PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 6 practice questions

New ERP Audit: When Can You Rely on Automated Controls?

A new ERP does not justify control reliance without evidence that relevant controls operate effectively. Follow the decision tree to assess migration evidence, hosted-system controls, and the need for more substantive testing.

The ruleUnderstand the new system and evaluate relevant controls' design and implementation. Before relying on automated controls, obtain evidence of operating effectiveness, including relevant IT general controls; otherwise, revise the audit response and increase substantive testing for affected assertions.

Try one first

During planning for the Year 2 audit of Avon Components, the auditor learns that in Year 2 the company replaced several legacy accounting applications with a new enterprise resource planning (ERP) system and migrated transaction processing to a centralized ERP environment. The conversion occurred mid-year, finance staff received limited training, previously manual spreadsheet reconciliations were replaced by automated ERP processes, and management provided no documentation of change-management or data-migration controls. No post-conversion testing of the ERP controls has been performed. Which of the following planned audit responses is most appropriate given the auditor's understanding of the entity and its environment?
Hint

Focus on how a mid‑year ERP conversion with limited documentation and training affects IT general controls and whether targeted IT/control testing plus adjusted substantive procedures are needed.

Decide it in order

  1. T1RetailCo moved revenue processing to a new ERP midyear. Has the auditor understood the changed process and evaluated the design and implementation of relevant application controls and IT general controls, including access, change management, and operations?

    NoUpdate the understanding and evaluate relevant controls before deciding on reliance. Involve an IT specialist if needed. A substantive approach does not eliminate this work.
  2. T2Does conversion evidence support complete and accurate migrated revenue data, with significant reconciliation differences resolved and relevant ERP reports shown to be reliable?

    NoDo not rely on affected automated controls or unverified reports. Investigate migration differences, consider IT specialist assistance, and expand revenue detail and cutoff testing using reliable evidence.
  3. T3Does RetailCo use a hosted ERP whose service-organization controls are relevant to planned reliance?

  4. T4Does a SOC 1 Type 2 report or alternative procedures provide sufficient evidence about relevant service controls, with coverage, exceptions, and complementary user controls addressed?

    NoDo not assume the hosted controls are effective. Obtain additional service-control evidence or plan additional substantive procedures using reliable evidence. A vendor's reputation is not audit evidence.
  5. T5Do tests establish that relevant automated controls and supporting IT general controls operated effectively over the intended reliance period, including the available period after a late go-live?

    YesReliance may support reducing substantive testing, but not eliminating it. Tailor revenue procedures to the assessed risks and the period supported by control evidence.
    NoDo not rely on the affected automated controls. Increase year-end revenue detail and cutoff testing. If substantive procedures alone cannot provide sufficient appropriate evidence, obtain the necessary control evidence.

Key points

  • Remember: documented control design is not evidence that the control operated effectively.
  • Conversion errors can undermine both automated controls and the reports used for substantive testing.
  • Use IT specialists when evaluating the new system or migration requires expertise beyond the audit team's skills.

How the exam traps you

  • Relying on automated controls because their design is documented. Test operating effectiveness over the period of intended reliance.
  • Accepting reasonable-looking ERP reports despite unresolved migration differences. Investigate conversion differences and establish report reliability before using the reports as audit evidence.
  • Treating a favorable SOC 1 report as automatic permission to reduce testing. Evaluate its coverage, exceptions, and relevant complementary user controls.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Broadline Manufacturing Co. (BMC) began implementing a new ERP system in early Year 2 that will automate inventory transaction processing and perform automated matching of purchase orders, receipts, and vendor invoices. Go‑live is July 1, Year 2, with only limited parallel testing completed. BMC is also shifting to a just‑in‑time (JIT) inventory strategy to reduce on‑hand balances. The auditor audited Year 1 and historically relied primarily on substantive procedures for inventory and accounts payable. Audit planning for Year 2 is in progress. Based solely on these facts, what is the most appropriate next step in the auditor's understanding of the entity and its environment?
Hint

Which procedures must the auditor perform early to decide whether automated controls can be relied on, evaluate controls (including ITGCs) or rely only on additional substantive tests?

Question 3

An engagement team is planning the Year 2 financial statement audit of NorthStar Electronics, a privately held manufacturer. During planning the team obtained these facts: Year‑2 revenue increased about 40% after the company launched a direct‑to‑consumer e-commerce channel in July Year 2. In June Year 2 management implemented a new ERP and migrated prior sales/customer data using a third‑party vendor; the integration was completed in September Year 2 but repeated data‑mapping errors required multiple patches and some reconciliation items remain unresolved. In August Year 2 the company outsourced order fulfillment to a 3PL that does not provide a SOC 1 report; NorthStar retains responsibility for recording sales. An unconsolidated affiliate purchased about 12% of Year‑2 sales on related‑party terms for which formal contracts/disclosures have not been provided to the auditors. Three customers account for roughly 55% of Year‑2 revenue. The internal audit function was disbanded in Year 1, the CFO was replaced in September Year 2, and the company obtained a loan covenant waiver in November Year 2. Returns and chargebacks increased after the e‑commerce launch, and a product redesign in October Year 2 creates inventory obsolescence risk. Based on the auditor's understanding of the entity and its environment, which of the following is the most appropriate planning conclusion regarding the audit approach for revenue‑related assertions for Year 2?
Hint

Which set of changes most directly affects the integrity of recognized revenue (new channel, ERP migration, outsourcing, related parties, and customer concentration) and whether it would be appropriate to rely on controls without evidence they operate effectively?

Question 4

An auditor is planning the Year 2 audit of NovaSoft, a mid-sized software company. During Year 2 NovaSoft migrated to a new cloud-hosted revenue recognition system midyear and adopted a subscription-based revenue model that requires significant judgment to estimate deferred revenue and variable consideration. The controller and revenue manager both left shortly after the migration, and NovaSoft has not documented or tested internal controls over revenue in the migrated environment. Based on the auditor's understanding of the entity and its environment, which of the following is the most likely effect on the auditor's planned response?
Hint

Focus on how system migration, a change in recognition requiring judgment, a hosted service organization, and turnover of key personnel affect inherent and control risk and what responses those increased risks normally trigger (IT expertise, more substantive evidence).

Question 5

You are the engagement partner planning the Year 1 audit of RetailCo, a retailer that launched a new e-commerce platform during Year 1. The platform now processes about 65% of sales and was implemented two months before year-end; it automates order entry, invoicing, and revenue recognition. Management also changed the company's revenue-recognition policy during Year 1. Senior management's bonuses are materially tied to achieving quarterly sales targets. The company has documented the design of automated controls over the platform, but the platform has limited operating history and the operating effectiveness of those automated controls has not been tested. Internal audit was reorganized during implementation and has had little involvement with the launch. When planning the nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures for revenue and related IT controls, which of the following is the most appropriate response?
Hint

When a new automated revenue-processing system is implemented shortly before year-end and revenue recognition changes, consider whether controls have operated long enough to be relied on and whether year-end substantive testing and IT specialist involvement are needed.

Question 6

During planning for the Year 2 audit of MfgCo (fiscal year-end Year 2), the auditor notes these facts: MfgCo implemented a new ERP system at the start of Year 2 that now processes sales orders, shipping records, inventory valuation and interfaces to the general ledger; data conversion from the legacy system occurred at implementation. The CFO resigned mid-Year 2 and was replaced six months before year-end by an external hire with limited industry experience. MfgCo uses a third-party logistics provider (3PL) to warehouse finished goods; legal title remains with MfgCo, the 3PL's shipping notices feed electronically into the ERP, and no SOC 1 report is available from the 3PL. The auditor relied on tests of controls in Year 1. Which of the following is the most appropriate treatment for the auditor's planned response to risks of material misstatement related to revenue and inventory?
Hint

Focus on how the ERP implementation, data conversion and third‑party warehousing affect inherent and control risk and what that implies for the nature, timing and extent of audit procedures.

Drill all 102 Understanding an Entity and Its Environment questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does a new ERP require tests of controls?

The auditor must understand the system and evaluate relevant controls' design and implementation. Operating-effectiveness testing is required when relying on controls or when substantive procedures alone cannot provide sufficient appropriate evidence.

Can auditors rely on ERP controls implemented late in the year?

Late implementation does not automatically prohibit reliance. Documented design alone is insufficient; the auditor needs operating-effectiveness evidence covering the period of intended reliance.

Is a SOC 1 Type 2 report enough to rely on a hosted ERP?

Not by itself. Evaluate the report's scope, period, results, and relevant complementary user controls, together with evidence about the company's own controls and migration.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Understanding an Entity and Its Environment, worked step by step.

Preliminary Analytics & Audit Procedures | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Understanding an Entity and Its Environment

All Understanding an Entity and Its Environment practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.