PracticeISCFree practice exam

ISC · Security and Confidentiality and Privacy · 9 practice questions

SOC 2 Privacy vs Confidentiality: Classify Incidents

Privacy governs personal information and its permitted handling; confidentiality protects information designated confidential. Below: sort NorthCo's separate incidents by the data involved and the promise broken.

The rulePrivacy covers handling identifiable personal information consistently with stated commitments and applicable requirements. Confidentiality protects information designated confidential by law, contract, or policy; both apply when an incident violates both sets of obligations.

Try one first

A payroll service organization stores employee bank account numbers, Social Security numbers, and compensation data for its clients. The organization encrypts payroll files and restricts access to authorized personnel. It also provides notice about what personal information it collects, how that information is used, how long it is retained, and how individuals can request correction of inaccurate data. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate controls that protect information from unauthorized access from practices that govern how personal information is collected, used, retained, and corrected.

Sort it

Privacy

Personal information handling violates a privacy commitment, with no separate confidentiality failure established.

Confidentiality

Access or disclosure violates a confidentiality restriction, with no privacy failure established.

Both

The same incident violates a confidentiality restriction and a privacy commitment for personal information.

Neither established

The stated facts establish neither a privacy failure nor a confidentiality failure.

ItemGoes to
NorthCo's authorized marketers use customer email addresses for promotions. Its notice permits only order updates. Encryption and access restrictions remain effective.PrivacyThe new use breaks the stated purpose. Working access controls do not cure that mismatch.
NorthCo places vendor pricing schedules marked confidential in an internal folder open to employees without a business need. The schedules contain no personal information.ConfidentialityUnauthorized internal access to designated confidential business information establishes a confidentiality failure without requiring external disclosure.
NorthCo publicly posts customer records designated confidential. Its privacy notice promises protection against unauthorized disclosure.BothOne disclosure breaks the confidentiality restriction and the privacy promise covering identifiable customers.
NorthCo securely sends an opted-in customer list to its authorized campaign provider solely to deliver promotions, exactly as its privacy notice permits.Neither establishedExternal sharing alone is not a failure. The recipient, purpose, and customer choices match the stated commitments.
NorthCo retains identifiable customer purchase histories beyond its promised deletion date. No law requires longer retention, and access remains properly restricted.PrivacyExcess retention violates the personal-information commitment even without unauthorized access or disclosure.
NorthCo's employee sends a confidential product formula to a competitor without permission. The formula contains no personal information.ConfidentialityThe unauthorized disclosure concerns a business secret, not information about identifiable individuals.
A NorthCo role error lets department managers view confidential payroll bank details. Its employee privacy notice restricts access to payroll staff with a business need.BothThe same unnecessary access violates the records' confidentiality restriction and the notice's access commitment. External disclosure is not required.
NorthCo rejects a customer's valid request to correct an inaccurate birth date, contrary to its privacy notice. Access remains properly restricted.PrivacyThe failure concerns a promised correction process for personal information, not unauthorized access.
NorthCo retains fully anonymous purchase summaries after its personal-data deletion deadline. They cannot reasonably identify anyone and have no confidentiality restriction.Neither establishedThe tempting deletion deadline covers personal information. These summaries are not identifiable, and no confidentiality restriction is stated.
NorthCo accidentally emails one spreadsheet containing confidential supplier prices and customer names to an unauthorized consultant, contrary to its privacy notice. The consultant immediately deletes it.BothThe single disclosure affects confidential business information and personal information. Prompt deletion does not erase either classification.
NorthCo collects customer birth dates without providing the collection notice its privacy policy requires. Encryption and access restrictions remain effective.PrivacyMissing required notice is a personal-information handling failure. Encryption does not supply that notice.
NorthCo exposes confidential compensation summaries to unauthorized staff. The summaries are fully anonymized and cannot reasonably be linked to any individual.ConfidentialityAnonymization removes the personal-information basis for privacy here, but it does not remove the stated confidentiality restriction.

Key points

  • Remember: identify the data, then the broken promise; personal information can trigger privacy, confidentiality, or both.
  • Authorized access does not authorize every use of personal information.
  • Encryption protects data but does not fix a broken notice, purpose, or retention promise.
  • Sharing personal information is not automatically a failure when the notice permits that sharing.

How the exam traps you

  • Treating encrypted data as proof of privacy compliance. Check permitted uses and retention even when access controls work.
  • Classifying every personal-data incident as privacy only. Also test whether access or disclosure violated a confidentiality restriction.
  • Ignoring an incident because the recipient immediately deleted the file. Deletion may reduce harm, but it does not undo the unauthorized disclosure.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Nova Manufacturing maintains an internal file containing product formulas, planned pricing, and supplier terms. The file does not contain customer, employee, or other personal information. A purchasing manager with authorized system access emails the file to a former employee now working for a competitor, which violates company policy. There is no evidence the file was altered or deleted. What is the primary issue?
Hint

Identify what kind of information was exposed, then decide whether the main problem is disclosure, alteration, or lack of access.

Question 3

A company uses one escalation path for privacy incidents involving personal information and a separate path for confidentiality incidents involving nonpersonal business information. Assume none of the events below affects system availability. Which event should be classified primarily as a privacy incident?
Hint

Ask yourself whether the exposed information is about identifiable people or mainly about the company itself.

Question 4

A company stores customers' names, addresses, and purchase histories, and it also stores a proprietary pricing algorithm. Management is drafting separate policy objectives for privacy and for confidentiality. Assuming each option is feasible, which objective most directly addresses privacy rather than general confidentiality?
Hint

Ask which option is about governing personal information throughout its lifecycle, not just blocking unauthorized access.

Question 5

A subscription platform stores subscribers' names, email addresses, device identifiers, and viewing histories in an encrypted environment. Access is limited by role-based permissions, activity is logged, and no unauthorized access or external disclosure has been identified. The platform's public privacy notice states personal information is collected to provide the service, prevent fraud, and comply with legal requirements, and that viewing history is deleted after 24 months unless a longer period is legally required. In Year 2, management decides to retain all viewing histories indefinitely to develop an internal advertising model, but it does not update the privacy notice or seek additional customer consent. Assume no law requires the longer retention and the existing security controls continue to operate effectively. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Distinguish obligations about how data are used, retained, and disclosed relative to published commitments (privacy) from obligations to prevent unauthorized access or disclosure (confidentiality).

Question 6

Lakeview Services is preparing for a SOC 2 examination covering both confidentiality and privacy. Its system includes (1) customer contract terms and pricing schedules that are designated confidential by agreement and (2) personal information collected under Lakeview's published privacy notice. Assume each answer choice describes a separate incident, only the information stated in that choice was affected, and no additional facts should be assumed. Which incident most clearly indicates a confidentiality matter without, by itself, also establishing a privacy matter?
Hint

Focus first on what type of information is involved, then ask whether the facts point to designated confidential information, personal information, or both.

Question 7

A service organization is updating controls over customer personal information. The project includes providing notice about what personal information is collected, limiting use of that information to stated purposes, setting retention periods, and securely disposing of the information when no longer needed. Under the AICPA Trust Services Criteria, which category is most directly addressed by this project?
Hint

Ask yourself whether the controls deal with information in general, or specifically with personal information and how the organization collects, uses, keeps, and disposes of it.

Question 8

A streaming company encrypts customer account data at rest and in transit and limits employee access based on job role. The company also collects customers' exact location and detailed viewing-history data that are not needed to provide the subscribed service, and it shares those data with advertising partners without clearly disclosing that practice to customers. Assume no system intrusion, data alteration, or service outage occurred. Which issue is primarily raised by these facts?
Hint

Focus on whether the problem is about protecting data from unauthorized access or about how personal data are collected, used, and shared.

Question 9

Mercury Co. is evaluating two incidents under its information governance program. Assume the company's internal policies and posted notices reflect the facts below. Incident 1: Employee compensation records are designated confidential and may be used internally for payroll, HR administration, and workforce planning. Because of a role-mapping error, an outside contractor assigned to facilities maintenance, who has no business need for those records, can view them. Incident 2: Customer email addresses were collected under a posted notice stating they would be used only for order confirmations and customer service. Mercury later transfers the email list to a marketing partner for the partner's own promotional purposes. The transfer was encrypted, and the partner limits access to authorized personnel. Which statement best classifies the primary issue raised by each incident?
Hint

Ask whether the core problem is improper access by someone without a need-to-know (confidentiality) or an improper use/disclosure contrary to the posted notice/consent (privacy).

Drill all 163 Confidentiality and privacy questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What is the difference between privacy and confidentiality in SOC 2?

Privacy governs how personal information is handled under commitments and requirements. Confidentiality protects designated confidential information, including both business information and personal information.

Can authorized employee access still cause a privacy violation?

Yes. NorthCo's authorized marketing use violates privacy when its notice permits only order processing, even if encryption and access controls remain effective.

Can one SOC 2 incident involve both privacy and confidentiality?

Yes. NorthCo's public posting of confidential customer records breaks both its confidentiality restriction and its privacy promise against unauthorized disclosure.

Watch it solved

A full CPA ISC task-based simulation on Confidentiality and privacy, worked step by step.

Data Classification & Privacy Compliance | CPA ISC Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice ISC like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Confidentiality and privacy

All Confidentiality and privacy practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.