Net included in UBTI before the specific deduction = $50,000 − $20,000 = $30,000.
Why not A: Tempting because rent from real property is often excluded from UBTI, but that exclusion is limited when the property is debt-financed. Since acquisition indebtedness existed, a portion of the net rental income (the debt-financed portion) must be included.
Why not C: Reflects applying the 25% debt ratio to gross rental income only. This ignores that directly connected deductions must be prorated by the same debt ratio, which reduces the includible amount to $30,000.
Why not D: $120,000 is the full net rental income (200,000 − 80,000). That would be included only if the property were 100% debt-financed; here only 25% is debt-financed, so only $30,000 is included.
Question 6
Hint
Apply the general UBTI rule and then test each activity for a specific statutory exclusion or exception. Pay particular attention to whether rental income is debt-financed and therefore treated as UBTI only to the extent of acquisition indebtedness.
Answer D. Rental income from real property is generally excluded from UBTI, but the unrelated debt-financed income rules treat income from property that is acquisition debt-financed as unrelated debt-financed income and includible in UBTI to the extent it is attributable to the acquisition indebtedness (see IRC §514). Because acquisition indebtedness on the office building remained outstanding during Year 1, the portion of rental income attributable to that indebtedness is the most likely source of UBTI. The other activities are excluded under the donated-merchandise, volunteer-labor, and convenience-of-employees exceptions given the stated facts.
Why not A: Tempting because retail sales can appear commercial, but receipts from the sale of merchandise substantially all of which was received as gifts or contributions are excluded from UBTI under the donated-merchandise rule; here the goods are donated.
Why not B: Tempting because food service is often an unrelated trade or business, but when substantially all of the work is performed by unpaid volunteers the volunteer-labor exception generally prevents treating those receipts as UBTI under these facts.
Why not C: Tempting because charging for parking can be a commercial activity, but a trade or business carried on primarily for the convenience of an organization's employees is excluded from UBTI; the fact pattern indicates employee use is primary.
Common questions
Is rental income from a debt-financed building UBTI for a 501(c)(3)?
Yes, to the extent attributable to acquisition indebtedness when no statutory exception applies. Providing only customary landlord services does not prevent that inclusion.
Can gain on the sale of debt-financed property be UBTI?
Yes. With acquisition debt outstanding at sale, the museum includes the debt-financed portion of its gain even though it held the building for investment.
Is rent from a debt-free investment building excluded from UBTI?
Under the museum's facts, yes, if there was no acquisition indebtedness at any relevant time. With that change alone, both the rent and investment sale gain remain excluded.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax-exempt organizations
- 501(c)(3) Automatic Revocation Date: Three Missed Filings
- UBTI Test: Trade or Business, Regularity, and Relatedness
- Qualified Sponsorship vs. Advertising: UBTI for 501(c)(3)s
- Form 990-T: The $1,000 Gross-Income Filing Threshold
- How to Compute UBTI for a 501(c)(3): Example
- §501(c)(6): Industrywide Improvement vs Member Services
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.