AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 12 practice questions
Restricted-Use SSAE Reports: Public vs. Private Criteria
Suitable public criteria permit general use only when no separate restriction applies. Below: one covenant examination with changes to the criteria or engagement terms, showing who the report is intended for.
Try one first
Hint
Ask what specifically causes restricted use under SSAEs: the nature of the users, the sensitivity of the subject matter, or whether the criteria are available beyond a narrow group.
Answer B. A restricted-use attestation report is appropriate when the criteria are available only to specified parties and general users would not have access to or be able to understand the criteria. Here the ratio definitions are set in a private agreement and are neither publicly available nor fully described in the report, so the CPA should include an alert restricting use to specified parties.
Why not A: Tempting because only one outside party requested the engagement, but restricted use hinges on limited availability of the criteria. If the criteria are publicly available, a restricted-use alert is not required solely because the grantor requested the engagement.
Why not C: Commercial sensitivity or a single customer does not by itself require restriction. Because the company criteria are fully described in the report, the criteria are available to users, so a restricted-use alert is not required on that basis alone.
Why not D: Expected readership or an anticipated narrow audience does not trigger a restricted-use alert when the framework (criteria) is publicly available and understandable by general users.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Harbor and its bank engage a CPA to examine Harbor's covenant-compliance assertion. The suitable, general-purpose criteria are public on an industry association's website. The report identifies their source. Evidence supports an unmodified opinion. No law or regulation separately requires restricted use, but the engagement terms require restricting use to Harbor and the bank.
Answer: Issue an unmodified examination opinion with an alert restricting use to Harbor and the bank.
Public criteria do not override the engagement terms. The terms require restricted use, while the evidence supports an unmodified opinion.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1The engagement terms no longer require restricted use.
Answer: Issue an unmodified examination opinion for general use.
The suitable criteria are public and general-purpose. With no restriction from law, regulation, or engagement terms, general use is appropriate.
Change 2The engagement terms restrict use to the bank alone.
Answer: Issue an unmodified examination opinion with an alert restricting use to the bank alone.
The alert identifies the users specified by the restriction. Both parties requesting the examination does not override the bank-only engagement terms.
Change 3The criteria instead are suitable private loan definitions intended only for Harbor and the bank and unavailable to others.
Answer: Issue an unmodified examination opinion with an alert restricting use to Harbor and the bank.
Use stays restricted. The private, specified-party criteria independently require restriction, so removing the engagement-term restriction alone would no longer permit general use.
Key points
- Remember: Public criteria make general use possible, not automatic; Harbor's engagement terms can still require restricted use.
- Identify the specified users from the restriction, not simply from who requested the engagement.
- Suitable private criteria can support an unmodified examination opinion while still requiring restricted use.
How the exam traps you
- Public criteria always mean a general-use report. Check the engagement terms. Harbor's terms still require restricted use.
- Restricted use requires a qualified examination opinion. Restriction identifies intended users. Harbor's evidence still supports an unmodified opinion.
- Name everyone who requested the engagement. Name the specified users required by the restriction, even when both Harbor and the bank requested the examination.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer B. The evidence supports an unmodified opinion, and the terms specify Harbor and the bank as intended users.
Why not A: Public criteria do not override the engagement's explicit use restriction.
Why not C: The terms specify both Harbor and the bank, not the bank alone.
Why not D: Restricted use does not modify the opinion; the evidence supports an unmodified opinion.
Question 2
Answer A. Suitable public criteria support general use when no separate restriction applies.
Why not B: Neither the public criteria nor the revised terms require restricting use to Harbor and the bank.
Why not C: The bank's involvement alone does not require bank-only use.
Why not D: The evidence supports an unmodified opinion; changing use terms does not create a qualification.
Question 3
Answer C. The opinion stays unmodified; the alert identifies the bank as the sole specified user.
Why not A: The revised terms still require restricted use.
Why not B: The revised terms identify only the bank, not Harbor and the bank.
Why not D: A restriction in engagement terms does not create a basis for qualifying the opinion.
Question 4
Answer B. The opinion remains unmodified, with use restricted to Harbor and the bank.
Why not A: The private, specified-party criteria and unchanged engagement terms both require restricted use.
Why not C: The criteria and engagement terms identify both Harbor and the bank.
Why not D: Suitable private criteria require a use restriction, not an opinion qualification.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on whether the criteria are suitable and available to users (and whether law/regulation or the engagement terms require restriction), not on how many parties requested the engagement.
Answer C. An engagement to provide reasonable assurance is an examination. Under AICPA attestation guidance, a general-use examination report is permissible when the criteria are suitable and are available to users; reproducing the criteria in the report is not required if the report identifies where they can be obtained. Given the facts (suitable criteria that are publicly available, independence, and no law/regulation requiring restriction), a general-use examination report is appropriate.
Why not A: Tempting because reproducing criteria seems thorough, but reproducing them in full is not mandatory. If the report clearly identifies and provides access to suitable criteria (for example, via a public website), a general-use report can be appropriate.
Why not B: Tempting because a small user group suggests limited distribution, but the number of requestors alone does not determine report classification. The governing assessment focuses on whether the criteria are suitable and available to users and whether law, regulation, or the terms of the engagement require restriction.
Why not D: Tempting because criteria from a private source may seem less authoritative, but the source alone does not make criteria unsuitable. Industry association criteria can support a general-use examination report if they meet the suitability and availability requirements.
Question 3
Hint
First decide whether AUP reports are automatically restricted under current standards; then decide whether the criteria used to evaluate the procedures will be available to the intended users.
Answer B. Current U.S. attestation standards do not automatically designate all agreed-upon procedures reports as restricted; such reports can be general-use in appropriate circumstances. However, when the procedures' results depend on criteria that are confidential or not made available to intended users, those users cannot properly interpret the findings. Because this engagement depends on confidential lending criteria that will not be provided to prospective participants, restricting distribution is appropriate.
Why not A: Tempting because older guidance treated AUP reports as restricted by default, but modern SSAEs removed an automatic restricted-use designation. The statement is incorrect as an absolute rule, even though restriction can still be appropriate for specific fact patterns.
Why not C: Tempting because AUP reports may be issued for general use and do not express an opinion; however, that permissive approach assumes intended users have access to the criteria needed to interpret the results. General distribution is inappropriate here because the criteria are confidential and unavailable to prospective participants.
Why not D: Tempting because the engaging party's objectives guide the engagement, but the engaging party's assessment does not make confidential criteria available to unrelated third parties. Recipients who lack the criteria cannot reliably interpret the procedures and results, so unrestricted distribution is not justified.
Question 4
Hint
First decide whether AUP reports are automatically restricted under current standards; then assess for each engagement whether the criteria/subject matter are limited to specified parties (private) or are publicly available and suitable for general use.
Answer B. Under current U.S. attestation standards, AUP reports are not automatically restricted; whether a report must be restricted depends on whether the subject matter and criteria are suitable only for specified parties. Engagement 1 relies on a private license agreement available only to the licensor and licensee, so that report should be restricted. The bond indenture has been filed with the SEC and is publicly accessible, and the sustainability framework is public, so those reports are not restricted solely because they are AUP or examination engagements.
Why not A: This is tempting because older guidance led candidates to assume many AUP reports were restricted; it is wrong because modern standards require restriction only when the criteria or subject matter are inherently limited to specified parties. A bond indenture filed with the SEC is publicly accessible and therefore not limited in that way.
Why not C: This choice is attractive insofar as AUP engagements no longer carry an automatic restriction, but it overgeneralizes; restrictions still apply when the criteria or subject matter are only appropriate for specified users, as with the private license agreement in engagement 1.
Why not D: This confuses level of assurance with distribution restrictions. Examination engagements provide assurance, but use restriction depends on the nature and intended users of the criteria; a public reporting framework is generally suitable for general use and does not by itself require restriction.
Question 5
Hint
Break the issue into two separate decisions: what kind of modification fits a material but limited problem, and whether privately developed criteria allow general-use reporting.
Answer B. This is an examination engagement, so the practitioner issues an opinion. The identified departure is material but limited (not pervasive), which supports a qualified opinion rather than an adverse opinion. Because the criteria were developed for use by Rho and its lender (not for general-purpose use), the report should be restricted to the specified parties.
Why not A: Incorrect, a material departure precludes an unmodified opinion. Also, criteria developed for a specific lender relationship are not suitable for general-use reporting, so the report should be restricted.
Why not C: Plausible but too severe, an adverse opinion is appropriate when a departure is both material and pervasive. The stem states the departure is limited to one requirement, which points to a qualified opinion instead.
Why not D: A disclaimer results from an inability to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence or a scope limitation. Here the CPA obtained sufficient appropriate evidence, so a disclaimer is not warranted; the issue affects the opinion content, not the practitioner's ability to form an opinion.
Question 6
Hint
Separate the problem into two decisions: the type of modification for the level of misstatement, and whether the criteria make the report general use or restricted use.
Answer A. A material but not pervasive departure from the applicable criteria in an examination engagement requires a qualified opinion (a modification) when sufficient appropriate evidence has been obtained. This situation is a misstatement relative to the criteria, not a scope limitation, so a qualified opinion, not an adverse opinion, is appropriate. Because the criteria are available only to specified parties and are not reproduced in the report, the report should be restricted to those parties.
Why not B: This distractor correctly recognizes the restricted-use issue but fails on the opinion. When the practitioner concludes there is a material departure from the criteria, an unmodified opinion is inappropriate; the report must be modified.
Why not C: This choice gets the opinion type right but incorrectly asserts the report should be general use. Examination engagements are not automatically general use; if the criteria are available only to specified parties and are not fully presented in the report, the report should be restricted to those parties.
Why not D: An adverse opinion is required only when the departure from the criteria is both material and pervasive. The facts state the departure is material but not pervasive, which calls for a qualified opinion instead of an adverse opinion.
Question 7
Hint
Distinguish the baseline rule (specified-party selection does not automatically restrict an AUP report) from the separate question of whether the criteria themselves are suitable for unspecified third parties and therefore require limiting distribution.
Answer C. Under AICPA attestation guidance (AT-C Section 215), AUP reports are not automatically restricted merely because specified parties selected the procedures. However, when the criteria or subject matter are tailored for, and usable only by, specified parties (for example, a private, transaction-specific earnout formula), the CPA should include a restricted‑use paragraph and advise management to limit distribution. Placing the report in a data room accessible to prospective lenders who were not among the specified parties increases distribution risk, so restricting use is appropriate unless the criteria are revised for broader users.
Why not A: This is tempting because it correctly recalls that specified-party selection by itself does not automatically mandate restriction. It is wrong here because the facts state the criteria are customized and suitable only for the contracting parties; that circumstance independently supports including a restricted‑use paragraph when broader distribution is contemplated.
Why not B: This choice overgeneralizes and reflects an incorrect bright-line rule. Contemporary attestation standards do not require an automatic restriction solely because specified parties selected procedures; the need for restriction depends on whether the criteria and report are usable by outside users.
Why not D: This overstates the consequence. Tailored criteria do not automatically bar issuance of an AUP report; instead, the CPA should limit distribution (for example, by including a restricted‑use paragraph) or advise management to revise the criteria if broader use is intended.
Question 8
Hint
Decide whether the criteria are 'specified requirements' of a contract/regulation (a standards-based trigger) versus publicly available or adequately described criteria.
Answer D. Attestation standards require restricting use when the criteria are the specified requirements of a contract or similar arrangement intended for specified users. Compliance with a private loan covenant is an example of contract-specific criteria and therefore calls for a restricted-use report. Publicly available frameworks or suitably described company-developed criteria do not, by themselves, trigger a restriction, nor does management's request for confidentiality.
Why not A: Tempting because a client's request to limit distribution suggests restriction, but management's request is not a standards-based trigger when the criteria are publicly available and appropriate for general users.
Why not B: Tempting because expecting a single user sounds like limited use, but expected readership alone does not create the standards-based restriction when the criteria are publicly available and suitable.
Why not C: Tempting because company-developed criteria can seem proprietary, but if the criteria are suitable and adequately described so users can understand them, attestation standards do not require a restricted-use report.
Common questions
When must an SSAE report be restricted to specified parties?
Restrict use when the criteria are intended only for specified parties or the engagement terms require restriction. Harbor's base report is restricted by its engagement terms despite having suitable public criteria.
Can an attestation examination report using public criteria be general use?
Yes, when the criteria are suitable for broader users and no separate restriction applies. Removing Harbor's engagement-term restriction permits a general-use examination report.
Do private loan criteria require a modified examination opinion?
No. Suitable private criteria and sufficient appropriate evidence can support an unmodified opinion. Criteria intended only for Harbor and its bank require a restricted-use alert, not an opinion qualification.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reports on Attestation Engagements, worked step by step.
Attestation Engagements & Reports | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reports on Attestation Engagements
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.