AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 13 practice questions
AU-C 610: When to Use Less Internal Audit Work
Even usable internal audit work must be used less as assessed risk or required judgment increases. Below, the same inventory allowance shows how changing risk or the task changes the auditor's approach.
Try one first
Hint
Focus on where the external auditor should be most cautious about using others' work: areas with more judgment and higher risk.
Answer D. Areas that involve significant judgment, high estimation uncertainty, or high assessed risk are generally the least appropriate for relying on internal audit work. A significant fair value estimate with high uncertainty requires substantial auditor judgment and is therefore the least appropriate area to use internal auditors' work.
Why not A: This is a routine, mechanical calculation that involves limited judgment; internal auditors can often perform such tasks reliably when they are objective and competent.
Why not B: This is a low-risk, low-judgment, transaction-level procedure. Because it is mechanical and routine, it is generally more appropriate for using work performed by internal auditors.
Why not C: Routine automated controls that are well-documented and of lower judgment are typical areas where internal auditors' work may be used; they are less problematic than testing significant fair value estimates with high uncertainty.
Same scenario, one fact changes
Base case
Harbor Co., a nonissuer, reports an inventory obsolescence allowance. The external auditor finds internal audit objective, competent, and using a systematic, disciplined approach. Assessed risk is low. Internal audit completed routine accuracy and completeness tests of supporting inventory data, requiring little judgment. The external auditor will evaluate and test any work used.
Answer: Use the routine data-testing work after evaluating and testing it.
The work involves low risk and little judgment. It is suitable for greater use of internal audit work, although the external auditor remains responsible for the audit conclusion.
Before you open each one, predict the answer.
Change 1Only assessed risk changes: the allowance is now a significant risk.
Answer: Reduce use of internal audit's data tests and perform more direct data testing.
A significant risk calls for more direct auditor work even when the data tests remain routine.
Change 2Only the task changes: evaluating significant demand forecasts and expected markdown assumptions.
Answer: Evaluate the significant assumptions directly rather than use internal audit's conclusions as primary support.
Low assessed risk does not remove the judgment limit. Evaluating these significant assumptions requires direct auditor procedures.
Change 3Only the task changes: testing management's allowance-review control, which requires significant judgment about forecasts.
Answer: Perform the key judgmental control tests directly rather than substitute internal audit's conclusions.
The control-testing label does not remove the judgment involved. The external auditor must perform the key judgmental evaluation.
Key points
- Remember: More risk or judgment means more direct auditor work, even when internal audit remains suitable.
- Routine data testing can support the allowance audit; substantive work is not automatically off-limits.
- A significant-risk designation limits use but does not automatically prohibit all internal audit evidence.
- Evaluate and test completed internal audit work before using it, even for routine data checks.
How the exam traps you
- Internal audit is strong, so its work can replace direct testing even when risk rises. Reduce its role in the significant-risk allowance audit and perform more direct procedures.
- A control test is always more suitable than substantive data testing. Compare required judgment: the forecast-based review control needs more direct auditor work than routine data checks.
Now the same facts as questions
Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.
Question 1
Answer A. Correct. Low risk and little judgment make these routine data tests suitable for use.
Why not B: Incorrect. Substantive testing is not automatically excluded; risk and judgment govern the extent of use.
Why not C: Incorrect. Employee status does not prohibit using an otherwise suitable internal audit function's work.
Why not D: Incorrect. Suitability does not eliminate the requirement to evaluate and test the completed work.
Question 2
Answer B. Correct. Higher risk requires less use of internal audit work and more direct auditor procedures.
Why not A: Incorrect. The higher assessed risk limits use even though internal audit remains suitable.
Why not C: Incorrect. Significant risk alone does not prohibit all use of completed routine data tests.
Why not D: Incorrect. Familiarity with the system does not override the need for more direct work as risk rises.
Question 3
Answer C. Correct. The external auditor must directly evaluate the significant assumptions and make the significant audit judgments.
Why not A: Incorrect. Internal audit's conclusions cannot replace the external auditor's evaluation of significant assumptions.
Why not B: Incorrect. Significant judgment independently limits use, even without an increase in assessed risk.
Why not D: Incorrect. Checking data does not establish whether significant forecast and markdown assumptions are reasonable.
Question 4
Answer D. Correct. Significant judgment requires direct auditor evaluation, even when the task is control testing.
Why not A: Incorrect. This review control requires significant judgment; control testing is not automatically routine.
Why not B: Incorrect. Internal audit's suitability does not remove the task-specific judgment limit.
Why not C: Incorrect. Accurate data alone does not establish whether management's forecast-based review control operated effectively.
Question 2
Hint
Which procedure depends most on management estimates and subjective judgment rather than objective, verifiable evidence?
Answer D. Areas that rely heavily on management estimates and judgment (forecasts, product life cycles) limit the extent to which the external auditor can substitute internal audit work because such areas increase measurement uncertainty and professional judgment needs. Even with an objective, competent internal audit function, the external auditor generally must perform their own substantive procedures or apply additional testing for estimate‑driven items.
Why not A: Tempting because control testing is a common area for reliance on internal auditors. It fails here because the control is automated and objective with little management estimation, so internal audit work in this area is generally more usable rather than one requiring extra caution.
Why not B: Tempting because cash reconciliations can detect important misstatements. It fails because when reconciling items are routine and independently supported, the procedures are objective and verifiable, making internal audit work more appropriate for reliance than in estimate‑heavy areas.
Why not C: Tempting because recomputation is a substantive procedure the external auditor performs. It fails because recomputations based on signed agreements and fixed schedules are highly objective and straightforward, so they present less limitation on using internal auditors' work.
Question 3
Hint
Separate the engagement into (1) source-data and control testing and (2) evaluation of significant actuarial assumptions; decide which parts the auditor may accept from others after evaluation and which parts require direct auditor evidence.
Answer D. U.S. GAAS permits the auditor to use internal audit work after evaluating objectivity, competence, and systematic approach; internal audit testing of source data and related controls can provide audit evidence. However, for a higher-risk estimate that involves significant judgment the auditor must obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence about the significant actuarial assumptions and methods, which may require independent procedures and/or use of an auditor's specialist rather than relying solely on management's actuary.
Why not A: Tempting because both internal audit and the actuary address important aspects of the reserve, but incorrect: for a higher-risk, judgmental estimate the auditor cannot rely primarily on those sources with only limited corroboration and still meet the requirement to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence about significant assumptions and methods.
Why not B: Misleading because administrative reporting alone does not automatically preclude use of internal audit work, functional reporting to the audit committee and an external quality assessment support evaluation and potential use; also, verifying credentials and documentation alone does not substitute for obtaining evidence about significant actuarial assumptions and methods.
Why not C: Appealing to candidates who overgeneralize that higher risk requires doing everything personally, but incorrect: competent internal audit testing of source data and controls may still be used after evaluation, and management's actuary's work can inform the auditor's procedures, complete disregard of available competent work is unnecessary and inefficient.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether the task is routine and objective versus one that requires the auditor's own significant judgment about management's estimate.
Answer B. This assignment is inappropriate for direct assistance because it requires the external auditor's own significant judgments about highly subjective, material accounting estimates (a Level 3 fair value measurement). AICPA guidance limits direct assistance to tasks that do not involve making the auditor's independent, significant judgments; evaluating key assumptions for a Level 3 estimate should be performed by the external auditor.
Why not A: This is a routine control test that involves relatively objective procedures. When the external auditor has evaluated objectivity and competence and provides appropriate direction, supervision, and review, such testing can be assigned as direct assistance because it does not require the auditor's independent, significant judgments.
Why not C: A straightforward recalculation using established company policy and recorded inputs is largely mechanical and objective. Because it does not require significant auditor judgment about estimates, it is generally suitable for direct assistance under appropriate supervision.
Why not D: At a low-risk location, count observation and tracing are largely procedural and objective. With appropriate direction, supervision, and review by the external auditor, such inventory procedures may be assigned as direct assistance; they are not automatically excluded simply because inventory is an important audit area.
Question 5
Hint
First determine whether the internal-audit function can be used (evaluate objectivity and competence); then match the nature of the internal-audit procedures to the assessed risk and the degree of auditor judgment required for each inventory assertion.
Answer D. Under AU-C 610 the external auditor may use the work of internal audit after evaluating objectivity, competence, and the systematic approach to the work. Even when the internal-audit function is usable, its work is generally more suitable for routine, lower-risk procedures (such as cycle counts supporting existence) than for significant-risk areas that involve substantial management judgment (such as valuation and obsolescence). Accordingly, the auditor may reduce testing of routine existence procedures based on internal-audit work but should perform valuation procedures directly in this engagement.
Why not A: Tempting because the facts show competence and functional reporting to the audit committee, but it overgeneralizes: significant-risk valuation work often requires the auditor's direct procedures and judgment, so IA work alone is not a sufficient substitute.
Why not B: Attractive because auditors often test IA work, but incorrect in degree: the auditor need not reperform a substantial portion of all IA procedures as a condition precedent, and reperformance does not automatically make IA work suitable for high-judgment, significant-risk valuation areas.
Why not C: This is appealing to candidates who treat any administrative reporting to management as disqualifying. It is incorrect because objectivity must be assessed in context; functional reporting to the audit committee plus evidence of competence and quality controls can permit appropriate use for some procedures.
Question 6
Hint
First decide whether the internal audit function is usable. Then analyze each area separately by assessed risk, degree of judgment, and any area-specific objectivity/self-review concerns.
Answer A. After concluding the internal audit function is generally usable, the auditor evaluates each area separately. Area 1 (low risk, routine, little judgment) is appropriate for reliance. Area 2 (moderate risk, some judgment) may be used only to a limited extent after the external auditor performs additional procedures. Area 3 is inappropriate because it is high risk, involves significant judgment, and presents a self-review/objectivity threat from the internal audit manager's prior involvement in designing the control; reperformance does not eliminate that threat.
Why not B: Tempting because reperformance can strengthen evidence, but it does not cure an objectivity/self-review threat arising from prior involvement in control design; such high-risk, judgmental work remains unsuitable as audit evidence.
Why not C: Tempting because auditors often observe inventory, but the primary reason to exclude area 3 is its high risk and self-review threat, not an inventory-observation rule; internal audit work can sometimes support inventory procedures, whereas area 3's objectivity/judgment concerns make it unsuitable.
Why not D: Tempting because prior involvement can impair objectivity in a specific area, but the auditor concluded the internal audit function is generally objective and competent; an area-specific self-review issue does not automatically disqualify all internal audit work.
Question 7
Hint
First decide whether the internal audit function is usable at all. Then consider how higher risk and greater judgment affect the amount of work the external auditor should do personally.
Answer A. Once the external auditor determines the internal audit function is usable, the next question is extent of use. In areas with higher assessed risk and more auditor judgment, the external auditor should use less of the internal auditors' work and perform more procedures directly. Revenue cutoff here is both a significant risk area and one requiring substantial judgment, so limited use is the best-supported conclusion.
Why not B: Objectivity, competence, and a systematic approach are threshold conditions for using internal auditors' work at all, but they do not justify extensive use in a high-risk, judgment-heavy area. The auditor should perform more direct procedures for revenue cutoff.
Why not C: A significant risk in one area does not prohibit use of internal auditors' work audit-wide. It affects the extent and appropriateness of use in that specific high-risk area rather than creating an automatic ban everywhere.
Why not D: Reperformance can help evaluate the quality of internal auditors' work, but it does not eliminate the need for the external auditor to do more direct work in a high-risk, judgment-heavy area. The extent of use should still be reduced compared to lower-risk areas.
Question 8
Hint
After concluding internal audit is usable, compare the two areas by assessed risk and how much auditor judgment is required; lower-risk, routine controls are more likely to be used with minimal extra testing.
Answer A. After objectivity, competence, and a systematic approach are established, the extent of reliance on internal audit work depends on assessed risk and the degree of judgment involved. Routine control testing in a lower-risk, low-judgment area (cash disbursements) is generally more suitable for greater reliance with minimal additional external testing, whereas a higher-risk accounting estimate requiring significant judgment typically warrants more external procedures. In all cases the external auditor remains responsible for evaluating the internal audit work before using it as audit evidence.
Why not B: Tempting because objectivity and competence are prerequisites for using internal audit work; however, those qualities do not permit equal reliance across areas. The auditor must also consider assessed risk and the degree of judgment, higher-risk, judgmental areas are generally less appropriate for minimal additional external testing and require more external procedures.
Why not C: Tempting because independence is central to audit quality, but this distractor misapplies the concept: the external auditor's decision to use internal audit work is based on assessed objectivity, competence, and a systematic approach. Lack of external-style independence does not automatically preclude use when those criteria are met.
Why not D: Tempting because efficiency and prior internal audit review are attractive, but an accounting estimate that involves significant judgment is a higher-risk area that typically requires more direct external testing and independent evaluation of management's assumptions rather than extensive reliance on internal audit work.
Question 9
Hint
Do not stop after competence and objectivity. Also ask which area requires the most direct auditor judgment and therefore permits the least reliance on internal auditors.
Answer D. Accounting estimates and impairment evaluations often involve significant management judgment and estimation uncertainty. Professional standards limit the extent to which the external auditor may rely on others' work in such areas, and the auditor must perform sufficient direct procedures to obtain adequate audit evidence. Therefore relying primarily on internal auditors' documentation and conclusions for management's significant assumptions in a judgmental impairment estimate is the least appropriate planned use.
Why not A: This distractor is tempting because high transaction volume may seem risky, but routine, standardized control testing (like three-way match) is the type of work the auditor may use when the internal audit function is competent and objective, provided the external auditor evaluates and tests some of that work.
Why not B: Inventory observation can be appropriate for internal auditors when the external auditor still attends selected counts and performs procedures on the internal auditors' work; the small size of the locations and the external auditor's attendance reduce the risk that would otherwise limit reliance.
Why not C: Bank reconciliations for routine operating accounts are generally objective and repetitive; with reperformance by internal auditors and targeted follow-up by the external auditor, reliance is more appropriate than in highly judgmental estimate areas.
Common questions
Can auditors use internal audit work for a significant risk under AU-C 610?
A significant risk does not automatically prohibit all use. For the allowance's routine data tests, reduce planned use and perform more direct procedures.
Can low assessed risk justify using internal audit conclusions about significant assumptions?
No. Even if the allowance's assessed risk remains low, evaluating significant forecast and markdown assumptions requires the external auditor's own judgment and direct procedures.
Are control tests always suitable for using internal audit work?
No. Testing the allowance-review control requires significant judgment about forecasts. That task calls for more direct auditor work than routine inventory data checks.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Planning for and using the Work of Others, worked step by step.
Using the Work of Others | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Planning for and using the Work of Others
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.