PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions

Attestation Report Wording: Examination vs Review vs AUP

Reasonable assurance calls for an opinion, limited assurance for a negative-form conclusion, and no assurance for procedures and findings only. Compare these report types using the same emissions schedule.

The ruleAn examination provides reasonable assurance and an opinion. A review provides limited assurance using negative-form wording; an AUP engagement provides no assurance and reports procedures and findings only.

Try one first

Yale, CPA, is engaged under the SSAEs to review Falcon Co.'s 20X5 schedule of energy-usage data against specified criteria. Falcon's management is responsible for the schedule and is also the engaging party. The criteria are suitable and available to intended users, Yale is independent, and Yale requests a written assertion from management about the schedule's conformity with the criteria. Management refuses to provide the written assertion. Which course of action is most appropriate?
Hint

Ask who refused the written assertion. When the party that engaged the practitioner is also the party responsible for the subject matter, refusal of the assertion leaves only one required response, and remember that direct engagements exist only for examinations.

Side by side

ExaminationReviewAgreed-upon procedures (AUP)
Shared subject matterFalcon's emissions schedule.Falcon's emissions schedule.Falcon's emissions schedule.
Assurance levelReasonable assurance.Limited assurance.No assurance.
Report outputA positive opinion.A negative-form conclusion.Procedures and findings only.
Illustrative wordingIn our opinion, Falcon's emissions schedule is presented in accordance with the stated criteria, in all material respects.Based on our review, we are not aware of any material modifications needed for Falcon's emissions schedule to conform to the stated criteria.We compared the schedule total with supporting records. The totals agreed.
A clean result still meansAn opinion, not absolute assurance.A limited-assurance conclusion, not an opinion.A finding about the tested total, not an overall conclusion.

Key points

  • Remember: Reasonable means opinion; limited means negative-form conclusion; no assurance means procedures and findings.
  • Clean results do not turn a review into an examination.
  • AUP findings cover the listed procedures, not the schedule as a whole.

How the exam traps you

  • Using 'not aware of' wording for an examination. Use a positive opinion for reasonable assurance.
  • Treating a review as a report with no conclusion. A review expresses a limited-assurance conclusion in negative form.
  • Adding an opinion or negative assurance to AUP findings. Report the procedures and findings only.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

A CPA is engaged to perform an examination attestation engagement on management's written assertion that Delta Co. complied with specified grant requirements during Year 2. The CPA completes the engagement, obtains sufficient appropriate evidence, and identifies no material noncompliance. Which conclusion is most appropriate for the CPA's report?
Hint

First identify the type of attestation engagement, then match it to the level of assurance and the report wording.

Question 3

Lane, CPA, was engaged to perform a review attestation engagement on Orion Co.'s Year 2 greenhouse gas emissions schedule. The engagement was accepted as a review of the subject matter itself, not of management's written assertion. Lane is independent, the stated criteria are suitable, and the review disclosed no material modifications that should be made. Which conclusion paragraph is most appropriate for Lane's report?
Hint

First determine whether the report is on the subject matter or on management's assertion. Then match that to the level of assurance provided in a review engagement.

Question 4

A CPA is engaged to report on whether Ridge Co. complied with specified contractual requirements as of December 31, 20X5. The engaging party asks the CPA to provide assurance on Ridge's compliance in the report. Assume the engagement preconditions are met. Which report is most appropriate under the attestation standards?
Hint

Start by asking which attestation engagement types are even permitted for compliance subject matter, then match the level of assurance requested to the type of report each provides.

Question 5

In a direct examination engagement under attestation standards, a CPA is engaged to report on Green Co.'s schedule of carbon-emissions intensity metrics for Year 1. Green Co. measures the metrics using internally developed criteria. The CPA has determined the criteria are suitable, and the criteria are fully described in an appendix that is part of the CPA's report. No law, regulation, or other circumstance otherwise requires restricting the report's use. Which reporting conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

Decide first whether a direct subject-matter examination is permitted; then decide whether the origin of the criteria by itself forces a restriction on the report's use.

Question 6

A CPA is engaged under SSAEs to perform an examination of whether Harbor Co. complied with specified cybersecurity requirements as of December 31, 20X5. Management accepts responsibility for the subject matter and the suitability of the criteria and will provide the practitioner's required written representations at the conclusion of the engagement. Management will not provide a separate written assertion because it prefers the CPA to report directly on the subject matter. Assume the criteria are suitable and available, the practitioner can obtain sufficient appropriate evidence, and there is no scope limitation. Which reporting approach is most appropriate?
Hint

Decide whether SSAE prerequisites for a direct examination are satisfied: management responsibility for the subject matter and criteria, availability of suitable criteria, written representations, and the practitioner's ability to obtain evidence.

Drill all 73 Reports on Attestation Engagements questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

What report wording does an SSAE examination use?

An examination provides reasonable assurance and uses a positive opinion, such as 'In our opinion...' It does not use review-style 'not aware of' wording.

Does an attestation review express a conclusion?

Yes. It provides limited assurance using negative-form wording: 'We are not aware of any material modifications...' Limited assurance is not no assurance.

Does an agreed-upon procedures report provide assurance?

No. It reports the procedures performed and the findings. Even if the totals agree, the CPA does not express an opinion or a limited-assurance conclusion.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reports on Attestation Engagements, worked step by step.

Attestation Engagements & Reports | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Reports on Attestation Engagements

All Reports on Attestation Engagements practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.