AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 10 practice questions
Changing an Audit to a Review Under AU-C 210
An auditor may change an audit to a review only with reasonable justification, not merely to reduce fees or avoid audit procedures. Below, the same client's request changes one fact at a time.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on why the client wants the engagement changed, not just on whether a lower-level service is now permissible.
Answer C. The primary issue is whether there is reasonable justification for downgrading the engagement. A genuine change in user needs (for example, the lender's amendment) can justify revising the engagement; however, the auditor should ordinarily refuse a change that appears driven by management's desire to avoid necessary audit procedures or a likely modified opinion. The CEO's comment makes assessment of management's motivation the critical consideration.
Why not A: This is tempting because a third party's changed needs are relevant, but the lender's amendment is not an automatic green light. The auditor must evaluate all facts, including management's motives, before agreeing to change the engagement.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to candidates who think the auditor must complete substantive work before any acceptance decision. Terms-of-engagement guidance requires assessing whether the requested change is appropriate (including whether it is motivated by avoidance of audit scrutiny) before acquiescing; apparent improper motivation can justify refusing the change without first doing extra audit procedures.
Why not D: While documentation of a revised engagement is necessary if the change is acceptable, a willingness to sign a review letter does not cure an unjustified change. Informed consent cannot legitimize a request that appears designed to evade audit procedures or a likely modified opinion.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Harbor Co.'s Year 2 audit has begun under signed terms. The CPA is independent; a review is otherwise permitted, and withdrawal is legal. No law requires an audit. The bank has always accepted reviews. Management understood that requirement when choosing an audit. It requests a review to reduce fees but will permit the audit to continue if refused. No audit problems have emerged.
Answer: Decline the change and continue the audit under the original terms.
Nothing changed in Harbor's reporting needs, and management understood the original requirement. A preference for lower fees alone does not provide reasonable justification.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1The bank previously required an audit and has just amended its covenant to accept a review.
Answer: May accept the change after agreeing to and documenting revised written review terms.
The bank's amendment genuinely changes Harbor's reporting needs. Fee savings do not invalidate that justification when management is not avoiding audit problems.
Change 2Management originally believed the bank required an audit; the bank now confirms in writing that reviews always sufficed.
Answer: May accept the change after documenting the misunderstanding and agreeing to revised written review terms.
A genuine, documented misunderstanding can justify the change even though the bank's actual requirement never changed.
Change 3Management will not permit the original audit to continue if the CPA declines the review.
Answer: Decline the change and withdraw; consider professional and legal responsibilities.
The fee-driven request remains unjustified. Because management now blocks the original audit, withdraw and consider professional and legal responsibilities.
Key points
- Remember: Ask why assurance is being reduced, not just whether the bank accepts a review.
- A bank's standing acceptance of reviews is not a new change in reporting needs.
- Agree to and document revised written terms before proceeding with an accepted review.
- Rejecting a downgrade does not require withdrawal when management still permits the audit.
How the exam traps you
- Accepting because the bank allows reviewed statements. Check whether its requirement actually changed or management genuinely misunderstood it.
- Treating a revised engagement letter as sufficient justification. Establish a valid reason first. Paperwork documents an acceptable change; it does not make an unjustified change acceptable.
- Withdrawing whenever management requests lower assurance. Decline an unjustified change and continue the audit if management permits it.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. Fee savings alone, without changed needs or a misunderstanding, do not reasonably justify the change.
Why not B: Incorrect. The bank always accepted reviews, so its requirement has not changed.
Why not C: Incorrect. Revised terms cannot supply the missing reasonable justification.
Why not D: Incorrect. Management permits the audit to continue, so withdrawal is not required.
Question 2
Answer C. Correct. The amendment changes Harbor's reporting needs, and revised terms document the new service.
Why not A: Incorrect. The lender's changed requirement provides reasonable justification despite the fee savings.
Why not B: Incorrect. Starting an audit does not prohibit a justified change.
Why not D: Incorrect. The parties must agree to and document the revised review terms.
Question 3
Answer B. Correct. Written bank confirmation supports the misunderstanding; revised terms document the accepted change.
Why not A: Incorrect. A genuine misunderstanding can justify a change without any change in the bank's actual requirement.
Why not C: Incorrect. Completing the audit is not a prerequisite to accepting a reasonably justified change.
Why not D: Incorrect. The original audit terms do not document the replacement review engagement.
Question 4
Answer D. Correct. The change remains unjustified, management blocks continuation, and withdrawal is legally permitted.
Why not A: Incorrect. Preserving the relationship does not justify an otherwise unjustified change.
Why not B: Incorrect. Management's refusal prevents continuation under the original audit terms.
Why not C: Incorrect. Withdrawal follows the inability to continue, not merely the request for lower assurance.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on when a change from an audit to a lower-assurance service is allowed and when the client's reason makes the change unacceptable.
Answer B. A change from an audit to a lower-assurance service is permitted only when there is reasonable justification for the change. A management request that appears intended to avoid audit procedures in a risky area is not a reasonable basis to reduce assurance. The auditor should decline the change and, if the audit cannot continue under appropriate terms, consider withdrawal.
Why not A: Tempting because engagement terms are documented in a letter, but signing a new engagement letter does not justify accepting a lower-assurance service when management's motive is to avoid audit procedures.
Why not C: Management's acknowledgment of responsibility is necessary for any service, but it does not validate a change intended to circumvent audit procedures; responsibility statements do not cure an unjustified reduction in assurance.
Why not D: Overly absolute: a mid-engagement change can be acceptable when justified by changed circumstances. Here the issue is the client's improper motive, not the timing alone.
Question 3
Hint
Ask why management wants the change. A valid reason usually involves a genuine change in circumstances, not a desire to avoid audit evidence problems or reporting consequences.
Answer B. AU-C 210 allows changing an audit to a lower-assurance engagement when there is a reasonable justification, such as a genuine change in users' reporting requirements. If the lender now only requires reviewed statements and management is not attempting to avoid a modified audit opinion, agreeing to the change is appropriate. Requests motivated by scope problems, avoiding a reportable modification, or mere convenience are not valid bases for reducing assurance.
Why not A: This is tempting because it sounds practical to scale back when evidence is missing. However, allowing a change driven by a scope problem would permit management to avoid addressing a deficiency rather than remedying it; that is not an acceptable justification under the standards.
Why not C: Candidates may be drawn to management's desire to soften user reactions, but changing the engagement to avoid a modified opinion is specifically disallowed. The auditor must not permit a lower-assurance engagement to be used to circumvent reporting responsibilities.
Why not D: Speed or convenience alone does not constitute a substantive change in circumstances or users' needs. AU-C 210 requires a legitimate reason (for example, a change in user requirements) to justify reducing the level of assurance, so timing concerns by themselves are not sufficient.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on why the client wants to change the engagement, not just on timing, fees, or paperwork.
Answer C. The auditor's decision should be governed primarily by whether management has a legitimate reason for changing the engagement terms. AU-C 210 allows changes when circumstances change or there was a misunderstanding about the originally agreed service, but a requested downgrade is inappropriate if it is being used to evade the consequences of an audit problem (for example, a likely scope limitation due to missing inventory support). Here, the inability to support inventory quantities suggests the client may be attempting to avoid an audit limitation, so the auditor should not agree to the change absent a reasonable justification.
Why not A: This distractor appeals to practical concerns about fees and progress, but fee recovery or the amount of work completed does not determine whether a change in engagement terms is professionally appropriate under AU-C 210.
Why not B: A review does provide limited assurance, making this seem plausible, but the primary issue is whether the client's request is justified or an attempt to avoid audit consequences, not whether a review would be generally useful.
Why not D: Obtaining a revised engagement letter is procedurally necessary if the change is appropriate, but management's willingness to sign paperwork does not justify agreeing to a downgrade that is intended to sidestep audit problems.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on the reason for the requested change and when that reason arose, not just on whether a review would otherwise satisfy the lender.
Answer A. AU-C 210 requires the auditor to evaluate requests to change an engagement and not to agree to a downgrade when the change is not reasonably justified or appears to be intended to avoid audit consequences. Here, management requested the change after Delta discovered significant inventory-record problems, which suggests the request is aimed at avoiding additional audit procedures. The lender's acceptance or management's business rationale does not override the auditor's obligation to refuse an unjustified reduction in assurance.
Why not B: While governance approval and a revised engagement letter are necessary if a legitimate change is agreed, they do not cure an unjustified change motivated by an audit-evidence problem. The auditor must independently determine whether the requested downgrade is appropriate and should refuse it if it appears intended to avoid audit procedures.
Why not C: This choice is tempting because a review may be permissible and the lender accepts it, but permissibility alone is insufficient after audit work has begun. The auditor must assess whether the change is reasonably justified, and a post-discovery request to reduce assurance suggests avoidance of audit consequences, which the auditor should not accept.
Why not D: An immediate withdrawal is an overreaction. The auditor should first evaluate whether the change is reasonably justified; refusal to accept an unjustified change is appropriate, but withdrawal is only necessary if other conditions (e.g., management-imposed scope limitation or unresolvable issues) make continuation impracticable.
Question 6
Hint
Do not focus first on who approves the change or whether a revised letter can be signed. Ask what substantive condition must exist before an auditor may accept a lower-assurance replacement engagement after an audit has begun.
Answer A. An auditor who has accepted an audit engagement should not agree to substitute a lower-assurance service merely to accommodate management or to avoid additional procedures. The controlling consideration is whether there is a reasonable, substantive justification (for example, a genuine change in circumstances or a misunderstanding about the originally agreed service). If the request is motivated by matters uncovered during the audit or by a desire to avoid further audit work, the auditor ordinarily should not accept the change.
Why not B: This is tempting because an auditor must document any change and obtain client agreement to revised terms. However, procedural willingness and paperwork do not substitute for substantive justification; the auditor must first determine whether the reason for the change is acceptable under the standards.
Why not C: User needs and efficiency of converting existing audit work are practically relevant considerations but are not the governing test. If the change is prompted by audit findings or a desire to avoid procedures, those practicalities do not make the change acceptable.
Why not D: Approval by governance and the fact that a report has not yet been issued are important procedural matters, but they do not override the substantive requirement that the change be reasonably justified. Governance authorization does not validate a change motivated by avoidance of audit findings or procedures.
Common questions
Can an audit be changed to a review after it starts?
Yes, with reasonable justification, such as a genuine change in reporting needs or a documented misunderstanding. Agree to and document revised written terms before proceeding with the review.
Does a bank's acceptance of reviewed statements justify switching?
A newly relaxed requirement or genuine misunderstanding can justify switching. A bank that always accepted reviews does not, by itself, justify a fee-driven downgrade.
What if management refuses to let the original audit continue?
Do not accept an unjustified change to a review. If management prevents the audit from continuing, withdraw when legally permitted and consider professional and legal responsibilities.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Terms of Engagement
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.