PracticeREGFree practice exam

REG · Tax Procedures and Accounting Issues · 6 practice questions

Cash vs. Accrual Deductions: The 12-Month Rule

A qualifying prepaid service expense can be deductible when paid under the cash method, but accrual deductions still require economic performance. Below, compare Maple's cleaning contract under both methods.

The ruleCash taxpayers may deduct qualifying prepayments when paid; accrual deductions need a fixed liability, reasonably determinable amount, and economic performance. The 12-month rule requires benefits to end within 12 months of starting and by the following tax year's end.

Try one first

Maple Services, a calendar-year C corporation, uses the accrual method for federal income tax purposes. On December 20, Year 1, Maple completed consulting services for a customer. The fee was fixed at $18,000 under the contract, and Maple sent the invoice on December 22, Year 1. The customer paid the invoice on January 15, Year 2. Assume collectibility was not in doubt and no special deferral rule applies. In which tax year should Maple include the $18,000 in gross income?
Hint

Focus on the tax timing rule for an accrual-method taxpayer, not on when cash is collected.

Side by side

Cash methodAccrual method
PaymentMaple pays $12,000 on December 1, Year 1.Maple pays $12,000 on December 1, Year 1.
Contract12 equal monthly cleanings, December, Year 1, through November, Year 2.12 equal monthly cleanings, December, Year 1, through November, Year 2.
AssumptionsCalendar year; ordinary expense; fixed liability and amount; no special elections or exceptions.Calendar year; ordinary expense; fixed liability and amount; no special elections or exceptions.
12-month rulePasses: 12 months of benefits, ending November 30 before the December 31, Year 2 deadline.Passes: 12 months of benefits, ending November 30 before the December 31, Year 2 deadline.
Year 1 services performedDecember cleaning completed: $1,000.December cleaning completed: $1,000.
Deduction timing triggerPayment, because the prepayment qualifies.Cleaning performed, because economic performance is required.
Year 1 deduction$12,000.$1,000.
Year 2 deduction$0; already deducted in Year 1.$11,000 as the remaining cleaning is performed.

Key points

  • Remember: The 12-month rule removes capitalization; it does not replace economic performance for accrual deductions.
  • Passing only one deadline is not enough; the cleaning contract must satisfy both.
  • A fixed contract price establishes the amount, not whether the cleaning has been performed.

How the exam traps you

  • Prorating Maple's cash-method deduction to $1,000. The qualifying prepaid contract allows the full $12,000 cash-method deduction in Year 1.
  • Deducting $12,000 under accrual because Maple paid. Only $1,000 of cleaning was performed in Year 1; payment does not complete economic performance.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

A calendar-year sole proprietor uses the cash method for federal income tax purposes and has no inventory. During Year 1, the taxpayer had the following items:
ItemAmount
On December 28, Year 1, the taxpayer completed services and billed a customer . The customer mailed a check on December 30, Year 1, but the taxpayer did not receive the check and had no ability to access the funds until January 3, Year 2$12,000
On December 31, Year 1, another customer paid by credit card for services already performed. The card processor recorded the charge and credited the taxpayer's merchant account for the full on December 31, Year 1; the processor withheld a $300 processing fee and remitted $9,700 cash on January 3, Year 2$10,000
On December 15, Year 1, the taxpayer received a nonrefundable advance payment for services to be performed entirely in January Year 2$6,000
Assume no special deferral method applies to the advance payment. What amount is most supportable for inclusion in Year 1 gross income from these items?
Hint

Treat each item separately under the cash method: was it actually received in Year 1 or constructively received (i.e., credited and available)? Pay attention to whether the merchant account was credited for the gross charge and whether the mailed check was accessible in Year 1.

Question 3

Nile, a calendar-year sole proprietor, uses the cash method for tax reporting. On December 1, Year 1, Nile paid $24,000 for a 24-month business insurance policy covering December 1, Year 1, through November 30, Year 3. No special exception applies other than the general prepaid-expense rules. How much of the payment may Nile deduct in Year 1?
Hint

Focus on whether the prepaid insurance qualifies for immediate deduction under the 12-month rule, and if not, how a prepaid benefit is usually recovered.

Question 4

Nolan, a calendar-year sole proprietor, uses the cash method for tax purposes. Nolan completed the related services in Year 1. On December 30, Year 1, Client A told Nolan that a $12,000 check was ready for pickup at Client A's office. The office was open on December 30 and December 31, and Nolan could have picked up and deposited the check on either day without restriction, but Nolan chose to wait until January 2, Year 2. On December 31, Year 1, Nolan received from Client B a $3,000 check dated January 5, Year 2. What is the most supportable amount Nolan should include in Year 1 gross income from these two payments?
Hint

For a cash-method taxpayer, ask whether the money was unrestrictedly available by year-end and whether each check was actually payable at that time.

Question 5

Jordan, a sole proprietor, uses the cash method of accounting for federal income tax purposes. On December 20, Year 1, Jordan received a $12,000 nonrefundable payment for consulting services to be performed in February of Year 2. Jordan had unrestricted use of the funds when received, and no special statutory deferral provision applies. What is the correct tax treatment of the $12,000?
Hint

Focus first on the taxpayer's accounting method and whether the payment was actually received with unrestricted use.

Question 6

Elm, a calendar-year accrual-method taxpayer, provides consulting services. Elm completed a client project on December 20, Year 1, and billed the client $18,000 on December 27, Year 1. The fee was not contingent or disputed. The client paid on January 15, Year 2. Assume Elm does not have an applicable financial statement and no special deferral rule applies. Under Elm's accounting method, which factor governs whether the $18,000 is included in Year 1 income?
Hint

Start by identifying whether this taxpayer is using the cash method or the accrual method, then apply the timing rule that matches that method.

Drill all 132 Accounting Methods questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does the 12-month rule apply to cash or accrual taxpayers?

It is a capitalization exception, not a replacement for an accounting method's timing rules. Maple's prepaid cleaning qualifies, but accrual timing still limits Year 1 deductions to completed services.

Can a cash-basis taxpayer deduct prepaid cleaning?

Yes, if the payment is otherwise deductible and satisfies the 12-month rule. Maple deducts $12,000 in Year 1 because the contract lasts 12 months and ends before Year 2 closes.

When does economic performance occur for prepaid cleaning services?

For Maple's contract, economic performance occurs as cleaning is performed. Only December's $1,000 qualifies for an accrual deduction in Year 1, despite full payment.

Watch it solved

A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Accounting Methods, worked step by step.

Cash-to-Accrual & Section 481 Adjustment | CPA REG TBS on YouTube

Practice REG like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Accounting Methods

All Accounting Methods practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.