ISC · Security and Confidentiality and Privacy · 9 practice questions
SOC 2 Privacy vs Confidentiality: Classify Incidents
Privacy governs personal information and its permitted handling; confidentiality protects information designated confidential. Below: sort NorthCo's separate incidents by the data involved and the promise broken.
Try one first
Hint
Separate controls that protect information from unauthorized access from practices that govern how personal information is collected, used, retained, and corrected.
Answer D. Confidentiality is about protecting information from unauthorized access or disclosure, so technical and access controls like encryption and restricted access are confidentiality measures. Privacy concerns how personal information is collected, used, retained, and corrected; providing notice and correction and setting retention practices are privacy-oriented controls that govern handling of personal data.
Why not A: This reverses the concepts. Encryption and access controls are classic confidentiality controls (protecting access/disclosure), whereas notice, retention, and correction relate to how personal data is managed and are privacy practices.
Why not B: Although the data is personal, protecting files from unauthorized access (encryption, access restrictions) is primarily a confidentiality control. Privacy and confidentiality overlap but are distinct concepts.
Why not C: While payroll data is sensitive, not every practice described is about preventing unauthorized access. Notice and correction obligations address privacy (how data is handled and individuals' rights), not just confidentiality.
Sort it
Personal information handling violates a privacy commitment, with no separate confidentiality failure established.
Access or disclosure violates a confidentiality restriction, with no privacy failure established.
The same incident violates a confidentiality restriction and a privacy commitment for personal information.
The stated facts establish neither a privacy failure nor a confidentiality failure.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| NorthCo's authorized marketers use customer email addresses for promotions. Its notice permits only order updates. Encryption and access restrictions remain effective. | PrivacyThe new use breaks the stated purpose. Working access controls do not cure that mismatch. |
| NorthCo places vendor pricing schedules marked confidential in an internal folder open to employees without a business need. The schedules contain no personal information. | ConfidentialityUnauthorized internal access to designated confidential business information establishes a confidentiality failure without requiring external disclosure. |
| NorthCo publicly posts customer records designated confidential. Its privacy notice promises protection against unauthorized disclosure. | BothOne disclosure breaks the confidentiality restriction and the privacy promise covering identifiable customers. |
| NorthCo securely sends an opted-in customer list to its authorized campaign provider solely to deliver promotions, exactly as its privacy notice permits. | Neither establishedExternal sharing alone is not a failure. The recipient, purpose, and customer choices match the stated commitments. |
| NorthCo retains identifiable customer purchase histories beyond its promised deletion date. No law requires longer retention, and access remains properly restricted. | PrivacyExcess retention violates the personal-information commitment even without unauthorized access or disclosure. |
| NorthCo's employee sends a confidential product formula to a competitor without permission. The formula contains no personal information. | ConfidentialityThe unauthorized disclosure concerns a business secret, not information about identifiable individuals. |
| A NorthCo role error lets department managers view confidential payroll bank details. Its employee privacy notice restricts access to payroll staff with a business need. | BothThe same unnecessary access violates the records' confidentiality restriction and the notice's access commitment. External disclosure is not required. |
| NorthCo rejects a customer's valid request to correct an inaccurate birth date, contrary to its privacy notice. Access remains properly restricted. | PrivacyThe failure concerns a promised correction process for personal information, not unauthorized access. |
| NorthCo retains fully anonymous purchase summaries after its personal-data deletion deadline. They cannot reasonably identify anyone and have no confidentiality restriction. | Neither establishedThe tempting deletion deadline covers personal information. These summaries are not identifiable, and no confidentiality restriction is stated. |
| NorthCo accidentally emails one spreadsheet containing confidential supplier prices and customer names to an unauthorized consultant, contrary to its privacy notice. The consultant immediately deletes it. | BothThe single disclosure affects confidential business information and personal information. Prompt deletion does not erase either classification. |
| NorthCo collects customer birth dates without providing the collection notice its privacy policy requires. Encryption and access restrictions remain effective. | PrivacyMissing required notice is a personal-information handling failure. Encryption does not supply that notice. |
| NorthCo exposes confidential compensation summaries to unauthorized staff. The summaries are fully anonymized and cannot reasonably be linked to any individual. | ConfidentialityAnonymization removes the personal-information basis for privacy here, but it does not remove the stated confidentiality restriction. |
Key points
- Remember: identify the data, then the broken promise; personal information can trigger privacy, confidentiality, or both.
- Authorized access does not authorize every use of personal information.
- Encryption protects data but does not fix a broken notice, purpose, or retention promise.
- Sharing personal information is not automatically a failure when the notice permits that sharing.
How the exam traps you
- Treating encrypted data as proof of privacy compliance. Check permitted uses and retention even when access controls work.
- Classifying every personal-data incident as privacy only. Also test whether access or disclosure violated a confidentiality restriction.
- Ignoring an incident because the recipient immediately deleted the file. Deletion may reduce harm, but it does not undo the unauthorized disclosure.
Question 2
Hint
Identify what kind of information was exposed, then decide whether the main problem is disclosure, alteration, or lack of access.
Answer B. The facts describe an unauthorized disclosure of sensitive business information, which is a confidentiality issue. Privacy specifically concerns personal information; the stem states there was no personal data. There is also no evidence of alteration or loss of access, so integrity and availability are not the primary issues.
Why not A: This is tempting because both privacy and confidentiality involve disclosure. However, privacy focuses on personal information (customers, employees, etc.), and the file contained no personal data, so privacy is not the best classification.
Why not C: Candidates might associate improper handling with integrity loss, but integrity relates to accuracy and whether data was altered. The stem explicitly says there is no evidence the file was changed, so integrity is not the primary issue.
Why not D: Availability concerns timely and reliable access to information or systems. The facts do not indicate the file became unavailable; the core problem is unauthorized disclosure, making confidentiality the primary issue.
Question 3
Hint
Ask yourself whether the exposed information is about identifiable people or mainly about the company itself.
Answer A. This is primarily a privacy incident because it involves unauthorized disclosure of personal information about identifiable individuals (names, birth dates, account numbers). Privacy incidents focus on improper collection, use, or disclosure of personal data. The other options involve nonpersonal company information and are confidentiality issues.
Why not B: Tempting because it's unauthorized and serious, but the exposed material is the company's intellectual property (nonpersonal business information), making this chiefly a confidentiality incident rather than a privacy one.
Why not C: This looks harmful, but pricing strategy is nonpersonal business information. Unauthorized access to it is a confidentiality breach, not a privacy incident.
Why not D: Although the diagrams are sensitive and marked confidential, they describe internal systems rather than personal data. That makes this primarily a confidentiality issue instead of a privacy one.
Question 4
Hint
Ask which option is about governing personal information throughout its lifecycle, not just blocking unauthorized access.
Answer D. Privacy concerns governance of personal information across its lifecycle, how it is collected, used, retained, and shared. Option D directly addresses those privacy governance requirements. The other choices are primarily confidentiality or security controls focused on preventing unauthorized access or disclosure of proprietary or sensitive information.
Why not A: This is a confidentiality control protecting a business secret (the pricing algorithm), not a privacy objective governing customer personal data handling.
Why not B: NDAs are confidentiality measures to prevent disclosure of trade secrets; they do not govern how personal data is collected, used, retained, or shared.
Why not C: Encryption is a technical security control that supports confidentiality of data in transit and can indirectly support privacy, but it does not itself set governance over the collection, use, retention, or disclosure of personal data.
Question 5
Hint
Distinguish obligations about how data are used, retained, and disclosed relative to published commitments (privacy) from obligations to prevent unauthorized access or disclosure (confidentiality).
Answer A. Privacy concerns whether personal information is collected, used, retained, and disposed of consistent with the entity's published commitments and applicable criteria. Management's decision to retain viewing histories indefinitely and repurpose them for advertising without updating the privacy notice or seeking consent departs from the stated retention and use, so a privacy deficiency is likely under the stated assumptions. The presence of encryption, role-based permissions, and logging suggests confidentiality controls may still be functioning, so a confidentiality deficiency is not clearly established by these facts.
Why not B: This option conflates confidentiality (protection against unauthorized access or disclosure) with privacy (authorized uses and retention consistent with notice). The scenario does not allege that access controls failed or that data were disclosed; it alleges a change in use and retention without notice, which points to a privacy issue rather than clear evidence of a confidentiality failure.
Why not C: Strong technical controls reduce the risk of a confidentiality breach but do not eliminate privacy obligations tied to the public notice and customer expectations. Using or retaining data contrary to the notice can constitute a privacy deficiency even when there is no external breach.
Why not D: Altering retention and use without notice indicates a privacy deficiency, but the facts explicitly state encryption, role-based permissions, and logging continued to operate and no unauthorized disclosure was identified; those facts do not by themselves establish a confidentiality failure.
Question 6
Hint
Focus first on what type of information is involved, then ask whether the facts point to designated confidential information, personal information, or both.
Answer B. This incident is a confidentiality matter because the exposed documents are explicitly designated confidential business information and, as stated, contain no personal information. Privacy matters concern personal information and the organization's commitments (collection, use, retention, disclosure, and individual rights); with no personal data involved, this incident does not, by itself, establish a privacy issue.
Why not A: Tempting because restricted access may sound like a confidentiality control, but this is a privacy issue: it describes a failure to follow retention commitments for personal information under Lakeview's privacy notice even though there was no unauthorized disclosure.
Why not C: Tempting because unauthorized disclosure is a classic confidentiality breach, but the data disclosed are personal information (names and account numbers), so the incident establishes both confidentiality and privacy concerns rather than confidentiality alone.
Why not D: Tempting because it involves sensitive data and a control failure, but this describes a privacy problem (accuracy and individual correction rights for personal information) rather than a standalone confidentiality incident.
Question 7
Hint
Ask yourself whether the controls deal with information in general, or specifically with personal information and how the organization collects, uses, keeps, and disposes of it.
Answer B. Privacy is the Trust Services category that most directly addresses the collection, use, retention, disclosure, and disposal of personal information. The stem focuses on lifecycle commitments such as notice, purpose limitation, retention, and disposal, which are central privacy concerns (although security controls often support privacy).
Why not A: This is tempting because secure disposal and protection of information are security controls. However, Security focuses broadly on protecting systems and information from unauthorized access and threats, not specifically on personal information lifecycle obligations like notice and purpose limitation.
Why not C: Confidentiality concerns keeping information secret or accessible only to authorized parties. While related, confidentiality does not specifically address notice, purpose limitation, retention, and disposal obligations tied to personal information, those are privacy issues.
Why not D: Processing integrity is about whether system processing is complete, valid, accurate, timely, and authorized. The stem does not focus on transaction accuracy or completeness but on governance of personal information, pointing to privacy instead.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on whether the problem is about protecting data from unauthorized access or about how personal data are collected, used, and shared.
Answer D. This is primarily a privacy issue because the company is collecting more personal data than is necessary and sharing it with third parties without clear disclosure or customer choice. Privacy concerns center on notice, consent, purpose limitation, and appropriate secondary use of personal information. The stem rules out unauthorized access, data alteration, or outages, so confidentiality, integrity, and availability are not the main issues.
Why not A: Availability relates to access to systems or data (e.g., outages or denial of service). The stem explicitly rules out service outages or access problems, so availability is not the primary issue here.
Why not B: This distractor is tempting because sharing data with outside parties can resemble a confidentiality problem. However, the facts describe the company's own collection and sharing practices rather than a security control failure or unauthorized disclosure; the primary concern is lack of notice/consent and improper secondary use (privacy), not an inability to keep data secret due to a breach.
Why not C: Integrity concerns the accuracy and trustworthiness of data (modification, corruption, or incompleteness). Nothing in the stem indicates the data were altered or inaccurate; the issue is that data were collected and shared in ways customers were not told about, which is a privacy matter.
Question 9
Hint
Ask whether the core problem is improper access by someone without a need-to-know (confidentiality) or an improper use/disclosure contrary to the posted notice/consent (privacy).
Answer D. Incident 1 is chiefly a confidentiality problem: a person without a business need obtained access to records the company had marked confidential (an access-control failure). Incident 2 is chiefly a privacy problem because customer emails were used and disclosed in a manner inconsistent with the posted notice; technical protections and partner access limits do not cure an improper use or disclosure.
Why not A: Attractive because both involve personal data, but incorrect because privacy is not necessarily the primary issue in Incident 1: the root is unauthorized access to confidential HR records (confidentiality). Incident 2 is correctly a privacy issue due to the improper use/disclosure relative to the notice.
Why not B: Tempting because compensation data is personal and the involvement of an external party in Incident 2 can look like a confidentiality concern. It fails because Incident 1's core problem is unauthorized access by someone without a need-to-know (confidentiality), while Incident 2's core problem is the use/disclosure contrary to the posted notice (privacy).
Why not C: Plausible because both incidents include data leaving intended controls (contractor access; transfer to a partner). It fails to distinguish that Incident 2's primary issue is a notice-driven misuse (privacy), whereas Incident 1 is an access-control (confidentiality) failure rather than a misuse of data under the posted purpose.
Common questions
What is the difference between privacy and confidentiality in SOC 2?
Privacy governs how personal information is handled under commitments and requirements. Confidentiality protects designated confidential information, including both business information and personal information.
Can authorized employee access still cause a privacy violation?
Yes. NorthCo's authorized marketing use violates privacy when its notice permits only order processing, even if encryption and access controls remain effective.
Can one SOC 2 incident involve both privacy and confidentiality?
Yes. NorthCo's public posting of confidential customer records breaks both its confidentiality restriction and its privacy promise against unauthorized disclosure.
Watch it solved
A full CPA ISC task-based simulation on Confidentiality and privacy, worked step by step.
Data Classification & Privacy Compliance | CPA ISC Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice ISC like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Confidentiality and privacy
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.