REG · Tax Procedures and Accounting Issues · 6 practice questions
Cash vs. Accrual Deductions: The 12-Month Rule
A qualifying prepaid service expense can be deductible when paid under the cash method, but accrual deductions still require economic performance. Below, compare Maple's cleaning contract under both methods.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the tax timing rule for an accrual-method taxpayer, not on when cash is collected.
Answer D. Under the accrual method, income is recognized when the all-events test is met: the taxpayer's right to receive the income is fixed and the amount can be determined with reasonable accuracy. Maple completed the services in Year 1, the fee was fixed, and collectibility was not in doubt, so the $18,000 is included in Year 1.
Why not A: Revenue for services isn't split between years for an accrual-method taxpayer absent a specific statutory or contractual basis for allocation or a deferral/ installment rule; the full amount is recognized when the all-events test is met.
Why not B: This reflects the cash-method rule; a cash-method taxpayer recognizes income on receipt. But Maple uses the accrual method, so the timing is governed by the all-events test rather than actual cash receipt.
Why not C: Sending an invoice alone doesn't always determine timing, but here the controlling facts are completion of the services and a fixed fee in Year 1, which satisfy the all-events test despite the invoice date being incidental.
Side by side
| Cash method | Accrual method | |
|---|---|---|
| Payment | Maple pays $12,000 on December 1, Year 1. | Maple pays $12,000 on December 1, Year 1. |
| Contract | 12 equal monthly cleanings, December, Year 1, through November, Year 2. | 12 equal monthly cleanings, December, Year 1, through November, Year 2. |
| Assumptions | Calendar year; ordinary expense; fixed liability and amount; no special elections or exceptions. | Calendar year; ordinary expense; fixed liability and amount; no special elections or exceptions. |
| 12-month rule | Passes: 12 months of benefits, ending November 30 before the December 31, Year 2 deadline. | Passes: 12 months of benefits, ending November 30 before the December 31, Year 2 deadline. |
| Year 1 services performed | December cleaning completed: $1,000. | December cleaning completed: $1,000. |
| Deduction timing trigger | Payment, because the prepayment qualifies. | Cleaning performed, because economic performance is required. |
| Year 1 deduction | $12,000. | $1,000. |
| Year 2 deduction | $0; already deducted in Year 1. | $11,000 as the remaining cleaning is performed. |
Key points
- Remember: The 12-month rule removes capitalization; it does not replace economic performance for accrual deductions.
- Passing only one deadline is not enough; the cleaning contract must satisfy both.
- A fixed contract price establishes the amount, not whether the cleaning has been performed.
How the exam traps you
- Prorating Maple's cash-method deduction to $1,000. The qualifying prepaid contract allows the full $12,000 cash-method deduction in Year 1.
- Deducting $12,000 under accrual because Maple paid. Only $1,000 of cleaning was performed in Year 1; payment does not complete economic performance.
Question 2
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| On December 28, Year 1, the taxpayer completed services and billed a customer . The customer mailed a check on December 30, Year 1, but the taxpayer did not receive the check and had no ability to access the funds until January 3, Year 2 | $12,000 |
| On December 31, Year 1, another customer paid by credit card for services already performed. The card processor recorded the charge and credited the taxpayer's merchant account for the full on December 31, Year 1; the processor withheld a $300 processing fee and remitted $9,700 cash on January 3, Year 2 | $10,000 |
| On December 15, Year 1, the taxpayer received a nonrefundable advance payment for services to be performed entirely in January Year 2 | $6,000 |
Hint
Treat each item separately under the cash method: was it actually received in Year 1 or constructively received (i.e., credited and available)? Pay attention to whether the merchant account was credited for the gross charge and whether the mailed check was accessible in Year 1.
Answer A. Under the cash method, amounts are included when actually or constructively received (Treas. Reg. §1.451-1; constructive receipt is defined in §1.451-2). The $10,000 credit-card charge is included in Year 1 because the processor credited the merchant account for the full $10,000 on December 31, making the gross amount constructively received; the $300 processing fee is a deductible business expense and does not reduce gross receipts. The $6,000 nonrefundable advance was received on December 15 and is includible in Year 1. The $12,000 check was not available to the taxpayer until January 3, Year 2 and therefore is not included in Year 1.
Why not B: This choice is tempting because some taxpayers net processor fees against card receipts and would treat the $10,000 less $300 as the amount received. It is incorrect because the merchant account was credited for the full $10,000 in Year 1 (constructive receipt), and the $300 is generally deductible as an expense rather than a reduction of gross receipts.
Why not C: This answer is attractive to those who both include the mailed $12,000 check in Year 1 and net the $300 fee against total receipts (10,000 + 12,000 + 6,000 − 300 = 27,700). It fails because the mailed check was not available to the taxpayer in Year 1 (no constructive receipt) and processor fees are treated as an expense, not a reduction of the gross charge.
Why not D: This option counts all three items at gross ($12,000 + $10,000 + $6,000). It is incorrect because the $12,000 check mailed late in Year 1 was not in the taxpayer's possession or otherwise available until Year 2, so it should not be included in Year 1.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on whether the prepaid insurance qualifies for immediate deduction under the 12-month rule, and if not, how a prepaid benefit is usually recovered.
Answer A. The 12-month rule does not apply because the policy's benefit extends beyond the earlier of 12 months after the benefit begins or the end of the next tax year. The $24,000 premium must be capitalized and deducted ratably over the 24-month coverage period (24,000/24 = 1,000 per month). Only December Year 1 (one month) is deductible in Year 1, so $1,000 is deductible.
Why not B: This reflects a misapplication of a one-year/12-month shortcut (treating half the premium as Year 1 expense). The 12-month rule is unavailable here because the policy's benefit extends past the applicable 12-month/end-of-next-year cutoff, so the premium is spread over 24 months.
Why not C: Tempting because Nile used the cash method, but prepaid expenses that provide future benefit beyond the allowable 12-month window must be capitalized rather than fully deducted when paid.
Why not D: Incorrectly assumes no portion is deductible until the policy ends. After capitalization, the prepaid premium is recovered ratably; the portion attributable to December Year 1 is deductible in that year.
Question 4
Hint
For a cash-method taxpayer, ask whether the money was unrestrictedly available by year-end and whether each check was actually payable at that time.
Answer D. A cash-method taxpayer includes income when actually or constructively received. The $12,000 check was constructively received in Year 1 because it was available for pickup without substantial limitation or restriction before year-end. The $3,000 postdated check is not currently payable on December 31, so it is not included until the later year.
Why not A: This is tempting if a candidate focuses only on when Nolan physically took possession of the first check and overlooks constructive receipt. It is wrong because the $12,000 was available without restriction in Year 1, so Nolan cannot defer income merely by choosing not to pick it up.
Why not B: This can attract candidates who think any check actually received by year-end is taxable immediately. It is wrong because a postdated check is not generally treated as currently available cash on the date received, while the $12,000 check was constructively received in Year 1.
Why not C: This is tempting if a candidate applies a broad 'all checks count when received or available' shortcut. It is wrong because the two payments are treated differently: the available $12,000 check is constructively received in Year 1, but the $3,000 postdated check is not includible until it becomes payable.
Question 5
Hint
Focus first on the taxpayer's accounting method and whether the payment was actually received with unrestricted use.
Answer B. A cash method taxpayer generally includes income when it is actually or constructively received. Because Jordan received the nonrefundable payment in Year 1 and had unrestricted use of the funds, the amount is included in Year 1 income. The fact that the services will be performed in Year 2 does not, by itself, permit a cash method taxpayer to defer recognition.
Why not A: This is tempting because financial accounting and some tax timing rules focus on when services are earned or performed. However, for a cash method taxpayer, receipt generally controls income recognition unless a specific deferral rule applies; the stem states that no special statutory deferral provision applies.
Why not C: This choice appeals to a fairness or matching instinct, but the cash method does not split a single received payment across years merely because the related services occur later. An unrestricted, nonrefundable payment is includible when received.
Why not D: Candidates may recall a one-year deferral concept for certain advance payments, but that is not an automatic rule that always applies; the question specifically disclaims any applicable statutory deferral provision.
Question 6
Hint
Start by identifying whether this taxpayer is using the cash method or the accrual method, then apply the timing rule that matches that method.
Answer B. For an accrual-method taxpayer, income is recognized when the all-events test is met: the right to receive the income is fixed and the amount can be determined with reasonable accuracy. Elm completed the work in Year 1 and the fee was not contingent or disputed, so the $18,000 is includible in Year 1 even though cash was collected in Year 2.
Why not A: This choice appeals to students who default to cash-basis timing. Because Elm uses the accrual method, recognition depends on the all-events test, not actual receipt of cash under these facts.
Why not C: Billing often occurs near recognition, so this can feel correct. However, the invoice date by itself does not control; the governing test is when the right to payment is fixed and the amount is reasonably determinable.
Why not D: This mixes a correct element (service completion can help fix the right to payment) with an incorrect extra requirement (requiring cash collection). Under accrual accounting, collection is not required once the all-events test is satisfied.
Common questions
Does the 12-month rule apply to cash or accrual taxpayers?
It is a capitalization exception, not a replacement for an accounting method's timing rules. Maple's prepaid cleaning qualifies, but accrual timing still limits Year 1 deductions to completed services.
Can a cash-basis taxpayer deduct prepaid cleaning?
Yes, if the payment is otherwise deductible and satisfies the 12-month rule. Maple deducts $12,000 in Year 1 because the contract lasts 12 months and ends before Year 2 closes.
When does economic performance occur for prepaid cleaning services?
For Maple's contract, economic performance occurs as cleaning is performed. Only December's $1,000 qualifies for an accrual deduction in Year 1, despite full payment.
Watch it solved
A full CPA REG task-based simulation on Accounting Methods, worked step by step.
Cash-to-Accrual & Section 481 Adjustment | CPA REG TBS on YouTube
Practice REG like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Accounting Methods
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.