BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 6 practice questions
Fair Value Hedge Accounting: Debt and Swap Example
A qualifying fair value hedge puts both the swap’s gain or loss and the debt’s hedged-risk adjustment in earnings. Below: a worked debt swap calculation showing the net earnings effect and the adjusted debt balance.
Try one first
Hint
First determine whether the hedge is protecting against fair value changes or cash flow variability. Then consider what a gain on a receive-fixed, pay-variable swap implies about the value of fixed-rate debt.
Answer C. This is a fair value hedge, so changes in the derivative's fair value and the hedged item's fair value attributable to the hedged risk are recognized in current earnings. A $160,000 gain on the receive-fixed swap corresponds to an equal $160,000 loss on the fixed-rate debt for the hedged interest-rate risk. For a liability, that loss is recorded by increasing the carrying amount of the debt, so the hedge-related amounts net to zero in earnings.
Why not A: This ignores the required fair value adjustment to the hedged liability. In a fair value hedge the derivative gain is offset by a corresponding loss on the hedged item recognized in earnings.
Why not B: The statement correctly asserts earnings are netted, but the direction of the liability adjustment is reversed. A loss on a liability increases its carrying amount, not decreases it.
Why not D: This confuses fair value hedges with cash flow hedges. Effective portions of cash flow hedges go to OCI, but fair value hedge gains and losses are reported in earnings and require an offsetting adjustment to the hedged item's carrying amount.
Worked example
Cedar Co. has $3,000,000 of fixed-rate debt carried at par. Its receive-fixed, pay-variable swap starts at zero fair value and qualifies as a fair value hedge of benchmark-rate risk, with no excluded components. During the year, the swap loses $70,000 and the debt’s fair value attributable to that risk decreases $65,000. Ignore interest, swap settlements, amortization, and taxes.
| 1 | Recognize the swap loss in earnings$0 - $70,000 = -$70,000; record a swap liability. | $70,000 loss |
| 2 | Reduce the debt and recognize a gain$3,000,000 - $65,000 = $2,935,000; the liability reduction creates a $65,000 gain. | $2,935,000 debt carrying amount |
| 3 | Calculate the net earnings effect-$70,000 + $65,000 = -$5,000 | $5,000 net loss |
Cedar reports debt of $2,935,000 and a $5,000 net loss in earnings from the hedge fair value changes. Neither change goes to OCI.
Check: Debt falls $65,000, but the swap adds a $70,000 liability, so total liabilities rise $5,000 and earnings fall $5,000.
Key points
- Use only the debt’s change attributable to the designated benchmark-rate risk, not its total fair value change.
- A qualifying hedge does not guarantee a zero net earnings effect.
- Record both sides separately. Reporting a net earnings effect does not replace the debt adjustment.
How the exam traps you
- Putting the $70,000 swap loss in OCI, leaving a $65,000 gain in earnings. Recognize the swap loss in earnings too. The result is a $5,000 net loss.
- Leaving debt unchanged and reporting only the $70,000 swap loss. Reduce debt by $65,000 and recognize the corresponding gain in earnings.
- Treating the $65,000 decrease in debt as another loss, producing a $135,000 loss. A liability decrease is a gain to the borrower, so it offsets part of the swap loss.
Question 2
Hint
First decide whether the hedged item is a firm commitment or a forecasted transaction; then recall whether fair value hedge accounting or cash flow hedge accounting governs the timing and presentation of hedge gains and losses.
Answer C. When a foreign-currency-denominated firm commitment is hedged with a qualifying fair value hedge, changes in the fair value of both the derivative and the firm commitment attributable to the hedged risk are recognized in earnings as they occur. The carrying amount established for the firm commitment is reflected in the cost basis of the acquired equipment on settlement. Therefore, the derivative gain and the offsetting loss on the firm commitment are reported in earnings at December 31, Year 1.
Why not A: This option is attractive because OCI is used for some hedges of future purchases, but OCI treatment applies to qualifying cash flow hedges of forecasted transactions. Here Kellan designated a fair value hedge of a firm commitment, which requires earnings recognition.
Why not B: This seems plausible because firm commitments are ordinarily not recognized before settlement; however, when the firm commitment is the hedged item in a qualifying fair value hedge, the change in the commitment's fair value attributable to the hedged risk must be recognized in earnings during the hedge period.
Why not D: This distractor mixes concepts: OCI would be relevant for cash flow hedges, but a fair value hedge of a firm commitment requires current-period earnings recognition for both the derivative and the hedged firm's commitment change.
Question 3
Hint
Start by asking whether Pine is hedging variability in future cash flows or changes in the value of an existing recognized item. Then match that hedge type to the earnings-vs-OCI model.
Answer D. Pine is hedging the fair value exposure of an existing recognized fixed-rate liability to changes in the benchmark interest rate, which is a fair value hedge under ASC 815. For a qualifying fair value hedge, changes in the derivative's fair value and an offsetting adjustment to the hedged item's carrying amount attributable to the hedged risk are recognized in current earnings. OCI accounting is used for cash flow hedges, not for fair value hedges.
Why not A: This is tempting because many candidates associate interest rate swaps with hedging future interest payments and therefore think of OCI. However, Pine's exposure is changes in the fair value of an existing fixed-rate liability (not variability in future cash flows), which points to a fair value hedge rather than a cash flow hedge.
Why not B: This choice correctly identifies the hedge type but mixes recognition models. For a fair value hedge, both the derivative's fair value change and the hedged‑item carrying amount adjustment attributable to the hedged risk are recognized in current earnings; reporting the derivative change in OCI would be consistent with a cash flow hedge, not a fair value hedge.
Why not C: This distractor lures candidates who focus on the income statement line item (interest expense) instead of the nature of the hedged risk. Because the hedged risk is the debt's fair value, fair value hedge accounting requires an adjustment to the debt's carrying amount, with both derivative and hedged-item changes in earnings.
Question 4
Hint
First classify the hedge. Then decide where the derivative's change and the hedged item's change attributable to the hedged risk are reported and whether the hedged item's carrying amount is adjusted.
Answer A. This is a fair value hedge: both the change in value of the hedging instrument and the hedged item's change in fair value attributable to the hedged risk are recognized in current earnings. The hedged item's recognized fair value change also adjusts its carrying amount, even if it is otherwise measured at amortized cost. Here Raven records a $92,000 derivative gain and an $89,000 loss on the note in earnings and reduces the note's carrying amount by $89,000 (a $3,000 net gain in earnings). The resulting basis adjustment is subsequently amortized into interest income (yield) over the life of the note.
Why not B: Tempting because candidates often associate hedging with OCI (cash flow hedges put gains/losses in OCI). But this is a fair value hedge: both the derivative change and the hedged item's change attributable to the hedged risk belong in earnings, and the hedged item's carrying amount is adjusted. OCI treatment and leaving the carrying amount unchanged are incorrect.
Why not C: This distractor is plausible because the note is measured at amortized cost and some candidates conclude that carrying amount cannot change. However, under a fair value hedge the hedged item's change in fair value attributable to the hedged risk is recognized in earnings and the carrying amount is adjusted accordingly; failing to adjust the carrying amount is incorrect.
Why not D: This mixes mechanics of cash flow and fair value hedges and is tempting to candidates who confuse hedge types: putting the derivative in OCI while recording the hedged-item loss in earnings. For a fair value hedge, the derivative's gain/loss is recognized in earnings (not OCI), so this treatment is inconsistent and incorrect.
Question 5
Hint
Identify the specific exposure named in the hedge documentation first. Then match that exposure to the hedge model and recall whether OCI or current earnings is used.
Answer D. The documentation specifies the exposure is changes in the debt's fair value due to benchmark interest-rate movements, which is the classic fair value hedge. In a fair value hedge the derivative is measured at fair value with gains and losses in current earnings, and the hedged item's carrying amount is adjusted for the change in fair value attributable to the hedged risk, with that adjustment also recognized in current earnings.
Why not A: Tempting because swaps often hedge interest payments, but the stem identifies a fair-value exposure (changes in the carrying amount of fixed-rate debt). Cash flow hedge accounting (OCI) applies when hedging variability in future cash flows, not fair-value changes of a fixed-rate liability.
Why not B: This confuses cash flow variability with fair-value hedging. Fixed-rate debt cannot be the subject of a cash flow hedge of its fixed coupons, but it can be the hedged item in a fair value hedge of interest-rate (benchmark) risk; the absence of variable coupon cash flows does not preclude a fair value hedge.
Why not C: Partially plausible because the derivative is marked to market in a fair value hedge, but incorrect because a qualifying fair value hedge requires an offsetting adjustment to the hedged item's carrying amount for the change in fair value attributable to the hedged risk, recognized in current earnings.
Question 6
Hint
Start with the exposure on the debt itself. Ask whether interest rate changes affect the debt's future contractual cash flows or its fair value.
Answer A. Because the hedged item is fixed-rate debt, the exposure being hedged is changes in the debt's fair value from benchmark interest rate movements rather than variability in its contractual cash flows. That classification requires fair value hedge accounting under ASC 815. In a qualifying fair value hedge, gains and losses on the derivative and the offsetting fair-value adjustment to the hedged item's carrying amount are recognized in current earnings.
Why not B: Tempting because swaps often hedge cash-flow variability, but cash-flow hedge treatment (OCI deferral) applies when the hedged risk is variability in future contractual cash flows. Here the debt is fixed-rate and the risk is changes in fair value, so cash-flow/OCI treatment is not appropriate.
Why not C: Incorrect: ASC 815 permits a qualifying fair value hedge of an item measured at amortized cost. The standard requires an adjustment to the carrying amount of the hedged item for changes in fair value attributable to the designated risk, with the offset recognized in earnings.
Why not D: This mixes correct hedge classification with incorrect presentation. OCI reporting of the effective portion is characteristic of cash-flow hedges, not fair value hedges. For fair value hedges both the derivative and the hedged-item adjustment are recorded in earnings.
Common questions
Why does a decrease in debt’s fair value create a gain?
For the borrower, a smaller liability is a gain. Cedar reduces the debt’s carrying amount by $65,000 and recognizes a $65,000 gain in earnings.
Do fair value hedge gains and losses go to OCI?
Not in this qualifying fair value hedge with no excluded components. Both the swap loss and the debt’s hedged-risk gain go to current earnings.
How do you calculate fair value hedge ineffectiveness?
Net the derivative’s gain or loss against the hedged item’s gain or loss attributable to the hedged risk. Cedar’s $70,000 swap loss exceeds its $65,000 debt gain, leaving a $5,000 loss in earnings.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Derivatives and hedge accounting, worked step by step.
Cash Flow Hedges and Undesignated Derivatives | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Derivatives and hedge accounting
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.