AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
Interim Review vs. Audit: Report Language.
An interim review provides limited assurance through a “we are not aware” conclusion, not an audit opinion. Below, compare the report language for Apex Co.'s interim review with the wording an audit would support.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on the level of assurance in an interim review and the kind of conclusion a CPA gives when no material modification is identified.
Answer D. A review provides limited (negative) assurance rather than the positive (reasonable) assurance of an audit. When a review identifies no material modifications, the appropriate conclusion states that the reviewer is not aware of any material modifications that should be made for the interim information to conform with GAAP.
Why not A: This is the wording of an audit opinion (reasonable assurance). A review does not provide an audit opinion and therefore should not use this positive-assurance language.
Why not B: Effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting is not the subject of an interim review conclusion. The review conclusion relates to whether the interim financial information needs material modification to conform with GAAP.
Why not C: Although a review uses limited procedures (inquiries and analytical procedures), the reviewer does provide limited (negative) assurance. The reviewer does express a conclusion that they are not aware of any material modifications, not a blanket statement of no assurance.
Side by side
| Apex: interim review | Apex: audit of the same interim information | |
|---|---|---|
| Engagement assumption | Apex is a nonissuer. Its annual auditor completes the review with no material GAAP departures or scope limitations. | Assume instead that an audit of the same interim information supports an unmodified opinion. |
| Assurance level | Limited assurance. | Reasonable assurance. |
| Type of report statement | Negative-assurance conclusion. | Opinion on fair presentation. |
| Standard conclusion wording | “Based on our review, we are not aware of any material modifications that should be made for the interim financial information to conform with U.S. GAAP.” | “In our opinion, the interim financial information presents fairly, in all material respects, in accordance with U.S. GAAP.” |
| No opinion versus no assurance | No audit opinion, but limited assurance. Saying “no assurance” is incorrect. | An audit opinion providing reasonable assurance. Saying “no assurance” is incorrect. |
Key points
- Remember: A review provides limited assurance, not an audit opinion and not zero assurance.
- Auditing Apex's annual statements does not turn its interim review into an audit.
- Read the entire choice: “no opinion” can be correct even when adding “no assurance” makes the answer wrong.
How the exam traps you
- Choosing “in our opinion” and “presents fairly” for the review conclusion. Choose “we are not aware of any material modifications,” which expresses limited assurance.
- Treating “we do not express an opinion” as equivalent to “we provide no assurance.” A review provides no audit opinion but still provides limited assurance.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on how the scope and assurance level of an interim review differ from a full audit.
Answer C. A review of interim financial information is narrower in scope than an audit and ordinarily consists primarily of inquiries and analytical procedures rather than substantive tests like confirmations or inventory observation. The auditor provides limited assurance (negative assurance), typically stating that nothing came to the auditor's attention that would indicate the interim financial information requires material modification. The assumption of no unusual circumstances supports keeping the engagement to standard review procedures.
Why not A: Tempting because candidates often associate auditor work with audit-style testing; however, confirmations and inventory observation are substantive audit procedures and are not ordinarily part of a routine interim review.
Why not B: Some may think the annual audit must be finished first, but a review engagement is a separate interim service and can be performed during the year before the annual audit is completed.
Why not D: This confuses reviews with services that provide no assurance; a review does provide limited (negative) assurance and requires inquiries and analytical procedures rather than just reading for obvious errors.
Question 3
Hint
Think about the difference between limited assurance and reasonable assurance.
Answer B. A review of interim financial information provides limited assurance rather than reasonable assurance, and the auditor ordinarily obtains that limited assurance primarily through inquiries and analytical procedures. Substantive audit procedures such as confirmations, inventory observations, or extensive tests of controls are not normally performed for a standard interim review unless unusual conditions require additional work. (See the review guidance, e.g., AU-C 930, for the standard distinction between reviews and audits.)
Why not A: This distractor appeals because control testing and reperformance are common audit procedures, but they are audit-type procedures used to obtain reasonable assurance. A standard interim review does not ordinarily rely on tests of controls as the primary basis for the limited-assurance conclusion.
Why not C: Confirmations and inventory observations are high-quality substantive evidence in an audit. However, those procedures are not typical for an interim review, which relies mainly on inquiries and analytical procedures unless specific risks or anomalies justify additional substantive work.
Why not D: This choice describes the scope of an audit that provides reasonable assurance. A review is explicitly more limited in scope and is not designed to provide reasonable assurance through detailed transaction testing.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on two steps: whether the prior-year matter is still relevant in the interim period, and whether adequate disclosure changes the type of reporting response.
Answer A. If a going-concern matter reported in the most recent annual financial statements remains relevant in the interim period, the accountant should address it in the interim review report. When management's interim disclosures about the matter are adequate and no material departure from GAAP is identified, the accountant ordinarily includes a separate section describing the matter rather than modifying the limited-assurance review conclusion.
Why not B: This distractor confuses seriousness of the matter with a GAAP departure. Adequate disclosure of the going-concern uncertainty does not by itself constitute a material misstatement requiring modification of the review conclusion.
Why not C: Tempting because reviews provide limited assurance, but the existence of a previously reported going-concern issue that remains relevant should not be ignored. The accountant should include a separate section describing the continuing uncertainty rather than omit mention of it.
Why not D: Withdrawal is an extreme response. The mere existence of substantial doubt does not require withdrawal if the accountant can perform the review and the interim disclosures are adequate.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on the level of assurance provided in a review versus an audit, and think about the wording that matches that level.
Answer D. A review provides limited (negative) assurance rather than reasonable assurance. When the reviewer identifies no material modifications, the standard review report uses negative-assurance wording (for example, stating the auditor is 'not aware of any material modifications' needed for conformity with the applicable framework).
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates often associate auditor reports with an opinion. It is incorrect because expressing an opinion on fair presentation is the result of an audit (reasonable assurance), not a review (limited assurance).
Why not B: Reasonable assurance is audit-level terminology. A review is limited in scope (inquiry and analytical procedures) and does not provide reasonable assurance that the interim financial information is free of material misstatement.
Why not C: This distractor plays on the narrower scope of a review. However, a review still provides limited (negative) assurance, so a standard clean review report does not simply disclaim all assurance.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on the level of assurance a review provides and how that assurance is phrased in the report.
Answer C. A review provides limited (negative) assurance rather than the positive assurance of an audit. When no material modifications are identified, the standard conclusion is stated in negative-assurance form that the auditor is not aware of any material modifications needed for conformity with the applicable financial reporting framework. That negative-assurance wording is the appropriate clean review conclusion.
Why not A: This wording is the positive opinion used in audits and implies reasonable assurance; a review does not provide that level of assurance, so this option is incorrect.
Why not B: This confuses reviews with compilations or nonassurance engagements. A review provides limited assurance (expressed as negative assurance), so it is not correct to say no assurance is provided.
Why not D: This is too strong, stating the information is 'free of material misstatement' is an affirmative assertion akin to audit-level assurance, which a review cannot support.
Common questions
What conclusion does AU-C 930 use for an interim review?
When no material modifications are identified, the conclusion states: “Based on our review, we are not aware of any material modifications that should be made for the interim financial information to conform with U.S. GAAP.”
Does an interim review report provide no assurance?
No. It provides limited assurance, even though it does not express an audit opinion.
Can the annual auditor use “presents fairly” in an interim review report?
No. The prior annual audit does not change the interim engagement. “In our opinion” and “presents fairly” are audit-opinion wording, not the appropriate review conclusion.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Review of Interim Financial Information, worked step by step.
Interim Financial Information Review | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Review of Interim Financial Information
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.