REG · Business Law · 5 practice questions
Agent Contract Liability: Disclosed, Unidentified, Undisclosed
An authorized agent is generally not liable for a disclosed principal but is liable for an unidentified or undisclosed principal. Below, compare Nora's authorized purchase for BlueCo by changing only what Supplier knows when the contract is made.
Try one first
Hint
First classify the principal's status at the time of contracting: disclosed, unidentified, or undisclosed. Then apply the liability rule for an authorized agent in that setting.
Answer D. Nora disclosed that she acted for a principal but did not disclose the principal's identity, making BlueCo a partially disclosed (unidentified) principal. An authorized agent who contracts for a partially disclosed principal generally leaves both the principal and the agent liable when there is no agreement releasing the agent. Because Nora had actual authority and there was no release, Supplier may hold both BlueCo and Nora liable.
Why not A: This distractor plays on the rule for a fully disclosed principal (where the principal, not the agent, is usually liable). Here the principal's identity was not disclosed, so the agent remains potentially liable as well.
Why not B: Failing to disclose the principal can leave the agent liable, but it does not prevent the principal from being bound when the agent has actual authority. Thus both the agent and the principal can be liable.
Why not C: Ratification is relevant when the agent lacked authority at the time of contracting. Here Nora had actual authority and the contract is already binding on BlueCo, so later ratification is unnecessary.
Side by side
| Disclosed principal | Unidentified (partially disclosed) principal | Undisclosed principal | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Same authorized purchase | BlueCo authorizes Nora to buy raw materials from Supplier. | BlueCo authorizes Nora to buy raw materials from Supplier. | BlueCo authorizes Nora to buy raw materials from Supplier. |
| What Nora discloses at signing | "I am buying for BlueCo." | "I am buying for a principal I cannot name." | Nora does not mention any principal. |
| Supplier knows Nora is an agent | Yes. | Yes. | No. Supplier believes Nora is the buyer. |
| Supplier knows BlueCo is the principal | Yes. | No. | No. |
| Agreement changing default liability | None. | None. | None. |
| Who Supplier may hold liable if BlueCo refuses to pay | Generally, BlueCo only. | Both BlueCo and Nora. | Both BlueCo and Nora. |
Key points
- Remember: Saying "I am an agent" is not enough; Supplier must also know BlueCo's identity.
- Judge disclosure when Nora and Supplier make the contract.
- Hiding the agency itself does not change the result: both Nora and BlueCo remain liable.
How the exam traps you
- Supplier knows Nora is an agent, so only BlueCo is liable. Knowing an agency exists is not enough. Without BlueCo's identity, Nora remains liable too.
- Only Nora is liable because BlueCo was not named. Nora's actual authority also binds BlueCo, even when Supplier does not know BlueCo exists.
Question 2
Hint
Classify the principal first: disclosed, partially disclosed, or undisclosed. Then recall how that classification affects the agent's contract liability.
Answer D. This is a partially disclosed principal situation: Vendor Co. knew Lena was an agent but did not know the principal's identity. When an agent with authority contracts on behalf of a partially disclosed principal, both the principal and the agent are generally liable unless the contract or law provides otherwise. The facts here show Lena had authority and no clause eliminating her personal liability.
Why not A: This choice confuses a fully disclosed principal with a partially disclosed one. If the principal's identity were fully disclosed, only the principal would normally be liable; because the principal's identity was not disclosed, the agent remains potentially liable as well.
Why not B: Students may overcorrect and assume that nondisclosure of the principal removes principal liability. That is incorrect: a partially disclosed principal can still be held liable on an authorized contract, and the agent is also generally liable unless the contract says otherwise.
Why not C: This distractor relies on the mistaken idea that failing to name the principal defeats contract liability. It does not; the contract can bind an authorized agent and a partially disclosed principal, so liability can attach to one or both parties.
Question 3
Hint
Classify the principal first: disclosed, unidentified, or undisclosed. The agent's contract liability changes depending on that classification.
Answer D. This is a partially disclosed (unidentified) principal situation: Seller knew Dana was acting for a principal but not the principal's identity. When an agent with actual authority contracts for a partially disclosed or unidentified principal, both the principal and the agent are generally liable to the third party unless the parties agree otherwise. The stem states there was no agreement excluding Dana's personal liability, so both Dana and the principal are liable on the breached contract.
Why not A: This confuses the disclosed-principal rule with a partially disclosed principal. If the principal's identity had been disclosed, the agent would normally avoid personal liability, but because the principal's identity is unknown, the agent remains potentially liable.
Why not B: This treats the agent as the sole obligor; however, an authorized principal who had capacity is also bound when the agent acted with actual authority. Therefore the principal, as well as the agent, may be held liable.
Why not C: Ratification applies when the agent lacked authority at the time of contracting. Here Dana had actual authority and the principal had capacity, so ratification is unnecessary and both parties are liable.
Question 4
Hint
First identify whether the principal was disclosed, unidentified, or undisclosed at the time of contracting. That classification drives who is liable.
Answer A. This is an undisclosed principal situation because Vendor was not told that Alex was acting for any principal. When an agent with actual authority contracts with a third party while the principal is undisclosed, the principal is bound by the contract and the agent is also personally liable to the third party. No later ratification is required because Alex had actual authority at the time the contract was made.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to the rule that actual authority binds the principal. It is incorrect here because, with an undisclosed principal, the agent generally remains personally liable to the third party as well.
Why not C: This choice is tempting because Vendor believed Alex was the buyer and Alex signed in his own name. However, when an agent acts with actual authority for an undisclosed principal, the third party may hold the principal liable as well as the agent.
Why not D: This option confuses ratification with lack of authority. Ratification applies when an agent lacked authority at the time of contracting. Here Alex had actual authority, so the contract is binding without any later ratification.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on the agent's fiduciary duty when a third party offers a personal benefit connected to the agent's work for the principal.
Answer C. An agent owes the principal a duty of loyalty and may not accept a personal benefit from a third party in connection with transactions conducted on the principal's behalf without the principal's informed consent. The vendor's $2,000 payment is a side benefit tied to Lee's decision for North, creating a conflict of interest. Therefore Lee must disclose the payment to North and obtain North's informed consent before accepting it.
Why not A: This choice relies on an economic-harm shortcut. The duty of loyalty is breached by the undisclosed side payment itself; it is not cured simply because the vendor's price appears reasonable to North.
Why not B: This distractor tempts candidates to focus on who funds the payment. But agency law bars undisclosed personal benefits tied to agency decisions regardless of whether the payment comes from the vendor or the principal.
Why not D: Good faith or honest belief does not eliminate the duty to avoid undisclosed personal benefits connected to agency transactions. Lee still must disclose the payment and obtain North's consent.
Common questions
When is an agent not liable for a disclosed principal?
If Supplier knows Nora is acting for BlueCo when the contract is made, BlueCo is generally liable and Nora is not. This assumes Nora has authority and no agreement changes the default rule.
Is a partially disclosed principal the same as an undisclosed principal?
No. With a partially disclosed, or unidentified, principal, Supplier knows Nora represents someone but does not know whom. With an undisclosed principal, Supplier believes Nora acts for herself; both cases leave Nora and BlueCo liable.
Who is liable on a contract with an unidentified principal?
Both Nora and BlueCo are liable on the authorized contract when no agreement changes the default rule.
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Agency
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.