REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 7 practice questions
AICPA Independence: Allowed vs. Prohibited Nonattest Services
A CPA may help an audit client with accounting but cannot make management decisions or authorize or execute its transactions. Sort services for Pine, a private audit client, assuming documented, qualified management oversight unless an item says otherwise.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the service that helps management process information from the service that makes management's accounting decision.
Answer A. For an attest client, a CPA may perform certain bookkeeping-type nonattest services, such as reconciliations and preparing proposed journal entries, if the client supervises the service, evaluates the results, and accepts responsibility. However, deciding whether costs should be capitalized or expensed is a management decision; assuming a management responsibility impairs independence even if client personnel later review or approve the work.
Why not B: This choice overstates the rule. Preparing reconciliations and proposed adjusting entries is not automatically prohibited when the client has suitable oversight and accepts responsibility. The independence problem arises from making management decisions, not from drafting proposed entries alone.
Why not C: This is tempting because client oversight is an important safeguard for permitted nonattest services. But that safeguard does not cure the CPA's taking on a management responsibility. Reviewing and approving the work does not make it acceptable for the CPA to decide the client's accounting treatment.
Why not D: Materiality can seem relevant, but the core issue is whether the CPA assumed a management responsibility. A management decision that displaces client judgment impairs independence regardless of materiality.
Sort it
The CPA only assists; Pine retains decisions, provides qualified oversight, and accepts responsibility under a documented understanding.
The CPA makes management decisions, approves or executes Pine's transactions, or creates original source documents, even with client approval.
The work is otherwise permitted, but Pine lacks a designee with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee it.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Prepare Pine's bank reconciliations for CFO review. Before performing otherwise permitted nonattest services for Pine, document the understanding with the client, including the services' objectives, the services to be performed, management's responsibilities, the CPA's responsibilities, and any engagement limitations. | Permitted with oversightThe understanding is documented before work begins; Pine's qualified CFO oversees, evaluates, and accepts responsibility for the reconciliation. |
| Decide which of Pine's overdue vendor invoices to defer until next month. | Impaired: management roleChoosing when Pine pays vendors is a management decision, even if the CFO later agrees. |
| Draft Pine's financial statements and notes from its trial balance for management's review and approval. | Permitted with oversightDrafting assists management; Pine evaluates the statements, makes the reporting decisions, and accepts responsibility. |
| Decide which proposed adjusting entries Pine should record, subject to the CFO's later approval. | Impaired: management roleSelecting entries is Pine's decision. Later approval does not cure the CPA's assumption of that responsibility. |
| Post adjusting entries to Pine's ledger only after management reviews and approves them. | Permitted with oversightPine has made the recording decisions and approved the entries. The CPA only performs the posting. |
| Create and issue Pine's original customer sales invoices from shipping records, with CFO oversight. | Impaired: management roleCreating original source documents is a management responsibility. Using Pine's records and obtaining oversight do not make it permissible. |
| Prepare proposed adjusting entries from Pine's records, leaving the recording decisions to management. | Permitted with oversightThe CPA recommends entries, while Pine evaluates them, decides whether to record them, and accepts responsibility. |
| Draft Pine's financial statements when its only designee cannot evaluate the work and promises to approve anything. | Impaired: missing oversightDrafting is otherwise permitted, but automatic approval does not replace oversight by someone with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience. |
| Approve Pine's routine vendor invoices for payment while its controller is temporarily absent. | Impaired: management roleApproving invoices authorizes client transactions. Routine payments and a temporary vacancy do not change that management role. |
| Select the assumptions Pine will use for its allowance for credit losses. | Impaired: management rolePine must choose its accounting assumptions. The CPA cannot take over that judgment, even with CFO oversight. |
| Compile payment information for invoices Pine has selected; Pine alone authorizes and executes payments. | Permitted with oversightCompiling information is assistance. Pine selects the invoices, authorizes the payments, and executes the disbursements. |
| Post proposed adjusting entries without obtaining Pine's review and approval. | Impaired: management roleWithout Pine's approval, the CPA is implementing accounting decisions that management has not authorized. |
| Authorize and release Pine's ACH payments after the CFO approves each disbursement. | Impaired: management roleExecuting client disbursements assumes management responsibility. CFO preapproval does not permit the CPA to authorize or release Pine's funds. |
| Sign Pine's vendor checks after the CFO approves each disbursement. | Impaired: management roleSigning client checks impairs independence even when management approves each disbursement. General oversight or specific payment approval cannot cure that management role. |
Key points
- Remember: Help Pine prepare the accounting; let Pine decide, approve, and execute its transactions.
- Posting approved entries is not the same as approving which entries to post.
- Document the nonattest-service understanding before work begins, not after Pine reviews the results.
- A signature is not oversight when Pine's designee cannot evaluate the work.
How the exam traps you
- Management approval makes every requested service permissible. Approval cannot cure the CPA's management decisions, invoice approvals, check-signing, or execution of ACH payments.
- Proposing entries and deciding which entries to record are the same. Propose entries for Pine's decision; post only entries Pine has reviewed and approved.
- An owner's promise to sign anything supplies adequate oversight. Pine needs a designee with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee and evaluate the work.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the analysis by client and first ask whether the firm performed an attest service or crossed into management decision-making.
Answer D. For Delta, the partner did more than assist management; the partner made management decisions by selecting payments, approving entries, and negotiating financing on the client's behalf. Those actions impair independence for an attest engagement such as a review. For Echo, independence is not required when the firm provides only nonattest tax services, but the firm still must maintain integrity and objectivity.
Why not A: This is tempting because it correctly recognizes that Delta is a problem. However, it overstates the rule for Echo. Under the AICPA Code, independence is generally required for attest services, not for all services; tax-only work still requires objectivity, but not independence solely because it is professional work.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to the idea that management's final approval fixes nonattest-service issues. But signing the statements does not cure the fact that Adams already performed management functions for Delta. The Echo portion is closer to the rule, but the Delta conclusion makes the overall option wrong.
Why not C: This is tempting if a candidate focuses on the short-term nature of the help provided. Temporary assistance still impairs independence when the CPA takes on management responsibilities. The second part is also incorrect because immateriality of tax work does not create an independence requirement for a client receiving only tax services.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether the CPA is merely assisting with accounting information or actually taking an action that belongs to management.
Answer A. Independence is impaired when the CPA assumes management responsibilities for an attest client. Authorizing and signing checks is an actual management function because it involves executing and committing the client's transactions, not merely preparing information for management's approval.
Why not B: Posting entries can be permissible if management authorizes and approves the entries and accepts responsibility; the CPA is not making management decisions in that scenario.
Why not C: This is a permitted nonattest service for many nonissuer clients when management retains responsibility: the CPA is preparing information from client records, and management reviews and accepts the results.
Why not D: Drafting disclosures is often allowed as an aid to management if management reviews, approves, and takes responsibility for the final financial statements and notes.
Question 4
Hint
Separate routine assistance from management decision-making. Ask who is making the final accounting judgment for the client.
Answer A. Under AICPA independence guidance, auditors may propose adjusting entries and, in limited circumstances, post entries only if management accepts responsibility, does not cede its judgment, and designates a competent individual to oversee the work. Deciding which entries the client should record is a management decision; because Dover did not designate a qualified overseer and the owner will simply approve whatever Marin decides, Marin would be assuming management responsibility and independence is impaired.
Why not B: This is tempting because auditors often propose adjustments and may post entries when management accepts responsibility. The flaw is that the stem goes further, Marin is being asked to decide which entries the client should record and there is no competent client oversight. That level of decision-making is management's responsibility and would impair independence.
Why not C: Client approval alone does not cure an independence impairment when the auditor effectively makes management decisions. If management will simply ratify whatever the auditor decides, the auditor has assumed management responsibilities and independence is impaired despite formal sign-off.
Why not D: Materiality is relevant to many audit judgments, but the core independence issue here is assumption of management responsibility. Independence can be impaired when an auditor takes on management decision-making regardless of whether the specific entries are material.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the two requested services. Ask whether each is merely assistance under management's oversight or whether one of them crosses into making management's decisions.
Answer A. Under AICPA independence rules, auditors must not assume management responsibilities. Preparing proposed journal entries from client-supplied information can be permitted if management accepts responsibility and provides oversight. However, deciding which vendor invoices to pay is a management decision (authorizing transactions), so independence would be impaired.
Why not B: This is tempting because management oversight can allow some nonattest assistance, but competent client oversight does not permit the auditor to assume management responsibilities. Choosing which invoices to pay is a management function, so independence is still impaired.
Why not C: This distractor incorrectly relies on materiality. The issue is the nature of the service, assuming management responsibility, which impairs independence regardless of whether the dollar amounts are material.
Why not D: Objectivity is required, but for an audit client the CPA must maintain independence when performing services related to the attest engagement. Objectivity does not replace the independence requirement in this context.
Question 6
Hint
Separate services that are generally allowed for an attest client from services that require the CPA to make management judgments the client should make.
Answer B. Preparing a client's tax return from the client's books and records is generally a permitted nonattest service and does not, by itself, impair independence. However, selecting assumptions for a significant accounting estimate and recording the related journal entry when the client has not designated a person with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience, and the client expects the firm's judgment to be relied upon, places the firm in a management/decision-making role and impairs independence.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates sometimes overgeneralize that any tax work for an attest client is barred. In fact, tax return preparation is generally permitted; the independence issue here arises from the firm making management-level judgments on the allowance estimate.
Why not C: Documentation and client acknowledgement are useful safeguards, but they do not cure a situation in which the firm is effectively performing management functions or the client lacks a designated person with suitable skill to oversee the work. The second request still impairs independence.
Why not D: Journal-entry or bookkeeping assistance is not categorically prohibited if the client assumes responsibility and has adequate oversight. The decisive problem here is that the firm would be selecting significant estimate assumptions and recording the entry without competent client oversight, which constitutes management responsibility.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on which task would require the CPA to perform actions that are, by nature, client management decisions (authorizing or directing client actions) rather than preparing drafts, recommendations, or calculations for management to approve.
Answer B. Authorizing which invoices to defer has the CPA making a client management decision (timing of vendor payments), which is a management function. AICPA independence guidance indicates an attest firm's independence is impaired when the firm assumes management responsibilities or makes client management decisions; even with management oversight, acting as management in this way is not a permissible nonattest service. See AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, independence guidance on nonattest services and management responsibility.
Why not A: Tempting because preparing financial statements can create a self-review threat; however, under AICPA guidance preparing financial statements for an attest client is generally permissible when client management accepts responsibility, designates a competent individual to oversee the service, and reviews and approves the statements.
Why not C: Attractive because proposed entries affect reported amounts, but when the firm only prepares proposed adjusting entries and management evaluates, approves, and posts them, the work is assistive and does not necessarily constitute assuming management responsibility.
Why not D: Plausible because depreciation entails judgment, but maintaining the schedule according to policies and methods chosen by management is an assistive bookkeeping/accounting service when management reviews and approves the results and therefore does not necessarily impair independence.
Common questions
Can an auditor prepare and post adjusting journal entries?
Yes, if Pine's qualified management oversees the service, decides which entries to record, approves them before posting, and accepts responsibility. The CPA may propose entries but cannot make Pine's recording decisions.
Does management's signature satisfy nonattest-service oversight?
Not by itself. Pine must designate someone with suitable skill, knowledge, and experience to oversee the services, evaluate the results, and accept responsibility.
Can a CPA sign audit-client checks if management approves?
Signing Pine's checks impairs independence even if management preapproves the disbursements; authorizing or executing ACH disbursements also assumes a management responsibility. Merely preparing payment information for management to authorize and execute is different.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Independence and Objectivity
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.