PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Business Law · 11 practice questions

Promoter Liability on Preincorporation Contracts

Adoption makes the corporation liable too, but it does not release the promoter. Compare the same preincorporation contract as the release, adoption, or signature facts change.

The ruleA promoter is generally personally liable on a preincorporation contract. Corporate adoption adds corporate liability; a novation agreed to by the third party substitutes the corporation and releases the promoter.

Try one first

Before Lakeview, Inc. was formed, Dana signed a supply contract with Vendor on behalf of "Lakeview, Inc., a corporation to be formed." After the corporation was properly formed in Year 1, Lakeview's board expressly adopted the contract and accepted delivery of the goods. Assume no novation was executed. Under the general rule, which party is liable on the contract?
Hint

Separate the promoter's original liability from the corporation's later adoption, and ask what additional step is required to release the promoter.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Before Lakeview, Inc. existed, Dana signed a supply contract with Vendor as "Dana, on behalf of Lakeview, Inc., a corporation to be formed." After incorporation, Lakeview's board expressly adopted the contract. The contract did not limit Dana's personal liability, and no novation or separate release occurred. Who is liable?

Answer: Both Dana and Lakeview, Inc.

Dana signed before Lakeview existed. The board's adoption made Lakeview liable too, but it did not release Dana.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1All parties agree to a novation substituting Lakeview for Dana and releasing Dana.

Answer: Only Lakeview, Inc.

Vendor agreed to replace Dana with Lakeview. Unlike adoption alone, this novation releases Dana.

Change 2Lakeview never adopts the contract, expressly or by conduct.

Answer: Only Dana.

Dana remains liable as the promoter. Lakeview's formation alone does not bind it to the contract.

Change 3Dana signs "Lakeview, Inc., by Dana, President."

Answer: Both Dana and Lakeview, Inc.

The title does not matter because Lakeview did not exist at signing. Adoption binds Lakeview without releasing Dana.

Change 4Lakeview adopts by accepting and using the supplies instead of passing a board resolution.

Answer: Both Dana and Lakeview, Inc.

The form of adoption does not change the result. Accepting and using the supplies binds Lakeview but does not release Dana.

Key points

  • Remember: Adoption adds the corporation; novation replaces the promoter.
  • Without adoption, incorporation alone does not make Lakeview liable.
  • Accepting and using the supplies can establish adoption without a board resolution.
  • Signing as president does not protect Dana when Lakeview does not yet exist.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating Lakeview's adoption as an automatic release of Dana. Look separately for Vendor's agreement to substitute Lakeview and release Dana.
  • Assuming Lakeview can never owe on a contract signed before formation. Post-formation adoption can make Lakeview liable too.
  • Treating Dana's corporate title as protection from personal liability. Lakeview did not exist when Dana signed. The title does not prevent promoter liability.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Before Lakeview, Inc. existed, Dana signed a supply contract with Vendor as "Dana, on behalf of Lakeview, Inc., a corporation to be formed." After incorporation, Lakeview's board expressly adopted the contract. The contract did not limit Dana's personal liability, and no novation or separate release occurred. Who is liable?

Question 2

Same facts, except Dana, Lakeview, and Vendor agree to a novation substituting Lakeview for Dana and releasing Dana. Who is liable?

Question 3

Same facts, except Lakeview never adopts the contract, expressly or by conduct. Who is liable?

Question 4

Same facts, except Dana signs "Lakeview, Inc., by Dana, President." Who is liable?

Question 5

Same facts, except Lakeview adopts by accepting and using the supplies instead of passing a board resolution. Who is liable?

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Before Metro Analytics, Inc. was formed, Lee signed a 3-year equipment lease with Lessor Co. as "Lee, on behalf of Metro Analytics, Inc., to be formed." Two weeks later, Metro was properly incorporated. Its board then approved taking over the lease, Metro used the equipment for 8 months, and all rent payments during that period were made from Metro's corporate account. Lessor Co. knew Metro had been incorporated and thereafter sent invoices directly to Metro, but Lessor Co. never expressly stated that Lee was released. Metro later defaulted, and Lessor Co. sued Lee personally. Assuming ordinary promoter-liability rules apply, which factor is most important in determining whether Lee remains personally liable?
Hint

Separate the question of when the corporation becomes bound from the question of when the promoter stops being bound.

Question 3

Before formation, Diaz signed a warehouse lease "on behalf of Apex Robotics, Inc., a corporation to be formed." The landlord knew Apex had not yet been incorporated. After Apex was formed in Year 1, its board expressly adopted the lease, Apex occupied the space, and Apex paid rent for six months before defaulting. Assume the lease did not disclaim Diaz's personal liability and the landlord never agreed at signing to look solely to the future corporation. Under standard corporate-law principles, what response would have been required to discharge Diaz from personal liability on the lease?
Hint

Ask two separate questions: when does the corporation become bound, and what is required to release the person who signed before the corporation existed?

Question 4

In Year 1, Jane negotiated and signed a contract with Supplier for equipment that she stated was "for XL Corp." (which did not yet exist). On the signature line she wrote: "XL Corp., by Jane, President." XL Corp. was incorporated in Year 2. After incorporation the board unanimously adopted the contract and the corporation accepted and used the equipment, but the corporation never paid Supplier. Supplier did not execute any novation or sign any release of Jane. Supplier sues Jane and XL Corp. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Determine whether Jane's pre‑incorporation signature makes her a promoter and whether Supplier agreed to substitute the corporation (novation) or release her.

Question 5

Before Beacon Analytics, Inc. was incorporated in Year 1, Hall signed a 3-year equipment lease with Lessor, signing "Hall, for Beacon Analytics, Inc., a corporation to be formed." Two weeks later, Beacon was properly incorporated. Beacon's board then adopted the lease by resolution, Beacon took possession of the equipment, and Beacon made six monthly payments from corporate funds. Lessor thereafter sent invoices directly to Beacon. Beacon later defaulted, and Lessor sued Hall personally for the remaining lease payments. Assume no state statute changes the common-law promoter rules, the lease contains no clause releasing Hall upon incorporation, and Lessor never expressly agreed orally or in writing to release Hall. In deciding Hall's personal liability, what is the primary legal issue?
Hint

Separate the question of whether the corporation became liable from the question of whether the promoter stopped being liable.

Question 6

Rios negotiated a 5-year office equipment lease with Lessor and signed the agreement "Rios, on behalf of Nova Analytics, Inc., a corporation to be formed." At the time of signing, Lessor knew Nova had not yet been incorporated. The lease did not state that Rios would be released if Nova was later formed. Two weeks later, Nova was properly incorporated. Nova's board then formally approved the lease, accepted delivery of the equipment, and made the first two monthly payments before defaulting. Lessor sues both Nova and Rios for the remaining lease obligations. Assume no novation or separate release was ever executed. Which conclusion is most supportable?
Hint

Separate the analysis into two questions: what makes the corporation liable after formation, and what event would be required to cut off the promoter's original liability?

Drill all 83 Business Organizations questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What is the difference between adoption and novation?

Adoption makes Lakeview liable without releasing Dana. A novation agreed to by Dana, Lakeview, and Vendor substitutes Lakeview for Dana and releases Dana.

Is a corporation liable if it never adopts a preincorporation contract?

Under these facts, no. If Lakeview never adopts the contract, expressly or by conduct, Dana alone remains liable.

Does signing as president avoid promoter liability?

No. Dana's title does not change the fact that Lakeview did not exist when the contract was signed.

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Business Organizations

All Business Organizations practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.