PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 9 practice questions

Audit, Review, Compilation, and Tax: Independence Rules

Audits and reviews require independence; compilations need report disclosure when independence is lacking, while tax services require objectivity, not independence. Below, sort services for Grant, a sole practitioner who directly owns stock in Maple Co., a private client, and remains objective.

The ruleUnder AICPA standards, audits and reviews require independence. A compilation without independence requires disclosure in the compilation report; tax preparation, tax planning, and IRS representation require integrity and objectivity, not independence.

Try one first

Grant, CPA, owns a direct financial interest in Maple Co., a nonissuer client; therefore the firm is not independent with respect to Maple. In Year 2, Maple asks the firm to (1) prepare Maple's federal income tax return, (2) perform a review of Maple's annual financial statements, and (3) issue a compilation report on Maple's annual financial statements. Assume no other ethics issues exist and that any compilation report would properly disclose the firm's lack of independence. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Decide separately for each requested service: is it an attest engagement that requires independence (reviews), a compilation where disclosure can permit issuance, or a nonattest tax-preparation engagement?

Sort it

Independence required

An audit or review requires independence, so Grant must decline while retaining the stock.

Compilation disclosure required

A compilation may proceed only if its report explicitly states that Grant is not independent.

Tax objectivity required

Tax preparation, tax planning, or IRS representation may proceed if Grant maintains integrity and objectivity.

ItemGoes to
Review Maple's annual financial statements.Independence requiredGrant's direct stock ownership impairs independence. A review requires independence.
Prepare Maple's federal corporate income tax return.Tax objectivity requiredTax return preparation is a nonattest service. Stock ownership does not automatically bar it, but integrity and objectivity remain required.
Compile Maple's financial statements with an explicit statement of nonindependence in the compilation report.Compilation disclosure requiredThe compilation may proceed because its report includes the required disclosure.
Audit Maple's annual financial statements.Independence requiredAn audit requires independence. Grant cannot accept it while holding the direct financial interest.
Review Maple's financial statements after disclosing Grant's ownership to Maple and its lender.Independence requiredDisclosure does not restore independence for a review. Grant must still decline.
Advise Maple on tax planning.Tax objectivity requiredTax planning does not itself require independence. Grant must still give objective advice and maintain integrity.
Compile Maple's financial statements without report disclosure because the lender already knows about Grant's stock.Compilation disclosure requiredThe lender's knowledge changes nothing. Grant must include the nonindependence disclosure in the compilation report.
Review Maple's financial statements when Grant's direct stock investment is immaterial to Grant.Independence requiredThe investment's small size changes nothing. A sole practitioner's direct financial interest impairs independence regardless of materiality.
Represent Maple during an IRS examination.Tax objectivity requiredIRS representation is a nonattest tax service. Advocacy does not itself create an independence requirement; integrity and objectivity still apply.
Compile Maple's financial statements with nonindependence disclosed only in a separate letter to Maple and its lender.Compilation disclosure requiredA separate letter is not enough. The compilation report itself must disclose that Grant is not independent.
Prepare Maple's federal tax return knowing its lender will also rely on the return.Tax objectivity requiredThird-party reliance changes nothing. Tax preparation does not become an attest engagement merely because a lender uses the return.
Audit Maple's financial statements after Maple signs a written consent to Grant's lack of independence.Independence requiredClient consent changes nothing. It cannot waive the independence requirement for an audit.

Key points

  • Remember: Identify the engagement first; the same stock ownership blocks a review but not objective tax work.
  • A sole practitioner's direct client stock ownership impairs independence even when the investment is small.
  • For compilations, disclose nonindependence in the report itself. A separate letter is not enough.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating disclosure or client consent as permission to perform a review. Decline the review. Neither disclosure nor consent restores independence.
  • Rejecting tax work solely because the CPA owns client stock. Tax work does not require independence. Integrity and objectivity still apply.
  • Omitting compilation disclosure because the lender already knows. The compilation report must explicitly disclose the lack of independence.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Patel, CPA, prepared a married couple's joint Year 1 federal income tax return. In Year 2, the IRS begins examining that return. During separate meetings, each spouse asks Patel to continue as representative but also asks Patel to assert that an unreported brokerage account belonged solely to the other spouse. Patel concludes that, if ethics rules permit, Patel could still provide competent and diligent representation to both spouses and assumes no law otherwise prohibits the representation. Under Circular 230, what is Patel's best next step?
Hint

Identify Circular 230's conflict-of-interest standard and the required form of client consent and documentation.

Question 3

Mora, CPA, in public practice, is engaged only to prepare Falcon LLC's Year 1 federal income tax return and provide tax planning advice. Mora will not perform an audit, review, examination, or any other engagement for which independence is required. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, which statement is most accurate?
Hint

First decide whether the engagement is attest or nonattest. Then ask which ethical standard still applies even when independence is not required.

Question 4

Rex, CPA, has two separate engagements in Year 2. For Able Corp, Rex is engaged only to prepare Able's federal income tax return and represent Able during an IRS examination. For Baker Corp, Rex is engaged to perform a review of Baker's year-end financial statements. In connection with the Baker engagement, Rex also helps propose year-end adjusting entries from management-prepared records. Baker's management will approve any entries and accept responsibility for the records and financial statements. Assume Rex has no financial interests, employment relationships, or family relationships with either client. Which conclusion is best supported regarding Rex's independence and objectivity?
Hint

First separate the two engagements by service type. Then ask which ethical requirement is tied specifically to attest work and which applies to all professional services.

Question 5

A CPA is considering four separate engagements for four unrelated clients. Assume no prohibited fees, loans, or financial interests exist, and none of the clients is already an attest client unless the service listed is itself an attest service. For which engagement must the CPA be independent under professional standards?
Hint

Ask which service is an attest engagement, not which service feels most sensitive or adversarial.

Question 6

A CPA provides only tax return preparation and tax planning services to Reed and performs no attest services for Reed. While preparing Reed's Year 2 individual income tax return, the CPA receives a Form 1099 showing consulting income. Reed tells the CPA to leave the income off the return because "this is just tax work, so independence does not matter." Assume the CPA has enough information to conclude the income is taxable and should be reported. What is the CPA's best action?
Hint

Focus on the difference between independence and objectivity in a tax-only engagement.

Question 7

Stone, CPA, is the engagement partner on a review engagement for Harbor Inc. Stone also oversees the firm's separate preparation of Harbor's corporate income tax return. Stone personally owns shares of Harbor directly. Assume no exception applies, the shares are not held through a diversified mutual fund or similar indirect vehicle, and no other rule or law limits the tax engagement. What is the most appropriate conclusion about the consequence of Stone's stock ownership?
Hint

Separate the consequence for the attest service from the consequence for the tax service, and focus on whether a direct financial interest can be fixed by materiality or disclosure.

Question 8

Diaz, CPA, is asked by Oak Co., a nonissuer, to perform one of the following engagements. Diaz is not independent with respect to Oak. Assume there is no separate issue involving integrity, objectivity, or competence. Which engagement may Diaz generally perform under current professional standards?
Hint

First sort the options by service type. Ask which services require independence and which service, if any, can still be performed with a disclosure.

Question 9

Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, Lane, CPA, is engaged only to prepare Orion Co.'s Year 1 federal income tax return. Lane's firm performs no audit, review, compilation, or other attest service for Orion. Lane personally owns a small amount of Orion common stock in a brokerage account. Assume no other law or regulator imposes stricter requirements. Which statement is most accurate?
Hint

Ask which rule is limited to attest work and which ethical duty continues across all professional services.

Drill all 95 Independence and Objectivity questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Do audits and reviews both require independence under AICPA standards?

Yes. A review provides limited assurance, but it still requires independence. Grant must decline either service while retaining the direct stock ownership.

Can a CPA perform a compilation without being independent?

Yes, if the compilation report explicitly discloses the lack of independence. A separate letter or the lender's prior knowledge does not replace that report disclosure.

Can a CPA who owns client stock prepare the client's tax return?

Yes, provided the CPA maintains integrity and objectivity and satisfies other professional responsibilities. Tax preparation, tax planning, and IRS representation do not themselves require independence.

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Independence and Objectivity

All Independence and Objectivity practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.