REG · Federal Taxation of Individuals · 4 practice questions
Capital Gain Buckets: Section 1250 and Collectibles
Qualified dividends and general long-term gains use 0%/15%/20% rates, while unrecaptured Section 1250 and collectibles gains have separate ceilings. Sort Taylor's alternative income items into rate buckets before applying tax rates.
Try one first
Hint
First assign each item to its statutory tax category (qualified dividends/regular LTCG; unrecaptured §1250; collectibles; short-term gain), then apply the applicable maximum or ordinary rates.
Answer C. Because Taylor's ordinary taxable income (excluding the listed items) already exceeds the threshold for the highest long-term capital gains/qualified dividend rate, qualified dividends and the regular long-term capital gain are taxed at 20%. Unrecaptured §1250 gain is a separate statutory category subject to a maximum 25% rate, and collectibles gain is a separate category subject to a maximum 28% rate. Short-term capital gains are taxed as ordinary income and do not receive long-term preferential rates.
Why not A: This choice tempts those who focus on form rather than tax treatment, dividends are not capital gains in form. Qualified dividends, however, are taxed under the same preferential long-term capital gain schedule (0%/15%/20%) and therefore receive the preferential rate here.
Why not B: This distractor lures by overgeneralizing the 20% rate to all long-term-type gains. It is incorrect because unrecaptured §1250 gain and collectibles gain are distinct categories with their own maximum rates (25% and 28%), not the general 20% rate.
Why not D: This option misclassifies unrecaptured §1250 gain as eligible for the general 20% rate. In reality, unrecaptured §1250 gain is taxed under a separate rule with a maximum 25% rate.
Sort it
Qualified dividends or remaining net long-term gain outside the §1250 and collectibles categories.
The amount is identified as unrecaptured §1250 gain after capital gain and loss netting.
The amount is net long-term collectibles gain after capital gain and loss netting.
The amount is a net short-term capital gain, even if the asset is a collectible.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| $25,000 of unrecaptured §1250 gain. | Unrecaptured §1250: up to 25%This separately identified gain has a 25% ceiling, not the general 20% ceiling. |
| $20,000 of qualified dividends falling entirely in the 15% band. | General 0%/15%/20%Qualified dividends use the general preferential schedule. Here, the applicable rate is 15%. |
| $7,000 of short-term stock gain. | Ordinary ratesShort-term gain uses ordinary rates, not the long-term capital gain schedule. |
| $15,000 of long-term collectibles gain less a $10,000 short-term capital loss carryforward. | Collectibles: up to 28%Netting leaves $5,000 of collectibles gain. The remaining gain keeps its 28% ceiling. |
| $15,000 of net long-term stock gain when ordinary taxable income already exceeds the 20% capital gain threshold. | General 0%/15%/20%The stock gain belongs in the general bucket. The stated taxable-income position makes its rate 20%. |
| $10,000 of short-term collectibles gain. | Ordinary ratesThe short-term holding period controls. A collectible does not automatically qualify for the 28% ceiling. |
| $25,000 of unrecaptured §1250 gain otherwise taxable at 22%. | Unrecaptured §1250: up to 25%The 25% ceiling does not raise an otherwise applicable 22% rate. |
| $24,000 of qualified dividends alongside $15,000 of long-term collectibles gain and a $10,000 short-term capital loss carryforward. | General 0%/15%/20%The full $24,000 of dividends stays outside capital netting. The loss reduces the collectibles gain instead. |
| $10,000 of net long-term collectibles gain otherwise taxable at 24%. | Collectibles: up to 28%The gain stays in the collectibles bucket, but the 28% ceiling does not raise its otherwise applicable 24% rate. |
| $15,000 of long-term stock gain less a $10,000 short-term capital loss carryforward. | General 0%/15%/20%Netting leaves $5,000 of general long-term gain. Apply the general schedule to that remainder, not the gross $15,000. |
Key points
- Remember: Sort by type before applying rates; long-term gains do not all share the 20% ceiling.
- Net capital gains and losses first; qualified dividends stay outside that netting.
- A rate ceiling is a limit, not an automatic flat rate.
- Each item is a separate alternative for Taylor, with no unlisted capital gains or losses.
How the exam traps you
- Applying the 20% ceiling to every long-term gain. Separate unrecaptured §1250 gain and long-term collectibles gain before applying rates.
- Reducing qualified dividends by a capital loss carryforward. Net the loss against capital gains; keep qualified dividends outside that netting.
- Treating 25% and 28% as mandatory flat rates. These are maximum rates; a lower otherwise applicable ordinary rate is not increased.
Question 2
Hint
Before applying the 0%/15%/20 schedule, identify and separate amounts that carry distinct maximum‑rate ceilings (for example, unrecaptured §1250 or collectibles).
Answer A. Compute tax using the qualified‑dividends and capital‑gain computation. Unrecaptured §1250 gain is subject to a maximum 25% rate and collectible gain to a maximum 28%; those amounts must be segregated and taxed at their ceilings. After removing those amounts, apply the 0%/15%/20 capital‑gain rate structure to the remaining qualified dividends and regular net capital gain.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate thinks character affects only labeling, but it is wrong because qualified dividends and long‑term capital gains receive preferential rates. Computationally, treating the $12,000 of qualified dividends and the $40,000 of long‑term gains ($16k stock + $18k §1250 + $6k collectibles) as ordinary income would ignore both the 0%/15%/20 structure and the 25%/28% special ceilings, producing an incorrect (typically higher) tax.
Why not C: This distractor appeals because it preserves preferential treatment, but it collapses categories that have distinct ceilings. Practically, it would place the $18,000 unrecaptured §1250 and $6,000 collectible gains into the 0%/15%/20 pool, which can under‑tax items that must instead be taxed up to 25% or 28%; §1250 and collectible amounts must be segregated and taxed at their ceilings before applying 0/15/20 to the remainder.
Why not D: This is tempting because many long‑term gains follow the 0%/15%/20 schedule, but it misstates §1250 and collectible treatment. Unrecaptured §1250 gain is not simply ordinary income; it is subject to a maximum 25% rate, and collectibles are subject to a maximum 28% rate, so treating them as ordinary income or otherwise ignoring their ceilings yields an incorrect computation.
Question 3
Hint
Ask first which items actually enter the capital gain/loss netting process, and only then decide which preferential rate applies to what remains.
Answer D. Capital loss carryforwards are applied in the capital gain/loss netting process, so the $10,000 short-term capital loss carryforward reduces the $15,000 long-term collectibles gain, leaving $5,000 of net collectibles gain. Qualified dividends are not part of the capital gain/loss netting process, so the $24,000 of qualified dividends remain unchanged and are taxed at the preferential qualified dividend rate (assumed here to fall in the 15% band). The remaining $5,000 of collectibles gain retains its separate 28% maximum-rate treatment.
Why not A: This distractor plays on the surface similarity that both qualified dividends and certain capital gains receive preferential rates. However, qualified dividends are not capital gains and do not enter the capital gain/loss netting process, so a capital loss carryforward cannot be applied directly against qualified dividends.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate conflates the general 0%/15%/20% long-term capital gain framework with the separate statutory 28% rate for collectibles. Collectibles gain is subject to its own 28% maximum rate and does not automatically convert to the ordinary long-term capital gain rate after netting.
Why not C: This answer appeals to an intuitive 'blend the benefits' approach, but tax rules do not prorate capital loss carryforwards across preferentially taxed items. Capital losses are netted against capital gains; qualified dividends remain outside that netting computation.
Question 4
Hint
First identify which items are in the general qualified-dividend/net-capital-gain bucket and which items have their own special maximum rates. Then determine how much of the general bucket fits between ordinary taxable income and the 20% breakpoint.
Answer A. Qualified dividends plus regular net long-term capital gain equal $70,000 and form the general 0/15/20 bucket. With $430,000 of ordinary taxable income and a $492,000 20% breakpoint, $62,000 of that $70,000 is taxed at 15% ($9,300) and $8,000 at 20% ($1,600). The $30,000 unrecaptured §1250 gain is taxed at 25% ($7,500) and the $20,000 collectibles gain at 28% ($5,600). Summing those amounts yields $9,300 + $1,600 + $7,500 + $5,600 = $24,000.
Why not B: This reflects taxing the entire $70,000 general bucket at 15% (70,000 × 15% = $10,500) while still applying 25% and 28% to the special categories. The error is failing to recognize that $8,000 of the general bucket exceeds the $492,000 breakpoint and should be taxed at 20%, not 15%.
Why not C: This distractor comes from a sequencing mistake that lets the 25% and 28% categories consume part of the room below the 20% breakpoint before slotting in the general 0/15/20 bucket. Under the stacking rules, the general qualified-dividend/regular-LTCG bucket is compared to ordinary taxable income to determine how much receives 15% vs 20% treatment; the special 25% and 28% categories do not determine that split.
Why not D: This results from assuming all $70,000 of qualified dividends/regular LTCG are taxed at 20% (70,000 × 20% = $14,000) because total taxable income exceeds the 20% breakpoint. That ignores the stacking computation where ordinary income is considered first, leaving $62,000 of the $70,000 taxed at 15%.
Common questions
Is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain always taxed at 25%?
No. The 25% rate is a ceiling, so an amount otherwise taxed at 22% stays at 22%.
Do capital loss carryforwards reduce qualified dividends?
Not directly through capital gain and loss netting. Taylor's $10,000 carryforward reduces the $15,000 collectibles gain to $5,000, not the $24,000 of qualified dividends.
Are short-term collectibles gains taxed at 28%?
No. Taylor's $10,000 short-term collectibles gain uses ordinary rates; the 28% ceiling applies to long-term collectibles gain.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Tax Computation, worked step by step.
Individual Tax Computation | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Tax Computation
- Form 1040 Refund or Balance Due: Credits and Payments
- Qualified Dividends and Long-Term Capital Gains: Tax Stacking
- Capital Loss Limits: $3,000, $1,500 MFS, and Carryovers
- Head of Household: Married but Considered Unmarried
- How to Calculate NIIT: The 3.8% Lesser-of Rule
- How Much Social Security Is Taxable? Provisional Income
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.