REG · Federal Taxation of Entities · 6 practice questions
501(c)(3) Automatic Revocation Date: Three Missed Filings
A 501(c)(3) required to file annually automatically loses exemption on the due date of its third consecutive missed return or notice. Follow Harbor's missed 990-N and 990-EZ filings through revocation and the later IRS notice.
Try one first
Hint
Count the three required filings and ask which event the automatic-revocation rule identifies as the effective date: a filing due date, a calendar-year end, or an IRS notice.
Answer D. Under the automatic-revocation rule (IRC §6033(j)), an organization that fails to file a required annual return or notice for three consecutive years is revoked by operation of law on the due date of the third missed return/notice. For a calendar-year filer the Year 3 return is due May 15 of Year 4, so revocation is effective on May 15, Year 4.
Why not A: This is tempting because it marks the close of the third year with no filings, but revocation is not triggered by year-end. The statutory trigger is the due date of the third missed return/notice, which falls after year-end.
Why not B: This is plausible because it is the start of the year after three misses, but entering the next tax year is not the legal trigger. The effective date is the due date of the third missed annual return/notice (May 15 for a calendar-year filer), not January 1.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the idea that the IRS must act to revoke status, but the law provides for automatic revocation on the third missed filing's due date; an IRS notice only informs the organization of a status change that already took effect.
The timeline
- May 15, Year 2Harbor misses its Year 1 Form 990-N deadline.
Harbor Arts Alliance is a calendar-year 501(c)(3) required to file annually. Assume no extensions or relief. This is its first missed filing.
- May 15, Year 3Harbor misses its Year 2 Form 990-N deadline.
The second required notice is not filed. Harbor now has two consecutive missed annual filings.
- December 31, Year 3Harbor's third tax year ends.
The Year 3 filing is not due until May 15, Year 4. The end of the third tax year does not trigger revocation.
- May 15, Year 4Harbor misses its Year 3 Form 990-EZ deadline.
This is the third consecutive missed required filing. The change in form does not reset the count. Exemption is automatically revoked effective today.
- September 30, Year 4The IRS mails Harbor an automatic-revocation letter.
The letter reports a revocation already effective May 15, Year 4. Its mailing date does not change the effective date.
Key points
- Remember: The third consecutive missed filing's due date triggers revocation, not the third tax year's end.
- A switch from Form 990-N to Form 990-EZ does not restart the nonfiling count.
- Match each tax year to its following-year filing deadline before choosing the revocation date.
How the exam traps you
- Revoking exemption on December 31, Year 3. Use May 15, Year 4, the third missed filing's original due date.
- Ignoring Years 1 and 2 because Form 990-N is only a notice. A required Form 990-N counts just like a required annual return.
- Using September 30, Year 4, when the IRS mails its letter. The letter reports revocation; it does not trigger it.
Question 2
Hint
Use the 27-month filing window, but measure it from the end of the month of organization rather than from the exact day the entity was formed.
Answer D. A §501(c)(3) organization that must apply generally receives recognition from its formation date if it files a complete application within 27 months after the end of the month in which it was organized. For an organization formed in April Year 1, that 27-month deadline is July 31 Year 3, so filing on July 31 Year 3 is timely and yields retroactive recognition to the formation date. The other organizations filed after their respective 27-month deadlines and, absent late-filing relief, would generally be recognized only from the filing date.
Why not A: This distractor trips up candidates who forget that the 27-month window is measured from the end of the month. A January Year 1 organization must generally file by April 30 Year 3; filing on May 1 Year 3 is one day late and therefore not timely absent relief.
Why not B: This choice is plausible if the student does not measure from the end of the organization month. A June Year 1 organization must generally file by September 30 Year 3; filing on October 1 Year 3 is late.
Why not C: Some may count 27 months from the exact date instead of the end of the month. A May Year 1 organization must generally file by August 31 Year 3; filing on September 1 Year 3 misses the deadline by one day.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the difference between applying for exemption and filing annual reports, and pay attention to how long it has been since formation.
Answer D. An organization that otherwise qualifies should file the appropriate exemption application (Form 1023 or Form 1023‑EZ, if eligible) within 27 months from the end of the month in which it was formed to obtain recognition effective from the date of formation. Here, the organization formed March 15, 20X5 and the board asked on May 1, 20X6, so it is still within that 27‑month window. Filing now maximizes the chance that the IRS will recognize exemption retroactive to formation; waiting risks losing that retroactive effect.
Why not A: Filing Form 1120 (a corporate income tax return) is not the appropriate step for an organization seeking 501(c)(3) recognition, and there is no general rule requiring a two‑year operating history before applying. Delaying the application can forfeit retroactive recognition.
Why not B: Form 990 is an annual information return for tax-exempt organizations and does not itself establish 501(c)(3) status. Waiting also risks missing the 27‑month timely-filing period needed for exemption to be effective from formation.
Why not C: State incorporation creates a nonprofit under state law but does not automatically create federal tax exemption under §501(c)(3). An IRS recognition application is required for federal tax-exempt status unless a specific automatic exemption applies (not indicated here).
Question 4
Hint
First decide whether the application was filed within the 27-month period measured from the end of the month of formation. Then ask what date a timely approved exemption usually relates back to.
Answer D. A Section 501(c)(3) organization that files its application within 27 months from the end of the month in which it was organized generally receives recognition of exemption retroactive to its date of formation. Here, July 31, Year 3 is within that 27-month window for an organization formed on April 12, Year 1. Therefore, the exemption is generally recognized as of April 12, Year 1.
Why not A: The determination letter is the formal confirmation of status, but a timely filed and approved application ordinarily results in retroactive recognition to the date of formation. The letter confirms approval; it does not usually set a later effective date in this fact pattern.
Why not B: This is tempting because the 27-month filing period is measured from the end of the month of formation. However, that end-of-month rule is used only to test whether the filing was timely; if timely, recognition generally relates back to the actual date of formation, not the month-end date.
Why not C: This reflects the common mistake of assuming exemption begins only on the filing date. When an application is filed late, recognition may only begin on the filing date absent relief. Here the filing was within the 27-month window, so recognition generally goes back to formation.
Question 5
Hint
Separate state nonprofit formation from federal exempt recognition, and focus on the timing step a new Sec. 501(c)(3) usually must take.
Answer C. A new organization that wants recognition as a Sec. 501(c)(3) generally should timely apply to the IRS for recognition of exemption. Because Harbor is not in an exception category such as a church and expects more than nominal receipts, relying only on state nonprofit status would be inappropriate. If it otherwise qualifies and files within the 27-month window, the IRS can generally recognize exemption as of the date of formation.
Why not A: A taxable corporation cannot simply deduct charitable program expenses as a substitute for tax-exempt status; filing Form 1120 would not create Sec. 501(c)(3) recognition or the benefits that come with it.
Why not B: Candidates may blur state-law nonprofit status with federal tax exemption, but state incorporation alone does not create federal exemption under Sec. 501(c)(3); Harbor must apply for IRS recognition unless it falls into a limited automatic-exemption category (excluded here).
Why not D: Electing S corporation status is a tax classification for for-profit entities and does not confer 501(c)(3) charitable status or qualified-donation treatment; it is not an appropriate route to nonprofit exemption.
Question 6
Hint
Identify the event that legally triggers automatic revocation after three consecutive nonfilings. It is not based on waiting for IRS action.
Answer A. Under IRC section 6033(j), an organization's tax-exempt status is automatically revoked if it fails to file the required annual return or notice for three consecutive years. The revocation is effective on the filing due date for the third missed annual filing (which would be the extended due date if an extension had been timely requested). Because Harbor missed Year 1, Year 2, and Year 3 and requested no extensions, the revocation is effective on the Year 3 filing due date.
Why not B: Tempting because students often think in calendar years, but the statutory trigger is the due date of the third missed filing, not the calendar year-end.
Why not C: Tempting because IRS correspondence feels authoritative, but the revocation is automatic by statute after three consecutive missed filings; the IRS notice simply confirms that revocation.
Why not D: This reflects a miscounting error; the statute requires three consecutive failures, so a fourth missed filing is not necessary for automatic revocation.
Common questions
When is a calendar-year 501(c)(3) automatically revoked for three missed filings?
Harbor's missed Year 1, Year 2, and Year 3 filings cause revocation on May 15, Year 4. That is the original due date of the Year 3 filing, not December 31, Year 3.
Does failing to file Form 990-N count toward automatic revocation?
Yes. Harbor's two missed Form 990-N notices and missed Form 990-EZ return make three consecutive missed annual filings.
Does an IRS revocation letter determine the effective date?
No. Harbor's September 30, Year 4, letter reports a revocation already effective May 15, Year 4.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax-exempt organizations
- UBTI Test: Trade or Business, Regularity, and Relatedness
- Qualified Sponsorship vs. Advertising: UBTI for 501(c)(3)s
- Form 990-T: The $1,000 Gross-Income Filing Threshold
- UBTI: Debt-Financed Property Rents and Gains
- How to Compute UBTI for a 501(c)(3): Example
- §501(c)(6): Industrywide Improvement vs Member Services
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.