REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 11 practice questions
AICPA Advertising: Facts, Guarantees, and IRS Influence
CPA advertising may state supportable facts but must not mislead through guaranteed outcomes or claims of improper IRS influence. Compare one website ad as a single added claim changes whether it is permitted.
Try one first
Hint
Do not focus on whether the firm is advertising at all. Focus on what professional standards care about most when evaluating promotional statements.
Answer D. Professional behavior and advertising rules focus on truthfulness and whether communications are misleading or deceptive. A blanket guarantee of a specific percentage reduction for every client is misleading because tax outcomes depend on the client's facts and the law; such an absolute promise is likely deceptive even if other claims are true. Therefore the primary governing factor is whether the ad contains false or misleading statements.
Why not A: This distractor plays on the overgeneralization that solicitation is inherently improper. In reality, solicitation or advertising is generally permitted for CPAs provided the communication is truthful and not misleading, so solicitation status is not the primary test here.
Why not B: Targeting can affect solicitation rules in some contexts, but it is not the central factor for acceptability of advertising content. Even communications to known contacts must not be false or misleading.
Why not C: Offering a free consultation is a marketing choice but not, by itself, an ethical violation. The primary concern is whether the overall message contains false or deceptive claims, not the presence of a free offer.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Hart CPA's tax-services website states, 'Initial consultations cost a flat $300.' The fee is accurate. Its tax director is a former IRS revenue agent. Records show 94% of last year's individual returns were completed within 10 business days after receiving all requested information. The director has no special IRS influence. Only the AICPA Code applies.
Answer: Permitted.
The advertised fee is accurate. The ad does not promise a tax outcome or imply special IRS treatment.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Add: 'We guarantee our tax clients will never owe an IRS penalty.'
Answer: Not permitted.
The added sentence guarantees an outcome Hart cannot control. The truthful fee statement does not cure the misleading guarantee.
Change 2Add: 'Our IRS relationships can move your case to the top of the pile.'
Answer: Not permitted.
The added sentence implies preferential IRS treatment, not merely relevant experience. Hart's director has no special IRS influence.
Change 3Add: 'Our tax director previously worked as an IRS revenue agent.'
Answer: Permitted.
True prior IRS employment describes experience, not special access. Adding this credential does not make the ad misleading.
Change 4Add: 'Last year, 94% of individual returns were completed within 10 business days after receiving all requested information.'
Answer: Permitted.
This documented, conditional statistic reports past performance, not a future promise. Adding it does not make the ad misleading.
Key points
- Remember: 'Former IRS revenue agent' describes experience; 'we can move your case ahead' promises special treatment.
- An accurate fee does not cure a misleading claim added to the same ad.
- A documented historical completion rate is not a guarantee for future clients.
How the exam traps you
- Rejecting the ad simply because CPAs advertise fees. Test whether the $300 fee statement misleads, not whether it advertises.
- Treating former IRS employment as proof of special access. A true credential is allowed; implying preferential IRS treatment is not.
- Reading a historical completion statistic as a future guarantee. Distinguish supported past performance from a promise about future results.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. The ad states an accurate fee without guaranteeing outcomes or implying special treatment.
Why not B: Incorrect. The AICPA Code permits advertising that is not false, misleading, or deceptive.
Why not C: Incorrect. Truthful fixed-fee information may appear in an advertisement.
Why not D: Incorrect. Permission to advertise does not extend to false, misleading, or deceptive statements.
Question 2
Answer B. Correct. Hart cannot guarantee that every client will avoid IRS penalties.
Why not A: Incorrect. An accurate fee does not cure a misleading guarantee elsewhere in the ad.
Why not C: Incorrect. Prior IRS employment does not justify guarantees about tax outcomes.
Why not D: Incorrect. Tax-services advertising is allowed when it is not false, misleading, or deceptive.
Question 3
Answer C. Correct. The statement implies special influence that Hart's director does not have.
Why not A: Incorrect. Prior IRS employment does not authorize claims of preferential treatment.
Why not B: Incorrect. The misleading advertisement is improper even before Hart takes any action.
Why not D: Incorrect. An accurate statement of prior IRS employment is generally permitted.
Question 4
Answer D. Correct. The statement describes a true credential without promising results or preferential treatment.
Why not A: Incorrect. Truthful statements about relevant experience are generally permitted.
Why not B: Incorrect. Stating experience alone does not claim special access or influence.
Why not C: Incorrect. IRS experience does not guarantee any client's tax outcome.
Question 5
Answer A. Correct. Records support the historical statistic, including its condition about receiving requested information.
Why not B: Incorrect. Reporting past completion times does not itself promise future turnaround.
Why not C: Incorrect. Past performance does not justify guarantees about future tax results.
Why not D: Incorrect. Supportable, nonmisleading performance information may also be advertised.
Question 2
Hint
Do not assume all solicitation is prohibited. Look for the choice that stays within the rule's limiting conditions on truthfulness and non-harassing conduct.
Answer B. The AICPA permits advertising and solicitation so long as communications are not false, misleading, or deceptive and do not involve coercion, overreaching, or harassment. A truthful, non-coercive email describing services, qualifications, and typical fees, without promises of results or persistent contact after a refusal, generally falls within permitted conduct.
Why not A: Tempting because emphasizing experience is acceptable marketing, but claiming favorable settlements in every case is an unsupported guarantee and would be misleading. Advertising must avoid promises of guaranteed outcomes.
Why not C: This seems plausible because solicitation itself is allowed, but repeated contact after a clear refusal crosses into harassment or coercion, which the rule prohibits. Persistence after a refusal is not permitted.
Why not D: Comparative claims are permissible only if they are truthful and can be substantiated. An unsupported assertion of 'lowest fees' is misleading even if competitors make similar claims.
Question 3
Hint
Look for the statement that is factual and supportable, without guarantees, exaggerated comparisons, or pressure tactics.
Answer C. Truthful, nonmisleading statements about a practitioner's credentials are generally permissible. An accurate description of prior experience does not promise a result, misstate facts, or pressure the public. That makes this the best answer under professional behavior standards.
Why not A: Clients want certainty, but audit outcomes cannot be guaranteed; this statement is misleading and inconsistent with professional behavior standards.
Why not B: An unqualified superiority claim is misleading unless clearly supportable; no evidence is provided to back this comparison, so it is not consistent with professional behavior standards.
Why not D: This wording uses pressure and fear rather than a fair, factual description of services and risks, making it an improper or misleading communication for tax practice marketing.
Question 4
Hint
Ask whether the ad merely describes experience or whether it suggests the practitioner can use personal influence to get a client better treatment.
Answer B. This is the best answer because practitioners may not use advertising that is false or misleading or that creates unjustified expectations. The ad goes beyond stating prior experience and implies Jordan can secure preferential treatment through personal relationships; given the assumption that Jordan has no such authority, the claim is misleading and professionally improper.
Why not A: Tempting because a practitioner may truthfully state prior government employment, but the ad does more than describe experience: it implies the ability to move a case ahead, which is misleading if Jordan lacks that authority.
Why not C: A disclaimer about facts and results does not cure a statement that directly implies special access or preferential treatment; the core marketing claim would remain misleading.
Why not D: Incorrect because the advertising statement itself is already improper: it implies special influence or favoritism even before any outreach to former coworkers occurs.
Question 5
Hint
For each statement, ask whether it is a verifiable factual claim the firm can support or an evaluative/comparative claim that would require objective substantiation.
Answer C. The AICPA advertising rule permits communications that are truthful, not misleading, and supportable. Statements (1) and (2) are factual, historical claims the firm can substantiate with its fee schedule and records, so they may be permissible when presented accurately. Statement (3) is a comparative evaluative claim about a named competitor without objective support and therefore risks misleading the public unless substantiated (for example, by documented surveys, verifiable metrics, or reliable testimonials).
Why not A: This is tempting because some candidates treat performance statistics as promises. However, (2) is a historical, conditioned statistic (it reports past results tied to receiving requested information) that the firm can document, so it can be permissible. The real issue is (3), which is an unsupported comparative quality claim.
Why not B: This distractor appeals by overstating permissiveness of advertising. Management belief alone does not satisfy the support requirement for evaluative or comparative claims; such claims require objective substantiation, so (3) remains problematic without documentation.
Why not D: This is tempting to those who recall restrictive advertising guidance, but it is too broad. The AICPA Code allows advertising that is truthful, not misleading, and supportable, so supported fee and historical performance statements (like (1) and (2) here) can be permissible.
Question 6
Hint
Look for the option that crosses from describing services into making a misleading claim about the IRS's decision.
Answer D. Practitioners are prohibited from making false, fraudulent, or misleading statements in connection with practice before the IRS (see Circular 230). Promising that the IRS will remove penalties is misleading because the IRS, not the practitioner, ultimately decides penalty relief based on the specific facts and law.
Why not A: This may seem tempting because fee practices can raise ethical issues, but a truthful statement that fees vary by complexity and will be disclosed is not a misleading promise about IRS outcomes.
Why not B: Candidates might overgeneralize that mentioning prior IRS employment is improper, but a truthful statement about experience is generally permissible so long as it does not imply improper influence or special access.
Why not C: A straightforward, accurate description of the types of matters a firm handles is an acceptable statement of services and does not by itself promise a particular outcome or suggest improper influence.
Common questions
Can CPAs advertise fixed fees under the AICPA Code?
Yes. Hart may advertise its accurate $300 consultation fee, but that truthful fee does not make a misleading guarantee elsewhere in the ad acceptable.
Can a CPA advertise being a former IRS revenue agent?
Yes, if the statement is accurate and not misleading. Hart may describe its director's experience but may not imply that IRS relationships will secure preferential treatment.
Can a CPA advertise turnaround statistics or guarantee tax results?
Hart may report its documented historical completion rate with the stated conditions. That differs from guaranteeing that every client will avoid IRS penalties, which is misleading.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Professional Behavior
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.