REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 6 practice questions
Listed Property Recapture When Business Use Falls to 50% or Less
A drop from more than 50% qualified business use to 50% or less triggers listed property recapture during the recovery period. Follow one automobile through the mileage test, ordinary-income calculation, and switch to ADS.
Try one first
Hint
For listed property, first determine whether qualified business use exceeds the required percentage in the placed-in-service year.
Answer A. Listed property must be used more than 50% in qualified business use to be depreciated under the regular accelerated rules. Because the automobile was only 40% business use in the year it was placed in service, the business-use portion must be depreciated using straight-line under ADS from Year 1. The lack of an ADS election does not matter when ADS is required by this rule.
Why not B: This postpones the consequence as if the first year were only a testing year. When the property fails the use requirement in the placed-in-service year, ADS straight-line applies immediately for Year 1.
Why not C: This applies the regular GDS method for qualified business-use listed property. That method is unavailable because the automobile did not exceed the required business-use percentage in its first year.
Why not D: This treats the failed use test as merely denying accelerated methods. The rule requires ADS, not GDS, when listed property is not used more than 50% for qualified business use.
Step by step
- Establish the prior depreciation
A sole proprietor used a listed passenger automobile 100% for business in Years 1 and 2, claiming allowable depreciation of $12,000 and $18,000. No Section 179 or bonus depreciation was claimed; ADS straight-line would have allowed $8,000 each year.
- Calculate current qualified business use
In Year 3, the automobile travels 20,000 miles: 8,000 visiting clients, 6,000 commuting, and 6,000 personally. Qualified business use is 8,000 / 20,000 = 40%; commuting and personal miles stay out of the numerator.
- Identify the recapture trigger
Qualified business use fell from 100% to 40% during the recovery period. Because it fell from more than 50% to 50% or less, the listed property recapture rule applies in Year 3.
- Compare both prior years
Prior depreciation claimed totals $12,000 + $18,000 = $30,000. The ADS allowance for those same years totals $8,000 + $8,000 = $16,000.
- Recognize only the excess
Year 3 ordinary-income recapture is $30,000 - $16,000 = $14,000. Do not multiply that excess by the current 40% business-use percentage.
- Switch to ADS now
Use ADS straight-line beginning in Year 3 and thereafter. Only the business-use portion is depreciable, which is 40% in Year 3.
Key points
- Remember: Recapture takes back the excess over ADS, not all prior depreciation.
- The current business-use percentage triggers recapture; it does not scale the recapture amount.
- Commuting stays in total miles but out of qualified business miles.
How the exam traps you
- Count commuting as qualified business use and avoid recapture. Only client miles qualify here: 8,000 / 20,000 = 40%, which triggers recapture.
- Recapture only Year 1's $4,000 excess depreciation. Include both prior years: ($12,000 - $8,000) + ($18,000 - $8,000) = $14,000 of ordinary-income recapture.
- Recapture all $30,000 of prior depreciation. Subtract the $16,000 prior ADS allowance. Only the $14,000 excess is recaptured.
Question 2
Hint
Separate ordinary passenger automobiles from vehicles treated as qualified nonpersonal-use vehicles.
Answer A. A sedan used by a regional sales manager is an ordinary passenger automobile. Passenger automobiles are listed property for depreciation purposes unless a specific qualified nonpersonal-use vehicle exception applies. A manager's sedan does not fit those exceptions.
Why not B: The mistake is classifying all sedans as listed property. A marked police patrol vehicle is a qualified nonpersonal-use vehicle, so it is excluded from listed property.
Why not C: The mistake is treating every business vehicle as listed property. An ambulance used as an ambulance is a qualified nonpersonal-use vehicle, so it is excluded from listed property.
Why not D: The mistake is focusing only on whether the vehicle travels on public roads. A hearse used as a hearse is a qualified nonpersonal-use vehicle, so it is excluded from listed property.
Question 3
Hint
For listed property, ask whether the records capture amount of use, time, and business purpose close to when the use occurred.
Answer B. Listed property requires adequate records or sufficient evidence showing the amount of use, the time and place of use, and the business purpose. A mileage log prepared near the time of each trip and showing date, destination, purpose, and miles directly documents those elements. That is the strongest support for the claimed business-use percentage.
Why not A: This answer comes from thinking total annual miles plus a calendar is enough. It fails because the records do not show mileage for each business use, so they do not adequately substantiate the amount of business use.
Why not C: This answer comes from assuming a reasonable reconstruction is always enough. For listed property, records made near the time of use are far more reliable, and a year-end reconstruction is generally weaker because it lacks contemporaneous trip-by-trip detail.
Why not D: This answer comes from focusing on vehicle expenses rather than vehicle use. Receipts and invoices may show the car was operated, but they do not establish miles driven for each business trip or the time and purpose of each use.
Question 4
Hint
Separate home-to-regular-office commuting from travel between two business locations.
Answer B. Qualified business use includes miles from the regular office to client sites and miles between two work locations. Those miles total 12,000. Commuting between home and the regular office is personal use, as are errands and family trips, so qualified business use is 12,000 divided by 20,000, or 60.0%.
Why not A: This choice results from counting only client-site travel as business and treating the branch-office travel as personal. Travel between two work locations in the same business is business use, so the 4,000 branch-office miles must be included.
Why not C: This choice results from treating the 5,000 home-to-office commuting miles as business use. Even in an employer-provided vehicle, commuting is personal use when the employee's home is not the principal place of business.
Why not D: This choice combines two errors: counting commuting miles as business and excluding branch-office miles as personal. The rule goes the other way on both categories: commuting is personal, while travel between work locations is business.
Question 5
Hint
For listed property, separate trade or business use from use for producing investment income.
Answer B. For listed property, qualified business use includes use in a trade or business. Use to produce investment income, such as attending shareholder meetings or meeting an investment adviser, is excluded. Only the client-site miles for the consulting practice are included in the numerator.
Why not A: This counts both consulting and investment miles in the numerator. Investment use may relate to income production, but it is not qualified business use for this listed property test.
Why not C: This treats the investment-adviser miles as qualified business use while excluding shareholder-meeting miles. Both uses relate to managing investments, so neither is included in the qualified business-use numerator.
Why not D: This treats shareholder-meeting miles as qualified business use because they involve companies in the brokerage account. Investment portfolio activity is excluded from qualified business use for listed property.
Question 6
Hint
For vehicles treated as trucks or vans, focus on the controlling weight measure for the threshold.
Answer B. The passenger automobile caps do not apply if the vehicle is outside the passenger automobile definition. For trucks and vans, including SUVs built on truck chassis, the 6,000-pound test uses GVWR. The SUV with 6,100-pound GVWR is over the threshold and is excluded from the caps.
Why not A: This answer results from applying the truck and van GVWR test to a sedan. For a sedan, unloaded gross vehicle weight controls, and 5,800 pounds is within the threshold.
Why not C: This answer assumes a minivan is automatically excluded because it is treated as a truck or van. The truck and van rule still requires GVWR above the threshold, and 5,950 pounds is not above it.
Why not D: This answer treats the threshold amount as if it were already outside the passenger automobile definition. A truck-chassis SUV at exactly 6,000 pounds GVWR is not over the threshold, so it is not excluded.
Common questions
How do you calculate listed property depreciation recapture?
Subtract prior ADS straight-line depreciation from prior depreciation claimed. Here, $30,000 minus $16,000 produces $14,000 of ordinary income in Year 3.
Does commuting count toward qualified business use?
No. The automobile's 6,000 commuting miles count in total miles, but not qualified business miles. Its qualified business use is 8,000 / 20,000, or 40%.
When does ADS begin after listed property business use drops?
ADS straight-line begins in the year qualified business use falls to 50% or less. Here, ADS begins in Year 3, and depreciation remains limited to the business-use portion.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Cost recovery: depreciation, amortization and depletion, worked step by step.
Section 179 & Bonus Depreciation | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Cost recovery: depreciation, amortization and depletion
- MACRS Conventions: Half-Year, Mid-Quarter, or Mid-Month
- Section 179 Investment Phaseout
- Bonus Depreciation: Acquisition Date vs. Service Date
- Section 197 Amortization: 180 Months From Acquisition
- Cost vs. Percentage Depletion: Calculate the Deduction
All Cost recovery: depreciation, amortization and depletion practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.