REG · Business Law · 6 practice questions
LLC, LLP, and LP: Personal Liability
LLC members, LLP partners, and LP limited partners are shielded from entity debts, not their own guaranties or wrongful acts. Sort Maya's liability at North Peak as its business form, her role, or her conduct changes.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on whether the business form provides a liability shield and whether anything in the facts removes that protection.
Answer A. A properly formed LLC generally shields its members and managers from personal liability for the LLC's contractual debts. Because Maya acted within her authority, signed for the LLC, and did not personally guarantee the obligation or engage in wrongful conduct, the contract liability remains with the LLC.
Why not B: Tempting because students may overgeneralize agency rules, but an authorized agent who signs on behalf of a disclosed principal (the LLC) is not personally liable unless she agreed to be or the principal is undisclosed or there is another basis for liability.
Why not C: This confuses LLCs with general partnerships. Members of a properly formed LLC do not automatically have personal liability for ordinary contract debts of the LLC.
Why not D: Being a member-manager does not itself remove the liability shield. Personal liability would require a separate basis such as a personal guarantee, piercing the corporate veil, or personal wrongdoing, none of which are alleged.
Sort it
The owner has a liability shield and neither guaranteed the obligation nor committed the wrongful act.
The owner personally guaranteed the obligation or committed the wrongful act giving rise to the claim.
The person is an LP general partner, even without a guaranty or personal wrongdoing.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Maya signs North Peak LLC's supply contract as an authorized member-manager. She gives no personal guaranty and commits no wrongdoing. | No personal liabilityMaya signed for the disclosed LLC. Her authorized signature does not make the LLC's contract debt her personal debt. |
| Maya signs a separate personal guaranty of North Peak LLC's supply debt. | Personal liability: guaranty or own wrongful actThe guaranty creates Maya's own payment obligation. LLC status does not cancel that promise. |
| At properly registered North Peak LLP, another partner commits malpractice. Maya has no involvement and gives no guaranty. | No personal liabilityAn LLP partner is not personally liable for another partner's malpractice solely because of partner status. |
| Maya is North Peak LP's general partner. She did not negotiate or sign its unpaid supply contract. | Personal liability: LP general partnerAn LP general partner is personally liable for partnership obligations. Not signing the contract does not create a shield. |
| Maya owns 70% of North Peak LLC and approves an expansion that fails. She gives no guaranty and commits no wrongdoing. | No personal liabilityMajority ownership and an unsuccessful business decision do not themselves make Maya personally liable for LLC debts. |
| Maya personally commits malpractice while serving a client of properly registered North Peak LLP. | Personal liability: guaranty or own wrongful actThe LLP shield does not protect Maya from liability for her own malpractice. |
| Maya, a limited partner in North Peak LP, inspects its books and votes to approve a sale of substantially all assets. | No personal liabilityExercising these governance rights does not by itself strip Maya of limited-partner protection. |
| Maya personally guarantees North Peak LLP's supply debt. She committed no wrongful act. | Personal liability: guaranty or own wrongful actA guaranty creates personal liability even when the LLP partner committed no wrongdoing. |
| Maya, a limited partner, signs North Peak LP's supply contract as its authorized agent. The supplier knows the principal; Maya gives no guaranty. | No personal liabilityActing as an authorized agent for a disclosed LP does not itself create personal contract liability or change Maya's limited-partner status. |
| An employee of properly registered North Peak LLP commits malpractice. Maya neither participates in nor supervises the work and has no knowledge of the negligence. | No personal liabilityMaya's LLP partner status alone does not make her personally liable for the employee's negligence. |
| Maya remains a limited partner in North Peak LP but personally guarantees its supply debt. | Personal liability: guaranty or own wrongful actMaya is liable on her guaranty, not because she became a general partner. |
| Another member guarantees North Peak LLC's supply debt. Maya gives no guaranty and commits no wrongful act. | No personal liabilityThe guaranty binds the signer, not every LLC member. |
Key points
- Remember: The shield blocks liability from ownership, not from your own guaranty or wrongful act.
- Signing for a disclosed entity is different from signing a personal guaranty.
- A guaranty binds its signer; it does not make every owner personally liable.
How the exam traps you
- Treating management or an authorized signature as a personal guaranty. Neither makes a shielded owner personally liable for entity debt by itself.
- Assuming the liability shield cancels a personal guaranty. A guaranty is a separate personal promise to pay the specified debt.
- Treating an LLP partner like an LP general partner. An LLP partner has a liability shield; an LP general partner is personally liable for partnership obligations.
Question 2
Hint
Ask which obligation exists only because Hall is a partner, and which exists because Hall personally agreed to be liable.
Answer A. An LLP generally shields a partner from personal liability for partnership obligations that arise solely from another partner's wrongful acts, including malpractice when the partner was not involved. That liability shield does not eliminate obligations a partner personally assumes. Because Hall signed a personal guarantee for the bank loan, Hall remains personally liable for that loan but, on these facts, not for the other partner's malpractice claim.
Why not B: Tempting if a candidate overgeneralizes partner liability from traditional partnerships; however, an LLP typically protects partners from personal liability for another partner's malpractice when they were not involved, so Hall would not be personally liable for that malpractice claim on these facts.
Why not C: This reflects the common mistake of treating an LLP like a general partnership for all claims. Hall is personally liable on the loan because of the personal guarantee but is not personally liable for the other partner's malpractice simply by being an LLP partner.
Why not D: This overgeneralizes the LLP shield. While an LLP protects partners from personal liability for partnership obligations arising solely from partner status, it does not protect a partner from obligations the partner personally undertakes, such as a signed personal guarantee.
Question 3
Hint
Focus first on the type of entity that was formed, then ask whether Quinn personally participated in or supervised the wrongful conduct.
Answer A. A properly formed LLP generally shields partners from personal liability for partnership obligations arising from another partner's or an employee's negligence when the partner was not personally involved. Because Quinn did not participate in, supervise, or have knowledge of the negligent audit work, Quinn is not personally liable merely because Quinn is a partner. (A partner can still be liable for his or her own personal malpractice or for obligations the partner personally incurred.)
Why not B: This reflects the general partnership rule that partners are jointly and severally liable, but it is incorrect here because PQR is an LLP and the LLP form limits an uninvolved partner's personal exposure for another's negligence.
Why not C: This distractor mixes concepts from other business forms (such as limited partners or investors). LLP protection is not correctly described as a personal liability capped at a partner's capital contribution.
Why not D: This overbroadly assumes that all partners are personally liable for any professional-services claim against the firm. In a properly formed LLP, an uninvolved partner is generally protected from personal liability for another partner's or an employee's negligent acts.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on the difference between liability arising from being an LLC member and liability arising from a separate personal promise.
Answer C. An LLC generally shields members from personal liability for the entity's debts. However, a member who personally guarantees an LLC obligation is liable on that separate guaranty. Because Lee did not sign a guaranty and no veil-piercing issue exists, Lee is generally not personally liable merely for being a member.
Why not A: This overstates the rule. The LLC shield generally protects members, but it does not eliminate liability a member voluntarily assumes by signing a personal guaranty; Mason signed such a guaranty.
Why not B: This confuses LLCs with general partnerships. Unlike general partners, LLC members are not personally liable for entity debts solely because of membership; only a separate guaranty or another basis for liability would expose a member personally.
Why not D: Ownership percentages govern internal profit and loss sharing, not third-party creditor liability. Without a guaranty, veil piercing, or similar basis, members are generally protected from personal liability to outside creditors.
Question 5
Hint
Separate two issues: Grace's status as a limited partner and Grace's role as an agent signing for a disclosed principal. Ask whether either fact, by itself, creates personal liability under current law.
Answer C. Under modern limited-partnership statutes and prevailing CPA-exam treatment, a limited partner does not lose limited-liability status merely by participating in management or exercising governance rights. Acting as an authorized agent for a disclosed principal likewise does not automatically impose personal liability unless the partner personally guaranteed or otherwise assumed the obligation.
Why not A: This distractor echoes the older 'control' concern. While tempting, modern uniform acts and most jurisdictions permit certain management-type activities by limited partners without stripping limited liability; the facts show no personal guaranty or separate assumption of debt.
Why not B: This misstates the relationship between agency and partnership status. Acting as the partnership's agent does not terminate Grace's status as a limited partner, and an agent for a disclosed principal is not typically personally liable absent a personal undertaking.
Why not D: This overgeneralizes the liability of general partners to all partners and ignores the distinction between signing for a disclosed principal and personally guaranteeing obligations. The supplier's awareness that it dealt with the LP and the absence of a guaranty defeat this claim.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on what breaks the normal LLC liability shield for a member on a company debt, not on who managed the business or made the bad decision.
Answer A. Members of an LLC are generally protected from personal liability for the company's contractual obligations. Signing the note as "Dana, Member, Harbor LLC" indicates a representative capacity and would not, by itself, create personal liability. A personal guaranty is a separate contractual promise that creates direct personal liability to the lender, so that fact would make Dana personally liable.
Why not B: This is tempting because candidates sometimes conflate LLC members with general partners, but active management alone does not expose a member to personal liability for entity debts absent a guaranty, veil piercing, or separate wrongful conduct.
Why not C: Majority ownership increases control but does not automatically remove the LLC liability shield; ownership percentage alone does not create personal liability for company debts.
Why not D: A poor business decision or voting for an expansion that fails does not usually make a member personally liable for the entity's contractual debts absent wrongdoing, a guaranty, or veil-piercing facts.
Common questions
Can an LLC member be personally liable for company debts?
Membership alone does not create personal liability. A member can be liable on a personal guaranty or for the member's own wrongful conduct.
Are LLP partners personally liable for another partner's malpractice?
An uninvolved LLP partner is generally not personally liable solely because of partner status. The partner who committed the malpractice remains personally liable for that act.
Can a limited partner participate in management without losing limited liability?
Under modern LP rules, inspecting books, voting on major matters, and signing as an authorized agent do not alone remove limited liability. A personal guaranty still creates personal liability.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Business Organizations
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.