PracticeISCFree practice exam

ISC · Security and Confidentiality and Privacy · 9 practice questions

CPA Privacy Retention: Delete When Your Notice Says

Keeping personal information beyond the privacy notice's deletion deadline is a privacy failure unless law requires longer retention. Below: follow a retailer's closed-account records from account closure through a missed deadline and correction.

The ruleDelete personal information within the period promised in the privacy notice unless law requires longer retention. Encryption and authorized access do not excuse over-retention or, by themselves, establish a confidentiality failure.

Try one first

An online retailer states in its customer privacy notice that personal information for closed customer accounts will be deleted within 90 days unless a longer retention period is required by law. In Year 2, internal audit found that names, addresses, email addresses, and dates of birth for accounts closed more than one year earlier were still being retained. The data remained encrypted, and access was limited to authorized personnel. Assume no legal retention requirement applied and no unauthorized access or disclosure occurred. Under the confidentiality and privacy concepts tested in ISC, which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Separate the obligation to protect information from unauthorized access from the obligation to handle personal information according to stated retention and disposal commitments.

The timeline

  1. Day 0A customer closes an online retail account.

    The retailer's privacy notice promises deletion of closed-account personal information within 90 days unless law requires longer retention. No legal requirement applies.

  2. Day 90The promised deletion deadline arrives.

    The retailer must delete the closed-account records by this deadline. Keeping them beyond it violates the privacy retention commitment.

  3. More than one year after closureInternal audit finds the records still retained.

    Names, addresses, email addresses, and birth dates remain encrypted and accessible only to authorized personnel. No unauthorized access or disclosure occurred. The supported finding is a privacy retention deficiency.

  4. After the reviewRemove the overdue records and correct the deletion process.

    Secure disposal addresses the missed privacy promise. Stronger encryption alone would leave the over-retention unresolved.

Key points

  • Remember: encryption protects retained data, but it does not make keeping that data past the promised deadline acceptable.
  • Account closure starts this retailer's retention clock, not the date internal audit discovers the records.
  • The notice permits legally required retention, but no legal requirement applies here.

How the exam traps you

  • No deficiency exists because the records stayed encrypted and no breach occurred. The missed deletion deadline violates the privacy commitment even without unauthorized access.
  • Both privacy and confidentiality automatically failed because the retained records contain personal information. Over-retention establishes the privacy failure. These facts alone do not establish a confidentiality failure.

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

A company collects customers' dates of birth only to verify that each customer is over age 18 when creating an account. Assume the company's privacy notice states this limited purpose, and no law, regulation, or contract requires the company to keep the date-of-birth data after verification. What is the most appropriate treatment of that data after the age check is completed?
Hint

Focus on privacy as more than just protecting data from unauthorized access. Ask whether the organization still needs this personal information for the purpose it originally disclosed.

Question 3

A lender's published privacy notice states that driver's license images submitted by applicants are collected only to verify identity during account opening and, unless required by law, are deleted 30 days after the approval or denial decision. In Year 2, the privacy officer discovers that denied applicants' images have remained in an encrypted internal archive for 14 months because a deletion job failed. Access to the archive is limited to analytics administrators. A data manager proposes using the retained images to build internal training materials for processing applications more efficiently. Assume no law, legal hold, contract, or investigation requires continued retention of the images. Which response is most appropriate?
Hint

Separate confidentiality safeguards from privacy commitments about permitted purpose and retention.

Question 4

A service organization processes consumer loan applications. Its published privacy notice states that personal information collected from applicants will be used only for underwriting and fraud screening and, for applicants who are declined, will be deleted within 90 days after the final decision unless a legal requirement or litigation hold applies. Assume no such requirement or hold exists, all applicant data are encrypted in transit and at rest, and logs show no unauthorized external access. Which finding would best support classifying an exception as primarily a privacy issue rather than primarily a confidentiality issue?
Hint

Distinguish unauthorized access or disclosure (confidentiality) from repurposing or retaining data beyond what the privacy notice permits (privacy).

Question 5

A mobile app collects users' location data to provide nearby-service recommendations. The company's published privacy commitment states location data will be collected only when needed to provide that feature, used only for that purpose unless the user affirmatively agrees otherwise, and deleted within 24 hours. Current controls include encryption of the location database, role-based access, logging, and employee confidentiality agreements. An internal review finds that, after a recent update, the app continuously collects location data in the background for analytics and retains the data for 90 days. Assume no legal or operational requirement justifies the broader collection or longer retention, and users were not notified of the change. Which action would most directly address the primary deficiency?
Hint

Decide whether the core problem is how data is being collected and retained versus who can access data after collection.

Question 6

A company's privacy notice states customer birthdates are collected solely to verify age for restricted-product sales and are deleted after that verification unless retention is otherwise required. The company retained an encrypted database linking birthdates to purchase history that remained accessible to authorized employees. In Year 2, the marketing department obtained an internal extract of those birthdates and purchase histories to build targeted advertising lists. No additional customer consent was obtained and no law or contract separately authorized this marketing use. Which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Distinguish protections against who can see data (confidentiality) from rules about what the data may be used for (privacy/purpose limitation).

Question 7

A payroll SaaS provider issues a public privacy notice stating that rejected job-applicant personal information will be deleted from production systems within 90 days unless longer retention is required by law. Client contracts separately require all uploaded strategic-planning files to be treated as confidential. In Year 2, internal audit confirms that: (1) due to a failed purge job, rejected applicants' SSNs and addresses remained in searchable production tables for 14 months, and no law required longer retention; (2) those applicant records were not accessed by unauthorized parties; and (3) a workflow defect sent Client A's merger-planning attachment to an HR director employed by Client B, who was an authenticated user of the platform but had no authorization to view Client A data. Ignoring breach-notification law and focusing only on the provider's confidentiality and privacy commitments, which conclusion is best supported?
Hint

Treat privacy and confidentiality separately: privacy includes promised handling across the data lifecycle (including retention/disposal); confidentiality concerns whether client-designated materials were limited to authorized client users (client-level authorization), not just platform authentication.

Question 8

In 20X6, Northbay Staffing collected job applicants' Social Security numbers solely to conduct background checks. Its posted privacy notice stated that Social Security numbers of rejected applicants would be disposed of within 60 days after hiring decisions. Instead, the company retained those Social Security numbers for more than 60 days. There was no unauthorized access, disclosure, or alteration. Which issue is most directly raised by these facts?
Hint

Decide whether the facts describe an exposure/unauthorized-access event or a deviation from stated retention/disposal commitments.

Question 9

An online retailer collected customers' birth dates for a one-time age-based promotion. The promotion has ended, and assume the birth dates are no longer needed for any legal, contractual, or ongoing business purpose. Which action would most directly address a privacy risk rather than only a confidentiality risk?
Hint

Focus on the difference between protecting data that should be kept and deciding whether the data should still be kept at all.

Drill all 163 Confidentiality and privacy questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Is retaining customer data too long a privacy or confidentiality issue?

Here, it is a privacy issue because the retailer missed its promised deletion deadline. Encryption, restricted access, and no unauthorized disclosure do not establish a confidentiality failure.

Does encryption allow a company to keep personal data past its privacy notice deadline?

No. Encryption protects the data but does not extend the promised retention period.

What should a company do after missing its privacy notice deletion deadline?

Identify and securely dispose of the overdue records when no legal retention requirement applies. Correct the deletion process so future records are removed within the promised period.

Watch it solved

A full CPA ISC task-based simulation on Confidentiality and privacy, worked step by step.

Data Classification & Privacy Compliance | CPA ISC Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice ISC like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Confidentiality and privacy

All Confidentiality and privacy practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.