AUD · Ethics and Professional Responsibilities and General Principles · 13 practice questions
Professional Skepticism: Past Honesty vs. Current Evidence
Prior honesty and effective controls never replace sufficient appropriate audit evidence or override current contradictions. Below, compare the same year-end sale as the evidence or prior experience changes.
Try one first
Hint
Ask yourself what prior experience with management is allowed to affect, and what it is not allowed to replace.
Answer B. AU-C guidance permits considering prior favorable experience with management when planning and performing the audit, but it does not replace a questioning mind or the need for persuasive evidence. A significant, unusual, year-end bill-and-hold transaction processed outside normal controls warrants more persuasive, corroborative evidence than management explanations and internally produced documents alone. Prior trust can influence planning and procedures, but cannot substitute for appropriate evidential work.
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may overinterpret that skepticism does not require assuming dishonesty. It is wrong because standards do not allow accepting significant unusual items at face value solely because no contradictory evidence is yet known, extra corroboration is required when transactions occur outside normal controls.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to those who conflate skepticism with distrust. It is incorrect because professional skepticism is a questioning mindset, not a presumption of dishonesty; the auditor should evaluate and corroborate management's explanations as necessary rather than automatically reject them.
Why not D: This is tempting because effective controls and reliable management can reduce risk in routine areas. It is wrong here because inquiry and written representations are complementary, not usually sufficient, evidence for a significant unusual transaction that was processed outside normal controls, more persuasive corroboration is required.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
In an AICPA audit, Lark Co. records a routine $100,000 sale on December 31, Year 2, under FOB shipping point terms. Prior audits found management candid, and sales controls tested effective. Management says shipment occurred December 31. A direct carrier confirmation agrees and is the only corroborating shipment evidence. Other revenue requirements are supported. No evidence conflicts.
Answer: Accept this item's December 31 cutoff based on corroborating shipment evidence.
The confirmation supports shipment before year-end under the contract's terms. Past honesty and tested controls do not substitute for that evidence.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1The direct carrier confirmation reports January 2, Year 3 shipment instead of December 31.
Answer: Obtain additional evidence to resolve the date conflict, reassess cutoff risk, and evaluate whether revenue needs adjustment.
January shipment contradicts December revenue under the stated terms. Effective controls and past candor cannot resolve that conflict.
Change 2The direct carrier confirmation is unavailable.
Answer: Obtain alternative corroborating shipment evidence before concluding on cutoff.
Management's statement is now unsupported. Obtain carrier tracking records or other corroboration; past candor and effective controls do not fill the gap.
Change 3The team has no prior experience with management.
Answer: Accept this item's December 31 cutoff based on corroborating shipment evidence.
The lack of prior experience does not change this conclusion. Persuasive current evidence supports cutoff; familiarity is not required.
Key points
- Remember: Current evidence supports the conclusion; past honesty only informs the approach.
- Match the carrier's shipment date to the contract's transfer terms, not just the recorded revenue date.
- A missing confirmation calls for alternative evidence; a conflicting confirmation calls for resolving the inconsistency.
How the exam traps you
- Past honesty makes corroboration optional. Obtain shipment evidence even when management has always been candid.
- Effective controls settle the conflicting shipment date. Investigate the carrier's January 2 date and reconsider the cutoff risk assessment.
- A contradiction proves fraud and requires immediate reversal. Resolve the date conflict, then evaluate the revenue adjustment and any fraud implications.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer B. The direct confirmation supports December shipment under the contract's terms, and no evidence conflicts.
Why not A: Past candor provides context but cannot substitute for evidence supporting shipment timing.
Why not C: Effective controls do not eliminate the need for sufficient appropriate evidence.
Why not D: Professional skepticism requires critical assessment, not a presumption that year-end sales are fraudulent.
Question 2
Answer C. The conflicting date requires targeted follow-up, risk reassessment, and evaluation of any needed adjustment.
Why not A: Prior candor cannot override evidence contradicting management's shipment date.
Why not B: Effective controls do not resolve this specific cutoff exception.
Why not D: The contradiction requires investigation; it does not prove fraud.
Question 3
Answer D. Alternative evidence, such as direct carrier tracking records, can support shipment timing.
Why not A: Management's past honesty does not make its unsupported statement sufficient.
Why not B: Control results alone do not fill the missing shipment-evidence gap.
Why not C: Missing corroboration does not establish that the sale is fictitious.
Question 4
Answer A. The direct carrier confirmation still supports December shipment, with other requirements supported and no conflicting evidence.
Why not B: A prior relationship is not required when sufficient appropriate current evidence supports the conclusion.
Why not C: Unfamiliarity alone does not make otherwise sufficient evidence inadequate.
Why not D: Professional skepticism does not require presuming dishonesty when management is unfamiliar.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on how an auditor should respond when observed evidence conflicts with management's explanation.
Answer B. Professional skepticism requires the auditor to investigate conflicting audit evidence rather than accept management's explanation at face value. When observed count results do not agree to records and the differences could matter, the auditor should perform additional procedures and evaluate the reliability of the evidence obtained. Prior-year results do not eliminate the need to resolve current-year inconsistencies.
Why not A: Tempting because of reliance on management and prior clean audits, but current conflicting evidence requires investigation; past absence of problems doesn't excuse unresolved discrepancies now.
Why not C: Written representations do not substitute for obtaining appropriate audit evidence. When evidence conflicts, the auditor must perform substantive procedures to resolve the issue rather than rely solely on management's statement.
Why not D: This incorrectly applies a per-item materiality shortcut. The auditor should consider the nature of the differences and their possible aggregate effect; items individually below overall materiality can still be significant when unresolved.
Question 3
Hint
Consider what professional skepticism requires when management's explanation is plausible but not independently supported and analytical procedures reveal unusual trends.
Answer D. The auditor should not accept management's oral explanation alone when analytical procedures show unusual trends. Appropriate professional skepticism requires obtaining corroborating evidence (testing return documentation and cutoff) and expanding substantive procedures where risk is indicated; consultation may be appropriate before reaching a conclusion.
Why not A: Tempting because management provided a plausible reason, but wrong: reducing testing without independent corroboration risks missing a misstatement when analytical procedures indicate unusual changes.
Why not B: Tempting because prior-year work informs planning, but wrong: current-year changes and unusual trends require current-year evidence and possibly expanded procedures; prior documentation alone does not address new risks.
Why not C: Tempting because risk has increased, but wrong: withdrawal is premature. The auditor should first attempt to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence and consult as needed; withdraw only if evidence cannot be obtained or management is uncooperative.
Question 4
Hint
Consider what additional procedures are appropriate when management's revised information both reconciles exceptions and reduces an estimate, does overall reasonableness alone suffice?
Answer C. When management provides revised information that resolves exceptions and favorably changes an estimate, the auditor must obtain sufficient appropriate evidence to support those revisions. Prior positive experience or broad analytics do not eliminate the need to corroborate material reclassifications and the accuracy and completeness of a revised schedule. The team should have tested the revised aging report and obtained support for the demonstration‑unit reclassifications before concluding.
Why not A: This appeals by correctly noting skepticism is not blind distrust, but it is wrong because auditors must still evaluate the reliability of management-generated information and obtain corroborative evidence when revisions change an estimate or eliminate exceptions.
Why not B: Tempting because overall reasonableness and explanations can be persuasive, but wrong because untested management-provided revisions that remove exceptions affecting an estimate require corroboration; the team did not obtain such evidence.
Why not D: Attractive to candidates who overreact to management-provided data, but wrong because standards do not automatically require a complete independent rebuild; they require sufficient appropriate evidence (which can include targeted testing) to support the revised report and reclassifications rather than always reconstructing the entire schedule.
Question 5
Hint
Focus on what professional skepticism requires when management gives an unsupported explanation for an unexpected trend.
Answer A. Professional skepticism requires a questioning mind and a critical assessment of audit evidence, including management explanations. A significant unexpected fluctuation should not be accepted without corroboration. The auditor should investigate further and then determine whether the risk assessment or planned procedures need to be revised.
Why not B: This is tempting because management often understands the business well. However, professional skepticism means management explanations alone are insufficient for an unexpected fluctuation; the auditor should seek corroborating evidence rather than simply accept the statement.
Why not C: Unusual results can indicate fraud risk, and skepticism requires alertness to misstatement. But assuming intentional misstatement without evidence is inappropriate; the auditor should investigate and gather evidence before drawing such a severe conclusion.
Why not D: Preliminary analytical procedures are meant to identify areas of potential risk and should influence planning when they reveal unexpected relationships. Delaying follow-up would weaken the audit's risk assessment and planned response.
Question 6
Hint
Ask yourself: what actually allows an auditor to accept management's explanation when independent evidence disagrees?
Answer C. Professional skepticism and judgment require that conclusions be based on sufficient appropriate (persuasive) audit evidence. When independent evidence conflicts with management's records, for example, an external confirmation materially lower than the client's balance, the auditor must evaluate persuasiveness and perform additional procedures until sufficient appropriate evidence is obtained. Management integrity, materiality, and initial risk assessments help plan the response but do not replace the need for persuasive evidence.
Why not A: Why tempting: judgments about management's honesty and competence influence the auditor's level of skepticism and the nature and extent of procedures. Why wrong: such assessments inform planning and responsiveness but cannot substitute for obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence when evidence is contradictory.
Why not B: Why tempting: materiality determines significance and often guides whether additional work is warranted. Why wrong: materiality affects the extent of procedures but the controlling issue here is evidence persuasiveness; contradictory evidence may require further work even if the amount is close to or below materiality.
Why not D: Why tempting: initial risk assessments direct audit focus and might suggest the likelihood of misstatement. Why wrong: initial risk assessments are planning inputs; the auditor must base the decision to perform more procedures on the actual evidence obtained and whether it is persuasive.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on the contradictory client-controlled documents versus third‑party carrier documents and remember what kinds of evidence are independent and persuasive when management explanations may be biased.
Answer C. There is contradictory evidence: client-controlled invoices and packing lists dated Dec 31 versus third-party bills of lading dated Jan 2. Because management had a sales incentive effective Dec 29, there is a reasonable concern about possible bias and the auditor should not rely solely on client-controlled documents or a written representation. The auditor should obtain independent external corroboration (inspect original bills of lading, obtain carrier confirmations, and examine customer receiving reports and subsequent cash receipts) to resolve the cutoff and determine whether the sales occurred before year-end.
Why not A: Tempting because internal invoices and a written representation appear to support management, but those are client-controlled and may be biased. They conflict with third‑party carrier documents dated after year‑end, and management representations do not replace independent external evidence when such evidence can be obtained.
Why not B: Tempting because analytics can highlight unusual patterns and may appear to support management, but analytical procedures cannot resolve a direct documentary contradiction between client records and third‑party shipping documents. When independent external evidence (carrier bills of lading, confirmations, customer receiving reports) can clarify shipment dates, those sources should be obtained.
Why not D: Tempting because there is uncertainty about cutoff, but issuing a modified opinion for a scope limitation should follow after the auditor has pursued all reasonable procedures. Here, independent third‑party documentation and confirmations should be sought before concluding that evidence cannot be obtained.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on what professional skepticism requires when evidence points in different directions and some of the key data comes from management.
Answer A. Professional skepticism requires the auditor to follow up on contradictory evidence rather than accept management explanations or representations at face value. The post‑year‑end claims and the exclusion of small claims from management's spreadsheet create inconsistencies that must be investigated (for example, by testing completeness of claims, verifying the spreadsheet, and determining whether claims relate to post‑year production). Only after obtaining and evaluating that additional evidence can the auditor conclude whether an adjustment, disclosure, or other response is appropriate.
Why not B: Tempting because post-year-end activity can be persuasive, but incorrect because the auditor must investigate whether the claims relate to the period under audit or to later production and must perform procedures to establish scope and cause before mandating an immediate adjustment.
Why not C: Tempting because auditors often rely on prior good experience and supportive analytics, but incorrect because contradictory evidence and management-prepared exclusions require corroboration; absence of suspected fraud does not eliminate the need for further procedures.
Why not D: Tempting because representation letters are common audit evidence, but incorrect because written representations do not substitute for independent or corroborative evidence when management's information appears incomplete or inconsistent.
Question 9
Hint
Focus on what professional skepticism requires once audit evidence conflicts with management's explanation, and ask what professional judgment cannot be used to bypass.
Answer A. GAAS requires the auditor to maintain professional skepticism and to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence when audit evidence is contradictory. A plausible management explanation alone does not resolve an inconsistency; prior good experience with management or an initial low-risk assessment does not eliminate the need to corroborate the explanation.
Why not B: Tempting since GAAS does not demand assuming dishonesty, but prior experience does not remove the auditor's duty to remain skeptical and investigate when evidence conflicts with management's assertions.
Why not C: Tempting because candidates often over-weight materiality and preliminary risk judgments, but an unresolved contradiction in audit evidence requires follow-up; the issue is the inconsistency, not just the estimated size of a potential misstatement.
Why not D: Tempting to those who overreact to contradictory evidence, but the side letter is not itself proof of fraud; GAAS calls for investigation and evidence gathering, not an automatic presumption of fraud or immediate blanket expansion of testing on these facts alone.
Common questions
Can an auditor rely on management's past honesty?
Past experience may inform risk assessment, but it cannot replace audit evidence. Lark's cutoff conclusion depends on shipment evidence, not management's reputation.
Do effective controls override contradictory audit evidence?
No. Even with effective sales controls, a carrier confirmation showing January 2 shipment requires follow-up before accepting December 31 cutoff.
Is management's statement enough when shipment evidence is missing?
No. If Lark's direct carrier confirmation is unavailable, the auditor needs alternative corroboration, such as carrier tracking records or a customer confirmation addressing shipment timing.
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement
- Related Parties, Side Letters, and Late Entries: Audit Response
- Auditing Warranty Estimates: Skepticism and Management Bias
All Professional Skepticism and Professional Judgement practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.