AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
Interim Review: What to Do After an Unusual Fluctuation
An interim reviewer must follow up when analytics and inquiry suggest a possible material misstatement that management cannot adequately explain. Below, compare possible responses to expanded return rights missing from a revenue summary.
Try one first
Hint
What must a reviewer do when analytical procedures raise a significant question and management's explanation is unsupported or conflicts with other information?
Answer C. Under PCAOB review standards, the reviewer primarily uses inquiry and analytical procedures. When those procedures reveal an unusual fluctuation that conflicts with other information, the reviewer must perform additional review procedures (further inquiries, targeted analytics, or limited testing) to attempt to resolve the inconsistency before completing the review. Here, the vague "more efficient" explanation, contradictory production reports, and an unsupported manual inventory adjustment require further procedures.
Why not A: Tempting because reviews provide limited assurance and rely heavily on inquiry, leading some candidates to think limited procedures are acceptable. Incorrect because limited assurance does not permit accepting unsupported explanations that conflict with other information; unexplained inconsistencies require additional review procedures to resolve them.
Why not B: Tempting because the production data and the unsupported inventory adjustment suggest possible misstatement. Incorrect because suspicion alone does not justify immediately concluding a material misstatement; the appropriate next step is to perform additional procedures to attempt to resolve the discrepancy, and only if it remains unresolved should the reviewer consider modifying the conclusion.
Why not D: Tempting because inventory valuation issues often require audit-level testing, making conversion to an audit seem reasonable to some candidates. Incorrect because conversion to an audit is not automatic; the reviewer should first perform additional review procedures and only consider expanding the engagement if those procedures fail to resolve the issue.
What should you do?
The situation
You audit Ridge Co., a nonissuer, and are reviewing its Q2 interim financial information under AU-C 930. Sales returns rose from 2% to 4% of sales after a new distributor program began. The CFO calls this a temporary launch effect. Sales operations reports expanded return rights missing from accounting's quarter-end revenue summary. The effect could be material. Management is providing records.
Inspect distributor agreements, question accounting, and assess omitted return rights before concluding.
Best The conflicting information suggests a possible material misstatement. Targeted follow-up is required before reaching a review conclusion.
Ask accounting to explain why the expanded return rights are missing from its summary.
Acceptable Targeted inquiry is appropriate, but an unsupported answer would require further procedures before concluding.
Accept the CFO's explanation and complete the review without further procedures.
Wrong Limited assurance does not excuse unresolved conflicting information about a potentially material revenue issue.
Modify the review report immediately because the rise in returns proves material misstatement.
Wrong The anomaly raises concern but does not establish a material misstatement. Follow-up comes before the reporting decision.
Convert the engagement to an audit because returns doubled.
Wrong A possible misstatement requires targeted additional procedures, not automatic conversion to an audit.
Key points
- Remember: A possible material misstatement triggers follow-up; a proven or quantified error is not required.
- Direct follow-up to the expanded return rights omitted from the revenue summary.
- Limited assurance does not mean accepting the CFO's explanation when sales operations provides conflicting information.
How the exam traps you
- Accept the CFO's launch explanation because the engagement provides limited assurance. Investigate the omitted return rights before concluding; a plausible explanation does not resolve conflicting information.
- Modify the report as soon as returns rise sharply. A fluctuation signals possible misstatement; perform follow-up before deciding whether modification is necessary.
- Automatically convert the interim review into an audit. Use targeted additional review procedures; this anomaly does not automatically require audit-level assurance.
Question 2
Hint
Think about the normal procedures in a review and what should happen when management's explanation for an unusual trend is not satisfactory.
Answer D. In a review of interim financial information, the accountant uses inquiries and analytical procedures to obtain limited assurance. When analytical procedures reveal a significant unexpected fluctuation and management's explanation is unsatisfactory, the accountant should perform additional review procedures to obtain a reasonable basis for the conclusion; neither an immediate audit nor withdrawal is automatically required.
Why not A: Withdrawal is an extreme step. The appropriate initial response is to attempt to resolve the matter through additional inquiries and analytical procedures; only if the accountant still cannot obtain a sufficient basis would more serious reporting or engagement actions be considered.
Why not B: Tempting because reviews provide limited assurance, but the accountant still must obtain a reasonable basis for the review conclusion. An unsupported explanation for a significant unexpected fluctuation is not enough to proceed without further procedures.
Why not C: This appeals to candidates who default to an audit response for unresolved issues. However, a significant fluctuation in a review does not automatically require converting the engagement to an audit; the accountant should first perform additional review procedures.
Question 3
Hint
Think about AU-C 930: what finding (from inquiry + analytics) moves the auditor from routine review work to performing additional procedures?
Answer C. Under AU-C 930 a review ordinarily consists of inquiry and analytical procedures. If those procedures indicate the interim financial information may require material modification to conform with the applicable financial reporting framework, the auditor must perform additional procedures to obtain a basis for the conclusion. Here, the analytical anomaly plus operations evidence about expanded return rights provides a reasonable basis to believe a material modification may be needed, triggering additional procedures.
Why not A: This distractor tempts because new contract terms can affect revenue recognition and often merit closer attention. It is wrong because identifying new terms alone does not automatically require audit-level procedures; the trigger is whether inquiry and analytics indicate a possible material modification that necessitates additional work.
Why not B: This option tempts because a management refusal affects reporting decisions. It is incorrect because the auditor should perform additional procedures once inquiry and analytical procedures indicate a possible material modification, not wait until management formally refuses to revise.
Why not D: This answer tempts by focusing on materiality quantification, which is important for reporting. It fails because the requirement to perform further procedures is triggered by indications from inquiry and analytics that a material modification may be needed, which may occur before precise quantification.
Question 4
Hint
In an interim review, ask what the auditor must do when analytical procedures raise a possible material misstatement and management's explanation is not adequately supported.
Answer A. In a review of interim financial information, inquiries and analytical procedures are primary, but when those procedures indicate a possible material misstatement the auditor must perform additional procedures to obtain a basis for the review conclusion. Here, management's explanation is not adequately supported because the sales-system reports are unreconciled and significant inventory adjustments were posted after close, and follow-up inquiries did not resolve the issue. Therefore the auditor should delay concluding until appropriate additional procedures address the reconciliation and inventory adjustments.
Why not B: This is tempting because reviews provide limited assurance and a verbal explanation may seem adequate. It is wrong because a plausible explanation is insufficient when supporting data are unreliable or unreconciled and the analytical procedures suggest a possible material misstatement, additional procedures are required.
Why not C: This distractor is appealing because the auditor lacks sufficient support at the moment. However, a report modification for a scope limitation is appropriate only when the auditor is prevented from obtaining necessary evidence; here management is making records available, so the next step is to perform additional procedures rather than immediately treating the situation as a scope limitation.
Why not D: Withdrawal is an extreme response. An unresolved fluctuation does not automatically require withdrawal; the auditor should first investigate further with additional procedures and then determine whether a conclusion can be reached or whether reporting or engagement actions are necessary.
Question 5
Hint
Consider what review standards require when inquiries and analytics raise concerns that management's explanation does not resolve.
Answer D. Review standards require that when inquiries and analytical procedures suggest the interim information may be materially misstated and management's explanation is inadequate, the accountant perform additional inquiries and other review procedures to obtain a reasonable basis for the review conclusion. Only after completing that follow-up should the accountant consider whether the report must be modified.
Why not A: This distractor tempts because reviews provide limited assurance and management cooperated. It fails, however, because limited assurance does not permit ignoring unresolved unusual fluctuations, when initial procedures raise concerns that management cannot adequately explain, further review procedures are required before issuing the report.
Why not B: This choice appeals to those who think any unresolved issue mandates audit procedures. It is wrong because a review engagement allows for additional review procedures; conversion to an audit is not automatically required and only occurs if the engagement terms change or the accountant cannot obtain sufficient evidence within the review.
Why not C: This is appealing because unexplained anomalies can signal misstatements. It is incorrect because modifying the report before performing additional targeted procedures would be premature, the standards require further investigation to determine whether a material misstatement exists and whether a report modification is warranted.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on what a review requires when analytics raise a potentially material question: limited assurance still requires follow-up on unresolved matters.
Answer D. In a review of interim financial information, inquiries and analytical procedures are the primary procedures, but when those procedures reveal an unexplained or potentially material fluctuation the auditor must perform additional review procedures to obtain a basis for limited assurance. A vague or unsupported management explanation is not sufficient. The auditor should perform tailored follow-up procedures before deciding whether a report modification is necessary.
Why not A: Modifying the review report may be necessary if the matter remains unresolved and is material, but it is premature to modify the report without first attempting to resolve the issue through additional review procedures.
Why not B: This is tempting because inquiries and analytical procedures are central to reviews; however, if those procedures identify a potentially material issue and management's explanation is unsatisfactory, the auditor must perform additional procedures rather than simply accept the explanation.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to those who overreact; an unresolved fluctuation does not automatically require converting the engagement to an audit. The appropriate immediate step is to perform additional review procedures tailored to the issue and only consider changing the engagement if further work shows that reasonable-assurance procedures are needed.
Common questions
What triggers additional procedures under AU-C 930?
The trigger is information suggesting that interim financial information may require material modification to conform with the reporting framework. Ridge's rising returns and omitted return rights meet that trigger without a quantified error.
Can an interim reviewer rely on management's explanation?
Not here. The CFO's launch explanation does not address the expanded return rights missing from accounting's summary.
Do unusual fluctuations require an audit or a modified review report?
Neither is automatic. First investigate Ridge's omitted return rights and assess their effect before deciding whether the review conclusion needs modification.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Review of Interim Financial Information, worked step by step.
Interim Financial Information Review | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Review of Interim Financial Information
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.