PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 6 practice questions

Audit and Review Engagement Letters: Contingent Fees

Contingent fees are prohibited for any service to an audit or review client. Sort Tanner's proposed fee terms to identify arrangements prohibited for an audit or review client.

The ruleDo not perform any service, including consulting, for an audit or review client for a contingent fee, even with signed terms or a fixed base fee. A fee fixed by a court is not contingent.

Try one first

Firm Green LLP received a draft engagement letter from Tanner Manufacturing (a privately held company) for the Year 1 financial statement audit. The draft letter: (1) sets the audit fee at 1% of any bank loan Tanner obtains using the audited financial statements (i.e., the fee is contingent on obtaining financing); (2) is signed only by Tanner's CFO (no board or other signatures); (3) asks the auditor to omit physical observation of inventory at an off-site distribution warehouse and rely on the company's perpetual records; and (4) prohibits the auditor from contacting Tanner's primary lending bank without prior management approval. Firm Green has not begun fieldwork. What is the primary professional issue the firm should address before proceeding?
Hint

Which term in the draft letter directly affects auditor independence and is prohibited for attest (audit) engagements under professional rules?

Sort it

Prohibited contingent fee

The fee depends on a result for Tanner, an audit or review client, and is not fixed by a court.

Not a contingent fee

The fee is fixed by a court or does not depend on a particular finding or result.

ItemGoes to
Tanner's audit fee equals 1% of any bank loan obtained using the audited statements.Prohibited contingent feeThe fee depends on Tanner obtaining financing, not simply on the firm performing the audit.
Tanner owes an $80,000 audit fee regardless of whether its bank approves financing.Not a contingent feeThe bank's decision does not change the fee.
Tanner's audit fee is $80,000 plus 2% of sale proceeds if Tanner is sold.Prohibited contingent feeThe success bonus is contingent. A fixed base fee does not cure the prohibited portion.
A court fixes Tanner's audit fee at $80,000.Not a contingent feeA fee fixed by a court falls outside the AICPA definition of a contingent fee.
Tanner signs an engagement letter making the audit fee payable only if bank financing is approved.Prohibited contingent feeManagement's signature does not matter. Agreement cannot make a prohibited financing-based fee acceptable.
Tanner pays a fixed audit fee and a separate consulting fee contingent on obtaining bank financing.Prohibited contingent feeSeparating the consulting engagement does not matter. The prohibition covers any service for the audit client.
Tanner's review fee equals hours worked at a fixed hourly rate, regardless of financing.Not a contingent feeHours measure work performed, not whether Tanner gets the loan.
Tanner's review fee is payable only if its bank approves financing based on the reviewed statements.Prohibited contingent feeA review also requires independence. Its lower assurance level does not permit a contingent fee.
Tanner pays an $80,000 audit fee, refundable if the bank rejects its financing application.Prohibited contingent feeThe refund makes the fee depend on financing. Calling the initial payment fixed does not change that.
Tanner's audit fee increases only if the firm issues an unmodified opinion.Prohibited contingent feeThe fee depends on the audit's result, creating a prohibited contingent arrangement.

Key points

  • Remember: A signed engagement letter cannot make a prohibited contingent fee acceptable.
  • Test every service for the same client, not just the fee labeled 'audit.'
  • A fixed base fee does not neutralize a contingent bonus.

How the exam traps you

  • Accepting a financing-based fee because a review provides less assurance than an audit. Reviews also require independence. Remove the contingent fee or decline.
  • Treating a separate consulting success fee as acceptable for an audit client. The prohibition covers any service for that audit client, including consulting.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

Year 1: PrimeCo (a privately held company) asks Stone & Co. to (1) perform an audit of PrimeCo's Year 1 financial statements for general distribution and (2) prepare a compilation of those same Year 1 financial statements for submission to a local bank. Stone & Co. is not independent with respect to PrimeCo because a partner has a material financial interest in the client. PrimeCo's CEO requests that Stone & Co. use a single engagement letter for both services and omit any disclosure of Stone & Co.'s lack of independence in the compilation report. Considering professional standards on terms of engagement, what is the best conclusion for Stone & Co.'s response?
Hint

First determine which types of engagements require auditor independence; then decide what disclosures and engagement documentation are required for engagements that do not require independence.

Question 3

An audit firm is negotiating engagement letters for Year 1 audits with two prospective nonissuer clients. Client A requests a clause that would prohibit the auditor from accessing records of a foreign subsidiary without prior written permission. Client B requests a clause that would cap the auditor's liability to $100,000. (Assume the firm is independent and there is no statutory prohibition on limitation-of-liability clauses.) Which factor should primarily govern the auditor's decision about whether to accept these requested terms, and how should that factor be applied to the two clauses?
Hint

Focus on which consideration directly affects the auditor’s practical ability to perform required procedures and gather evidence.

Question 4

Peterson & Co. was asked to perform a review of Year 1 financial statements for Lamar Company (a private company). Management circulated a proposed engagement letter that (a) states the accountant "will provide reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free of material misstatement," (b) says Lamar will not provide a written management representation letter (management prefers oral confirmations), and (c) limits the engagement to review of two of Lamar's four operating divisions. There is no prior engagement letter. Which is the best conclusion for the partner deciding whether to accept the engagement?
Hint

Recall what a review engagement is expected to provide and what the engagement letter and management representations must include; think about whether management's proposed terms are compatible with those requirements.

Question 5

Before accepting a 20X6 audit engagement for a private company, an auditor is asked to agree to the following terms: management will prepare the financial statements under U.S. GAAP, provide access to records, and acknowledge its responsibility for internal control relevant to the preparation of the statements. Management will also allow communication with those charged with governance and external legal counsel. However, management will not allow positive confirmations of accounts receivable because of customer-relations concerns, although detailed aging schedules and subsequent cash-receipt data will be available. Management also will not allow the auditor to observe the year-end count of inventory stored in the company's only warehouse because the production formulas are proprietary, and no perpetual records exist to permit a reliable rollforward or rollback. Inventory is approximately 35% of total assets and is central to gross profit. No law or regulation requires an audit. Which factor most strongly governs whether the auditor should decline the engagement at the outset?
Hint

Separate the client’s general acceptance preconditions from any specific management-imposed scope limitation, and ask which item would likely prevent a supportable opinion before the engagement even begins.

Question 6

CPA Firm Larkin is engaged to prepare a compilation of ClientCo's Year 1 financial statements (compilation only; no audit or review). ClientCo plans to provide the compiled statements to its bank. According to AICPA professional standards on terms of engagement (SSARS for compilations, AU-C for audits), which of the following must be included in a compilation engagement letter but is NOT required in an audit engagement letter?
Hint

Compare what SSARS compilation letters are required to disclaim (what the accountant will not provide) with what AU-C audit letters describe as the auditor's objective and planned procedures.

Drill all 75 Terms of Engagement questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can a CPA charge a contingent fee for a review?

No. A review requires independence, and a fee contingent on the client obtaining financing is prohibited. Remove the term or decline the review.

Can an audit client pay a contingent consulting fee?

No. The prohibition covers any service for an audit client. A separate consulting engagement or a fixed audit fee does not cure it.

Is an audit fee fixed by a court a contingent fee?

No. A fee fixed by a court is not a contingent fee under the AICPA rule.

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Terms of Engagement

All Terms of Engagement practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.