REG · Tax Procedures and Accounting Issues · 6 practice questions
Who Can Use the Cash Method With Inventory?
A taxpayer that meets the Section 448(c) gross receipts test and is not a tax shelter generally may use cash accounting, even with inventory. Below: follow Maple's eligibility check and roll the testing period forward.
Try one first
Hint
Separate the issue into two steps: first, whether Maple can use the cash method at all; second, whether a qualifying small taxpayer must still use §471 inventories.
Answer B. Because Maple satisfies the §448(c) gross receipts test and is not a tax shelter, current law permits the use of the cash method even for a taxpayer that sells merchandise. A qualifying small taxpayer is not required to account for inventories under §471 and instead may apply an IRS-permitted small-taxpayer inventory method for those items.
Why not A: This reflects the older, pre‑gross-receipts-test rule; it is incorrect here because the stated facts say Maple meets the gross receipts test and is not a tax shelter, so the cash method is allowed.
Why not C: This is partially correct about the cash method but incorrect about inventories: a qualifying small taxpayer is not required to treat items under §471 and may use a permitted small-taxpayer approach instead.
Why not D: This relies on an outdated limitation. Current law allows many C corporations beneath the gross receipts threshold to use the cash method regardless of personal service corporation status, provided they are not tax shelters.
Step by step
- Set the eligibility year
Maple is a calendar-year C corporation that sells merchandise and holds inventory. Determine its cash-method eligibility for Year 4; assume no other exception or method restriction applies.
- Test the prior three years
For Year 4, average Maple's gross receipts for Years 1 through 3. The average must not exceed the applicable Section 448(c) threshold; Maple's average is below it.
- Check tax-shelter status
Maple is not a tax shelter, so this restriction does not block cash accounting. If Maple were a tax shelter, low receipts would not permit cash accounting.
- Decide Year 4 eligibility
Maple generally may use cash accounting for Year 4 despite its inventory and C corporation status.
- Roll the test forward
At the end of Year 4, Maple's average gross receipts for Years 2 through 4 exceed the applicable threshold. Maple must use accrual for Year 5, but its Year 4 cash-method eligibility remains unchanged.
Key points
- Remember: Inventory does not bar cash accounting if the receipts test is met and the taxpayer is not a tax shelter.
- Cash-method eligibility permits cash accounting; it does not require the taxpayer to choose it.
- Failing the next testing period does not retroactively invalidate a properly used cash method.
How the exam traps you
- Inventory automatically requires accrual. Check gross receipts and tax-shelter status; Maple's inventory does not bar cash accounting.
- Low gross receipts override tax-shelter status. Tax shelters cannot use cash accounting, even when their receipts are below the threshold.
- An excessive Years 2 through 4 average forces accrual in Year 4. That average governs Year 5; Year 4 eligibility uses Years 1 through 3.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the current federal eligibility rule for using the cash method, not on older generalizations about entity type.
Answer C. Eligibility to use the cash method generally depends on meeting the small-business gross-receipts test (average gross receipts for the prior three years below the statutory threshold) and not being in a category barred from the cash method. The facts eliminate inventory and tax-shelter complications, so the gross-receipts-based eligibility rule controls.
Why not A: Candidates may think balance-sheet positions force accrual accounting, but the tax permissibility of the cash method hinges on statutory eligibility tests, not the relative size of receivables and payables.
Why not B: This is tempting because older guidance sometimes tied entity form to method rules. Under current rules, entity type alone does not disqualify a small business that satisfies the gross-receipts test and is not otherwise prohibited.
Why not D: Consistent profitability might raise compliance questions but is not the statutory test for method eligibility; the gross-receipts threshold and prohibited categories are the controlling factors.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the question of overall eligibility to use the cash method from the separate question of how merchandise costs are treated.
Answer A. Under current federal tax rules, a taxpayer that is below the Sec. 448(c) gross-receipts threshold and is not a tax shelter is generally allowed to use the cash method, even if it purchases and resells merchandise. Inventory on hand no longer automatically forces such a taxpayer onto the accrual method. However, qualifying to use cash does not mean all merchandise purchases are immediately deductible; the taxpayer must still apply a permitted tax treatment for inventory.
Why not B: This is tempting because many candidates remember the older general rule that inventory-producing or inventory-holding taxpayers used accrual. But under the current small-business exception, inventory by itself does not bar the cash method if the taxpayer meets the gross-receipts test and is not a tax shelter. The presence of merchandise still matters for inventory treatment, but it is not automatically disqualifying for overall method eligibility.
Why not C: This distractor is appealing because students often assume tax accounting must match book accounting. In general, tax and financial-statement methods do not have to be the same, and keeping accrual books does not by itself prevent use of the cash method for federal income tax. The tax eligibility question here turns on the statutory limits, not book-method conformity.
Why not D: This choice is tempting because it correctly focuses on the gross-receipts threshold, but it applies the rule too broadly. The tax-shelter limitation must also be considered, and even a qualifying cash-method taxpayer that sells merchandise cannot simply deduct all purchases when paid without regard to a permitted inventory treatment. It confuses eligibility for the cash method with the separate timing rules for merchandise costs.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on the rule that can block the cash method even when the gross receipts test is satisfied.
Answer B. Meeting the Sec. 448(c) gross receipts test generally permits a taxpayer to use the cash method, but certain categories remain ineligible. Tax shelters are a statutory exception and generally are barred from using the cash method even if they meet the gross receipts threshold. Therefore the C corporation that is a tax shelter is not permitted to use the cash method.
Why not A: This distractor plays on overbroad memories of cash-method limits. A small sole proprietorship that meets the gross receipts test and has no special industry rule is generally allowed to use the cash method.
Why not C: Many candidates think inventory automatically forces accrual accounting. Under the current small‑business exceptions, meeting the gross receipts test often permits cash-method treatment even where inventory exists (subject to the specific inventory rules), so this partnership is not the best answer.
Why not D: Some students overgeneralize that all C corporations must use accrual accounting. If a C corporation meets the gross receipts test and is not a tax shelter, it may generally use the cash method, so this option is incorrect.
Question 5
Hint
Identify whether any statutory disqualification (for example, tax‑shelter status under IRC §448) remains effective even when the taxpayer otherwise meets the small‑business gross‑receipts exception.
Answer A. IRC §448 limits use of the cash method and includes a statutory disqualification for taxpayers that meet the definition of a tax shelter; the small‑business gross‑receipts exception does not override that separate disqualification. Thus, although Larch's gross receipts are below the applicable threshold and the presence of a C corporation partner alone would not always be dispositive, Larch's tax‑shelter status is the controlling statutory bar to using the cash method for Year 1.
Why not B: Tempting due to historical rules about partnerships with corporate partners, but incorrect: the mere presence of a C corporation investor is not automatically dispositive when the small‑business exception applies, and here the decisive issue is the tax‑shelter disqualification.
Why not C: Tempting because the small‑business gross‑receipts exception often permits cash accounting, but incorrect: the tax‑shelter disqualification is a separate statutory bar that is not negated simply by meeting the gross‑receipts test.
Why not D: Tempting because book accounting can influence tax accounting, but incorrect: statutory eligibility to use the cash method is determined by the Internal Revenue Code and regulations, not simply by GAAP treatment.
Question 6
Hint
Do not rely on the older shortcut that selling merchandise always forces accrual. Start with the gross receipts test and the tax-shelter limitation.
Answer D. Because Pine meets the three-year average gross receipts test under IRC §448(c) and is not a tax shelter, it qualifies for the small-business exception and generally may use the cash method even for a resale business. The older blanket rule that selling merchandise always forces accrual does not apply to qualifying taxpayers.
Why not A: This answer plays on the hybrid-method misconception. While hybrid methods exist in some situations, a qualifying small-business taxpayer that meets Sec. 448(c) generally may use the cash method overall under these facts; accrual for sales is not automatically required.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to the historical rule that inventory businesses and many C corporations used accrual, but the Sec. 448(c) small-business exception allows qualifying taxpayers to use the cash method despite holding merchandise.
Why not C: This choice misleads by tying the method decision to year-end inventory levels. The controlling test here is the gross receipts exception and tax-shelter status, not simply whether merchandise remains on hand at year-end.
Common questions
Does inventory require a small C corporation to use accrual?
No. Maple may use cash for Year 4 because its prior three-year gross receipts average passes Section 448(c) and it is not a tax shelter.
Can a tax shelter use the cash method with low gross receipts?
No. If Maple were a tax shelter, the gross receipts exception would not allow it to use cash accounting.
Which three years count for the Section 448(c) gross receipts test?
Use the three tax years immediately before the year being tested. Maple uses Years 1 through 3 for Year 4 and Years 2 through 4 for Year 5.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Accounting Methods, worked step by step.
Cash-to-Accrual & Section 481 Adjustment | CPA REG TBS on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Accounting Methods
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.