AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 6 practice questions
Related Parties, Side Letters, and Late Entries: Audit Response
Conflicting evidence about a related-party sale requires corroboration, not acceptance of management's explanation. Follow the steps below to test a late entry, investigate a side letter, and address management's refusal to permit confirmation.
Try one first
Hint
Decide whether the client actively prevented access to necessary evidence (a scope restriction) versus whether the circumstance merely made the audit more difficult (staffing, timing, or inherent limitations).
Answer C. Management's explicit refusal to allow confirmations and to produce original contracts is a management-imposed scope limitation that directly impedes the auditor's ability to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence about significant related-party receivables and contract terms. The alternative procedures were insufficient, so the limitation most directly impairs professional skepticism and evidence gathering. If the limitation is material and cannot be remedied, the auditor may need to modify the opinion (qualified or disclaimer) or consider withdrawal depending on materiality and pervasiveness.
Why not A: This is tempting because inherent limitations explain why auditors cannot obtain absolute assurance and emphasize the need for professional skepticism. It fails because those limitations are universal to every audit and are not a specific exception or management-imposed barrier that accounts for the inability to obtain additional evidence in this engagement.
Why not B: This distractor tempts because partner continuity affects institutional knowledge, supervision, and judgment, which can impair audit quality. It fails because it is an internal staffing/supervision issue the auditor can mitigate (for example, through added supervision and review) and is not a client-imposed restriction that actively prevents access to evidence.
Why not D: This distractor tempts because compressed timing is client-imposed and can materially constrain the auditor's ability to perform procedures. It fails because, as described, the timetable merely increases audit difficulty; only an active refusal to allow sufficient time or an explicit blocking of procedures converts timing pressure into a scope limitation that prevents evidence gathering.
Step by step
- Identify the conflicting evidence
Raven records a material year-end related-party sale through a late manual entry; its signed contract conflicts with customer emails describing a side letter granting return rights. Management calls the entry routine and refuses permission to confirm the terms.
- Investigate management's refusal
Ask why management refuses confirmation and seek evidence supporting its reason. Evaluate whether the refusal indicates fraud risk or restricts access to necessary evidence.
- Corroborate the disputed terms
Seek direct confirmation of the sale's terms and inspect executed agreements, including the side letter; confirming only the balance leaves the return-rights conflict unresolved. Management's explanations and written representations cannot replace needed corroboration.
- Test the entry and subsequent activity
Trace the manual entry to source documents, inspect its approval and whether it bypassed controls, and test subsequent returns and cash receipts. Cash collection alone does not establish the contract terms or proper revenue timing.
- Reassess risk and escalate
Reassess fraud and management override risks and involve the engagement partner. Communicate significant unresolved concerns or suspected management fraud to those charged with governance.
- Evaluate alternative evidence
If confirmation remains blocked, perform alternative procedures directed at the disputed return rights and revenue timing. Before concluding the audit, evaluate whether those procedures provide sufficient appropriate evidence or leave a material scope limitation.
- Document the evidence and conclusion
Document the contradictions, management's reasons for refusing confirmation, procedures performed, and consultations and communications. Explain whether the evidence resolves the disputed terms and supports the audit conclusion.
Key points
- Remember: A confirmed balance does not resolve a side letter that changes the sale's terms.
- Cash collection supports collection, not every contract term or the timing of revenue.
- Management's written representations cannot replace needed corroborating evidence.
How the exam traps you
- Accept the sale because management calls the entry routine. Resolve the conflicting contract terms and test the entry's underlying support.
- Treat subsequent cash collection as proof that revenue timing is correct. Investigate the side letter and return rights before concluding on revenue timing.
- Treat refused confirmation as an automatic reason to modify the report. Investigate the refusal and perform alternatives before deciding whether sufficient appropriate evidence remains unavailable.
Question 2
Hint
Think about the auditor's immediate obligations when there are indicators of possible management override or fraud, what steps begin the response, and which steps are final?
Answer A. The combination of late-period reclassifications, an anonymous whistleblower allegation, and a related‑party vendor connection are indicators of possible fraud or management override that require increased professional skepticism. Auditing standards require the auditor to perform additional targeted substantive procedures, make inquiries, reassess fraud risk and controls, and, if the evidence suggests, involve forensic specialists. Only after obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence should the auditor consider reporting actions or modifying the opinion.
Why not B: Tempting because the facts point to significant risk; however, modifying the audit opinion is a final action that requires sufficient appropriate evidence and completion of required procedures. The auditor must first perform expanded procedures and evaluate results before concluding fraud or changing the opinion.
Why not C: Tempting because written representations are a familiar and quick response; however, representations do not substitute for independent, corroborative audit evidence when indicators of fraud or override exist. Relying solely on management's statements would be insufficient under the circumstances.
Why not D: Tempting because postponing work may seem efficient, but deferring necessary procedures ignores the requirement to respond promptly to indications of possible fraud and increases the risk of concealment. Standards call for timely, targeted responses rather than blanket delay.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on when GAAS stops the auditor from leaning on prior experience with management and on when apparently regular documents stop being enough.
Answer C. GAAS allows the auditor to consider prior experience with management and ordinarily to accept records and documents as genuine unless there is a reason to doubt them. That principle is limited when contradictory evidence arises that calls the reliability of management's representations or documents into question. Because the customer-system emails directly conflict with the signed contract provided by management, the auditor must elevate skepticism and investigate further rather than rely on past candor.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates sometimes overread professional skepticism as requiring original paper documents rather than reasonable third-party corroboration. However, GAAS does not mandate exhaustive authentication of electronic copies when there is no reason to doubt authenticity, and independent confirmation from the counterparty reduces the need for heightened skepticism.
Why not B: This is tempting because a high-end assumption can suggest management bias. But if the assumption remains within the auditor's independently developed reasonable range and is supported by internal documentation, it calls for careful evaluation rather than the clear trigger for heightened skepticism that contradictory external evidence provides.
Why not D: This is tempting because internally generated evidence is generally less persuasive than external evidence, leading some candidates to assume heightened skepticism is required. However, the fact pattern does not present an inconsistency or reason to suspect falsity; it lacks the direct contradiction of management-supplied documents that most clearly limits reliance on prior candor.
Question 4
Hint
Identify the risks the facts raise (related‑party, management bias, revenue recognition) and pick the response that addresses those risks by seeking independent corroborating evidence rather than relying solely on management statements.
Answer B. The facts raise heightened risk of management override and a possible related‑party transaction; professional skepticism requires independent, corroborative evidence rather than reliance on management's memo or a post‑year‑end cash receipt alone. Confirming the counterparty and terms, inspecting approvals, and tracing cash are appropriate to evaluate whether control transferred at year‑end and whether revenue recognition at December 31 is appropriate. If those procedures do not resolve the concern, further action (e.g., specialist involvement or communication with governance) is warranted.
Why not A: This is tempting because a subsequent cash receipt suggests collectibility, but it is wrong: post‑year‑end collection and an unsigned memo do not prove the transaction was arms‑length or that control transferred on December 31, and related‑party indicators require independent corroboration.
Why not C: A management representation letter is routine and thus tempting, but it cannot substitute for external evidence when there is a heightened risk of misstatement or related‑party transactions; independent corroboration is required.
Why not D: Alerting governance is important if fraud is suspected, which makes this option tempting, but it is premature to withhold the report or conclude fraud before performing additional procedures to obtain corroborating evidence; escalation follows insufficient or adverse evidence, not immediately in lieu of further audit work.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on the auditor's immediate responsibilities when audit evidence suggests an undisclosed related-party relationship and possible concealment, what evidence and communications are required before deciding on the opinion or external reporting?
Answer D. The facts contain indicators of a potentially concealed related-party relationship and questionable timing/recognition, so the auditor must obtain independent corroborative evidence through expanded substantive procedures. Because management (including the CFO) may be implicated, the auditor should consult the engagement partner (and legal counsel if needed) and promptly communicate concerns and relevant findings to those charged with governance. The auditor should document the evaluation and continue gathering evidence before deciding on modifications to the opinion or external reporting.
Why not A: Tempting because management gave an explanation and a promise to correct, but relying solely on management representations is inappropriate when audit evidence suggests possible concealment; independent substantive procedures are required.
Why not B: While expanded testing is necessary, deferring communication to those charged with governance is incorrect when indicators suggest management involvement; the auditor should consult the engagement partner and promptly inform those charged with governance rather than waiting for definitive proof.
Why not C: Nondisclosure is serious, but issuing a modified opinion or notifying authorities is premature before completing evidence gathering and following escalation procedures; such steps are appropriate only after sufficient appropriate evidence and after management has been given opportunity to respond or refuses to correct.
Question 6
Hint
When you see contradictory evidence and a material change in accounting, think: question management, seek independent corroboration, expand targeted procedures, and consult before deciding on the audit conclusion.
Answer B. Professional skepticism requires auditors to seek independent corroboration when evidence is contradictory. The auditor should obtain external confirmations and inspect any side agreements, expand substantive procedures (including testing subsequent returns and cash receipts), and consult with the engagement partner or technical resources before determining whether the financial statements are misstated or whether disclosures or a report modification are required.
Why not A: Tempting because management provided an explanation and initial documents appear to support the sale, but oral explanations are insufficient when there is contradictory evidence (large subsequent returns and staff references to undocumented side letters). Independent corroboration and expanded testing are required.
Why not C: A report modification is premature. The auditor must first perform further procedures to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence and attempt to resolve the issue before concluding that a modification of the opinion is necessary.
Why not D: While communication to those charged with governance may be appropriate, simply treating this as a control deficiency and accepting management's explanation ignores contradictory substantive evidence. The auditor must gather corroborative evidence and complete additional testing before deciding on the appropriate opinion or disclosures.
Common questions
Does a related-party balance confirmation resolve a conflicting side letter?
Not by itself. The auditor must investigate the disputed terms, including return rights, rather than confirm only the amount owed.
Does a late manual journal entry prove management override?
No. In Raven's sale, the late entry and conflicting terms require targeted testing and reassessment of fraud risk, not an immediate fraud conclusion.
Is management's refusal to allow confirmation a scope limitation?
Investigate management's reasons and perform alternative procedures. If sufficient appropriate evidence remains unavailable, evaluate whether a material scope limitation remains before concluding the audit.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement
- Professional Skepticism: Past Honesty vs. Current Evidence
- Auditing Warranty Estimates: Skepticism and Management Bias
All Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.