AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 6 practice questions
Audit and Review Engagement Letters: Contingent Fees
Contingent fees are prohibited for any service to an audit or review client. Sort Tanner's proposed fee terms to identify arrangements prohibited for an audit or review client.
Try one first
Hint
Which term in the draft letter directly affects auditor independence and is prohibited for attest (audit) engagements under professional rules?
Answer A. Contingent-fee arrangements for attest engagements (including audits) create an independence impairment under professional standards and are prohibited; therefore the contingent-fee clause must be resolved (removed) or the firm must decline the engagement before accepting or continuing. The other items, scope limitation, authorization questions, or restricted third-party contact, are important but generally addressable and secondary to the immediate, nonnegotiable independence prohibition.
Why not B: This distractor tempts because omitting physical inventory observation can materially impair evidence gathering. It is incorrect as the primary issue because scope limitations can often be addressed through alternative procedures, renegotiation of terms, or by declining if unresolved, whereas a contingent-fee clause presents an immediate independence prohibition.
Why not C: This option is attractive because proper authorization is required and signatures matter. It fails as the primary issue because signature by an authorized management official (e.g., the CFO) typically evidences agreement for a privately held entity and is generally a documentation/authorization concern rather than the categorical independence impairment caused by a contingent-fee arrangement.
Why not D: This choice tempts because prohibiting contact with a lender can block important corroborative evidence. It is not the primary issue here because contact restrictions are an access/scope limitation that can often be negotiated or addressed with alternative procedures, whereas contingent fees create a nonnegotiable independence violation.
Sort it
The fee depends on a result for Tanner, an audit or review client, and is not fixed by a court.
The fee is fixed by a court or does not depend on a particular finding or result.
| Item | Goes to |
|---|---|
| Tanner's audit fee equals 1% of any bank loan obtained using the audited statements. | Prohibited contingent feeThe fee depends on Tanner obtaining financing, not simply on the firm performing the audit. |
| Tanner owes an $80,000 audit fee regardless of whether its bank approves financing. | Not a contingent feeThe bank's decision does not change the fee. |
| Tanner's audit fee is $80,000 plus 2% of sale proceeds if Tanner is sold. | Prohibited contingent feeThe success bonus is contingent. A fixed base fee does not cure the prohibited portion. |
| A court fixes Tanner's audit fee at $80,000. | Not a contingent feeA fee fixed by a court falls outside the AICPA definition of a contingent fee. |
| Tanner signs an engagement letter making the audit fee payable only if bank financing is approved. | Prohibited contingent feeManagement's signature does not matter. Agreement cannot make a prohibited financing-based fee acceptable. |
| Tanner pays a fixed audit fee and a separate consulting fee contingent on obtaining bank financing. | Prohibited contingent feeSeparating the consulting engagement does not matter. The prohibition covers any service for the audit client. |
| Tanner's review fee equals hours worked at a fixed hourly rate, regardless of financing. | Not a contingent feeHours measure work performed, not whether Tanner gets the loan. |
| Tanner's review fee is payable only if its bank approves financing based on the reviewed statements. | Prohibited contingent feeA review also requires independence. Its lower assurance level does not permit a contingent fee. |
| Tanner pays an $80,000 audit fee, refundable if the bank rejects its financing application. | Prohibited contingent feeThe refund makes the fee depend on financing. Calling the initial payment fixed does not change that. |
| Tanner's audit fee increases only if the firm issues an unmodified opinion. | Prohibited contingent feeThe fee depends on the audit's result, creating a prohibited contingent arrangement. |
Key points
- Remember: A signed engagement letter cannot make a prohibited contingent fee acceptable.
- Test every service for the same client, not just the fee labeled 'audit.'
- A fixed base fee does not neutralize a contingent bonus.
How the exam traps you
- Accepting a financing-based fee because a review provides less assurance than an audit. Reviews also require independence. Remove the contingent fee or decline.
- Treating a separate consulting success fee as acceptable for an audit client. The prohibition covers any service for that audit client, including consulting.
Question 2
Hint
First determine which types of engagements require auditor independence; then decide what disclosures and engagement documentation are required for engagements that do not require independence.
Answer B. Audits require auditor independence, so Stone & Co. must decline the audit if it is not independent. Compilations do not require independence, but the accountant must document the compilation engagement terms and disclose any lack of independence in the compilation report. Therefore accepting only the compilation with proper engagement documentation and disclosure is the appropriate response.
Why not A: Tempting because a candidate might think disclosure resolves independence issues or that one letter is efficient; it is wrong because independence is a prerequisite for issuing an audit opinion, disclosure does not permit performing an audit when the auditor is not independent.
Why not C: Tempting for a cautious student who assumes independence is required for all attest work; it is incorrect because compilations do not require independence and may be accepted if the lack of independence is disclosed and the engagement terms are documented.
Why not D: Tempting because disclosure seems transparent; it is wrong because professional standards do not allow issuing an audit opinion if the auditor is not independent, the auditor must decline or withdraw from the audit engagement.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on which consideration directly affects the auditor’s practical ability to perform required procedures and gather evidence.
Answer A. The auditor's primary consideration is whether engagement terms would impair compliance with professional auditing standards or the ability to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence. Client A's clause could prevent access to necessary subsidiary records and should be rejected or modified. A liability cap, by itself, does not prevent gathering evidence and may be acceptable if it does not otherwise impede audit procedures.
Why not B: Tempting because issuer status does affect regulatory oversight and some engagement requirements. It fails because the decisive test is whether terms impede the auditor's ability to comply with standards and obtain sufficient evidence, an access restriction that blocks evidence must be rejected regardless of issuer status.
Why not C: Tempting because commercial reasonableness and fee negotiation are central to firm risk management. It fails because higher fees do not justify accepting terms that would prevent performance of required audit procedures or obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not D: Tempting because legal enforceability affects the firm's contractual remedies and risk exposure. It fails because enforceability is secondary: even legally enforceable clauses must be declined if they would impair the auditor's ability to perform the audit and obtain sufficient evidence.
Question 4
Hint
Recall what a review engagement is expected to provide and what the engagement letter and management representations must include; think about whether management's proposed terms are compatible with those requirements.
Answer A. A review engagement provides only limited assurance, not reasonable assurance; the engagement letter must state the review's limited-assurance objective. Professional standards also require a written management representation and access to information sufficient for the engagement. The firm should insist on terms that comply with review standards or decline the engagement if management will not agree.
Why not B: This is tempting because more procedures feel like more assurance, but a review cannot be converted into an audit by adding procedures; reasonable assurance requires an audit performed under audit standards and the associated scope and documentation.
Why not C: Oral assurances are easier to obtain, but professional standards require a written management representation for reviews to document management's responsibilities and to support the practitioner's conclusion.
Why not D: An agreed-upon procedures engagement can be limited in scope and avoids giving assurance, but it changes the nature of the engagement and does not provide the limited assurance the client requested; the partner's first response should be to obtain compliant review terms or decline if management refuses.
Question 5
Hint
Separate the client’s general acceptance preconditions from any specific management-imposed scope limitation, and ask which item would likely prevent a supportable opinion before the engagement even begins.
Answer B. Under AU-C 210, if management imposes a scope limitation before the auditor accepts the engagement and the auditor believes the limitation will likely result in a disclaimer of opinion, the auditor should not accept the engagement unless required by law or regulation. Here inventory is material (about 35% of assets) and central to gross profit, the company has a single warehouse, and management prohibits observation while no perpetual records exist to permit reliable rollforward/rollback. That combination makes the inventory-observation restriction the governing acceptance factor.
Why not A: This is attractive because confirmations are commonly used and client resistance is a red flag. However, a refusal to allow confirmations does not automatically make the engagement unacceptable if other procedures (aging, subsequent receipts) can provide sufficient appropriate evidence. In this scenario the receivables restriction is less severe than the inventory limitation.
Why not C: While true that alternative procedures can address the receivables-confirmation restriction, acceptance must consider all management-imposed limitations. A solvable limitation on receivables does not overcome a separate limitation on inventory that is material and pervasive and likely to prevent obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence.
Why not D: Meeting preconditions (management responsibility for the financial statements and access to records) is required to accept an engagement, but satisfying preconditions does not override a scope limitation imposed by management that would probably result in a disclaimer when an audit is not legally required.
Question 6
Hint
Compare what SSARS compilation letters are required to disclaim (what the accountant will not provide) with what AU-C audit letters describe as the auditor's objective and planned procedures.
Answer D. SSARS compilation engagement letters must include an explicit statement that the accountant will not audit or review the financial statements and therefore will not express assurance. Audit (AU-C) engagement letters, by contrast, set out the auditor's objective to obtain reasonable assurance and would not contain a 'no assurance' disclaimer.
Why not A: Tempting because obtaining an understanding of internal control is a standard audit-planning activity; wrong because that requirement pertains to audits and is not required in compilation engagement letters.
Why not B: Tempting because management's responsibilities are important to any engagement; wrong because both compilation and audit engagement letters document management's responsibility for the financial statements and for providing information, so this is not unique to compilations.
Why not C: Tempting because 'verify accuracy' sounds like an accountant's duty; wrong because compilation engagements do not include verification or assurance procedures, those are characteristics of audits (and, to a lesser extent, reviews), not compilations.
Common questions
Can a CPA charge a contingent fee for a review?
No. A review requires independence, and a fee contingent on the client obtaining financing is prohibited. Remove the term or decline the review.
Can an audit client pay a contingent consulting fee?
No. The prohibition covers any service for an audit client. A separate consulting engagement or a fixed audit fee does not cure it.
Is an audit fee fixed by a court a contingent fee?
No. A fee fixed by a court is not a contingent fee under the AICPA rule.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Terms of Engagement
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.