REG · Federal Taxation of Property Transactions · 6 practice questions
Cost vs. Percentage Depletion: Calculate the Deduction
For a qualifying mineral property, compare cost depletion with percentage depletion after applying its taxable income limit, then deduct the larger amount. Below: a worked coal-property calculation showing why the limit comes before the comparison.
Try one first
Hint
Compute cost depletion and percentage depletion separately for the year, then compare the two results.
Answer D. Cost depletion is $88,000, computed as $440,000 divided by 220,000 tons, times 44,000 tons sold. Percentage depletion is $120,000, computed as 15% of $800,000 gross income. The allowable deduction is the greater of the two amounts, so $120,000 is deductible.
Why not A: This is the correctly computed cost depletion amount. It fails because the taxpayer must compare cost depletion with percentage depletion and deduct the larger amount.
Why not B: This comes from subtracting cost depletion from percentage depletion. The rules do not allow deduction of only the excess. The taxpayer deducts the full larger amount.
Why not C: This results from adding cost depletion and percentage depletion together. The methods are alternatives for the same property and year, so only one amount is deducted.
Worked example
Summit owns a coal property eligible for percentage depletion. Its beginning adjusted depletable basis is $40,000, with 100,000 recoverable tons remaining. During the year, Summit sells 25,000 tons. Gross income from the property is $600,000, and allocable deductions excluding depletion are $500,000. The percentage depletion rate is 10%. What depletion deduction may Summit claim?
| 1 | Compute cost depletion$40,000 ÷ 100,000 tons = $0.40 per ton; $0.40 × 25,000 tons | $10,000 |
| 2 | Compute percentage depletion before the cap10% × $600,000 | $60,000 |
| 3 | Compute property taxable income before depletion$600,000 − $500,000 | $100,000 |
| 4 | Apply the percentage depletion cap50% × $100,000 = $50,000; smaller of $60,000 and $50,000 | $50,000 |
| 5 | Choose the larger allowable deductionLarger of $10,000 cost depletion and $50,000 percentage depletion | $50,000 |
Summit deducts $50,000 of percentage depletion.
Check: Selling one-quarter of the remaining tons recovers only $10,000 of cost, so the capped $50,000 percentage amount wins.
Key points
- Cost depletion uses adjusted depletable basis and recoverable units remaining at the start of the year.
- Multiply the cost depletion rate by units sold during the year.
- The taxable income cap limits percentage depletion, not cost depletion.
- The methods are alternatives. Do not add their deductions together.
How the exam traps you
- Deducting the uncapped $60,000 percentage amount. Apply the $50,000 taxable income cap before comparing the methods.
- Stopping after computing $10,000 of cost depletion. Compare it with the allowable $50,000 percentage amount and deduct the larger.
- Limiting the deduction to the $40,000 remaining basis. Percentage depletion can exceed remaining basis, so deduct $50,000.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on which resources are covered by statutory percentage depletion rates and which are recovered only by units cut or extracted.
Answer A. Percentage depletion applies to mines, oil and gas wells for qualifying owners, and geothermal deposits. Standing timber does not qualify for percentage depletion. Its basis is recovered through cost depletion, generally based on units of timber cut.
Why not B: This mistake treats geothermal property as outside the mineral depletion rules. Geothermal deposits are specifically eligible for percentage depletion, so they are not limited to cost depletion only.
Why not C: This choice usually comes from assuming only high-value minerals receive percentage depletion. Gravel is one of the listed mineral properties that qualifies for a statutory percentage depletion rate, so percentage depletion is available.
Why not D: This answer often reflects the idea that oil and gas properties never qualify for percentage depletion. Qualifying independent producers and royalty owners may claim percentage depletion on oil and gas property, subject to applicable limitations.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the special regular-tax election for domestic intangible drilling costs paid by a working-interest operator.
Answer C. For domestic oil and gas wells, an operator with a working interest may elect to deduct intangible drilling costs currently for regular tax. If the operator does not deduct them, the costs are capitalized into the depletable basis of the property. The AMT preference is outside the facts given.
Why not A: This result imports a fifteen-year amortization rule for other intangibles. Intangible drilling costs for a domestic working-interest owner are not recovered under fifteen-year amortization when the regular IDC election applies.
Why not B: This result treats the costs as subject to a sixty-month amortization regime. That confuses IDC rules with special limitations or other capital cost recovery rules; for these facts, current deduction is available, and capitalization is to depletable basis if not deducted.
Why not D: This result assumes the deduction is deferred until the well begins producing income. The IDC election is based on the nature of the drilling costs, not on waiting for production, so current deduction can be elected in Year 1.
Question 4
Hint
For separate mineral properties bought in one package, start with total cost and allocate it using each property's share of total FMV.
Answer A. When multiple mineral properties are bought for one price, the total basis is allocated among them by relative fair market values. West Mine's share is $480,000 divided by $1,200,000, or 40 percent. Applying 40 percent to the $960,000 purchase price gives $384,000.
Why not B: This is East Mine's allocated basis, not West Mine's. East Mine gets 60 percent of the $960,000 cost because its FMV is $720,000 out of the $1,200,000 total.
Why not C: This comes from assigning East Mine its full $720,000 FMV and giving West Mine the leftover cost. That fails because lump-sum cost must be allocated proportionally by FMV, not by giving one property its FMV first.
Why not D: This treats West Mine's FMV as if it were its tax basis. That fails because the properties were purchased together for less than their combined FMV, so each property takes only a proportionate share of the actual cost.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on whether the taxpayer and related persons cross the refinery-run ceiling during the year.
Answer C. The independent producer exception is unavailable if the taxpayer and related persons have refinery runs exceeding 75,000 barrels on any day during the year. Aster's combined refinery runs are 75,000 barrels, which does not exceed the amount. Because the facts say the other limits are satisfied, the refining activity does not bar the exception.
Why not A: This answer results from looking only at Bex's own 40,000 barrels. The refinery runs of related persons are aggregated, and 40,000 plus 36,000 exceeds 75,000 on that day.
Why not B: This answer results from focusing on each refinery separately. The rule combines refinery runs of the taxpayer and related persons, producing 76,000 barrels on that day.
Why not D: This answer results from treating 75,000 barrels for the taxpayer alone as determinative. The affiliate's 500 barrels are included, so the combined refinery runs exceed the ceiling.
Question 6
Hint
Start with the cost of acquiring the mineral interest, then separate out tangible assets used at the site.
Answer A. Depletable basis includes the cost of acquiring the mineral interest, including the lease bonus and legal fees to obtain the lease. Tangible assets used in operations, such as extraction equipment and buildings, are recovered through depreciation rather than depletion.
Why not B: This answer adds the extraction equipment to depletable basis. Equipment is a separate tangible asset recovered through depreciation, not depletion.
Why not C: This answer ignores the legal fees. Costs paid to acquire or perfect the mineral lease are added to the mineral property's depletable basis.
Why not D: This answer treats all site costs as depletable. The extraction equipment and storage building are depreciable assets, not part of the mineral property's depletable basis.
Common questions
How do you calculate cost depletion?
Divide adjusted depletable basis by recoverable units remaining at the start of the year, then multiply by units sold. Here, $40,000 ÷ 100,000 tons × 25,000 tons equals $10,000.
Does the taxable income limit apply before comparing depletion methods?
Yes. Summit's coal percentage depletion falls from $60,000 to the $50,000 cap before comparison with $10,000 of cost depletion.
Can percentage depletion exceed remaining basis?
Yes, if the property qualifies and applicable limits are satisfied. Here, the $50,000 deduction exceeds the $40,000 remaining basis.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Cost recovery: depreciation, amortization and depletion, worked step by step.
Section 179 & Bonus Depreciation | CPA REG Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Cost recovery: depreciation, amortization and depletion
- MACRS Conventions: Half-Year, Mid-Quarter, or Mid-Month
- Section 179 Investment Phaseout
- Bonus Depreciation: Acquisition Date vs. Service Date
- Listed Property Recapture When Business Use Falls to 50% or Less
- Section 197 Amortization: 180 Months From Acquisition
All Cost recovery: depreciation, amortization and depletion practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.