PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 9 practice questions

Circular 230: Prior-Year Errors and Current Returns

Promptly advise the client of a known prior-year error and its consequences; without consent or a legal duty, do not disclose it to the IRS. Below, compare responses when the client refuses amendment but the current return can be accurate.

The rulePromptly advise the client of a known prior-year error and its consequences, and recommend correction. Do not disclose without consent or legal duty; prepare the current return only if accurate and not perpetuating the error.

Try one first

A CPA authorized to practice before the IRS is preparing a client's Year 2 federal income tax return. During the engagement, the CPA learns that the client omitted $40,000 of taxable interest income from the already filed Year 1 return. The omission does not affect any Year 2 basis, carryover, or other item on the Year 2 return. The client refuses to amend Year 1 but asks the CPA to complete an otherwise accurate Year 2 return. Assume the CPA can prepare Year 2 without repeating the Year 1 omission. Under Circular 230, which response is most appropriate?
Hint

Separate the practitioner's duty to the client from any duty to the IRS, and then consider whether the current-year return would perpetuate the prior-year error.

What should you do?

The situation

While preparing Apex Co.'s Year 2 federal return, you confirm that another firm omitted $40,000 of taxable interest from Apex's filed Year 1 return. The omission affects no Year 2 item. Apex refuses to amend and forbids IRS disclosure. No law requires disclosure. You can prepare Year 2 accurately, but have not calculated the additional Year 1 tax, penalties, or interest. What should you do?

  1. Promptly explain the error and consequences, recommend amendment, and prepare Year 2 accurately.

    Best Document the advice and refusal. Accurate Year 2 preparation is permitted; IRS disclosure is neither authorized nor required.

  2. Report Apex's Year 1 omission to the IRS before completing Year 2.

    Wrong Circular 230 requires client advice, not automatic IRS reporting. Apex has not consented, and no law requires disclosure.

  3. Require an amended Year 1 return before agreeing to prepare Year 2.

    Wrong Amendment is recommended, but not an automatic prerequisite when Year 2 can be accurate without perpetuating the error.

  4. Prepare Year 2 without discussing Year 1 because another firm prepared it.

    Wrong Your knowledge requires prompt client advice. Neither the prior preparer's identity nor the unaffected current return removes that duty.

  5. Add the omitted $40,000 to Year 2 income to correct the problem.

    Wrong Reporting Year 1 income in Year 2 would misstate Year 2. Recommend correcting the year containing the omission.

Key points

  • Remember: Advise the client about Year 1; judge Year 2 by whether Year 2 will be accurate.
  • Knowing the error triggers advice; you need not calculate exact tax, penalties, or interest first.
  • Document the advice and Apex's refusal to amend.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating knowledge of an error as a duty to report the client to the IRS. Advise Apex promptly. Without consent or a separate legal requirement, do not disclose the omission.
  • Making amendment of Year 1 an automatic condition for preparing Year 2. Apex's refusal does not automatically bar preparation of an accurate, unaffected Year 2 return.
  • Ignoring the omission because another firm prepared Year 1. Your knowledge triggers the duty to advise, regardless of who prepared the earlier return.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

CPA Vega is engaged in 20X6 to represent Rios in an IRS collection matter. While reviewing Rios's records, Vega discovers that Rios's already-filed 20X5 federal return omitted $14,000 of taxable interest income. Vega did not prepare the 20X5 return. Vega has sufficient information to know the 20X5 return is incorrect but has not computed the exact additional tax. Under Circular 230, when must Vega address the omission and with whom must Vega communicate?
Hint

Focus on which event (the practitioner's knowledge, calculating liability, an IRS inquiry, or prior-preparer status) triggers the practitioner's duty under Circular 230 and whether the rule requires independently notifying the IRS.

Question 3

While preparing Apex Co.'s 20X6 federal income tax return, a CPA practicing before the IRS discovers that Apex's 20X5 return omitted $18,000 of taxable interest income. Assume the omission is clear, material, and not reasonably disputable. Apex asks the CPA to ignore the issue and finish the 20X6 return. Under Circular 230, what is the CPA's required next step?
Hint

Focus on what the practitioner must do after discovering a prior-year tax error, and keep separate the duty to advise the client from any duty to report directly to the IRS.

Question 4

Lopez, a CPA in public practice, is engaged only to represent Green Corp. in an IRS correspondence examination of Year 2 payroll tax matters. While reviewing records for that engagement he discovers that Green's separately filed Year 1 federal income tax return omitted a significant item of taxable income. The Year 1 return was prepared by another firm. Green's controller acknowledges the omission and instructs Lopez not to raise it with the IRS and not to prepare an amended return. Assume no law, court order, or client consent requires disclosure to the IRS. Under the CPA's professional responsibilities, which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate the duty to advise the client from the separate question of whether the CPA may or must disclose to the IRS; ask whether consent or legal compulsion exists.

Question 5

CPA Nia is preparing Arden's Year 2 federal income tax return. While reviewing prior-year records prepared by another firm, Nia discovers that Arden's Year 1 federal return omitted a material amount of taxable interest income. Assume the Year 1 omission does not affect any amount on the Year 2 return, and there is no indication of fraud. Under the professional standards governing practice before the IRS, which action is most appropriate for Nia?
Hint

Separate what the CPA must do for the client from what the CPA must do directly with the IRS after discovering a prior-year error.

Question 6

While preparing Green's Year 2 federal income tax return, CPA Lane discovers that Green's filed Year 1 return omitted $40,000 of taxable interest, resulting in an overstated NOL carryforward to Year 2. Lane did not prepare the Year 1 return. After Lane explains the issue, Green refuses to amend Year 1 and instructs Lane to use the overstated carryforward on Year 2 so the returns remain consistent. Assume no law independently requires Lane to notify the IRS. What is Lane's best action?
Hint

Differentiate duties to inform the client versus duties to the IRS, and then ask whether the practitioner may knowingly use information the practitioner knows is incorrect.

Question 7

In 20X6, a CPA who practices before the IRS is engaged to prepare Patel's 20X5 federal income tax return. While reviewing Patel's records, the CPA discovers that Patel's 20X4 return, prepared by another firm, omitted taxable interest income, and the CPA has sufficient information to know the omission occurred. Under Circular 230, when is the CPA required to advise Patel about the 20X4 noncompliance and its consequences?
Hint

Identify which event, what the practitioner knows or does, triggers the practitioner's initial duty under Circular 230.

Question 8

CPA Moreno, a practitioner before the IRS, is engaged to prepare Lee's Year 2 individual federal income tax return. During the engagement, Moreno discovers records showing that Lee omitted $85,000 of taxable consulting income from Year 1; the statute-of-limitations period for Year 1 remains open. Lee tells Moreno, 'Do not amend Year 1. And for Year 2, leave off the same type of income unless the IRS already has a matching form.' Assume no separate law, court order, or subpoena independently requires Moreno to disclose Lee's prior omission to the IRS. Which response is most appropriate under current professional standards governing tax practice?
Hint

Distinguish the practitioner's duty to advise and to refuse participation in noncompliance from any distinct duty to disclose to the IRS; then decide whether the practitioner may prepare a current-year return that omits known income.

Question 9

While preparing Maple, Inc.'s Year 2 federal income tax return, CPA Lee discovers from Maple's records that $120,000 of service revenue was earned and received in Year 1 but was omitted from Maple's Year 1 return, which had been prepared by another firm. Maple's controller tells Lee, "Do not revisit Year 1. Just include the $120,000 on the Year 2 return so the IRS still gets the income." Assume the revenue clearly belongs in Year 1, reporting it in Year 2 would make the Year 2 return inaccurate, and Maple does not authorize Lee to contact the IRS. Under current Treasury Circular 230 standards, what is Lee's most appropriate response?
Hint

Separate the practitioner's duty to advise the client from any duty to disclose to the IRS, and then consider whether the requested Year 2 treatment would itself be accurate.

Drill all 86 Professional Behavior questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does Circular 230 require reporting a client's prior-year error to the IRS?

No. Advise Apex promptly, explain potential consequences, and recommend correction; do not disclose the omission without Apex's consent or a separate legal requirement.

Can a CPA prepare the current return if the client refuses to amend?

Yes, if the return is accurate and does not repeat or rely on the prior error. Adding Apex's omitted Year 1 interest to Year 2 would make Year 2 incorrect.

When must a CPA tell a client about a prior-year tax error?

Promptly once the CPA knows of the error, even if another firm prepared the return. Do not wait to calculate the exact additional tax, penalties, or interest.

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Professional Behavior

All Professional Behavior practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.