PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 13 practice questions

Professional Skepticism: Past Honesty vs. Current Evidence

Prior honesty and effective controls never replace sufficient appropriate audit evidence or override current contradictions. Below, compare the same year-end sale as the evidence or prior experience changes.

The rulePrior favorable experience and effective controls may inform risk assessment, but they do not replace sufficient appropriate audit evidence. Resolve contradictory evidence before concluding, without automatically assuming fraud.

Try one first

In the Year 2 audit of a nonissuer under AICPA auditing standards, the audit team is evaluating a $3.1 million year-end revenue entry from a one-off bill-and-hold transaction recorded on 12/31/X2. The controller and CFO have been consistently accurate and cooperative in prior audits, and routine sales controls tested effectively this year. However, this transaction was negotiated in the final week of the year, processed outside normal shipping controls, and supported primarily by the signed contract and management's explanation. Assume no other contradictory evidence is currently known. Which conclusion best reflects the limiting condition on using prior favorable experience with management when applying professional skepticism?
Hint

Ask yourself what prior experience with management is allowed to affect, and what it is not allowed to replace.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

In an AICPA audit, Lark Co. records a routine $100,000 sale on December 31, Year 2, under FOB shipping point terms. Prior audits found management candid, and sales controls tested effective. Management says shipment occurred December 31. A direct carrier confirmation agrees and is the only corroborating shipment evidence. Other revenue requirements are supported. No evidence conflicts.

Answer: Accept this item's December 31 cutoff based on corroborating shipment evidence.

The confirmation supports shipment before year-end under the contract's terms. Past honesty and tested controls do not substitute for that evidence.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1The direct carrier confirmation reports January 2, Year 3 shipment instead of December 31.

Answer: Obtain additional evidence to resolve the date conflict, reassess cutoff risk, and evaluate whether revenue needs adjustment.

January shipment contradicts December revenue under the stated terms. Effective controls and past candor cannot resolve that conflict.

Change 2The direct carrier confirmation is unavailable.

Answer: Obtain alternative corroborating shipment evidence before concluding on cutoff.

Management's statement is now unsupported. Obtain carrier tracking records or other corroboration; past candor and effective controls do not fill the gap.

Change 3The team has no prior experience with management.

Answer: Accept this item's December 31 cutoff based on corroborating shipment evidence.

The lack of prior experience does not change this conclusion. Persuasive current evidence supports cutoff; familiarity is not required.

Key points

  • Remember: Current evidence supports the conclusion; past honesty only informs the approach.
  • Match the carrier's shipment date to the contract's transfer terms, not just the recorded revenue date.
  • A missing confirmation calls for alternative evidence; a conflicting confirmation calls for resolving the inconsistency.

How the exam traps you

  • Past honesty makes corroboration optional. Obtain shipment evidence even when management has always been candid.
  • Effective controls settle the conflicting shipment date. Investigate the carrier's January 2 date and reconsider the cutoff risk assessment.
  • A contradiction proves fraud and requires immediate reversal. Resolve the date conflict, then evaluate the revenue adjustment and any fraud implications.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

In an AICPA audit, Lark Co. records a routine $100,000 sale on December 31, Year 2, under FOB shipping point terms. Prior audits found management candid, and sales controls tested effective. Management says shipment occurred December 31. A direct carrier confirmation agrees and is the only corroborating shipment evidence. Other revenue requirements are supported. No evidence conflicts. What is the best cutoff conclusion?

Question 2

Same facts, except the direct carrier confirmation reports shipment on January 2, Year 3. What should the auditor do next?

Question 3

Same facts, except the direct carrier confirmation is unavailable. What should the auditor do before concluding on cutoff?

Question 4

Same facts, except the team has no prior experience with management. What is the best cutoff conclusion?

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

While observing the year-end inventory count, an auditor notes that several high-value items on the count sheets do not agree to the perpetual inventory records. The warehouse manager says the records are often updated after the count and asks the auditor not to expand testing because no similar problem occurred last year. Assume the differences are large enough that, if unresolved, they could affect the financial statements. What is the auditor's best action?
Hint

Focus on how an auditor should respond when observed evidence conflicts with management's explanation.

Question 3

During the Year 2 audit of Belden Co., an auditor's analytical procedures reveal a 25% increase in sales returns and a larger concentration of receivables in two customers compared with Year 1. Management explains orally and provides an internal memo that the company introduced a more lenient return policy during Year 2. There are no independent documents immediately provided to corroborate this. Which action best demonstrates appropriate professional skepticism and professional judgment?
Hint

Consider what professional skepticism requires when management's explanation is plausible but not independently supported and analytical procedures reveal unusual trends.

Question 4

In an audit of a manufacturer's allowance for excess and obsolete inventory, the team identified several high-dollar SKUs on the initial inventory aging report with no sales activity for over 18 months. Management attributed this to a recent system conversion that created duplicate item codes and provided a revised aging report in which most of those SKUs were merged into active items or reclassified as demonstration units excluded from the allowance. The senior noted management had been candid in prior audits, no specific fraud risk had been identified in this area, the final allowance fell within the auditor's expected range, and gross-margin analytics did not suggest broad overstatement. However, the team did not test the accuracy or completeness of the revised aging report and obtained no support for the demonstration-unit reclassifications beyond management inquiry. Assume all other procedures were properly performed. Which conclusion is best?
Hint

Consider what additional procedures are appropriate when management's revised information both reconciles exceptions and reduces an estimate, does overall reasonableness alone suffice?

Question 5

During planning for the audit of Apex Co.'s Year 2 financial statements, the auditor notes that gross margin increased sharply from the prior year even though sales volume and industry conditions were relatively stable. Apex's CFO says the increase was caused by "better production efficiency," but does not provide supporting analysis. Which action best reflects appropriate professional skepticism and professional judgment by the auditor?
Hint

Focus on what professional skepticism requires when management gives an unsupported explanation for an unexpected trend.

Question 6

During the Year 2 audit of ClientCo, the engagement team discovers a $2.1 million, unusual accounts receivable write-off recorded just before year-end. Management explains the write-off as the result of a new credit policy and the bankruptcy of a single large customer, and provides an internal aging schedule and a written representation. The auditor sent external confirmations; most confirmations agree with ClientCo's records, but one major customer returned a confirmation showing a materially lower balance than ClientCo's records. The audit team must decide whether to accept management's explanation or perform additional procedures. According to professional skepticism and professional judgment, which factor should govern the auditor's decision about whether additional audit procedures are necessary?
Hint

Ask yourself: what actually allows an auditor to accept management's explanation when independent evidence disagrees?

Question 7

During the Year 1 audit of Orion Co., the auditor notes that about 12% of annual revenue was recorded on December 31 with a sharp spike in sales on December 30-31. Orion's sales contracts specify FOB shipping point. For a sample of the Dec 31 transactions, the client provided invoices dated Dec 31 and internal packing lists signed by the company's shipping clerk dated Dec 31. However, bills of lading from the third‑party common carriers for many of those same shipments are dated Jan 2 (Year 2). Management explains that the goods were shipped Dec 31 and provides a written representation to that effect; management also had a sales incentive program that became effective Dec 29. Applying professional skepticism and professional judgment, what is the most appropriate next audit response?
Hint

Focus on the contradictory client-controlled documents versus third‑party carrier documents and remember what kinds of evidence are independent and persuasive when management explanations may be biased.

Question 8

In a GAAS audit of a nonissuer, the auditor is evaluating management's Year 2 warranty liability. The controller, who has been accurate in prior years, explains that a sharp increase in claims filed shortly after year-end relates only to one defective production batch that had been fully remediated before year-end. The auditor also notes that: (1) service logs show claims continuing on products manufactured after year-end, (2) a spreadsheet prepared by management for the auditor excludes claims under $500, and (3) overall substantive analytics remain within the auditor's expected range. Assume the matter is material and no scope limitation exists other than the facts stated. Under professional skepticism and professional judgment, what is the auditor required response?
Hint

Focus on what professional skepticism requires when evidence points in different directions and some of the key data comes from management.

Question 9

During the audit of a long-time client, the team finds a signed side letter for a year-end sale that appears to grant the customer a broad return right inconsistent with the standard sales contract. The controller says the side letter was superseded before year-end, but no superseding document has yet been obtained. The engagement senior argues that no further work is needed because management has been reliable in prior audits, revenue was not identified as a significant risk this year, and reversal of the sale would be below performance materiality but above clearly trivial. Under GAAS, which statement best describes the limiting condition on the senior's use of professional judgment here?
Hint

Focus on what professional skepticism requires once audit evidence conflicts with management's explanation, and ask what professional judgment cannot be used to bypass.

Drill all 89 Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can an auditor rely on management's past honesty?

Past experience may inform risk assessment, but it cannot replace audit evidence. Lark's cutoff conclusion depends on shipment evidence, not management's reputation.

Do effective controls override contradictory audit evidence?

No. Even with effective sales controls, a carrier confirmation showing January 2 shipment requires follow-up before accepting December 31 cutoff.

Is management's statement enough when shipment evidence is missing?

No. If Lark's direct carrier confirmation is unavailable, the auditor needs alternative corroboration, such as carrier tracking records or a customer confirmation addressing shipment timing.

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement

All Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.