REG · Business Law · 11 practice questions
Promoter Liability on Preincorporation Contracts
Adoption makes the corporation liable too, but it does not release the promoter. Compare the same preincorporation contract as the release, adoption, or signature facts change.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the promoter's original liability from the corporation's later adoption, and ask what additional step is required to release the promoter.
Answer C. A promoter who signs a preincorporation contract is generally personally liable on that contract. After the corporation is formed it may adopt the contract and become liable as well. Adoption does not by itself release the promoter; only a novation (an agreement by the other contracting party to substitute the corporation) will discharge the promoter's personal liability.
Why not A: Tempting because adoption makes the corporation liable, but adoption alone does not release the promoter. The promoter remains liable unless the other party agrees to a novation substituting the corporation.
Why not B: This relies on the fact the corporation did not yet exist when the contract was signed, but once formed the corporation can adopt the preincorporation contract and become liable going forward.
Why not D: Incorrect, preincorporation contracts are not automatically void. The promoter can be personally bound when signing, and the later-formed corporation can assume liability by adopting the contract.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Before Lakeview, Inc. existed, Dana signed a supply contract with Vendor as "Dana, on behalf of Lakeview, Inc., a corporation to be formed." After incorporation, Lakeview's board expressly adopted the contract. The contract did not limit Dana's personal liability, and no novation or separate release occurred. Who is liable?
Answer: Both Dana and Lakeview, Inc.
Dana signed before Lakeview existed. The board's adoption made Lakeview liable too, but it did not release Dana.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1All parties agree to a novation substituting Lakeview for Dana and releasing Dana.
Answer: Only Lakeview, Inc.
Vendor agreed to replace Dana with Lakeview. Unlike adoption alone, this novation releases Dana.
Change 2Lakeview never adopts the contract, expressly or by conduct.
Answer: Only Dana.
Dana remains liable as the promoter. Lakeview's formation alone does not bind it to the contract.
Change 3Dana signs "Lakeview, Inc., by Dana, President."
Answer: Both Dana and Lakeview, Inc.
The title does not matter because Lakeview did not exist at signing. Adoption binds Lakeview without releasing Dana.
Change 4Lakeview adopts by accepting and using the supplies instead of passing a board resolution.
Answer: Both Dana and Lakeview, Inc.
The form of adoption does not change the result. Accepting and using the supplies binds Lakeview but does not release Dana.
Key points
- Remember: Adoption adds the corporation; novation replaces the promoter.
- Without adoption, incorporation alone does not make Lakeview liable.
- Accepting and using the supplies can establish adoption without a board resolution.
- Signing as president does not protect Dana when Lakeview does not yet exist.
How the exam traps you
- Treating Lakeview's adoption as an automatic release of Dana. Look separately for Vendor's agreement to substitute Lakeview and release Dana.
- Assuming Lakeview can never owe on a contract signed before formation. Post-formation adoption can make Lakeview liable too.
- Treating Dana's corporate title as protection from personal liability. Lakeview did not exist when Dana signed. The title does not prevent promoter liability.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer C. Correct. Adoption adds Lakeview's liability while Dana remains liable without a release.
Why not A: Incorrect. Adoption makes Lakeview liable but does not release Dana.
Why not B: Incorrect. Lakeview became liable when its board adopted the contract.
Why not D: Incorrect. Signing before incorporation does not make the contract void.
Question 2
Answer A. Correct. The novation substitutes Lakeview and releases Dana.
Why not B: Incorrect. Dana is released, and Lakeview is the substituted obligor.
Why not C: Incorrect. Unlike adoption alone, this novation ends Dana's liability.
Why not D: Incorrect. The novation releases Dana, not Lakeview.
Question 3
Answer B. Correct. Dana remains liable, and Lakeview never became bound through adoption.
Why not A: Incorrect. Lakeview did not adopt the contract, and Dana was not released.
Why not C: Incorrect. Incorporation alone does not make Lakeview liable.
Why not D: Incorrect. Dana's original promoter liability continues.
Question 4
Answer C. Correct. The title changes nothing: adoption binds Lakeview, and Dana has not been released.
Why not A: Incorrect. The president title does not eliminate Dana's promoter liability.
Why not B: Incorrect. Lakeview's later adoption makes it liable too.
Why not D: Incorrect. The title neither voids the contract nor prevents liability.
Question 5
Answer C. Correct. Lakeview adopted by conduct, while Dana remains liable without a release.
Why not A: Incorrect. Accepting contract benefits does not release Dana.
Why not B: Incorrect. Lakeview can adopt through conduct without a board resolution.
Why not D: Incorrect. Dana's signature and Lakeview's adoption create liability for both.
Question 2
Hint
Separate the question of when the corporation becomes bound from the question of when the promoter stops being bound.
Answer C. A promoter who signs a preincorporation contract is ordinarily personally liable because no corporation existed at the time of contracting. After incorporation the corporation may adopt or assume the contract, but adoption or corporate performance alone does not discharge the promoter. The critical issue is whether there was a novation or an express release by the third party, i.e., whether Lessor Co. agreed to look only to the corporation and released Lee.
Why not A: Adoption by the corporation shows that the corporation became bound and liable, which makes the corporation a proper defendant, but adoption alone does not release the promoter from his original personal liability unless the third party also agreed to substitute and release him.
Why not B: Disclosure rules for agents and principals are inapplicable to a nonexistent entity: naming a 'to-be-formed' corporation does not eliminate promoter liability at the time of contracting. The decisive post-formation fact is whether the third party later accepted the corporation as obligor and released the promoter.
Why not D: Acceptance of benefits and corporate performance are strong evidence of corporate adoption and that the corporation is liable, but they do not by themselves release the promoter from personal liability absent a novation or express release by the third party.
Question 3
Hint
Ask two separate questions: when does the corporation become bound, and what is required to release the person who signed before the corporation existed?
Answer A. A promoter who enters a preincorporation contract is generally personally liable unless the contract provides otherwise or the parties later enter into a novation. A corporation's later adoption of the contract makes the corporation liable as well, but adoption alone does not release the promoter. Because the landlord never agreed to substitute Apex for Diaz, Diaz remains liable unless all three parties agree to a novation.
Why not B: This is tempting because accepting benefits and performing can create implied adoption by the corporation. But implied adoption has the same limitation as express adoption: it may bind the corporation without discharging the promoter. The landlord's assent to a substitution is still required.
Why not C: This is tempting because express adoption is the classic step that causes the newly formed corporation to become bound on the contract. However, the trap is confusing corporate liability with promoter release. Adoption adds Apex as an obligor; it does not by itself eliminate Diaz's personal liability.
Why not D: This distractor appeals to the common shortcut that formation of the corporation cures the promoter problem. It does not. A unilateral notice after incorporation cannot release Diaz from a contract already made in a preincorporation capacity; the third party must agree to the substitution through a novation.
Question 4
Hint
Determine whether Jane's pre‑incorporation signature makes her a promoter and whether Supplier agreed to substitute the corporation (novation) or release her.
Answer B. Jane acted as a promoter by entering into a contract on behalf of a not‑yet‑formed corporation. Under the rules governing promoters and pre‑incorporation contracts, a promoter remains personally liable on such contracts unless the third party agrees to a novation or otherwise releases the promoter. When the corporation adopted the contract after incorporation and accepted the equipment, it became liable as well, but adoption alone does not discharge the promoter.
Why not A: Tempting because corporate adoption binds the corporation to the contract, but incorrect: adoption does not automatically release the promoter, the third party must consent to a novation or expressly release the promoter before personal liability is extinguished.
Why not C: Tempting because promoters are personally liable on pre‑incorporation contracts, but incorrect because the corporation also became liable when it adopted the contract, both can be liable concurrently absent a novation or release.
Why not D: Tempting because signing in a corporate capacity can suggest intent to bind only the corporation, but incorrect because the corporation did not exist at signing and Supplier did not agree to release Jane; mere use of a title does not eliminate promoter liability without a novation or release.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the question of whether the corporation became liable from the question of whether the promoter stopped being liable.
Answer A. Under common-law promoter rules, a promoter who signs a contract before incorporation is personally liable on that contract. A corporation's adoption of a preincorporation contract makes the corporation liable as well, but adoption alone does not discharge the promoter. The promoter is released only if the third party (here Lessor) agrees to a novation that substitutes the corporation for the promoter and releases the promoter.
Why not B: Adoption is relevant because it binds the corporation, but it does not by itself release the promoter from personal liability; candidates who stop the analysis at adoption miss the separate novation requirement for discharge.
Why not C: Disclosure that the corporation was not yet formed may affect reliance or notice, but it does not negate the promoter's personal liability; the critical issue for release is whether the third party agreed to substitute the corporation (novation).
Why not D: Subsequent payments and billing can show corporate adoption or assent, but they do not by themselves constitute a novation releasing the promoter absent the third party's assent to substitute the corporation and discharge the promoter.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the analysis into two questions: what makes the corporation liable after formation, and what event would be required to cut off the promoter's original liability?
Answer C. A promoter who enters into a preincorporation contract is generally personally liable unless the parties agree otherwise or a later novation releases the promoter. After formation, the corporation can become liable by adopting the contract, either expressly or by conduct such as accepting benefits and making payments. Here, Nova adopted the lease, but nothing indicates Lessor released Rios, so both remain liable.
Why not A: Tempting because corporate adoption creates the corporation's liability, but adoption alone does not discharge the promoter. A novation or an express release by the other contracting party is required to relieve the promoter of personal liability.
Why not B: This appeals to the rule that a nonexistent corporation cannot be an original contracting party, but after incorporation a corporation may adopt a preincorporation contract and assume liability; Nova's board approval, acceptance of the equipment, and payments support adoption.
Why not D: Lessor's knowledge that the corporation did not yet exist does not automatically prevent corporate adoption or relieve the promoter. Absent a novation or release, the promoter remains personally liable even if the corporation later adopts the contract.
Common questions
What is the difference between adoption and novation?
Adoption makes Lakeview liable without releasing Dana. A novation agreed to by Dana, Lakeview, and Vendor substitutes Lakeview for Dana and releases Dana.
Is a corporation liable if it never adopts a preincorporation contract?
Under these facts, no. If Lakeview never adopts the contract, expressly or by conduct, Dana alone remains liable.
Does signing as president avoid promoter liability?
No. Dana's title does not change the fact that Lakeview did not exist when the contract was signed.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Business Organizations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.