REG · Federal Taxation of Individuals · 9 practice questions
Form 1040 Refund or Balance Due: Credits and Payments
Nonrefundable credits reduce regular tax only to zero; add other taxes before comparing total tax with payments and refundable credits. Below, follow one Form 1040 example from regular tax to balance due.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the calculation into two parts: first reduce tax with the nonrefundable credit, then compare remaining tax to refundable credits and withholding.
Answer D. The $1,200 nonrefundable credit can reduce Reed's $1,000 tax to zero, but it cannot create a negative tax; the extra $200 of nonrefundable credit is lost. After the nonrefundable credit reduces tax to zero, Reed is entitled to the $500 refundable credit and has $300 withheld, totaling $800 available for refund. Therefore, Reed receives an $800 refund.
Why not A: This stems from stopping the calculation after applying the nonrefundable credit. Even with tax reduced to zero, refundable credits and withholding can generate a refund, so Reed is due an $800 refund.
Why not B: This reflects the error of treating the nonrefundable credit as refundable (allowing it to reduce tax below zero). A nonrefundable credit is limited to the tax liability, so only $1,000 of the $1,200 can be used; the extra $200 does not increase the refund.
Why not C: This choice ignores wage withholding. After the nonrefundable credit reduces tax to zero, both the $500 refundable credit and $300 withholding apply, for an $800 refund, not $500.
Step by step
- List the return amounts
For Year 1, Nori has $6,300 regular tax, a $1,100 nonrefundable credit, $500 additional tax on an early IRA distribution, $3,900 withholding, $200 estimated payments, and a $700 refundable credit. All amounts are allowable; no other items apply.
- Apply nonrefundable credits
$6,300 regular tax minus the $1,100 nonrefundable credit leaves $5,200. Nonrefundable credits cannot reduce regular tax below zero.
- Add other taxes
Add the $500 early IRA distribution tax to the remaining $5,200. Nori's total tax is $5,700.
- Total payments and refundable credits
$3,900 withholding + $200 estimated payments + $700 refundable credit = $4,800 total payments. Keep these amounts separate from the total tax calculation.
- Determine refund or balance due
Total tax of $5,700 exceeds payments of $4,800 by $900. Nori reports a $900 balance due, not a refund.
Key points
- Remember: Nonrefundable credits reduce tax; refundable credits count as payments.
- Withholding and estimated payments do not change the total tax line.
- A refundable credit does not guarantee a refund when total payments remain below total tax.
How the exam traps you
- Omitting the early IRA distribution tax produces a $400 balance due. Add the $500 additional tax after nonrefundable credits and before comparing total tax with payments.
- Ignoring estimated payments produces a $1,100 balance due. Include the $200 estimated payment along with withholding and the refundable credit.
- Leaving out the refundable credit produces a $1,600 balance due. Add the $700 refundable credit to payments, even though the return still shows a balance due.
Question 2
| Tax Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Regular income tax before credits | $6,300 |
| Allowable nonrefundable credit | $1,100 |
| Additional tax on an early IRA distribution | $500 |
| Federal income tax withheld | $3,900 |
| Estimated tax payments | $200 |
| Allowable refundable credit | $700 |
Hint
Compute total tax first, including any additional taxes and nonrefundable credits. Then compare that result with all payments and refundable credits.
Answer D. Compute total tax first: regular tax $6,300 minus the nonrefundable credit $1,100 plus the additional IRA distribution tax $500 gives total tax of $5,700. Total payments and refundable credits equal $3,900 (withheld) + $200 (estimated) + $700 (refundable credit) = $4,800. The balance due is $5,700 − $4,800 = $900.
Why not A: This results from subtracting the nonrefundable credit from regular tax (6,300 − 1,100 = 5,200) and comparing to payments (4,800) but forgetting to add the $500 additional IRA distribution tax; the additional tax must be included in total tax.
Why not B: This comes from ignoring the refundable credit ($700). Refundable credits are treated as payments and reduce the amount due dollar for dollar, so omitting it overstates the balance.
Why not C: This overstates the balance if a candidate omits the $200 estimated tax payment; estimated payments reduce the balance due just like withholding does.
Question 3
Hint
Separate items that reduce income, reduce tax, add to tax, and count as payments. One of these belongs in the 'other taxes' category.
Answer B. Self-employment tax is an additional tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes for self-employed individuals) that is included in total tax on the return. Although one-half of self-employment tax is deductible for AGI, the self-employment tax itself increases total tax rather than reducing income or acting as a payment.
Why not A: A deductible traditional IRA contribution reduces adjusted gross income (an above-the-line deduction), so it reduces taxable income rather than increasing total tax.
Why not C: A child tax credit is a credit applied against tax liability and therefore reduces total tax, not increases it.
Why not D: Federal income tax withheld from wages is treated as a payment (a withholding credit) against the taxpayer's liability, not as an item that increases total tax.
Question 4
Hint
Ask two questions: Does the item reduce income or reduce tax, and what does "nonrefundable" prevent from happening?
Answer A. A nonrefundable credit reduces tax liability dollar for dollar, but only up to the amount of tax owed. Here, Maya's $1,500 credit offsets her $1,200 tax liability and reduces her tax to zero; because the credit is nonrefundable and no refundable credits or payments are present, the extra $300 cannot be refunded to her.
Why not B: This is tempting because both deductions and credits lower a taxpayer's overall tax burden. However, a tax credit is applied after taxable income and tax are computed; it directly reduces the tax liability rather than reducing taxable income.
Why not C: This distractor relies on confusing nonrefundable and refundable credits. A nonrefundable credit can reduce tax to zero but, by itself, cannot generate a refund beyond the tax liability unless the credit is explicitly refundable or other refundable amounts exist.
Why not D: Some tax benefits (above-the-line deductions) reduce AGI, which then affects taxable income. A nonrefundable credit is not an adjustment to income; it is applied after taxable income and tax have been calculated.
Question 5
Hint
Compute the return in two parts: first reduce tax by any nonrefundable credit, then compare the remaining tax with withholding plus any refundable credit.
Answer D. Start with the $5,000 tax and subtract the $800 nonrefundable credit, leaving $4,200 of tax. Payments equal $4,000 withheld plus the $700 refundable credit = $4,700. Because payments exceed tax by $500, Avery is entitled to a $500 refund.
Why not A: This comes from comparing tax before credits to withholding only: $5,000 - $4,000 = $1,000. It is wrong because both the nonrefundable credit (which reduces tax) and the refundable credit (which counts as a payment) affect the final amount.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate applies only the nonrefundable credit: $5,000 - $800 = $4,200, compared with $4,000 withheld, leaving $200 due. It ignores the $700 refundable credit, which increases payments and can create a refund.
Why not C: This reflects applying only the refundable credit: $5,000 - $700 = $4,300, compared with $4,000 withheld, leaving $300 due. It is incorrect because the $800 nonrefundable credit also reduces tax before comparing to payments.
Question 6
Hint
First reduce tax using nonrefundable credits, but do not let them go below zero. Then consider which remaining items can still be refunded.
Answer A. Nonrefundable credits can only reduce Lee's $2,400 tax liability to zero, so $300 of the $2,700 nonrefundable credits are unused. After tax is reduced to zero, the refundable credits of $600 and the $500 withholding are refundable amounts. Therefore, Lee receives a total refund of $1,100.
Why not B: This reflects the mistake of applying nonrefundable credits below zero and then treating the excess as refundable; nonrefundable credits cannot create a refund when they exceed tax.
Why not C: This shows the error of counting only refundable credits and forgetting that withholding is also a payment that can generate a refund once tax is zero.
Why not D: This option ignores that after nonrefundable credits reduce tax to zero, remaining refundable credits and withholding still produce a refund.
Question 7
Hint
Compute in order: regular income tax, then nonrefundable credits, then additional taxes, then withholding and other payments.
Answer D. The $5,200 nonrefundable credit can reduce Rivera's $4,800 regular income tax to zero but cannot create a negative regular tax. The $600 additional tax is then added, so total tax is $600. With $3,000 withheld, Rivera receives a refund of $3,000 - $600 = $2,400.
Why not A: This assumes the candidate correctly limits the nonrefundable credit to eliminating the regular tax but forgets that the $600 additional tax must still be added before netting withholding.
Why not B: This comes from incorrectly applying the $5,200 credit against the combined $4,800 regular tax plus $600 additional tax (total $5,400). Nonrefundable credits reduce the regular income tax to zero first; the additional tax is added afterward.
Why not C: This reflects correctly recognizing the $600 additional tax after the credit but failing to account for the $3,000 of withholding, which more than covers the remaining tax.
Question 8
Hint
First reduce tax using the nonrefundable credit, but do not let tax go below zero. Then consider which remaining amounts can still be refunded.
Answer D. Apply the nonrefundable credit first: it can only reduce tax to zero, so only $1,200 of the $1,500 nonrefundable credit is usable and the remaining $300 is lost. That reduces Riley's tax liability to zero. The $1,000 refundable credit and the $900 withholding are refundable payments, producing a total refund of $1,900.
Why not A: This reflects returning only the withholding and ignores that the $1,000 refundable credit is also refunded once tax liability is reduced to zero.
Why not B: This counts the refundable credit but overlooks the $900 of tax withholding, which is also refundable after tax liability is eliminated.
Why not C: This incorrectly treats the entire $1,500 nonrefundable credit as refundable. Nonrefundable credits cannot reduce tax below zero, so $300 of that credit is lost and cannot increase the refund.
Question 9
Hint
Separate the computation into two parts: first reduce tax by nonrefundable credits, then compare the remaining amount to withholding and refundable credits.
Answer B. Start with total federal income tax of $4,200. Subtract the $2,000 nonrefundable credit, leaving $2,200 of tax due. Then apply the $900 refundable credit and the $1,100 withholding (total payments/credits = $2,000). Because $2,200 exceeds $2,000, Taylor still owes $200.
Why not A: This is tempting if a candidate applies the nonrefundable credit and the withholding but forgets the refundable credit: 4200 - 2000 = 2200, then 2200 - 1100 = 1100. The $900 refundable credit must also be applied, which reduces the balance to $200 owed.
Why not C: This mistakes the refundable credit as automatically producing a refund without considering the tax after nonrefundable credits and other payments. Here, after the nonrefundable credit there is still $2,200 of tax, so the refundable credit plus withholding do not fully cover the balance.
Why not D: This results from stopping after subtracting the nonrefundable credit (4200 - 2000 = 2200) and failing to apply withholding and the refundable credit, both of which reduce the final amount due.
Common questions
What order do credits and payments follow on Form 1040?
Subtract nonrefundable credits from regular tax, stopping at zero, then add other taxes. Compare that total tax with withholding, estimated payments, and refundable credits.
Do refundable credits reduce total tax on Form 1040?
No. Nori's $700 refundable credit increases total payments; it does not reduce the $5,700 total tax line.
Why do I owe tax if I have a refundable credit?
A refundable credit counts as a payment, but all payments combined may still fall short of total tax. Nori's $4,800 of payments leaves $900 due against $5,700 of total tax.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Tax Computation, worked step by step.
Individual Tax Computation | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax Computation
- Qualified Dividends and Long-Term Capital Gains: Tax Stacking
- Capital Loss Limits: $3,000, $1,500 MFS, and Carryovers
- Capital Gain Buckets: Section 1250 and Collectibles
- Head of Household: Married but Considered Unmarried
- How to Calculate NIIT: The 3.8% Lesser-of Rule
- How Much Social Security Is Taxable? Provisional Income
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.