REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 7 practice questions
Section 121: Taxable Gain After Rental Use
For pre-residence rental use, separate nonexcludable depreciation before allocating the remaining gain to nonqualified use. Below: follow Taylor’s home sale from total gain to taxable gain.
Try one first
Hint
First decide whether the principal residence exclusion applies, then compare the realized gain with the maximum exclusion amount for a single taxpayer.
Answer B. Under Section 121 an unmarried taxpayer may exclude up to $250,000 of gain on the sale of a principal residence if the ownership and use tests (2 of last 5 years) and frequency test are met. Mia qualifies, so she excludes $250,000 of her $280,000 realized gain and recognizes the remaining $30,000.
Why not A: Tempting if a candidate recalls that the principal residence exclusion can eliminate gain entirely, but the exclusion for an unmarried taxpayer is limited to $250,000. Because Mia's gain exceeds that amount, she cannot exclude all $280,000.
Why not C: This is the maximum exclusion amount for a qualifying unmarried taxpayer, so it's the amount excluded, not the amount recognized. The question asks for recognized gain, which is the excess over the exclusion ($280,000 − $250,000 = $30,000).
Why not D: This reflects failing to apply Section 121. The facts state Mia meets the tests and no limits apply, so she is eligible for the $250,000 exclusion and does not recognize the full $280,000.
Step by step
- Start with Taylor’s sale
Taylor, single, rented a home for three years, then used it as a principal residence for three years, all after 2008; realized gain is $210,000, including $12,000 attributable to depreciation, with no nonqualified-use exception. Taylor otherwise qualifies for Section 121, and the applicable exclusion cap does not limit the exclusion.
- Separate the depreciation gain
The $12,000 attributable to depreciation allowed or allowable after May 6, 1997, is not excludable. Remaining gain = $210,000 − $12,000 = $198,000.
- Find the nonqualified-use fraction
The three initial rental years are nonqualified use. Divide those years by all six ownership years: 3/6.
- Allocate the remaining gain
Nonexcludable gain from nonqualified use = $198,000 × 3/6 = $99,000. The other $99,000 is eligible for exclusion.
- Combine the taxable portions
Taxable gain = $12,000 depreciation-attributable gain + $99,000 nonqualified-use gain = $111,000. Check: $210,000 total gain − $99,000 excluded = $111,000.
Key points
- Remember: Separate depreciation first, then apply the nonqualified-use fraction to the remaining gain.
- The ownership denominator includes both Taylor’s rental years and principal-residence years.
- Taylor’s $210,000 gain already reflects depreciation through adjusted basis; do not increase it again.
How the exam traps you
- Allocate the full $210,000, then add $12,000, producing $117,000 taxable gain. Remove depreciation before allocating: $198,000 × 3/6 + $12,000 = $111,000.
- Recognize only the $12,000 depreciation amount. Also recognize $99,000 allocated to the initial rental period.
- Allocate the full gain and subtract depreciation, producing $93,000. Depreciation is taxable, not a deduction from taxable gain.
Question 2
Hint
Look at the overall facts and circumstances, especially time spent and which address appears on key official records.
Answer C. A principal residence is identified from all the facts and circumstances. Here, Taylor spent more time in the townhouse and used that address for employment, tax, licensing, voting, and banking records. Those facts support the townhouse as the principal residence.
Why not A: This answer comes from focusing on the property sold or treating any regularly used home as principal. But the cottage had fewer days of use and none of the listed official ties. Under the stated facts, it is the secondary residence.
Why not B: This answer comes from assuming both homes can be principal at the same time because Taylor genuinely lived in both. Section 121 allows only one principal residence at a time. The facts must be weighed to identify the main home.
Why not D: This answer comes from thinking two residences cancel each other out so neither qualifies as principal. Section 121 does not require a taxpayer to own only one home. The rule asks which home is the principal one under the facts and circumstances.
Question 3
Hint
Compute realized gain first, then reduce that gain by the available Section 121 exclusion.
Answer C. Realized gain equals the amount realized of $940,000, which is the $960,000 sales price less $20,000 of selling expenses, minus the $240,000 adjusted basis. That produces a $700,000 gain. After the $500,000 Section 121 exclusion, $200,000 remains taxable.
Why not A: This comes from computing the realized gain correctly but failing to apply the Section 121 exclusion. Because the taxpayers qualify for the full exclusion, only the excess over $500,000 is included in income.
Why not B: This comes from ignoring the $20,000 of selling expenses and computing gain as $720,000 before the exclusion. Selling expenses reduce the amount realized, so the gain before exclusion is $700,000, not $720,000.
Why not D: This comes from subtracting the exclusion from the sales price instead of from realized gain. Section 121 excludes gain only after gain is computed using amount realized less adjusted basis.
Question 4
Hint
Check the special 2-year post-death rule that can preserve the larger Section 121 exclusion amount.
Answer D. Pat's realized gain is $750,000, computed as $950,000 minus $200,000. Because the sale occurred within 2 years of Robin's death, Pat did not remarry, and the prior ownership, use, and prior-sale conditions are met, Pat may use the $500,000 exclusion ceiling. The recognized gain is therefore $250,000.
Why not A: This results from assuming no Section 121 exclusion is available after a spouse dies. That is incorrect. The law specifically allows a qualifying surviving spouse to use the exclusion, including the $500,000 ceiling if the sale occurs within the 2-year window.
Why not B: This reflects using the regular $250,000 exclusion ceiling for a single taxpayer. That misses the special rule allowing an unmarried surviving spouse to use the $500,000 ceiling for a sale within 2 years of the spouse's death when the other conditions are satisfied.
Why not C: This comes from inventing a prorated exclusion based on selling 18 months after the spouse's death. The surviving spouse rule is not prorated in that way. If the requirements are met and the sale is within 2 years, the full $500,000 ceiling is available.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on whether Section 121 counts only one ownership period or lets separate periods within the 5-year window be added together.
Answer D. Section 121 requires ownership for periods aggregating at least 2 years during the 5-year period ending on the sale date. The ownership months do not have to be continuous. Omar owned the house for 12 months from July 1, Year 1, to June 30, Year 2, and 12 months from July 1, Year 5, to June 30, Year 6, totaling 24 months.
Why not A: This mistake counts calendar years touched rather than months owned. Section 121 uses an aggregate 24-month ownership test within the 5-year window, not the number of calendar years involved.
Why not B: This mistake assumes uninterrupted ownership is required. The rule allows separate ownership periods to be added together as long as they fall within the 5-year period ending on the sale date.
Why not C: This mistake ignores earlier ownership of the same residence within the testing window. The rule counts all ownership periods during the 5 years before sale, not just the most recent stretch.
Question 6
Hint
For replacement property later used as a home, apply the normal residence tests and the separate five-year rule tied to the exchange acquisition date.
Answer D. The special Section 121 rule for property acquired in a Section 1031 exchange bars the exclusion for a sale during the five-year period beginning on the acquisition date. Mora acquired the property on January 1, Year 1, so Year 3, Year 4, and Year 5 listed sale dates fall too soon. April 1, Year 6 is the earliest listed sale date after that period.
Why not A: This treats an additional year after satisfying the residence-use test as sufficient. Section 121 still is unavailable during the five-year period beginning with the like-kind exchange acquisition.
Why not B: This treats four years after the exchange acquisition as enough. The special rule requires waiting until after the five-year exchange-related period, assuming the other Section 121 requirements are met.
Why not C: This comes from applying only the normal two-year ownership and use requirement. The exchange acquisition creates a separate five-year bar, so two years of residence use is not enough.
Question 7
Hint
Identify whether the earlier excluded sale falls within the lookback period ending on the later sale date.
Answer A. The frequency rule disallows a Section 121 exclusion if another excluded sale occurred during the two-year period ending on the later sale date. A sale on August 20, Year 3 is exactly two years after the August 20, Year 1 excluded sale, so it is not barred. Waiting one additional day is unnecessary when all other requirements are met.
Why not B: This answer treats the exact second anniversary as still barred and waits one extra day. The frequency limitation is satisfied on the second anniversary of the earlier excluded sale.
Why not C: This answer treats a sale one day before the second anniversary as sufficient. The prior excluded sale would still be too recent for the frequency limitation, absent a reduced-exclusion exception.
Why not D: This answer treats a sale two days before the second anniversary as sufficient. The prior excluded sale would still fall within the barred frequency period, so the later exclusion would be denied.
Common questions
How do I calculate taxable home sale gain after pre-residence rental use?
Separate the depreciation-attributable gain, then allocate the remainder to nonqualified use. Taylor recognizes $12,000 of depreciation-attributable gain plus $99,000 allocated to rental use, totaling $111,000.
What denominator is used for Section 121 nonqualified use?
Use total ownership time, not just principal-residence time. Taylor’s three rental years divided by six total ownership years gives a 3/6 fraction.
Can Section 121 exclude depreciation on a former rental home?
No exclusion applies to gain attributable to depreciation allowed or allowable after May 6, 1997. Taylor must recognize that $12,000 separately from the nonqualified-use allocation.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Gains and losses on property dispositions, worked step by step.
Section 1245 Recapture & Section 1231 Netting | CPA REG TBS on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Gains and losses on property dispositions
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.