AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 6 practice questions
AU-C 315 Risk Assessment Procedures and Walkthroughs
Risk assessment procedures explain how the business and relevant controls work; tests of details do not replace that understanding. Follow Lumen's new revenue process through inquiry, inspection, a walkthrough, and planning analytics.
Try one first
Hint
Which procedure traces the flow of a transaction end-to-end and uses inquiry, inspection, and observation to show whether controls are actually in place?
Answer B. A walkthrough traces individual transactions end-to-end and combines inquiry, inspection, and observation (and sometimes re-performance). It directly tests both the design of controls and whether they were implemented in practice, making it the most effective procedure to understand order-to-cash controls after an ERP change.
Why not A: Inspecting bank reconciliations can provide evidence about cash receipts and reconciliation controls, but it only offers indirect or partial insight into how revenue-related controls operate throughout the order-to-cash process and whether those controls were implemented from order to revenue recognition.
Why not C: Analytical procedures are useful for identifying unusual trends or areas of risk during planning, but they do not show the design of internal controls or whether those controls are actually implemented in the entity's transaction processing.
Why not D: Observing an inventory count yields direct evidence about inventory existence and related controls, but it addresses a different cycle (inventory) and does not provide a comprehensive, process-level understanding of sales and revenue recognition controls.
Step by step
- Identify the process change
Lumen Manufacturing implemented a new ERP system and redesigned its order-to-cash process. Update the current-year understanding rather than simply rolling forward prior-year narratives.
- Inspect minutes and sales contracts
Review board and audit committee minutes and relevant sales contracts to understand the reasons for the redesign and significant sales terms. Use that information to direct further inquiries about revenue recognition.
- Ask management and IT
Ask management and IT personnel how the new ERP initiates, processes, and records sales and where relevant controls operate. Treat their answers as a starting point, not sufficient evidence of control implementation.
- Walk a sale through
Trace a sale from order initiation through invoicing and posting, combining inquiry, document inspection, and observation. Evaluate whether relevant controls are suitably designed and implemented; tracing one sale does not establish operating effectiveness throughout the year.
- Perform planning analytics
Compare current-year revenue and gross margin trends with prior years and industry averages to identify unusual relationships requiring follow-up. These analytics help direct risk assessment but do not establish control design or implementation.
- Keep substantive testing separate
Customer confirmations test receivable assertions, not how Lumen's new revenue process works, so do not substitute them or other tests of details for required risk assessment procedures. Even with a primarily substantive approach and no planned operating-effectiveness testing, obtain the required understanding of relevant controls and evaluate their design and implementation.
Key points
- Remember: Understanding how a sale gets recorded is different from testing whether a receivable balance is correct.
- A walkthrough establishes understanding of design and implementation, not operating effectiveness throughout the year.
- A primarily substantive audit still requires understanding relevant controls and evaluating their design and implementation.
How the exam traps you
- Send customer confirmations instead of understanding the new revenue process. Use risk assessment procedures first; confirmations test receivable assertions.
- Accept management's description of the new controls without corroboration. Inspect documents and observe the process during a walkthrough.
- Roll forward last year's narratives and skip planning analytics. Update the understanding for the new ERP and perform current-year planning analytical procedures.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on what auditors do early in planning to understand the client's business model, industry, and external risks before performing detailed testing.
Answer B. When planning an audit and seeking to understand the entity and its environment, auditors begin by reviewing industry and regulatory developments and discussing significant changes with management. Those activities identify entity-level business risks and show how the foreign expansion and subscription model may affect operations, accounting, and financial reporting. Detailed control tests or substantive procedures are performed later after the auditor has assessed where material misstatement risks are likely.
Why not A: Testing operating effectiveness is a later, detailed audit procedure used after the auditor has assessed control risk and decided to rely on controls. The question asks for the best next step to improve entity-level and external understanding before completing risk assessment, so control testing is premature.
Why not C: Confirmations are substantive procedures aimed at verifying specific assertions (existence of sales) and are not an initial planning activity. The auditor should first develop a planning-level understanding of business and external factors that create risk before doing targeted evidence gathering.
Why not D: Recalculation of deferred revenue is a narrow substantive test of a specific account and assertion. While appropriate later given the subscription model, it is not the best first step to gain a broad understanding of entity-level risks and the external environment.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the general duty to understand internal control from the narrower list of controls that must be specifically identified at the assertion level.
Answer B. AU-C 315 requires the auditor to identify certain controls for evaluation of design and implementation, specifically controls that address significant risks, controls over journal entries used in the financial reporting process, and controls for which substantive procedures alone cannot provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence. Options A, C, and D each trigger one of those categories (A = significant risk over valuation; C = journal-entry control; D = control necessary because substantive procedures alone are insufficient). Option B lacks any of these limiting conditions, so the auditor is least likely to need to identify that specific control at the assertion level.
Why not A: This is tempting because valuation work can often be tested substantively; however, when an assertion is identified as a significant risk the auditor is required to identify and evaluate controls related to that risk as part of the risk-assessment understanding.
Why not C: Candidates may treat journal-entry procedures as a later fraud or substantive matter, but AU-C 315 specifically calls out controls over journal entries as controls the auditor must identify and evaluate during the understanding of internal control.
Why not D: It can be misleading to think a control only matters if the auditor plans to rely on it. If substantive procedures alone cannot provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence for a relevant assertion, the auditor must identify and evaluate the related control even if no decision to rely on it has yet been made.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on what the auditor must do during risk assessment when there has been a significant change in the client's operations.
Answer B. As part of planning the audit, the auditor must obtain and update an understanding of the entity and its environment and perform risk assessment procedures. Significant changes, such as a new subscription revenue model and a new billing system, can affect the risks of material misstatement, so the auditor should use inquiries, inspection, walkthroughs, and other risk assessment procedures to update that understanding before designing further audit procedures.
Why not A: This is tempting because some candidates think new transaction types can be handled later by substantive procedures. It is incorrect because understanding the entity and its environment is a planning-stage requirement used to identify and assess risks before designing detailed audit procedures.
Why not C: This choice is attractive because prior-year knowledge often helps on recurring engagements. However, the auditor must update that understanding for current-year changes even if there is not yet evidence of a misstatement.
Why not D: This distractor is tempting because a new billing system raises control concerns. But obtaining an understanding does not automatically require tests of operating effectiveness; whether to test controls depends on the auditor's risk assessment and whether the auditor plans to rely on those controls.
Question 5
Hint
Ask whether the team understands only how transactions move, or also why the business changed and how that change affects risk.
Answer B. AU-C 315 requires the auditor to obtain a broad understanding of the entity and its environment, including changes in the nature of the entity, external factors, objectives, and related business risks, before finalizing risk assessment. Here, bundled offerings with installation and software access, price-protection credits, expansion into new jurisdictions, and an EBITDA-linked covenant can materially change operations, regulatory expectations, management incentives, and accounting-policy judgments (for example, revenue recognition). Those matters must be understood more deeply rather than deferred to account-level testing.
Why not A: This is tempting because teams often equate updated process flows with adequate planning. It is wrong because understanding how the business model and external pressures change risks and accounting judgments is part of identifying and assessing risks, not something that can simply be cured later by substantive tests.
Why not C: This distractor confuses understanding internal controls (for reliance decisions) with the auditor's obligation to understand the entity and its environment for risk assessment. Even with a substantive approach, the auditor still needs a deep understanding of changed operations and external factors to target procedures appropriately.
Why not D: Walkthroughs are useful, but this choice is too narrow. The primary gap is broader: how bundled offerings, new licensing, and covenant pressures alter business risks and accounting policy judgments across the entity, not just process-level steps.
Question 6
Hint
Think about which procedures are primarily for planning and understanding the business (inquiry, inspection, observation, analytics) versus those used later to gather evidence about specific account balances.
Answer D. Customer confirmations are substantive procedures aimed at obtaining evidence about the existence and accuracy of account balances, not primarily procedures for obtaining an understanding of the entity and its environment during planning. By contrast, inspecting minutes and contracts, touring facilities, and researching industry/regulatory factors are common planning procedures used to learn about the business and identify risks.
Why not A: This is a standard planning procedure: minutes and contracts often reveal objectives, strategies, and significant commitments that affect risk assessment, so it is appropriate for obtaining an understanding of the entity.
Why not B: Observing operations and touring facilities help auditors understand the entity's processes, internal controls, and risk areas; these are appropriate planning activities rather than substantive evidence gathering.
Why not C: External research on industry, economic, and regulatory factors informs the auditor about external influences and business risks and is a valid procedure for understanding the entity and its environment.
Common questions
What are risk assessment procedures under AU-C 315?
They include inquiry, analytical procedures, observation, and inspection. For Lumen, these procedures explain the new revenue process and help identify and assess risks of material misstatement.
Does a walkthrough test operating effectiveness?
Tracing one Lumen sale helps evaluate control design and implementation. It does not establish that the controls operated effectively throughout the year.
Do I need to understand controls for a substantive audit?
Yes. Even without planned tests of operating effectiveness, the auditor must understand relevant controls and evaluate their design and implementation; customer confirmations do not replace that work.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Understanding an Entity and Its Environment, worked step by step.
Preliminary Analytics & Audit Procedures | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Understanding an Entity and Its Environment
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.