PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 10 practice questions

Changing an Audit to a Review Under AU-C 210

An auditor may change an audit to a review only with reasonable justification, not merely to reduce fees or avoid audit procedures. Below, the same client's request changes one fact at a time.

The ruleUnder AU-C 210, accept an audit-to-review change only with reasonable justification, such as changed needs or a genuine misunderstanding. Otherwise, decline the change; if management prevents continuing the audit, withdraw when legally permitted.

Try one first

A CPA firm, independent with respect to a nonissuer client, was engaged to audit the client's 20X5 financial statements. After planning began but before substantive fieldwork, three facts arise: (1) the client's lender amends its covenant and will now accept either audited or reviewed financial statements; (2) year-end inventory records from a system conversion are incomplete, although the auditor believes alternative procedures are likely available; and (3) the CEO tells the engagement partner, "If this is going to mean extra audit work and a possible modified opinion over inventory, we'd rather switch to a review." Assume no law or regulation requires an audit, and the firm is permitted to perform either service. Under the guidance on terms of engagement, what is the primary issue in deciding whether to accept the requested change?
Hint

Focus on why the client wants the engagement changed, not just on whether a lower-level service is now permissible.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Harbor Co.'s Year 2 audit has begun under signed terms. The CPA is independent; a review is otherwise permitted, and withdrawal is legal. No law requires an audit. The bank has always accepted reviews. Management understood that requirement when choosing an audit. It requests a review to reduce fees but will permit the audit to continue if refused. No audit problems have emerged.

Answer: Decline the change and continue the audit under the original terms.

Nothing changed in Harbor's reporting needs, and management understood the original requirement. A preference for lower fees alone does not provide reasonable justification.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1The bank previously required an audit and has just amended its covenant to accept a review.

Answer: May accept the change after agreeing to and documenting revised written review terms.

The bank's amendment genuinely changes Harbor's reporting needs. Fee savings do not invalidate that justification when management is not avoiding audit problems.

Change 2Management originally believed the bank required an audit; the bank now confirms in writing that reviews always sufficed.

Answer: May accept the change after documenting the misunderstanding and agreeing to revised written review terms.

A genuine, documented misunderstanding can justify the change even though the bank's actual requirement never changed.

Change 3Management will not permit the original audit to continue if the CPA declines the review.

Answer: Decline the change and withdraw; consider professional and legal responsibilities.

The fee-driven request remains unjustified. Because management now blocks the original audit, withdraw and consider professional and legal responsibilities.

Key points

  • Remember: Ask why assurance is being reduced, not just whether the bank accepts a review.
  • A bank's standing acceptance of reviews is not a new change in reporting needs.
  • Agree to and document revised written terms before proceeding with an accepted review.
  • Rejecting a downgrade does not require withdrawal when management still permits the audit.

How the exam traps you

  • Accepting because the bank allows reviewed statements. Check whether its requirement actually changed or management genuinely misunderstood it.
  • Treating a revised engagement letter as sufficient justification. Establish a valid reason first. Paperwork documents an acceptable change; it does not make an unjustified change acceptable.
  • Withdrawing whenever management requests lower assurance. Decline an unjustified change and continue the audit if management permits it.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Harbor Co.'s Year 2 audit has begun under signed terms. The CPA is independent; a review is otherwise permitted, and withdrawal is legal. No law requires an audit. The bank has always accepted reviews. Management understood that requirement when choosing an audit. It requests a review to reduce fees but will permit the audit to continue if refused. No audit problems have emerged. What should the CPA do?

Question 2

Same facts, except the bank previously required an audit and has just amended its covenant to accept a review. What should the CPA do?

Question 3

Same facts, except management initially believed the bank required an audit. The bank now confirms in writing that reviews always sufficed. What should the CPA do?

Question 4

Same facts, except management will not permit the original audit to continue if the CPA declines the review. What should the CPA do?

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

After fieldwork has begun on an audit of Ridge Co.'s 20X6 financial statements, management asks the auditor to change the engagement to a review. Management explains that it does not want the auditor to send accounts receivable confirmations because several disputed customer balances could slow issuance of the statements. No law or regulation requires an audit. Under the standards on terms of engagement, what is the auditor's most appropriate response?
Hint

Focus on when a change from an audit to a lower-assurance service is allowed and when the client's reason makes the change unacceptable.

Question 3

Dalton & Co. accepted an audit engagement for Lakeview Inc.'s 20X6 financial statements. Before substantive testing begins, management asks Dalton to change the engagement to a review. Assume Dalton is independent, a review would otherwise be appropriate, and no law or regulation requires an audit. Under AU-C 210, in which situation is agreeing to the change most appropriate?
Hint

Ask why management wants the change. A valid reason usually involves a genuine change in circumstances, not a desire to avoid audit evidence problems or reporting consequences.

Question 4

Stone, CPA, was engaged to audit Harbor Co.'s Year 1 financial statements. After fieldwork began, Harbor discovered it cannot support inventory quantities because its records are incomplete. Management asks Stone to change the engagement from an audit to a review to save time and cost. Assume there has been no change in Harbor's reporting needs and no misunderstanding about the original audit engagement. Which factor should primarily govern Stone's decision on the requested change in the terms of engagement?
Hint

Focus on why the client wants to change the engagement, not just on timing, fees, or paperwork.

Question 5

Delta, CPA, was engaged to audit the Year 2 financial statements of Apex Co., a nonissuer. After audit fieldwork began, Delta identified significant problems with Apex's inventory records for a major warehouse and advised management that extensive additional procedures would likely be needed. Management then asked Delta to change the engagement from an audit to a review, explaining that (1) it wants to reduce professional fees during a system conversion, (2) a new CFO would prefer limited assurance this year, and (3) Apex's lender has confirmed that a review would satisfy the loan covenant. Assume no law or regulation requires an audit and Delta is qualified to perform either service. What is Delta's most appropriate response regarding the requested change in terms?
Hint

Focus on the reason for the requested change and when that reason arose, not just on whether a review would otherwise satisfy the lender.

Question 6

Hall, CPA, was engaged to audit Woodmere Co.'s Year 2 financial statements. After planning and some substantive testing, Hall told management that additional inventory procedures would be necessary and that, depending on the results, the audit report could require modification. Management then asked Hall to change the engagement to a review. Management cites all of the following: the company refinanced after year-end and the former lender's audit requirement no longer applies; the new CFO says she thought prior services had been only "annual financial statement reviews"; and management wants to avoid the cost and delay of further inventory work. Assume no law or regulation requires an audit, no report has been issued, and Hall is permitted to perform the review if the change is acceptable. Under the applicable standards on terms of engagement, what factor should govern Hall's decision on whether to agree to the requested change?
Hint

Do not focus first on who approves the change or whether a revised letter can be signed. Ask what substantive condition must exist before an auditor may accept a lower-assurance replacement engagement after an audit has begun.

Drill all 75 Terms of Engagement questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can an audit be changed to a review after it starts?

Yes, with reasonable justification, such as a genuine change in reporting needs or a documented misunderstanding. Agree to and document revised written terms before proceeding with the review.

Does a bank's acceptance of reviewed statements justify switching?

A newly relaxed requirement or genuine misunderstanding can justify switching. A bank that always accepted reviews does not, by itself, justify a fee-driven downgrade.

What if management refuses to let the original audit continue?

Do not accept an unjustified change to a review. If management prevents the audit from continuing, withdraw when legally permitted and consider professional and legal responsibilities.

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Terms of Engagement

All Terms of Engagement practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.