REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 6 practice questions
Stock Holding Period: When Long-Term Starts and Gifts Tack
Long-term capital gain requires holding stock for more than one year, including the donor’s holding period when the donor’s basis carries over. Below, a gift timeline shows why the gift date does not restart the clock.
Try one first
Hint
For a gift sold at a gain, determine whether the donee adds the donor's holding period, then exclude the acquisition date when counting.
Answer D. For gifted property sold at a gain, the donee tacks the donor's holding period. Reed's holding period began on April 11, Year 1, because the purchase date is excluded. Long-term treatment requires more than one year, so the earliest long-term sale date is April 11, Year 2.
Why not A: This answer comes from counting the donor's purchase date as part of the holding period. The acquisition date is excluded, so a sale on April 10, Year 2 is only one year, not more than one year.
Why not B: This answer comes from correctly excluding the gift date but still ignoring tacking. Because Nolan keeps Reed's holding period for gain property, Nolan does not need to hold the stock for a full year after the gift.
Why not C: This answer comes from starting Nolan's holding period on the gift date and ignoring the donor's tacked period. For gain property received by gift, Nolan includes Reed's prior holding period, and the gift date itself is not counted.
The timeline
- April 10, Year 1Reed purchases investment stock.
Exclude the purchase date when counting the holding period.
- April 11, Year 1Reed’s holding period begins.
This is the first day counted toward the more-than-one-year requirement.
- September 1, Year 1Reed gives the stock to Nolan.
Nolan’s basis for determining gain is Reed’s basis. Nolan tacks Reed’s holding period; the gift does not restart it.
- April 10, Year 2The original purchase reaches its one-year anniversary.
A sale today would produce short-term gain. Exactly one year is not more than one year.
- April 11, Year 2Nolan can first sell at a gain with long-term treatment.
Include the sale date. The combined holding period now exceeds one year, so the entire gain is long-term.
Key points
- Remember: A carryover-basis gift changes the owner, not the holding-period clock.
- The purchase anniversary is exactly one year, so it is still too early for long-term treatment.
- The combined holding period determines the character of the entire gain, not separate portions before and after the gift.
How the exam traps you
- Counting the purchase date and choosing April 10, Year 2. Exclude April 10, Year 1. The earliest long-term sale date is April 11, Year 2.
- Starting a new clock when Nolan receives the gift. Nolan uses Reed’s basis for gain, so Reed’s holding period carries over.
- Splitting the gain between the donor’s and recipient’s ownership periods. Use the combined holding period to characterize the entire gain.
Question 2
Hint
Look for a special holding-period requirement in section 1244, not in capital gain rules.
Answer B. Section 1244 does not impose a special minimum holding period for ordinary loss treatment. If the stock otherwise qualifies, a loss on stock held only one day can still qualify for section 1244 ordinary loss treatment.
Why not A: This mistake imports the more-than-one-year long-term capital holding period. Section 1244 ordinary loss eligibility does not depend on reaching long-term holding status.
Why not C: This mistake assumes a six-month minimum applies. Section 1244 has no six-month holding-period requirement, so waiting six months is not necessary if other requirements are met.
Why not D: This mistake confuses section 1244 with rules that use a five-year holding period. Section 1244 ordinary loss treatment has no five-year minimum holding period.
Question 3
Hint
Count from the day after acquisition, and remember section 1231 requires more than one year.
Answer A. Section 1231 applies to qualifying business property only if it is held for more than one year. The holding period begins the day after acquisition, so a January 2, Year 1 purchase is held exactly one year on January 2, Year 2. It first exceeds one year on January 3, Year 2.
Why not B: This answer comes from counting nearly a full year as enough. The property is still short of one year on that date, so it cannot be section 1231 property yet.
Why not C: This answer applies the more-than-one-year rule but misses the word first. The machine already meets the holding period requirement on the prior day.
Why not D: This answer comes from treating the one-year anniversary as sufficient. Section 1231 requires a holding period of more than one year, not exactly one year.
Question 4
Hint
First decide whether the stock gets a new holding period or inherits the transferred property's period.
Answer A. Because Dana transferred investment land in a qualifying Sec. 351 exchange, the stock received takes the land's holding period. Investment land is a capital asset, so the stock is treated as held since the land was acquired. Therefore, the holding period begins on June 10, Year -2.
Why not B: This answer results from tying the stock's holding period to the corporation's formation date. That fails because the shareholder's holding period is determined by the transferred property's status and prior holding period, not by when the corporation was organized.
Why not C: This answer comes from assuming stock always starts a new holding period on the exchange date. That fails here because stock received for investment land in a Sec. 351 exchange tacks onto the land's existing holding period.
Why not D: This answer comes from applying the usual day-after-acquisition rule to newly received stock. That fails because the tacking rule applies when the transferred property is a capital asset, so the stock does not begin with a fresh post-exchange period.
Question 5
Hint
For securities, determine whether trade date or settlement date controls, then exclude the acquisition day itself.
Answer D. For stock bought in a regular-way market trade, the acquisition date is the trade date, not the settlement date. The holding period begins on the day after the acquisition date. Because Ava bought the stock on June 28, Year 1, the holding period starts June 29, Year 1.
Why not A: This answer comes from counting the purchase date itself as the first day. That fails because the acquisition date is excluded when starting the holding period.
Why not B: This answer comes from treating settlement as the acquisition date. That fails because a regular-way stock purchase is acquired on the trade date, not on settlement.
Why not C: This answer comes from using settlement and then applying the day-after rule. That fails because settlement does not control the acquisition date for this type of stock purchase.
Question 6
Hint
For QSBS transferred by gift, decide whether the recipient starts fresh or steps into the donor's holding period.
Answer A. For qualified small business stock received by gift, the donee generally tacks the donor's holding period. Priya measures the five-year requirement from Omar's acquisition date, assuming the stock otherwise continues to qualify as QSBS. That makes the relevant starting date April 2, Year 1.
Why not B: This answer comes from treating the gift as a new acquisition that restarts the holding period. That fails because a gift transfer generally carries over the donor's holding period for QSBS purposes.
Why not C: This answer misapplies the rule that counting often starts the day after an acquisition. The issue here is not day-counting after the gift, but whether Priya includes Omar's prior holding period, which she does.
Why not D: This answer assumes a new holding period starts with the next tax year or first full year of ownership. QSBS has no such convention, and the donee includes the donor's earlier holding period.
Common questions
What is the earliest long-term sale date for stock bought April 10?
April 11 of the following year. The holding period starts the day after purchase and includes the sale date.
Does receiving stock as a gift restart the holding period?
Not when the recipient sells at a gain using the donor’s basis. Nolan adds Reed’s holding period rather than starting over on September 1.
Is gain after the gift short-term if the recipient sells within a year?
Not in this carryover-basis example. If the combined holding period exceeds one year, the entire gain is long-term.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Gains and losses on property dispositions, worked step by step.
Section 1245 Recapture & Section 1231 Netting | CPA REG TBS on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Gains and losses on property dispositions
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.