REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 9 practice questions
Circular 230: Prior-Year Errors and Current Returns
Promptly advise the client of a known prior-year error and its consequences; without consent or a legal duty, do not disclose it to the IRS. Below, compare responses when the client refuses amendment but the current return can be accurate.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the practitioner's duty to the client from any duty to the IRS, and then consider whether the current-year return would perpetuate the prior-year error.
Answer C. Under Circular 230, a practitioner who knows of a client's noncompliance, error, or omission must promptly advise the client of that fact and the potential consequences. There is no general requirement under Circular 230 to notify the IRS of a prior-year omission without the client's consent. Because the Year 2 return can be prepared accurately without perpetuating the Year 1 error, withdrawal is not automatically required.
Why not A: This seems attractive since the omission doesn't carry over, but practitioners who learn of a client's prior noncompliance must still advise the client of the error and its consequences before continuing representation.
Why not B: This is tempting because some candidates think a practitioner must report client noncompliance to the IRS. Circular 230 requires advising the client and discussing corrective steps, but does not impose a general duty to notify the IRS without client authorization.
Why not D: Withdrawal is required only in some circumstances (for example, if continued representation would assist in ongoing or intended wrongdoing). Here the practitioner can prepare an accurate Year 2 return that does not repeat the error, so automatic withdrawal is not mandated by Circular 230.
What should you do?
The situation
While preparing Apex Co.'s Year 2 federal return, you confirm that another firm omitted $40,000 of taxable interest from Apex's filed Year 1 return. The omission affects no Year 2 item. Apex refuses to amend and forbids IRS disclosure. No law requires disclosure. You can prepare Year 2 accurately, but have not calculated the additional Year 1 tax, penalties, or interest. What should you do?
Promptly explain the error and consequences, recommend amendment, and prepare Year 2 accurately.
Best Document the advice and refusal. Accurate Year 2 preparation is permitted; IRS disclosure is neither authorized nor required.
Report Apex's Year 1 omission to the IRS before completing Year 2.
Wrong Circular 230 requires client advice, not automatic IRS reporting. Apex has not consented, and no law requires disclosure.
Require an amended Year 1 return before agreeing to prepare Year 2.
Wrong Amendment is recommended, but not an automatic prerequisite when Year 2 can be accurate without perpetuating the error.
Prepare Year 2 without discussing Year 1 because another firm prepared it.
Wrong Your knowledge requires prompt client advice. Neither the prior preparer's identity nor the unaffected current return removes that duty.
Add the omitted $40,000 to Year 2 income to correct the problem.
Wrong Reporting Year 1 income in Year 2 would misstate Year 2. Recommend correcting the year containing the omission.
Key points
- Remember: Advise the client about Year 1; judge Year 2 by whether Year 2 will be accurate.
- Knowing the error triggers advice; you need not calculate exact tax, penalties, or interest first.
- Document the advice and Apex's refusal to amend.
How the exam traps you
- Treating knowledge of an error as a duty to report the client to the IRS. Advise Apex promptly. Without consent or a separate legal requirement, do not disclose the omission.
- Making amendment of Year 1 an automatic condition for preparing Year 2. Apex's refusal does not automatically bar preparation of an accurate, unaffected Year 2 return.
- Ignoring the omission because another firm prepared Year 1. Your knowledge triggers the duty to advise, regardless of who prepared the earlier return.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on which event (the practitioner's knowledge, calculating liability, an IRS inquiry, or prior-preparer status) triggers the practitioner's duty under Circular 230 and whether the rule requires independently notifying the IRS.
Answer A. Circular 230 requires a practitioner who knows a client has failed to comply with the revenue laws or that a return contains an error or omission to promptly advise the client of the noncompliance, error, or omission and the potential consequences (see Circular 230, 31 C.F.R. ยง 10.21). That duty is triggered by the practitioner's knowledge and does not depend on having prepared the earlier return or on first computing the exact tax. The rule does not impose a general duty to notify the IRS without the client's authorization; the practitioner should discuss corrective options (e.g., amendment, payment, penalties) and consider further steps if the client refuses to correct the error.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates may think a firm quantification is required before acting and that reporting to the IRS is mandatory; however, the practitioner's duty to advise is triggered by knowledge of the omission, not by completing a tax calculation, and Circular 230 does not require unconditional notification of the IRS without client consent.
Why not C: Tempting because some practitioners wait to act until an IRS inquiry surfaces; but Circular 230 requires the practitioner to promptly advise the client once aware of an error or omission. There is no general rule that the practitioner should wait for an IRS question or must proactively disclose the omission to the IRS absent authorization.
Why not D: Tempting because responsibility for preparing a prior return can feel like the trigger for corrective action; however, Circular 230's duty to advise the client applies regardless of who prepared the return. The practitioner representing the client must inform the client of known noncompliance and discuss corrective options.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on what the practitioner must do after discovering a prior-year tax error, and keep separate the duty to advise the client from any duty to report directly to the IRS.
Answer A. Circular 230 requires a practitioner who knows of a client's noncompliance, error, or omission in a return or other document submitted to the IRS to promptly advise the client of that fact and of the potential consequences. The rule does not itself require the practitioner to disclose the prior-year error directly to the IRS without the client's consent, so advising the client is the required next step.
Why not B: This answer confuses ethical duties with mandatory reporting. Circular 230 requires advising the client about known errors but does not automatically compel the practitioner to report the omission to the IRS without client authorization.
Why not C: While encouraging correction is appropriate, Circular 230's clear required action is prompt advice about the omission and consequences; it does not make filing an amended return an automatic precondition to continuing the engagement in every case.
Why not D: Taking no action is insufficient. Once the practitioner knows of the prior-year omission, Circular 230 requires prompt advice to the client about the omission and its potential consequences.
Question 4
Hint
Separate the duty to advise the client from the separate question of whether the CPA may or must disclose to the IRS; ask whether consent or legal compulsion exists.
Answer A. A practitioner who becomes aware that a client has not complied with the tax law or that a return omits material income must promptly advise the client of the issue and its potential consequences, even if the practitioner did not prepare the original return. Except with client consent, a court order, or other legal authority, a CPA generally may not disclose client tax information to the IRS. Lopez should inform Green and encourage corrective action but should not unilaterally notify the IRS on these facts.
Why not B: Why tempting: Candidates may overstate the practitioner's role in protecting tax administration and assume disclosure is required when a material error is found. Why wrong: Client confidentiality is not displaced simply by discovering an omission; disclosure to the IRS requires client consent, a court order, or another legal compulsion, none of which exist here.
Why not C: Why tempting: The omission relates to a return prepared by another firm and falls outside Lopez's narrow engagement, so it may seem outside his duties. Why wrong: A CPA who becomes aware of a client's noncompliance has a professional duty to advise the client about the problem and its consequences regardless of who prepared the earlier return.
Why not D: Why tempting: Immediate withdrawal feels like an appropriate way to avoid complicity in a client's concealment. Why wrong: Withdrawal is not automatically required here; it is mandated only if continuing would cause the practitioner to violate law or professional standards, which is not established by the facts given.
Question 5
Hint
Separate what the CPA must do for the client from what the CPA must do directly with the IRS after discovering a prior-year error.
Answer D. When a practitioner becomes aware of a client's noncompliance, error, or omission on a tax return, the practitioner must promptly advise the client of the issue and its potential consequences and recommend corrective action (such as filing an amended return). Absent fraud or other special circumstances, the practitioner is not generally required to disclose the client's prior-year error directly to the IRS without the client's authorization. The practitioner's duty is to counsel the client and take further steps only as professional standards and facts require.
Why not A: Withdraw might be necessary in some situations, but automatic withdrawal is not the required first step here. The appropriate initial action is to advise the client and recommend corrective action; withdrawal depends on the client's response and additional facts.
Why not B: Tempting because it emphasizes public interest, but practitioners are generally required to advise the client first. Direct disclosure to the IRS is not automatically mandated for nonfraudulent prior-year errors and would breach client confidentiality absent authorization or a specific obligation.
Why not C: This distractor misreads responsibility: the duty to advise arises when a practitioner becomes aware of an error, regardless of who prepared the earlier return. Doing nothing would fail to meet the practitioner's obligation to inform and counsel the client.
Question 6
Hint
Differentiate duties to inform the client versus duties to the IRS, and then ask whether the practitioner may knowingly use information the practitioner knows is incorrect.
Answer D. A practitioner who becomes aware of a client's prior-year error should promptly inform the client and recommend corrective action. Absent a legal requirement or client consent to disclose, the practitioner generally does not report the matter directly to the IRS; withdrawal from the engagement is an appropriate option if the client refuses to correct (see Circular 230; AICPA Code of Professional Conduct). A practitioner must not prepare or sign a return that the practitioner knows is incorrect.
Why not A: A signed client statement may seem to shift responsibility, but it does not permit the practitioner to prepare or sign a return the practitioner knows is incorrect; ethical obligations cannot be cured simply by client acknowledgments.
Why not B: This option is tempting because it appears proactive, but it is incorrect: direct reporting to the IRS is not the default response absent a legal requirement or client consent. The practitioner's first duty is to inform the client and recommend correction; withdrawal (not automatic self-reporting) is the appropriate recourse if the client refuses.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the usual practice of relying on filed prior-year returns, but reliance becomes unreasonable once Lane knows the prior-year information is wrong. Knowingly using the incorrect carryforward would violate professional obligations.
Question 7
Hint
Identify which event, what the practitioner knows or does, triggers the practitioner's initial duty under Circular 230.
Answer C. Circular 230 requires a practitioner who knows that a client has not complied with the revenue laws or who knows of an error or omission in a return to promptly inform the client of the noncompliance and the possible consequences. The practitioner's knowledge of the prior-year omission triggers the duty to advise, regardless of who prepared the earlier return or whether an amendment will ultimately be filed; client decisions or materiality issues affect subsequent steps but do not delay the initial advisory obligation.
Why not A: Why tempting: It reflects a common belief that the practitioner need only speak up if the client refuses to correct an error. Why wrong: Circular 230 requires prompt notice to the client once the practitioner knows of the noncompliance; waiting until a refusal would improperly delay that required advice (the client's later response may change next steps but not the initial duty).
Why not B: Why tempting: It confuses materiality thresholds (relevant for some return positions and follow-up actions) with the basic duty to inform. Why wrong: The duty to advise is triggered by knowledge of the omission itself, not by whether the omission materially changes the later year's tax; materiality may influence what the practitioner does next, but not the obligation to inform the client promptly.
Why not D: Why tempting: Practitioners sometimes associate obligations with the act of signing or filing a return. Why wrong: Circular 230 requires advising the client when the practitioner becomes aware of the noncompliance; the duty is not deferred until the preparation or signing of a subsequent return.
Question 8
Hint
Distinguish the practitioner's duty to advise and to refuse participation in noncompliance from any distinct duty to disclose to the IRS; then decide whether the practitioner may prepare a current-year return that omits known income.
Answer C. Tax-practice standards require a practitioner to promptly advise a client of known omissions or errors, explain potential consequences, and recommend corrective action; they also prohibit preparing or signing a return the practitioner knows omits taxable income. These standards, by themselves and absent separate legal compulsion, do not create a general duty to report the client's prior omission directly to the IRS. Thus Moreno should advise Lee and refuse to prepare or sign a Year 2 return that omits the income.
Why not A: This distractor is tempting because candidates sometimes overstate the practitioner's duty to report clients to the government. It is wrong: the practitioner should advise and must not assist in filing a known false return, but the professional standards do not, by themselves, require unilateral IRS notification absent legal compulsion.
Why not B: Documentation and a written client acknowledgment are important, but they do not permit a practitioner to participate in preparing or signing a return the practitioner knows omits taxable income; the practitioner must refuse to prepare or sign such a return.
Why not D: This choice overstates the immediate obligation to withdraw. Withdrawal may become appropriate if the client persists in noncompliance or the engagement cannot proceed ethically, but the initial professional duties are to advise the client and not to assist in preparing a known noncompliant return.
Question 9
Hint
Separate the practitioner's duty to advise the client from any duty to disclose to the IRS, and then consider whether the requested Year 2 treatment would itself be accurate.
Answer D. Circular 230 requires a practitioner who knows of a client's noncompliance, error, or omission to promptly advise the client of that fact and the potential consequences. Lee is not authorized to disclose the matter to the IRS, but Lee also cannot prepare or sign a return that he knows is inaccurate by shifting Year 1 income into Year 2. Advising the client and refusing the improper Year 2 treatment is the appropriate response under Circular 230.
Why not A: A limited engagement for Year 2 does not excuse a practitioner's duty to advise once they become aware of the client's error or omission; silence is not an acceptable response under Circular 230.
Why not B: Although Lee has actual knowledge of the omission, Circular 230 requires prompt advice to the client rather than unilateral disclosure to the IRS in this scenario; direct disclosure without client authorization would exceed the practitioner's standard duty here.
Why not C: Reporting income in the wrong year makes the Year 2 return inaccurate even if tax is ultimately collected; a practitioner may not knowingly prepare or sign a return that misstates the year of income to conceal a prior-year omission.
Common questions
Does Circular 230 require reporting a client's prior-year error to the IRS?
No. Advise Apex promptly, explain potential consequences, and recommend correction; do not disclose the omission without Apex's consent or a separate legal requirement.
Can a CPA prepare the current return if the client refuses to amend?
Yes, if the return is accurate and does not repeat or rely on the prior error. Adding Apex's omitted Year 1 interest to Year 2 would make Year 2 incorrect.
When must a CPA tell a client about a prior-year tax error?
Promptly once the CPA knows of the error, even if another firm prepared the return. Do not wait to calculate the exact additional tax, penalties, or interest.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Professional Behavior
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.