REG · Ethics and Professional Responsibility · 9 practice questions
Audit, Review, Compilation, and Tax: Independence Rules
Audits and reviews require independence; compilations need report disclosure when independence is lacking, while tax services require objectivity, not independence. Below, sort services for Grant, a sole practitioner who directly owns stock in Maple Co., a private client, and remains objective.
Try one first
Hint
Decide separately for each requested service: is it an attest engagement that requires independence (reviews), a compilation where disclosure can permit issuance, or a nonattest tax-preparation engagement?
Answer D. A direct financial interest impairs independence. Under SSARS, review engagements are attest in nature and require independence, so the firm must decline the review. Compilations do not require independence if the lack of independence is disclosed in the compilation report. Preparation of a federal income tax return is a nonattest service and does not require independence. Therefore the firm may prepare the tax return and issue a compilation report (with disclosure), but must decline the review.
Why not A: This is tempting because disclosure permits a compilation to proceed; however, disclosure does not restore independence for review engagements. Reviews are attest engagements and independence is required under SSARS, so simply disclosing the conflict does not allow performing a review.
Why not B: This is tempting for those who conflate independence with general objectivity and assume impairment bars all client work. It is wrong because impaired independence prevents performing a review, not tax-return preparation; tax services are nonattest and do not require independence, and compilations may be issued with appropriate disclosure.
Why not C: This attracts candidates who treat all financial-statement services the same. It fails because compilations differ from reviews: under SSARS a compilation may be issued when the firm is not independent if the report discloses the lack of independence, whereas reviews require independence.
Sort it
An audit or review requires independence, so Grant must decline while retaining the stock.
A compilation may proceed only if its report explicitly states that Grant is not independent.
Tax preparation, tax planning, or IRS representation may proceed if Grant maintains integrity and objectivity.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Review Maple's annual financial statements. | Independence requiredGrant's direct stock ownership impairs independence. A review requires independence. |
| Prepare Maple's federal corporate income tax return. | Tax objectivity requiredTax return preparation is a nonattest service. Stock ownership does not automatically bar it, but integrity and objectivity remain required. |
| Compile Maple's financial statements with an explicit statement of nonindependence in the compilation report. | Compilation disclosure requiredThe compilation may proceed because its report includes the required disclosure. |
| Audit Maple's annual financial statements. | Independence requiredAn audit requires independence. Grant cannot accept it while holding the direct financial interest. |
| Review Maple's financial statements after disclosing Grant's ownership to Maple and its lender. | Independence requiredDisclosure does not restore independence for a review. Grant must still decline. |
| Advise Maple on tax planning. | Tax objectivity requiredTax planning does not itself require independence. Grant must still give objective advice and maintain integrity. |
| Compile Maple's financial statements without report disclosure because the lender already knows about Grant's stock. | Compilation disclosure requiredThe lender's knowledge changes nothing. Grant must include the nonindependence disclosure in the compilation report. |
| Review Maple's financial statements when Grant's direct stock investment is immaterial to Grant. | Independence requiredThe investment's small size changes nothing. A sole practitioner's direct financial interest impairs independence regardless of materiality. |
| Represent Maple during an IRS examination. | Tax objectivity requiredIRS representation is a nonattest tax service. Advocacy does not itself create an independence requirement; integrity and objectivity still apply. |
| Compile Maple's financial statements with nonindependence disclosed only in a separate letter to Maple and its lender. | Compilation disclosure requiredA separate letter is not enough. The compilation report itself must disclose that Grant is not independent. |
| Prepare Maple's federal tax return knowing its lender will also rely on the return. | Tax objectivity requiredThird-party reliance changes nothing. Tax preparation does not become an attest engagement merely because a lender uses the return. |
| Audit Maple's financial statements after Maple signs a written consent to Grant's lack of independence. | Independence requiredClient consent changes nothing. It cannot waive the independence requirement for an audit. |
Key points
- Remember: Identify the engagement first; the same stock ownership blocks a review but not objective tax work.
- A sole practitioner's direct client stock ownership impairs independence even when the investment is small.
- For compilations, disclose nonindependence in the report itself. A separate letter is not enough.
How the exam traps you
- Treating disclosure or client consent as permission to perform a review. Decline the review. Neither disclosure nor consent restores independence.
- Rejecting tax work solely because the CPA owns client stock. Tax work does not require independence. Integrity and objectivity still apply.
- Omitting compilation disclosure because the lender already knows. The compilation report must explicitly disclose the lack of independence.
Question 2
Hint
Identify Circular 230's conflict-of-interest standard and the required form of client consent and documentation.
Answer D. Circular 230 (31 C.F.R. §10.29) allows representation of clients with directly adverse positions only if the practitioner reasonably believes they can competently and diligently represent each affected client, the representation is not otherwise prohibited by law, and each affected client gives informed consent confirmed in writing. The fact pattern indicates the first two conditions are met, so Patel must obtain and document written informed consent from both spouses before continuing; oral consent alone is insufficient.
Why not A: This is tempting because independence rules principally govern attest engagements, not tax practice. It is wrong because the issue here is a conflict of interest between clients with directly adverse positions; Circular 230 requires informed consent confirmed in writing before such joint representation may continue.
Why not B: Tempting because an oral agreement might seem sufficient in practice, but Circular 230 requires that informed consent be confirmed in writing (31 C.F.R. §10.29). Oral consent alone does not meet that documentation requirement.
Why not C: This is tempting because directly adverse client positions raise significant ethics concerns. It is incorrect to state a categorical bar; Circular 230 does not automatically prohibit joint representation if the practitioner can competently represent both, the representation is not prohibited by law, and both clients give informed consent confirmed in writing.
Question 3
Hint
First decide whether the engagement is attest or nonattest. Then ask which ethical standard still applies even when independence is not required.
Answer D. Preparing tax returns and providing tax planning are nonattest services for which independence is generally not required under the AICPA Code. However, the CPA remains bound by the Integrity and Objectivity rule and must perform the services honestly and without bias.
Why not A: This overgeneralizes the independence requirement. Independence is required for attest engagements (e.g., audits, reviews, examinations), not automatically for every service a CPA provides.
Why not B: A client waiver does not create independence where it is required, nor is a waiver necessary when independence is not required. The key issue here is that independence isn't required for the stated nonattest tax services, but objectivity and integrity remain mandatory.
Why not C: While tax services are nonattest and typically don't require independence, that does not remove ethical obligations. The CPA must still maintain objectivity and integrity when performing tax work.
Question 4
Hint
First separate the two engagements by service type. Then ask which ethical requirement is tied specifically to attest work and which applies to all professional services.
Answer C. A review engagement is an attest service that requires the CPA to be independent. Preparing a tax return and representing a client before the IRS are nonattest services and do not, by themselves, create an independence requirement, although the CPA must still remain objective and not subordinate professional judgment. Proposing adjusting entries for an attest client can threaten independence only if the CPA assumes management responsibility; management's approval and acceptance of responsibility helps address that concern but does not remove the independence requirement for the review.
Why not A: This is tempting because both activities involve opinion and advocacy, but tax return preparation and IRS representation are nonattest services that do not by themselves require independence. The review engagement for Baker is the service that triggers the independence requirement.
Why not B: Management approval is an important safeguard for certain nonattest services, but it does not eliminate the independence requirement for an attest engagement such as a review.
Why not D: This reverses the applicable rule: IRS representation alone does not create an attest-independence requirement, while a review engagement does. Management approval of entries may help avoid assuming management responsibility but does not negate the review's independence requirement.
Question 5
Hint
Ask which service is an attest engagement, not which service feels most sensitive or adversarial.
Answer A. Independence is required for attest engagements; a review of financial statements is an attest engagement that provides limited assurance and therefore requires independence. Tax return preparation, IRS representation, and tax advisory work are professional services that require integrity and objectivity but do not, by themselves, trigger the independence requirement.
Why not B: Advocacy before the IRS can feel adversarial, but representing a taxpayer in an IRS examination is not an attest engagement and does not by itself require independence.
Why not C: Tax return preparation is a professional service governed by tax standards, but it is not an attest engagement. Independence is not required solely because the CPA prepares a client's tax return.
Why not D: Tax advisory work may create pressures to favor a client's desired outcome, but it is not an attest engagement; independence is specifically required for attest services such as reviews and audits.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on the difference between independence and objectivity in a tax-only engagement.
Answer D. Although independence is not required for a tax-only engagement, professional responsibilities such as objectivity, integrity, and compliance with the tax law still apply. A CPA should advise the client that the income must be reported and should decline to prepare or sign a return the CPA knows is incorrect. If the client persists, the CPA should withdraw from the engagement and consider advising the client to seek legal counsel.
Why not A: This distractor incorrectly equates absence of an independence requirement with permission to prepare an incorrect return. Even in tax-only engagements, the CPA must not prepare or sign a return that omits known taxable income.
Why not B: A client's written instruction does not absolve the CPA of ethical and professional duties. The CPA cannot shift responsibility away and should not prepare or sign a knowingly incorrect return.
Why not C: Unilateral disclosure of client information is generally not appropriate; the CPA's first step is to advise the client and refuse to participate in the improper filing. There are narrow legal exceptions requiring disclosure, but this scenario's best professional response is refusal to prepare or sign the noncompliant return, not an unauthorized report and continued representation.
Question 7
Hint
Separate the consequence for the attest service from the consequence for the tax service, and focus on whether a direct financial interest can be fixed by materiality or disclosure.
Answer A. A direct financial interest in an attest client by a covered member, such as the engagement partner, impairs independence. Because a review is an attest service, the firm should not perform the review while that interest exists. Tax return preparation is generally not an independence-required service, so the firm may still perform it if it complies with objectivity and other applicable ethical rules.
Why not B: Tempting because students often think in terms of materiality, but a covered member's direct financial interest in an attest client impairs independence regardless of the amount.
Why not C: Disclosure can address some ethical concerns in other contexts, but it does not cure a lack of independence caused by a covered member's direct ownership interest in an attest client.
Why not D: This overgeneralizes independence requirements. Independence is required for attest services (like a review) but generally is not required for nonattest services such as tax return preparation, assuming no other rule prohibits the work and the CPA remains objective.
Question 8
Hint
First sort the options by service type. Ask which services require independence and which service, if any, can still be performed with a disclosure.
Answer A. Independence is required for attest engagements such as audits, reviews, and examinations. A compilation is not an attest engagement and may be performed when the CPA is not independent, provided the compilation report explicitly discloses the lack of independence. Therefore the compilation with disclosure is the permitted engagement.
Why not B: A review provides limited assurance but is still an attest engagement; independence is required. Disclosure of nonindependence does not permit performing a review when independence is lacking.
Why not C: This is appealing because it involves financial statement reporting, but an audit is an attest engagement for which independence is required. A CPA who is not independent should not accept an audit.
Why not D: An examination of prospective financial information is an attest engagement, so independence is required. Even though the subject matter differs, the independence requirement still applies.
Question 9
Hint
Ask which rule is limited to attest work and which ethical duty continues across all professional services.
Answer D. Under the AICPA Code, independence is required for attest engagements but is not generally required for a standalone tax return preparation engagement. Nevertheless, objectivity and other ethical obligations still apply when providing tax services.
Why not A: Incorrect: while independence may not be required for nonattest tax services, objectivity and other ethical duties still apply to all professional services.
Why not B: This overgeneralizes independence. AICPA independence rules are tied to attest engagements; they do not automatically apply to every professional service such as routine tax return preparation.
Why not C: This confuses materiality rules. For attest engagements a direct financial interest is a threat to independence regardless of materiality; moreover, independence isn't required for a tax-only engagement under the AICPA Code in the fact pattern given.
Common questions
Do audits and reviews both require independence under AICPA standards?
Yes. A review provides limited assurance, but it still requires independence. Grant must decline either service while retaining the direct stock ownership.
Can a CPA perform a compilation without being independent?
Yes, if the compilation report explicitly discloses the lack of independence. A separate letter or the lender's prior knowledge does not replace that report disclosure.
Can a CPA who owns client stock prepare the client's tax return?
Yes, provided the CPA maintains integrity and objectivity and satisfies other professional responsibilities. Tax preparation, tax planning, and IRS representation do not themselves require independence.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Independence and Objectivity
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.