PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 6 practice questions

Related Parties, Side Letters, and Late Entries: Audit Response

Conflicting evidence about a related-party sale requires corroboration, not acceptance of management's explanation. Follow the steps below to test a late entry, investigate a side letter, and address management's refusal to permit confirmation.

The ruleInvestigate contradictory evidence and obtain sufficient appropriate corroborating evidence before accepting management's explanation. If management restricts access, investigate its reasons and perform alternative procedures before concluding that a scope limitation remains.

Try one first

An accounting firm is auditing Delta Manufacturing's Year 2 financial statements. Significant receivables are from a related-party affiliate and revenue depends on bespoke long-term sales contracts. The audit team requested external confirmations of the related-party receivables and the original sales contracts to verify contract terms and related-party disclosures, but management refused confirmations and declined to provide originals, offering only internal summaries. The team performed alternative procedures (bank deposits, invoice copies, shipping records) but concluded evidence about contract terms and related-party disclosures remained insufficient. There was also a late replacement of the engagement partner and the client requested an accelerated reporting timetable that compressed fieldwork. Which of the following best describes an "exception or limiting condition" that most directly impairs the auditor's ability to exercise professional skepticism and obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence in this engagement, and what is the likely auditor response?
Hint

Decide whether the client actively prevented access to necessary evidence (a scope restriction) versus whether the circumstance merely made the audit more difficult (staffing, timing, or inherent limitations).

Step by step

  1. Identify the conflicting evidence

    Raven records a material year-end related-party sale through a late manual entry; its signed contract conflicts with customer emails describing a side letter granting return rights. Management calls the entry routine and refuses permission to confirm the terms.

  2. Investigate management's refusal

    Ask why management refuses confirmation and seek evidence supporting its reason. Evaluate whether the refusal indicates fraud risk or restricts access to necessary evidence.

  3. Corroborate the disputed terms

    Seek direct confirmation of the sale's terms and inspect executed agreements, including the side letter; confirming only the balance leaves the return-rights conflict unresolved. Management's explanations and written representations cannot replace needed corroboration.

  4. Test the entry and subsequent activity

    Trace the manual entry to source documents, inspect its approval and whether it bypassed controls, and test subsequent returns and cash receipts. Cash collection alone does not establish the contract terms or proper revenue timing.

  5. Reassess risk and escalate

    Reassess fraud and management override risks and involve the engagement partner. Communicate significant unresolved concerns or suspected management fraud to those charged with governance.

  6. Evaluate alternative evidence

    If confirmation remains blocked, perform alternative procedures directed at the disputed return rights and revenue timing. Before concluding the audit, evaluate whether those procedures provide sufficient appropriate evidence or leave a material scope limitation.

  7. Document the evidence and conclusion

    Document the contradictions, management's reasons for refusing confirmation, procedures performed, and consultations and communications. Explain whether the evidence resolves the disputed terms and supports the audit conclusion.

Key points

  • Remember: A confirmed balance does not resolve a side letter that changes the sale's terms.
  • Cash collection supports collection, not every contract term or the timing of revenue.
  • Management's written representations cannot replace needed corroborating evidence.

How the exam traps you

  • Accept the sale because management calls the entry routine. Resolve the conflicting contract terms and test the entry's underlying support.
  • Treat subsequent cash collection as proof that revenue timing is correct. Investigate the side letter and return rights before concluding on revenue timing.
  • Treat refused confirmation as an automatic reason to modify the report. Investigate the refusal and perform alternatives before deciding whether sufficient appropriate evidence remains unavailable.

5 more, each from a different angle

0 of 5 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

During the interim audit of Year 2 for a privately held manufacturing company, the engagement team identifies several large, late-period journal entries recorded by the controller that reclassify expense amounts to 'other adjustments.' Management says the entries correct routine estimate differences. The auditor also receives an anonymous whistleblower message alleging the CFO used company funds for personal travel, and a public-records check shows the CFO has an ownership interest in a vendor that received several large, late-period payments. The team has not yet performed substantive testing on the late-period entries or the vendor payments. Given professional skepticism and professional judgment, what should the auditor do next?
Hint

Think about the auditor's immediate obligations when there are indicators of possible management override or fraud, what steps begin the response, and which steps are final?

Question 3

On a recurring audit, the engagement senior notes that management has been candid in prior years and argues that the team need not treat every management-supplied document as suspect or expand work on every unusual item. Under GAAS, which additional fact pattern most clearly creates a limiting condition on that reasoning and requires heightened professional skepticism? Assume no scope limitation and that the facts below are the only additional facts.
Hint

Focus on when GAAS stops the auditor from leaning on prior experience with management and on when apparently regular documents stop being enough.

Question 4

During the year-end audit of PrimaTech, the auditor identifies a December 31 sale recorded for $2.5 million (about 8% of current-year revenue). The buyer, NorthBridge LLC, was formed three weeks before year-end; public records list the CEO's home as NorthBridge's registered address. The file includes a bill of lading dated December 31 and an invoice; cash of $2.5 million was deposited to PrimaTech's bank on January 20. Management provided a one-page memo stating the sale was arms-length and supplied an unsigned purchase order but no signed contract or board approval. The auditor is concerned about a possible related-party sale and improper revenue recognition. Given professional skepticism and professional judgment, what is the most appropriate next step?
Hint

Identify the risks the facts raise (related‑party, management bias, revenue recognition) and pick the response that addresses those risks by seeking independent corroborating evidence rather than relying solely on management statements.

Question 5

During the Year 2 audit of BNC Inc., the auditor identified payments totaling $1.2 million to Alpha Services (about 12% of operating expenses). Alpha Services is owned by the CFO's brother, but the company did not disclose the relationship or the transactions as related-party in the financial statements. There is no written contract, several invoices are dated after year-end but were recorded in Year 2, and supporting documentation is limited. Management explains that Alpha is a legitimate subcontractor and that omission of the related-party disclosure was an oversight; the CFO says the disclosure will be included in next year's filing. The auditor's initial risk assessment did not identify related-party transactions as a significant risk. What is the most appropriate action for the auditor at this stage?
Hint

Focus on the auditor's immediate responsibilities when audit evidence suggests an undisclosed related-party relationship and possible concealment, what evidence and communications are required before deciding on the opinion or external reporting?

Question 6

During the Year 1 audit of public company Halia Corporation, the audit team noted that management changed its revenue recognition policy for product-sales contracts in Year 1; management's change increased reported revenue by 8% and was material to the financial statements. While testing December year-end sales, the team identified a $2.7 million shipment to Reseller X recorded as revenue. The sales file included an invoice and shipping document but did not include any written side letters. Management orally explained the sale was part of a promotional program and that return rights are limited. Subsequent evidence showed Reseller X processed a large return credit memo in January and several sales staff referenced an undocumented side letter that altered pricing and return terms. Management maintains the recognition was appropriate and that any side arrangements are immaterial. As the engagement senior exercising professional skepticism and professional judgment, what is the most appropriate next step?
Hint

When you see contradictory evidence and a material change in accounting, think: question management, seek independent corroboration, expand targeted procedures, and consult before deciding on the audit conclusion.

Drill all 89 Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Does a related-party balance confirmation resolve a conflicting side letter?

Not by itself. The auditor must investigate the disputed terms, including return rights, rather than confirm only the amount owed.

Does a late manual journal entry prove management override?

No. In Raven's sale, the late entry and conflicting terms require targeted testing and reassessment of fraud risk, not an immediate fraud conclusion.

Is management's refusal to allow confirmation a scope limitation?

Investigate management's reasons and perform alternative procedures. If sufficient appropriate evidence remains unavailable, evaluate whether a material scope limitation remains before concluding the audit.

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement

All Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.