AUD · Forming Conclusions & Reporting · 6 practice questions
Attestation Report Wording: Examination vs Review vs AUP
Reasonable assurance calls for an opinion, limited assurance for a negative-form conclusion, and no assurance for procedures and findings only. Compare these report types using the same emissions schedule.
Try one first
Hint
Ask who refused the written assertion. When the party that engaged the practitioner is also the party responsible for the subject matter, refusal of the assertion leaves only one required response, and remember that direct engagements exist only for examinations.
Answer B. Under AT-C 210, the practitioner in a review engagement must request a written assertion from the responsible party stating whether the subject matter is in accordance with the criteria. When the engaging party is also the responsible party, as here, and refuses to provide the written assertion, the practitioner is required to withdraw from the engagement when withdrawal is possible under applicable law or regulation. The assertion is a required element of the engagement, not a formality, because it establishes management's accountability for the measurement of the subject matter against the criteria.
Why not A: This is tempting because Yale performed the work and found nothing requiring modification, but a limited-assurance review report cannot be issued when the responsible engaging party refuses the required written assertion. Merely noting the refusal in the report does not cure the missing precondition; withdrawal is required.
Why not C: This confuses engagement types. Under the SSAEs, direct engagements, in which the practitioner measures the subject matter and reports on it without an assertion requirement, exist only for examinations under AT-C 206. There is no direct review engagement. And while AT-C 210 permits the practitioner in an assertion-based review to word the conclusion directly on the subject matter, that reporting choice still presumes the written assertion was requested and provided.
Why not D: An agreed-upon procedures engagement is a different service with different terms and reporting, and nothing in the standards automatically converts a review into AUP when an assertion is refused. Changing the engagement would require agreement with the client on new terms and a reasonable justification, not a unilateral switch.
Side by side
| Examination | Review | Agreed-upon procedures (AUP) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shared subject matter | Falcon's emissions schedule. | Falcon's emissions schedule. | Falcon's emissions schedule. |
| Assurance level | Reasonable assurance. | Limited assurance. | No assurance. |
| Report output | A positive opinion. | A negative-form conclusion. | Procedures and findings only. |
| Illustrative wording | In our opinion, Falcon's emissions schedule is presented in accordance with the stated criteria, in all material respects. | Based on our review, we are not aware of any material modifications needed for Falcon's emissions schedule to conform to the stated criteria. | We compared the schedule total with supporting records. The totals agreed. |
| A clean result still means | An opinion, not absolute assurance. | A limited-assurance conclusion, not an opinion. | A finding about the tested total, not an overall conclusion. |
Key points
- Remember: Reasonable means opinion; limited means negative-form conclusion; no assurance means procedures and findings.
- Clean results do not turn a review into an examination.
- AUP findings cover the listed procedures, not the schedule as a whole.
How the exam traps you
- Using 'not aware of' wording for an examination. Use a positive opinion for reasonable assurance.
- Treating a review as a report with no conclusion. A review expresses a limited-assurance conclusion in negative form.
- Adding an opinion or negative assurance to AUP findings. Report the procedures and findings only.
Question 2
Hint
First identify the type of attestation engagement, then match it to the level of assurance and the report wording.
Answer C. An examination engagement provides reasonable assurance and results in a positive opinion. When no material noncompliance is identified, the practitioner opines that the entity complied, in all material respects, with the specified requirements. That contrasts with negative assurance wording, which belongs to review reports, and with agreed-upon procedures, which report findings without an opinion. For compliance subject matter the choices are narrower than many candidates expect: AT-C 210 prohibits a review of compliance, so only an examination or agreed-upon procedures engagement is permitted.
Why not A: Tempting because the wording sounds professional, but it is negative assurance language from a review report. An examination supports a positive opinion, and a review of compliance is prohibited in any event.
Why not B: An examination provides reasonable assurance, which is a high but not absolute level of assurance. No attestation engagement provides absolute assurance.
Why not D: This confuses an examination with an agreed-upon procedures engagement. In agreed-upon procedures the practitioner reports findings and does not express an opinion, but the scenario describes an examination, which requires an opinion.
Question 3
Hint
First determine whether the report is on the subject matter or on management's assertion. Then match that to the level of assurance provided in a review engagement.
Answer B. This is a review attestation engagement on the subject matter (the schedule), so the practitioner should express limited assurance using negative wording such as "we are not aware of any material modifications." Because the engagement is on the subject matter itself rather than on management's written assertion, the conclusion should refer to the schedule. Option B matches both the appropriate assurance level and the correct reporting object.
Why not A: Tempting because it uses the correct limited-assurance phrasing, but it is wrong here because the engagement was accepted on the subject matter itself, not on management's assertion; the conclusion should address the schedule directly, not an assertion.
Why not C: This wording conveys reasonable assurance (an examination-level conclusion) rather than the limited assurance appropriate for a review. Even though it references the schedule, it is too strong for a review engagement.
Why not D: This distractor confuses the extent of assurance with expressing no conclusion. A review engagement ordinarily results in a limited-assurance (negative) conclusion; it is not a no-op or a no-op conclusion unless there is a reportability or scope problem.
Question 4
Hint
Start by asking which attestation engagement types are even permitted for compliance subject matter, then match the level of assurance requested to the type of report each provides.
Answer B. For compliance subject matter, the attestation standards permit only two types of engagements, an examination under AT-C 315 or an agreed-upon procedures engagement. AT-C 210 specifically prohibits a practitioner from performing a review of compliance with laws, regulations, contracts, or grants. Because the engaging party wants the CPA to provide assurance, the only permitted engagement that provides assurance is an examination, in which the CPA expresses an opinion on compliance based on reasonable assurance.
Why not A: This is tempting because review reports do provide limited assurance conclusions on other subject matters, but a review of compliance is prohibited under AT-C 210, so this report may not be issued regardless of the engaging party's preferences.
Why not C: Agreed-upon procedures engagements are permitted for compliance subject matter, but they present only procedures performed and findings; they provide no assurance and no opinion or conclusion, so they do not satisfy a request for assurance on compliance.
Why not D: A compilation is a SSARS service for financial statements, provides no assurance, and is not an attestation report on compliance, so it does not fit the engagement at all.
Question 5
Hint
Decide first whether a direct subject-matter examination is permitted; then decide whether the origin of the criteria by itself forces a restriction on the report's use.
Answer B. Under attestation standards, an examination engagement may be a direct examination of subject matter or an examination of management's assertion; a CPA may therefore report directly on the subject matter when suitable criteria exist. Criteria need only be suitable and adequately disclosed, they need not be externally issued. Because the CPA has determined the internally developed criteria are suitable and has fully described them in the report, and no law or regulation requires restriction, the report need not be restricted solely because the criteria are company-developed.
Why not A: This distractor is tempting because students may recall that management often provides assertions and may overgeneralize that attestation requires an assertion. It fails because attestation examinations can be direct subject-matter reports when suitable criteria exist and are available; here the CPA has already judged the internally developed criteria suitable and disclosed them, so a direct examination is permissible.
Why not C: This choice tempts because candidates often associate unrestricted reports with externally developed standards. It fails because the need to restrict a report is driven by law/regulation or by whether criteria and evidence are available to intended users, not simply by the origin of the criteria; here the criteria are suitable and fully disclosed, so origin alone does not mandate restriction.
Why not D: This distractor is tempting because some believe only industry-established criteria can be adequate. It fails because the attestation requirement is suitable criteria, not necessarily industry-issued criteria; since the CPA determined these internally developed criteria are suitable and documented them in the report, replacement or a disclaimer is not required solely for that reason.
Question 6
Hint
Decide whether SSAE prerequisites for a direct examination are satisfied: management responsibility for the subject matter and criteria, availability of suitable criteria, written representations, and the practitioner's ability to obtain evidence.
Answer B. Under SSAEs a practitioner may perform a direct examination and report on the subject matter rather than on a separate written assertion if management accepts responsibility for the subject matter and the suitability of the criteria, the criteria are available, the practitioner obtains sufficient appropriate evidence, and the practitioner receives written representations from management. Those conditions are met here, so the CPA may issue an examination report expressing an opinion directly on Harbor's compliance.
Why not A: This distractor appeals to the mistaken belief that a separate written assertion is always required. In fact, SSAEs permit a direct examination without a separate written assertion when management accepts responsibility and the practitioner obtains the required written representations and evidence.
Why not C: This seems plausible because reviews provide limited (negative) assurance, but it is incorrect to assume reviews are the only option. A direct examination (positive assurance) is permissible when the attestation prerequisites are satisfied; converting to a review would change the level of assurance unnecessarily.
Why not D: This tempts by suggesting the CPA can frame the opinion around an implied assertion, but management asked for direct reporting on the subject matter. Issuing an opinion on a nonexistent written assertion is inconsistent with the direct-examination structure and the stated facts.
Common questions
What report wording does an SSAE examination use?
An examination provides reasonable assurance and uses a positive opinion, such as 'In our opinion...' It does not use review-style 'not aware of' wording.
Does an attestation review express a conclusion?
Yes. It provides limited assurance using negative-form wording: 'We are not aware of any material modifications...' Limited assurance is not no assurance.
Does an agreed-upon procedures report provide assurance?
No. It reports the procedures performed and the findings. Even if the totals agree, the CPA does not express an opinion or a limited-assurance conclusion.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Reports on Attestation Engagements, worked step by step.
Attestation Engagements & Reports | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, every topic in the section. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Reports on Attestation Engagements
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.