AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 9 practice questions
AU-C 610: Objectivity, Competence, and Systematic Approach
All three prerequisites must be met before using internal audit work: objectivity, competence, and a systematic, disciplined approach. Below, follow a planning decision and see how a reporting-line change triggers reassessment.
Try one first
Hint
Think about the prerequisites the external auditor must evaluate before efficiency or risk-based planning considerations matter.
Answer D. Under AICPA standards (AU-C 610), the external auditor must evaluate the internal audit function's objectivity, competence, and use of a systematic and disciplined approach before deciding to use its work. Practical benefits such as time or cost savings, or management preference, do not replace this threshold evaluation and the auditor remains responsible for the audit opinion.
Why not A: Written agreement or representations from management do not establish the suitability of internal audit work for external audit use. The external auditor must perform an independent assessment of the internal audit function and remains responsible for the evidence relied upon.
Why not B: This is tempting because efficiency can motivate using others' work, but time or cost savings are not the governing criteria. The auditor must first determine whether the internal audit function meets the required objectivity, competence, and systematic-approach standards.
Why not C: Risk assessments affect the nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures, but they do not replace the need to evaluate the internal audit function itself. Even work in a low-risk area should only be used if the internal audit function is sufficiently objective, competent, and systematic.
Step by step
- Evaluate before deciding on use
Ridge Co. is a nonissuer whose internal audit function tested a routine cash-disbursement control. For the AICPA audit, the external auditor evaluates all three prerequisites before deciding whether and to what extent to use that work.
- Assess objectivity
Ridge's internal audit function reports functionally to the audit committee and administratively to the CFO, with no operating responsibility. These facts support objectivity; administrative reporting to the CFO is not an automatic disqualification.
- Assess competence
Ridge's assigned internal auditors have relevant training and experience. Assess whether those skills provide sufficient competence for the planned use.
- Assess the systematic, disciplined approach
Ridge uses written audit programs, documentation standards, supervisory review, and quality assessments, supporting a systematic, disciplined approach. With all three prerequisites met, the auditor may consider use but remains responsible for the audit opinion.
- Reassess after a reporting change
Before the plan is finalized, functional reporting shifts to the controller and audit committee oversight ends. Reassess objectivity; without safeguards supporting sufficient objectivity, do not use the work despite unchanged competence and methods.
Key points
- Remember: all three prerequisites must be met; strength in one cannot replace another.
- Administrative reporting to the CFO does not automatically disqualify a function that reports functionally to the audit committee.
- An initial favorable assessment does not eliminate reassessment when reporting lines change.
How the exam traps you
- Using experienced internal auditors without checking objectivity or methods. Evaluate all three prerequisites before deciding whether and how much work to use.
- Rejecting internal audit solely because it reports administratively to the CFO. Assess the full reporting structure; functional reporting to the audit committee supports objectivity.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on the nature of the activities performed (ongoing internal assurance and reporting lines), not only on whether the provider is external.
Answer D. Under AU-C 610, an entity's internal audit function may be performed by an outsourced provider when it carries out internal audit activities on a continuing basis. GovRisk's ongoing execution of the internal audit plan, reporting to the audit committee, and follow-up on remediation demonstrate it performs internal audit activities; its external status does not change that classification.
Why not A: Tempting because MarketQuotes supplies valuation inputs and models that both management and the auditor use, which could be mistaken for an ongoing service relationship. It fails because MarketQuotes is an external information source that provides data/evidence, not an internal assurance function that reports to governance or follows up on remediation (see distinctions in AU-C 500 and AU-C 610).
Why not B: Tempting because ValuPro provides specialized valuation expertise that relates directly to amounts in the financial statements. It fails because that role supports management in preparing an accounting estimate (a management's specialist role, see AU-C 540), not performing ongoing internal audit activities for governance and control.
Why not C: Tempting because the work relates to controls and may look like assurance activity. It fails because the expert is on the auditor's side, employed by the audit firm to obtain audit evidence, and therefore is an auditor's specialist (see AU-C 620), not the client's internal audit function.
Question 3
Hint
Focus on who directs Apex’s work and to whom Apex reports, not just whether Apex is an outside firm.
Answer A. AICPA guidance treats an outsourced provider that performs recurring internal audit activities under the entity's governance and reporting structure as the entity's internal audit function. Apex's annual plan is approved by the audit committee and it reports findings directly to the committee, indicating it functions as North's internal audit. The external auditor may use internal audit work only after evaluating objectivity, competence, and the nature/timing of the work (AU‑C 610 principles).
Why not B: This is tempting because Apex is an outside firm engaged by the entity. However, a management's specialist is retained to assist management in developing or measuring specific financial statement amounts or disclosures (for example, valuations or actuarial inputs). Apex is performing internal audit activities under audit‑committee oversight, not preparing financial statement amounts, so it is not a management's specialist.
Why not C: Candidates may be tempted because the auditor is considering using Apex's testing. But an auditor's specialist is engaged or directed by the auditor to provide specialized expertise. Apex was engaged by the entity to perform internal audit work; the auditor can use that work only after evaluation, which does not convert Apex into the auditor's specialist.
Why not D: This distractor is plausible because Apex is a third‑party firm. However, classification depends on role and reporting relationships. Because Apex operates under a work plan approved by, and reports significant findings to, the audit committee, its role aligns with the entity's internal audit function; its work is evaluated under guidance for using the internal audit function rather than treated solely as generic external evidence.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on who engaged the person and whose work that person is helping perform: management's financial reporting, the entity's internal audit activities, or the auditor's evidence-gathering.
Answer A. Item 1 is the entity's internal audit function and should be evaluated under the guidance for using the work of internal auditors. Item 2 is a management's specialist because management (Norwell) engaged the external valuation firm to develop an amount included in the financial statements; being external does not by itself make the firm an auditor's specialist. Item 3 is an auditor's specialist because the CPA firm assigned its own IT professional to assist the engagement team in obtaining audit evidence.
Why not B: Tempting because the valuation firm is external, but the key is who engaged and for whose purposes the work was done. Management (Norwell) hired the valuation firm to support amounts in the financial statements, so it is a management's specialist, not an auditor's specialist.
Why not C: This distractor confuses employment with category. Internal audit is a distinct category under auditing standards (work of internal auditors) rather than being treated as a management's specialist simply because it is employed by the entity.
Why not D: Although item 3 involves control testing, classification depends on who performed the work and their relationship to the auditor or the entity. The IT professional in item 3 is employed by the CPA firm and is assisting the auditor, so that is an auditor's specialist, not the entity's internal audit function.
Question 5
Hint
First determine whether the internal audit function is usable (objectivity, competence, systematic approach). Then consider how assessed risk and the degree of required management judgment affect how much of that completed work the external auditor can accept without additional procedures.
Answer D. AU-C 610 permits use of completed internal audit work only after the auditor evaluates the internal audit function's objectivity, competence, and systematic approach and assesses the adequacy of the specific work. The extent of use should decrease as assessed risk and the need for auditor judgment increase. Thus, after appropriate evaluation and testing, it is reasonable to use internal audit work for the lower-judgment control areas, while the significant-risk, highly judgmental obsolete inventory allowance should be addressed primarily by the external audit team.
Why not A: Plausible because oversight and qualifications support reliability, but incorrect: the auditor cannot accept internal audit conclusions as audit evidence without assessing the adequacy of the specific work and performing any necessary procedures to support its use.
Why not B: Tempting because the internal audit function appears reliable, but incorrect: even when internal audit is objective and competent, the auditor must consider assessed risk and degree of management judgment, significant-risk, highly judgmental estimates typically require auditor-performed procedures rather than relying on completed internal audit work alone.
Why not C: Attractive as an overly cautious stance, but overly broad: standards do not impose a blanket prohibition on using completed internal audit work based solely on an account's size; after evaluating the function and testing the specific work, internal audit work may be used for lower-risk, lower-judgment inventory procedures.
Question 6
Hint
Focus on the three key evaluations for using internal auditors' work, and ask which fact in the stem creates the biggest problem.
Answer B. When deciding whether to use the work of an internal audit function, the external auditor evaluates objectivity, competence, and whether the function applies a systematic and disciplined approach. Here, competence and documentation are favorable, but the internal audit function's reporting relationship to the controller creates a meaningful objectivity concern. That concern makes significant reliance less appropriate, even for routine areas.
Why not A: This is tempting because competence and written procedures are important factors. However, they do not eliminate an objectivity problem. The auditor must consider objectivity as a primary factor, and a compromised reporting relationship can materially limit or preclude reliance.
Why not C: Lower inherent risk can affect the nature, timing, and extent of testing, but it does not override an evaluation of the internal audit function's objectivity. Even for routine transactions, a significant objectivity concern can reduce or preclude reliance.
Why not D: Reperformance may be a response if the auditor uses internal auditors' work, but objectivity is absolutely a planning consideration. The statement that objectivity is not relevant is incorrect, making this choice implausible.
Question 7
Hint
Think first about what gives the external auditor confidence in the internal auditors themselves, not about efficiency or familiarity with the process.
Answer A. This option best addresses the auditor's primary concerns when considering use of internal audit work: objectivity and competence. Functional reporting to the audit committee and lack of operating responsibility support objectivity, while relevant training supports competence. Because routine cash disbursements are not a highly judgmental area, these factors make it more appropriate to rely on the internal auditors' work.
Why not B: Tempting because a stable process seems lower risk, but reporting to the controller impairs objectivity. Stability of the process does not overcome a meaningful independence concern, so this does not strongly support using their work.
Why not C: Understanding the controls is helpful, but having helped design the procedures raises a self-review threat and reduces objectivity. That self-review concern weakens the case for relying on their work despite their familiarity.
Why not D: Management's request and long tenure are not proper bases for the auditor's decision. Tenure alone does not establish independence or sufficient competence, and the auditor must evaluate objectivity and competence, not management convenience.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on what using the work of internal auditors can change in the external auditor's own procedures, and what responsibility the external auditor still keeps.
Answer D. When the internal audit function is sufficiently objective, competent, and systematic, the external auditor may use its work in planning and performing the audit. In a routine area with limited judgment, that can affect the external auditor's planned response by reducing the extent of some procedures. However, the external auditor must still evaluate the internal auditors' work and remains responsible for the audit opinion.
Why not A: Incorrect because the external auditor may use internal auditors' work in relation to tests of controls as well as substantive procedures, subject to proper evaluation and the nature of the area involved.
Why not B: Tempting because a strong internal audit function provides useful evidence, but the external auditor cannot simply accept the internal auditors' conclusion without evaluating the work and obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence.
Why not C: This distractor plays on the idea that internal auditors lack external independence. Lack of external independence does not automatically bar use of their work; the key considerations are objectivity, competence, and whether the work is systematic and disciplined.
Question 9
Hint
Focus on what must happen first: deciding to use the work of others, or evaluating whether that work can be used.
Answer B. Under U.S. GAAS (AU-C 610), the external auditor must evaluate the internal audit function's objectivity, competence, and whether it uses a systematic and disciplined approach before deciding to use its work. That initial assessment informs the auditor's determination of whether, and to what extent, internal audit work is appropriate to rely on.
Why not A: While the auditor should assess the adequacy of specific internal audit work before relying on it, the required evaluation of the internal audit function itself must occur earlier, before deciding to use that work at all.
Why not C: The need to evaluate the internal audit function is triggered by consideration of using its work, regardless of whether the auditor's overall strategy emphasizes controls or substantive procedures.
Why not D: This is incorrect because the evaluation affects planning and the nature, timing, and extent of the auditor's own procedures; it must be done before using internal audit work, not after the engagement is complete.
Common questions
What must an auditor evaluate under AU-C 610?
Evaluate the internal audit function's objectivity, competence, and systematic, disciplined approach. All three must be sufficient before deciding whether and to what extent to use its work.
Does reporting to the CFO disqualify internal audit work?
Administrative reporting to the CFO is not an automatic disqualification. Functional reporting to the audit committee supports objectivity, but the auditor must still evaluate all three prerequisites.
When must an auditor reassess internal audit objectivity?
Reassess when circumstances change, such as a shift in functional reporting from the audit committee to the controller. Unchanged competence and methods do not remove the need to reassess objectivity.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Planning for and using the Work of Others, worked step by step.
Using the Work of Others | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Planning for and using the Work of Others
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.