BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 6 practice questions
ASC 842: Initial Lease Liability and ROU Asset for Advance Rent
Rent paid at commencement increases the right-of-use asset, not the initial lease liability. Below: a worked calculation showing how beginning-of-year rent, a broker commission, and a cash incentive affect the two balances.
Try one first
Hint
Measure the lease liability first using only lease payments that remain unpaid at commencement. Then build the right-of-use asset by adjusting that amount for payments made at commencement, lease incentives, and qualifying initial direct costs.
Answer A. The lease liability at commencement equals the present value of lease payments that remain unpaid, so it includes only the four payments due after commencement: $170,000. The right-of-use asset equals the lease liability plus any lease payments made at or before commencement and qualifying initial direct costs, less lease incentives. Thus ROU asset = $170,000 + $50,000 + $4,000 - $6,000 = $218,000.
Why not B: This is tempting because a candidate may think all five fixed payments belong in the initial lease liability. However, the lease liability includes only lease payments not yet paid as of commencement; the $50,000 payment at commencement is not part of the liability but is included in the ROU asset.
Why not C: This choice correctly reports the lease liability but treats the $4,000 of qualifying legal fees as if they were expensed. Under ASC 842, qualifying initial direct costs are included in the initial measurement of the ROU asset, so omitting the $4,000 understates the asset.
Why not D: This choice capitalizes the $50,000 payment made at commencement and the $4,000 initial direct costs but fails to reduce the ROU asset for the $6,000 lease incentive received. Lease incentives received reduce the lessee's initial ROU asset.
Worked example
Cedar Co. begins a four-year equipment lease with $60,000 payments at each year's beginning. It pays the first installment at commencement, pays a $3,000 broker commission owed only if the lease is obtained, and receives an $8,000 cash lease incentive. There are no other payments. At 5%, the ordinary annuity factor for three periods is 2.72325.
| 1 | Count unpaid installments4 total installments − 1 paid at commencement = 3 | 3 unpaid installments |
| 2 | Measure the initial lease liability$60,000 × 2.72325 = $163,395 | $163,395 |
| 3 | Add the commencement payment to the ROU asset$163,395 + $60,000 = $223,395 | $223,395 |
| 4 | Add the qualifying broker commission$223,395 + $3,000 = $226,395 | $226,395 |
| 5 | Subtract the cash lease incentive$226,395 − $8,000 = $218,395 | $218,395 |
Cedar records an initial lease liability of $163,395 and an initial ROU asset of $218,395.
Check: Shortcut: the ROU asset equals the PV of all rent, $60,000 × (1 + 2.72325) = $223,395, less the $5,000 incentive net of commission, giving $218,395.
Key points
- After removing the first payment, the remaining annual payments use an ordinary annuity factor.
- A broker commission qualifies as an initial direct cost only if obtaining the lease triggers the cost.
- A cash incentive received at commencement reduces the ROU asset, not the unpaid rent liability.
How the exam traps you
- Including the paid first installment produces a $223,395 liability. Exclude the $60,000 already paid. The liability is $163,395.
- Omitting the broker commission produces a $215,395 ROU asset. Add the qualifying $3,000 commission to the ROU asset.
- Adding the incentive produces a $234,395 ROU asset. Subtract the $8,000 incentive received from the lessor.
Question 2
Hint
First separate lease payments from nonlease and variable amounts. Then focus on which lease payments are still unpaid at commencement.
Answer B. The initial lease liability is the present value at commencement of lease payments not paid at commencement. Exclude the separately stated $6,000 maintenance (nonlease) and exclude sales-based variable payments that depend on future sales. Include the three unpaid lease-component payments of $90,000 (96,000 less 6,000) at Jan 1 of Years 2-4 and the $15,000 probable residual guarantee at year-end. PV = 90,000/(1.05) + 90,000/(1.05)^2 + 90,000/(1.05)^3 + 15,000/(1.05)^4 ≈ $257,433.
Why not A: This reflects including the full $96,000 payment as a lease payment (treating the $6,000 maintenance as a lease component). The maintenance portion is a separately stated nonlease component and is excluded from the lease liability.
Why not C: This reflects including the expected sales-based variable payments in the initial liability. Under ASC 842, variable payments based on future sales are generally excluded from the initial measurement of the lease liability.
Why not D: This reflects wrongly adding the first $90,000 lease-component payment (the payment made at commencement) to the initial lease liability. Payments made at or before commencement are not included in the initial lease liability.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the initial lease liability from the initial right-of-use asset, and distinguish index-based variability from usage-based variability.
Answer A. Under ASC 842 the lease liability is measured at the present value of lease payments not yet paid at commencement, including fixed payments and variable payments that depend on an index or rate (measured using the index/rate at commencement). Variable payments based solely on usage or performance are excluded from the initial lease liability. The right-of-use asset starts with the lease liability and is adjusted for lease payments made at or before commencement and for initial direct costs (such as an incremental broker commission).
Why not B: This overgeneralizes that all variable payments are excluded; amounts that vary with an index or rate are included at commencement using the index in effect. Also, an incremental broker commission that would not have been incurred except to obtain the lease is an initial direct cost capitalized to the ROU asset, not expensed immediately.
Why not C: This distractor treats all cash outflows as part of the lease liability, but ASC 842 excludes purely usage-based variable payments from initial measurement. It is also incorrect to state the ROU asset simply equals the liability here because payments made at commencement and initial direct costs affect the ROU asset measurement.
Why not D: This reverses the correct treatment: CPI/index-based amounts are included at commencement using the commencement index, while usage-based amounts are excluded. It also misstates broker commission treatment, incremental broker commissions are initial direct costs that increase the ROU asset, not the lease liability.
Question 4
Hint
Start with what is included in the initial lease liability at commencement, then adjust that amount to arrive at the right-of-use asset.
Answer C. The lease liability at commencement excludes the $30,000 payment made at the beginning of the lease; the remaining three $30,000 payments have PV = $30,000 × 2.72325 = $81,698. The right-of-use asset = lease liability + payments made at or before commencement ($30,000) + initial direct costs ($2,000) − lease incentive ($3,000) = $110,698. Variable machine‑hour payments are excluded from initial measurement because they are not in‑substance fixed.
Why not A: This equals the present value of the unpaid lease payments (the lease liability) only. It is incorrect because the question asks for the right‑of‑use asset, which also adds the payment made at commencement and initial direct costs and subtracts the lease incentive.
Why not B: This equals the liability plus the commencement payment less the lease incentive but omits the $2,000 of initial direct costs that must be capitalized into the ROU asset.
Why not D: This is higher because it reflects (incorrectly) inclusion of the expected $4,000 per year machine‑hour payments in the initial measurement. Those variable payments, based solely on actual usage and not in‑substance fixed, are excluded from the initial lease liability and asset.
Question 5
Hint
Use the lessee's initial ROU asset formula, and be careful to separate unpaid lease payments from amounts already paid at commencement.
Answer A. Initial ROU asset = lease liability (PV of unpaid lease payments) + lease payments made at or before commencement + initial direct costs − lease incentives. Here: $77,309 (PV of the three unpaid payments) + $30,000 (payment made at commencement) + $2,000 (external broker commission, an initial direct cost) − $5,000 (lease incentive) = $104,309. The $3,000 internal payroll cost is excluded because it would have been incurred regardless of whether the lease was obtained.
Why not B: This result occurs if a candidate incorrectly capitalizes both the $2,000 external broker commission and the $3,000 internal payroll cost as initial direct costs. Capitalizing both adds $5,000, producing $77,309 + $30,000 + $2,000 + $3,000 − $5,000 = $107,309. The internal payroll cost is explicitly nonqualifying and should be excluded.
Why not C: This answer reflects including the $30,000 commencement payment and subtracting the $5,000 incentive but omitting the qualifying $2,000 external broker commission. Under ASC 842, incremental costs that would not have been incurred but for obtaining the lease (like the external commission) are initial direct costs and should be added to the ROU asset.
Why not D: This reflects double-counting the $30,000 payment by including it in the lease liability and again as a payment made at commencement (and possibly including the $2,000 commission). The lease liability at commencement already excludes amounts paid at that date, so the $30,000 should be added only once when measuring the ROU asset.
Question 6
Hint
Measure the lease liability first using only unpaid lease payments as of commencement, then adjust that amount to build the initial ROU asset.
Answer B. The lease liability equals the present value of lease payments that remain unpaid at commencement. Because the first $50,000 was paid on the commencement date, only the remaining four payments are discounted: $50,000 × 3.4651 = $173,255. The initial ROU asset equals the lease liability plus any lease payments made at or before commencement ($50,000) plus qualifying initial direct costs ($4,000), less lease incentives received ($6,000), giving $173,255 + 50,000 + 4,000 − 6,000 = $221,255.
Why not A: This option treats all five payments (including the immediate payment) as part of the liability (an annuity-due approach), producing a larger PV. Under ASC 842 the lease liability excludes payments made at or before commencement, so the $50,000 paid at commencement is not included in the liability.
Why not C: This answer correctly measures the liability and accounts for the lease incentive but omits the qualifying initial direct cost ($4,000) that must be added to the initial ROU asset.
Why not D: This choice fails to subtract the lease incentive (or treats the incentive as increasing the asset). Lease incentives received from the lessor reduce the initial ROU asset; they do not increase it.
Common questions
Is the first lease payment included in the initial lease liability?
Not when it is paid at commencement. Cedar excludes that $60,000 from the liability but adds it to the ROU asset.
Which present value factor applies to beginning-of-year lease payments?
Once the commencement payment is removed, discount the remaining payments using an ordinary annuity factor. Cedar has three unpaid payments, so it uses the three-period factor.
How do lease incentives and broker commissions affect the initial ROU asset?
Add qualifying broker commissions and subtract cash incentives received at commencement. Cedar adds $3,000 and subtracts $8,000, reducing the asset by $5,000 overall.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Leases, worked step by step.
Sales-Type Lease & Lessee Measurement | CPA BAR Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Leases
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.