BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 8 practice questions
ASC 842: What Counts in Lease Payments at Commencement?
The initial lease liability includes unpaid fixed payments, index-based amounts measured at commencement, and probable residual guarantee payments, but excludes purely usage-based payments. Below: sort payment terms to see what enters the liability and what stays out.
Try one first
Hint
Separate items that affect the initial lease liability from items that affect only later expense or the right-of-use asset. The key distinctions are index/rate-based versus sales/use-based payments, and probable guarantee exposure versus maximum exposure.
Answer A. ASC 842 requires a lessee to include fixed payments, variable payments that depend on an index or rate (measured using the index or rate at commencement), and amounts probable of being owed under a residual value guarantee in the initial lease liability. Sales- or usage-based variable payments are excluded and recognized when incurred. Initial direct costs and lease incentives adjust the right-of-use asset, and option-related payments are included only if exercise is reasonably certain.
Why not B: This option is tempting because it groups all variable-looking items together and defers them. It is incorrect: CPI/index-based payments are included at commencement using the commencement-date index, and amounts probable of being owed under a residual value guarantee must be included in the initial liability.
Why not C: This distractor correctly separates initial direct costs from the liability but overreaches on what to include. ASC 842 uses the commencement-date index (not forecasts of future CPI changes), excludes sales-based variable payments from the initial liability, and requires inclusion only of the amount probable of being owed under a residual guarantee, not the maximum exposure.
Why not D: This choice incorrectly treats sales-based payments as part of the liability and delays recognition of index-based amounts. Under ASC 842, index/rate-based payments are included using the commencement-date index, and probable residual guarantee amounts are included at commencement; sales-based payments are recognized when incurred.
Sort it
Include unpaid fixed amounts, commencement-index-based amounts, and probable residual guarantee amounts; include fixed service payments only when components are combined.
Exclude purely sales- or usage-based amounts, forecast index increases, separate service components, guarantee exposure not probable, and payments already made.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Pine's equipment lease requires $50,000 of fixed rent at each year-end. | Include in initial liabilityThese are unpaid fixed lease payments. |
| Pine must pay 2% of equipment-generated sales and reliably forecasts those payments. | Exclude from initial liabilityThe forecast does not matter. The payments depend solely on future sales. |
| Pine's additional annual CPI-based payment equals $4,000 using CPI at commencement. | Include in initial liabilityIndex-based payments enter initial measurement using the commencement-date index. |
| Pine allocates $4,000 annually to maintenance and does not elect to combine components. | Exclude from initial liabilityThe allocated maintenance amount belongs to a separate nonlease component. |
| Pine guarantees a $50,000 residual value; $12,000 is probable of being owed. | Include in initial liabilityInclude the $12,000 probable payment, not the full guarantee. |
| Pine forecasts CPI increases that would add amounts above the commencement-index-based payments. | Exclude from initial liabilityDo not forecast future index changes when measuring the initial liability. |
| Pine's variable-labeled equipment charge has an unavoidable annual minimum of $10,000. | Include in initial liabilityThe unavoidable minimum is in-substance fixed despite its label. |
| Pine's equipment charge exceeds the $10,000 minimum only when actual operating hours trigger additional charges. | Exclude from initial liabilityThe excess depends solely on future usage; only the unavoidable minimum enters initial measurement. |
| The remaining $38,000 of Pine's $50,000 residual guarantee is not probable of being owed. | Exclude from initial liabilityMaximum exposure does not determine the included amount. Only the probable $12,000 enters initial measurement. |
| Same facts, except Pine elects to combine the maintenance component with the lease component. Consider the fixed $4,000 annual maintenance payment. | Include in initial liabilityThe election brings fixed maintenance payments into the combined component. |
| Same facts, except maintenance payments depend solely on future operating hours. Pine still elects to combine components. | Exclude from initial liabilityCombining components does not turn purely usage-based service payments into fixed payments. |
| Same facts, except Pine pays the first $50,000 rent payment at commencement. Consider that payment only. | Exclude from initial liabilityThe payment is already paid, so it is not part of the unpaid lease obligation. |
Key points
- Remember: An index-based payment enters the initial liability; a payment driven solely by future sales or usage does not.
- Use the commencement index for future scheduled payments. Do not forecast index increases.
- A reliable sales forecast does not turn a sales-based payment into a fixed payment.
- A payment already made at commencement is not an unpaid obligation.
How the exam traps you
- Adding forecast CPI increases to the commencement-date payment amount. Use only the CPI in effect at commencement.
- Including the full residual guarantee because the lessee could owe it. Include only the amount probable of being owed.
- Including every service payment after electing to combine components. Include fixed combined-component payments, but continue to exclude purely usage-based amounts.
Question 2
| Lease Component | Annual/Total Amount |
|---|---|
| Fixed year-end payments | $90,000/yr |
| CPI-indexed payments (measured using CPI at commencement) | $5,000/yr |
| Expected usage-based payments | $12,000/yr |
| Residual value guarantee (probable, estimated at lease end) | $18,000 |
| Purchase option (not reasonably certain to exercise) | $40,000 |
Hint
Include fixed payments, index-linked amounts measured at commencement, and probable residual guarantees; exclude expected usage-based payments and purchase options not reasonably certain to be exercised.
Answer D. Include fixed payments (5 × $90,000 = $450,000), CPI-indexed payments measured at commencement (5 × $5,000 = $25,000), and the probable residual guarantee ($18,000). Exclude expected usage-based payments and a purchase option not reasonably certain to be exercised. Total = $450,000 + $25,000 + $18,000 = $493,000.
Why not A: Tempting because it equals fixed plus CPI-indexed payments (450,000 + 25,000 = 475,000). It is wrong because it omits the $18,000 residual value guarantee, which is probable and must be included in the initial liability.
Why not B: Tempting because it adds expected usage-based payments to the included amounts (450,000 + 25,000 + 18,000 + 60,000 = 553,000). It is wrong because expected usage-based variable payments unrelated to an index are excluded from initial measurement under the lease guidance.
Why not C: Tempting because it equals fixed + CPI + the $40,000 purchase option (450,000 + 25,000 + 40,000 = 515,000). It is wrong because the $40,000 purchase option is not reasonably certain to be exercised and should be excluded; the probable residual guarantee, not the option, is included.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which amounts are part of lease payments at commencement versus amounts that belong in the right-of-use asset or future-period expense.
Answer C. The lease liability initially includes lease payments the lessee is obligated to make at commencement, such as fixed payments and amounts probable to be owed under a residual value guarantee. Sales-based variable payments are excluded from initial measurement because they depend on future performance and are recognized when incurred. Broker commissions are initial direct costs capitalized as part of the right-of-use asset, not included in the lease liability.
Why not A: This is tempting because both are future cash outflows, but sales-based variable payments depend on future sales and are generally excluded from the initial lease liability; they are expensed when the related sales occur. The probable residual value guarantee amount, which is part of the liability, is missing.
Why not B: Candidates who recall that broker commissions are capitalized may choose this, but the commission is an initial direct cost added to the right-of-use asset, not to the lease liability. This option also omits the probable residual value guarantee amount, which should be included in the liability.
Why not D: This option correctly includes the residual value guarantee amount, but incorrectly includes the broker commission in the lease liability. Broker commissions are included in the right-of-use asset as initial direct costs, not in the lease liability.
Question 4
Hint
First identify which parts of the contract are lease payments for initial measurement, then apply present value only to those amounts.
Answer C. A lessee initially measures the lease liability using the present value of lease payments, not total contract cash flows. Because the $20,000 maintenance amount is a separately stated nonlease component and Apex did not elect to combine components, it is excluded. The sales-based extra rent is also excluded from initial measurement because it depends solely on Apex's sales, not on an index or rate. The lease liability is therefore $100,000 × 3.546 = $354,600.
Why not A: This result comes from discounting the full $120,000 cash payments (including the $20,000 maintenance portion). Because the maintenance services are a separately stated nonlease component and were not combined, they are excluded from the lease liability.
Why not B: This is tempting if a candidate attempts to include an estimated or partially included amount for the sales-based extra rent. Variable payments that depend solely on the lessee's sales are excluded from the initial lease liability under ASC 842 and should not be included here.
Why not D: This equals the undiscounted stream of the included lease payments ($100,000 × 4). The initial lease liability must be measured at present value, so failing to discount the future lease payments is incorrect.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the two measurements: first identify what belongs in the lease liability, then adjust to the initial right-of-use asset for prepaid rent, lease incentives, and initial direct costs.
Answer C. The lease liability is $440,000 because ASC 842 excludes sales‑based variable payments (not based on an index or rate and with no minimum) from the initial lease liability; the PV given in the stem already reflects the payments to be included. The $20,000 fixed payment due at commencement is a prepaid lease payment. The initial right‑of‑use asset equals the lease liability plus prepaid lease payments plus initial direct costs minus lease incentives: 440,000 + 20,000 + 8,000 − 15,000 = 453,000.
Why not A: This keeps the sales‑based variables out of the liability (correct) but fails to treat the $15,000 lessor reimbursement as a lease incentive that reduces the initial ROU asset, so the asset cannot be $468,000.
Why not B: This reflects including the expected $15,000 of sales‑based variable payments in the initial liability and asset; under ASC 842 such sales‑based variable payments with no minimum and not tied to an index or rate are excluded from initial measurement and recognized when incurred.
Why not D: This incorrectly includes the $20,000 commencement payment in the lease liability (yielding $460,000). The $20,000 is a prepaid lease payment at commencement and should not increase the lease liability; it is included in the ROU asset instead.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on which variable payments are measured at commencement and which are recognized only when the underlying activity occurs.
Answer B. ASC 842 requires inclusion of fixed lease payments and variable lease payments that depend on an index or rate, measured using the index or rate in effect at commencement (here, the CPI at commencement). Variable payments based on sales are excluded from the initial lease liability and are recognized when the related sales occur. Nonlease components accounted for separately are not part of the lease liability.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may overgeneralize that variable payments are excluded. It's incorrect because index- or rate-based variable payments (CPI adjustments) are included at commencement using the commencement-date index.
Why not C: This choice is tempting because it treats expected cash outflows as part of the initial liability. It's incorrect because sales-based variable lease payments are excluded from initial measurement and recognized when the sales occur.
Why not D: This distractor appeals to an 'include everything expected' approach. It's incorrect because nonlease components accounted for separately are excluded, and most variable payments (except those tied to an index or rate measured at commencement) are not included in the initial lease liability.
Question 7
Hint
Compute the lease liability as the PV of unpaid lease payments at commencement (which payments are included?), then build the initial ROU: add payments made at or before commencement, add qualifying initial direct costs, and subtract lease incentives.
Answer C. Include the fixed $40,000 and the CPI‑based $2,000 (index‑based amounts are included using the index at commencement) but exclude the 3% revenue‑based payment because it depends on future performance. The PV of the three unpaid payments ($42,000 each) = $42,000 × 2.72325 = $114,377 (rounded). Initial ROU = lease liability $114,377 + payment made at commencement $42,000 − lease incentive $6,000 + initial direct costs $1,500 = $151,877.
Why not A: Tempts because a candidate may compute the PV of unpaid payments and then only adjust for the lease incentive and initial direct costs (114,377 − 6,000 + 1,500). It's incorrect because the ROU asset must also include lease payments made at or before commencement, the $42,000 paid on Jan 1, 20X5 must be added.
Why not B: Tempts because a candidate may add the commencement payment and subtract the lease incentive (114,377 + 42,000 − 6,000) but overlook initial direct costs. It's incorrect because qualifying initial direct costs of $1,500 are added to the initial ROU asset.
Why not D: Tempts because a candidate may add the commencement payment and initial direct costs to the liability (114,377 + 42,000 + 1,500) but forget to subtract the lease incentive. It's incorrect because lease incentives received ($6,000) reduce the initial ROU asset.
Question 8
Hint
Break the cash flows into categories: fixed, index-based variable, performance-based variable, residual value guarantee, and optional renewal payments. Then ask which categories ASC 842 includes at commencement.
Answer A. Include the undiscounted fixed payments (3 × $50,000 = $150,000), the CPI-linked index-based payments measured using the commencement-date index (3 × $4,000 = $12,000), and the amount probable under the residual value guarantee ($6,000). Exclude sales-based variable payments because those depend on future performance and are recognized when the triggering event occurs, and exclude renewal payments because Rowan is not reasonably certain to exercise the option. Total included = $150,000 + $12,000 + $6,000 = $168,000.
Why not B: This correctly adds the CPI-linked amounts to the fixed payments (150,000 + 12,000 = 162,000) but still omits the $6,000 that is probable under the residual value guarantee, which must be included in the initial liability.
Why not C: Tempting if a candidate counts only the fixed lease payments. It omits the CPI-linked index-based payments (included using the commencement-date index) and the probable residual value guarantee amount, both of which should be included at commencement.
Why not D: This reflects including all expected outflows (including the estimated sales-based payments). It is incorrect because variable payments based on sales are excluded from the initial measurement of the lease liability and are recognized when the related sales occur.
Common questions
Are CPI-based payments included in the initial lease liability?
Yes. Measure the scheduled index-based payments using CPI at commencement. Do not add forecast future CPI increases.
How much of a residual value guarantee goes into lease payments?
Include the amount probable of being owed, not the maximum exposure. If Pine guarantees $50,000 but probably owes $12,000, include $12,000.
Does combining lease and nonlease components include variable service payments?
Not automatically. The election includes fixed service payments in the combined component, but payments driven solely by future usage remain excluded from the initial liability.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Leases, worked step by step.
Sales-Type Lease & Lessee Measurement | CPA BAR Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Leases
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.