BAR · Technical Accounting and Reporting · 6 practice questions
Cash Flow Hedge Discontinuation: When to Release AOCI
Ending cash flow hedge accounting does not automatically release existing AOCI to earnings. Follow one forecasted purchase through the probability test and the two-month window to determine when AOCI must be released.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on what happens in a cash flow hedge when the designated forecasted transaction stops being probable, and then ask where the derivative goes after hedge accounting ends.
Answer D. When the forecasted transaction in a cash flow hedge is determined to be no longer probable, the accumulated amount in AOCI must be reclassified into earnings immediately. Hedge accounting also ceases at that point, so subsequent changes in the fair value of the still-outstanding derivative are recognized in current earnings.
Why not A: This reflects the pattern while the forecasted transaction remains probable. Once the transaction is no longer probable, however, deferral in AOCI is not permitted and future derivative changes do not continue to flow through OCI.
Why not B: Deferred hedge amounts may be included in the cost of the hedged item only when the designated forecasted transaction actually occurs. Here the designated purchase will not occur and no replacement is designated, so the amount cannot be deferred into inventory and must be reclassified to earnings.
Why not C: Although subsequent fair value changes belong in earnings after hedge accounting ends, waiting until termination to release the accumulated AOCI is incorrect, the loss or gain must be reclassified to earnings when the forecasted transaction is no longer probable, regardless of whether the derivative is terminated.
Step by step
- Identify the documented purchase
Redd Co. has a $180,000 gain in AOCI from a qualifying cash flow hedge of a raw-material purchase documented for October 20X5. Assume no qualifying extenuating circumstances justify extending the two-month window.
- Mark the retention deadline
The originally specified period ends October 31, 20X5. The additional two-month window ends December 31, 20X5.
- Separate discontinuation from release
If the October purchase becomes only reasonably possible, discontinue hedge accounting prospectively. That conclusion alone does not require releasing the $180,000 from AOCI.
- Test whether deferral can continue
Retain the $180,000 unless it becomes probable the purchase will not occur by December 31. If retained, reclassify it when the purchased materials affect earnings through cost of goods sold, not merely when purchased.
- Release when timing fails
On December 15, Redd concludes the purchase is probable but will occur January 20, 20X6, outside the permitted window. Reclassify the $180,000 gain to earnings immediately on December 15, without waiting until December 31 or the purchase date.
Key points
- Remember: No longer probable to occur is not the same as probable not to occur within the permitted window.
- Measure the two-month window from the end of the documented transaction period, not the date hedge accounting stops.
- Release AOCI when the adverse timing conclusion is reached, not when the two-month window expires.
How the exam traps you
- Releasing all AOCI merely because the purchase is no longer probable. Discontinue hedge accounting, then separately test whether nonoccurrence within the permitted window is probable.
- Keeping AOCI because the purchase remains probable, even though it is expected after the window. Test timing too. A probable January purchase falls outside an October forecast's December 31 deadline.
Question 2
Hint
For a cash flow hedge of a forecasted transaction, do not stop at documentation and effectiveness. Check whether the forecasted transaction is probable.
Answer C. Cash flow hedge accounting for a forecasted transaction requires that the transaction be specifically identified and probable of occurring at the designation date. Here, the borrowing is contingent on uncertain future market demand, has not been approved by the board, and lenders have not been contacted, facts indicating the debt issuance is not probable. Therefore Pine cannot designate the derivative as a cash flow hedge of that forecasted issuance.
Why not A: This is tempting because cash flow hedges can cover forecasted (uncommitted) transactions. However, that allowance applies only when the forecasted transaction is probable of occurring. The facts here show only a possible, not probable, borrowing.
Why not B: Effectiveness is a required element of hedge accounting but it does not replace the separate probability requirement for a forecasted transaction. Even a highly effective derivative cannot qualify as a cash flow hedge if the underlying forecasted borrowing is not probable.
Why not D: This distractor incorrectly asserts that only recognized items can be hedged. In fact, cash flow hedge accounting can apply to certain probable forecasted transactions (including a forecasted debt issuance). The disqualifying issue here is the lack of probability, not that the debt is unrecorded.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on the specific extra condition required when the hedged item is a forecasted transaction, not on the basic features of the derivative itself.
Answer C. For cash flow hedge accounting the forecasted transaction that is being hedged must be probable of occurring. If the sale is only "reasonably expected" (i.e., less than probable), it fails the required threshold and cannot be designated as the hedged item for a cash flow hedge even if the derivative and documentation requirements are otherwise met. This is the specific limiting condition that prevents hedge accounting here.
Why not A: This is tempting because some candidates assume hedge accounting applies only to recognized assets or liabilities; however, cash flow hedges explicitly may be used for eligible forecasted transactions, including forecasted sales, provided the other qualification criteria (such as probability) are met.
Why not B: This distractor plays on confusion about settlement form and scope exceptions, but a derivative that is net cash settled can still be designated as a hedging instrument for a cash flow hedge; net settlement alone does not disqualify the hedge accounting.
Why not D: This sounds like a limitation but actually describes a typical characteristic of a derivative; having no significant initial net investment helps the contract meet the derivative definition and does not, by itself, prevent hedge accounting.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether the forecasted variable-rate interest payments that were specifically designated as the hedged item remain probable, rather than on the probability of a financing event in general.
Answer B. Under ASC 815, amounts accumulated in OCI for an effective cash flow hedge are reclassified into earnings when the hedged forecasted transaction affects earnings; if it becomes probable that the originally designated forecasted transaction will not occur, hedge accounting must be discontinued and the accumulated OCI amount reclassified into earnings immediately. Harbor specifically hedged forecasted variable-rate interest payments, which are no longer expected because Harbor will issue fixed-rate debt instead; therefore hedge accounting must be discontinued and the $180,000 recognized in current earnings on 6/1/20X5.
Why not A: Tempting because the debt issuance is still expected, but incorrect: hedge accounting depends on the probability of the designated forecasted transaction (the variable-rate interest cash flows), not on the general probability of obtaining financing; those variable-rate cash flows are no longer expected, so continuation is not permitted.
Why not C: This would be correct only if the originally hedged variable-rate interest payments were still probable and therefore the OCI amount should be reclassified when the hedged cash flows affect earnings. Because those variable-rate payments will not occur, immediate reclassification into earnings is required under ASC 815.
Why not D: This confuses the basis-adjustment rule that can apply when a hedged forecasted transaction results in a recognized asset or liability and still occurs. Here the designated hedged transaction (variable-rate interest payments) will not occur, so the deferred amount cannot be included in the initial carrying amount of the new debt.
Question 5
Hint
Apply the U.S. GAAP timing limit for forecasted transactions in cash flow hedges: the originally specified period plus an additional two months (see ASC 815).
Answer A. ASC 815 requires discontinuing cash flow hedge accounting if it becomes probable the forecasted transaction will not occur within the originally specified period or within an additional two‑month window. Because management concluded on Aug. 15 that the purchase will occur in Jan. 20X7 (after Nov. 30, 20X6), hedge accounting must be discontinued prospectively and amounts previously accumulated in OCI related to the hedge are reclassified into earnings at that time. The later probability of the purchase outside the permitted window does not permit retaining the OCI deferral.
Why not B: This distractor is plausible because some discontinuations lead to retaining OCI until the hedged transaction affects earnings. But when discontinuation is required due to failing the two‑month timing condition for a forecasted transaction, ASC 815 requires the accumulated OCI related to the hedge to be reclassified to earnings at discontinuation.
Why not C: This is tempting because a 'probable' forecast normally supports hedge accounting. However, U.S. GAAP contains a specific timing limit (original period plus two months); once management concludes the transaction will occur after that window, continuation of cash flow hedge accounting is not allowed.
Why not D: This confuses hedge types and permissibility. Redesignation to a fair value hedge would require the hedged item to be a recognized asset/liability or a firm commitment rather than a postponed forecasted purchase; additionally, fair value hedges affect earnings rather than deferring amounts in OCI, so this approach would not preserve the OCI deferral.
Question 6
Hint
Apply the cash-flow hedge timing exception: the forecasted transaction must be probable within the originally specified period or within an additional two-month extension measured from the end of that period.
Answer C. Under ASC 815 (cash-flow hedges), amounts deferred in AOCI generally are reclassified into earnings when the forecasted transaction affects earnings. However, if it is probable the forecasted transaction will occur outside the originally specified period plus an additional two-month extension measured from the end of that period, the amounts in AOCI are reclassified into earnings immediately. The documented period was October 20X5, so the two-month extension runs through December 31, 20X5; because Arbor now expects the purchase on January 20, 20X6, the AOCI balance should be reclassified into earnings on December 15, 20X5. In practice, hedge accounting would also generally be discontinued prospectively as of that date.
Why not A: This is tempting because the normal cash-flow hedge rule defers effective-portion gains and losses in AOCI until the hedged transaction affects earnings. But that deferral is limited by the special timing rule: if it is probable the forecasted transaction will occur after the original period plus the two-month extension, the AOCI amounts must be reclassified immediately.
Why not B: This mixes concepts. Even if hedge accounting is (or would be) discontinued prospectively, the AOCI balance cannot remain deferred when the forecasted transaction is probable to occur outside the allowed window; ASC 815 requires reclassification into earnings in that circumstance.
Why not D: This distractor relies on the idea that probability alone is sufficient. The timing tolerance is not open-ended: the forecasted transaction must be probable within the originally specified period or within a two-month extension measured from its end. Expecting the purchase on January 20, 20X6 is outside that window, so continued deferral is not appropriate.
Common questions
Does discontinuing a cash flow hedge immediately release AOCI?
No. If the purchase is merely no longer probable, discontinue hedge accounting but separately evaluate AOCI. Immediate release requires probable nonoccurrence within the original period plus two months, absent qualifying extenuating circumstances.
How do you calculate the ASC 815 two-month window?
Count two months from the end of the originally documented transaction period. For a purchase documented for October, the window ends December 31.
Can AOCI stay deferred if the purchase is still probable but delayed?
Not if it becomes probable the purchase will occur outside the permitted window and no qualifying exception applies. In the example, the December 15 conclusion that delivery will occur in January requires immediate release.
Watch it solved
A full CPA BAR task-based simulation on Derivatives and hedge accounting, worked step by step.
Cash Flow Hedges and Undesignated Derivatives | CPA BAR TBS on YouTube
Practice BAR like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Derivatives and hedge accounting
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.