PracticeAUDFree practice exam

AUD · Assessing Risk and Developing a Planned Response · 13 practice questions

AU-C 610: When to Use Less Internal Audit Work

Even usable internal audit work must be used less as assessed risk or required judgment increases. Below, the same inventory allowance shows how changing risk or the task changes the auditor's approach.

The ruleEven when internal audit is objective, competent, and systematic, use less of its work as assessed risk or required judgment increases. The external auditor must make all significant audit judgments.

Try one first

In planning an audit of a nonissuer, the external auditor determines that the client's internal audit function is objective, competent, and applies a systematic and disciplined approach. The auditor is considering using work performed by internal auditors in several areas. In which area would using that work generally be least appropriate?
Hint

Focus on where the external auditor should be most cautious about using others' work: areas with more judgment and higher risk.

Same scenario, one fact changes

Base case

Harbor Co., a nonissuer, reports an inventory obsolescence allowance. The external auditor finds internal audit objective, competent, and using a systematic, disciplined approach. Assessed risk is low. Internal audit completed routine accuracy and completeness tests of supporting inventory data, requiring little judgment. The external auditor will evaluate and test any work used.

Answer: Use the routine data-testing work after evaluating and testing it.

The work involves low risk and little judgment. It is suitable for greater use of internal audit work, although the external auditor remains responsible for the audit conclusion.

Before you open each one, predict the answer.

Change 1Only assessed risk changes: the allowance is now a significant risk.

Answer: Reduce use of internal audit's data tests and perform more direct data testing.

A significant risk calls for more direct auditor work even when the data tests remain routine.

Change 2Only the task changes: evaluating significant demand forecasts and expected markdown assumptions.

Answer: Evaluate the significant assumptions directly rather than use internal audit's conclusions as primary support.

Low assessed risk does not remove the judgment limit. Evaluating these significant assumptions requires direct auditor procedures.

Change 3Only the task changes: testing management's allowance-review control, which requires significant judgment about forecasts.

Answer: Perform the key judgmental control tests directly rather than substitute internal audit's conclusions.

The control-testing label does not remove the judgment involved. The external auditor must perform the key judgmental evaluation.

Key points

  • Remember: More risk or judgment means more direct auditor work, even when internal audit remains suitable.
  • Routine data testing can support the allowance audit; substantive work is not automatically off-limits.
  • A significant-risk designation limits use but does not automatically prohibit all internal audit evidence.
  • Evaluate and test completed internal audit work before using it, even for routine data checks.

How the exam traps you

  • Internal audit is strong, so its work can replace direct testing even when risk rises. Reduce its role in the significant-risk allowance audit and perform more direct procedures.
  • A control test is always more suitable than substantive data testing. Compare required judgment: the forecast-based review control needs more direct auditor work than routine data checks.

Now the same facts as questions

Each question changes one fact from the one before. Watch which change flips the answer.

Question 1

Harbor Co., a nonissuer, reports an inventory obsolescence allowance. The external auditor finds internal audit objective, competent, and using a systematic, disciplined approach. Assessed risk is low. Internal audit completed routine accuracy and completeness tests of supporting inventory data, requiring little judgment. The external auditor will evaluate and test any work used. Which planned use is most appropriate?

Question 2

Same facts, except the allowance is assessed as a significant risk rather than low risk. How should planned use of the completed routine data tests change?

Question 3

Same facts, except internal audit evaluated significant demand forecasts and expected markdown assumptions instead of testing inventory data, requiring significant judgment. What approach is appropriate?

Question 4

Same facts, except internal audit tested management's allowance-review control, requiring significant judgment about forecasts, instead of testing inventory data. What approach is appropriate?

8 more, each from a different angle

0 of 8 answered · 0 correct

Question 2

During audit planning, the external auditor concluded North Bay Co.'s internal audit function is objective, competent, and systematic. Where should the external auditor be most cautious about extensively using completed internal audit work?
Hint

Which procedure depends most on management estimates and subjective judgment rather than objective, verifiable evidence?

Question 3

During planning of a nonissuer audit under U.S. GAAS, the engagement team is evaluating how to use the work of others in auditing management's workers' compensation reserve. Internal audit has a documented methodology, underwent a recent external quality assessment, reports functionally to the audit committee and administratively to the CFO, and did not participate in preparing the reserve. Internal audit tested the completeness and accuracy of claims data extracted from the claims system and the operation of access and change controls over the data feed. Management engaged an external actuary to develop the reserve using assumptions about claim severity, settlement patterns, and discount rates. The auditor assessed the reserve as a higher-risk estimate involving significant judgment. Which planned response is most appropriate?
Hint

Separate the engagement into (1) source-data and control testing and (2) evaluation of significant actuarial assumptions; decide which parts the auditor may accept from others after evaluation and which parts require direct auditor evidence.

Question 4

In an audit of a nonissuer conducted under AICPA auditing standards, the external auditor has evaluated the internal audit function and concluded that its organizational status, policies, and staff competence are sufficient to permit limited direct assistance. Assume no law or regulation prohibits direct assistance, and the external auditor will direct, supervise, and review the work. Which planned assignment should be classified as inappropriate for direct assistance by internal auditors?
Hint

Focus on whether the task is routine and objective versus one that requires the auditor's own significant judgment about management's estimate.

Question 5

During planning for a nonissuer audit, the engagement partner considers using the client's internal audit function. Internal audit reports functionally to the audit committee and administratively to the CFO. Its staff includes experienced CPAs, follows documented work programs, and its work is subject to periodic internal quality reviews. Internal audit recently tested cycle counts at several warehouses and also reviewed management's process for estimating obsolete inventory and standard-cost variances. The external auditor assessed inventory existence as a moderate-risk area involving largely routine procedures, but identified inventory valuation as a significant risk because of subjectivity in obsolescence and overhead absorption. Assume the external auditor will appropriately evaluate any internal audit work before using it. Which planned use of the internal audit function is most appropriate under U.S. GAAS?
Hint

First determine whether the internal-audit function can be used (evaluate objectivity and competence); then match the nature of the internal-audit procedures to the assessed risk and the degree of auditor judgment required for each inventory assertion.

Question 6

In planning the audit of a nonissuer, the external auditor concluded that the client's internal audit function is generally objective, competent, and applies a systematic and disciplined approach. Internal audit completed Year 2 work in the following areas: (1) testing of automated three-way match controls in purchases, where assessed risk is low and little judgment was required; (2) test counts and follow-up of discrepancies at a remote warehouse, where assessed risk is moderate and some judgment was required; and (3) testing of the contract-review control used to recognize revenue on customized arrangements, where assessed risk is high, significant judgment was required, and an internal audit manager who directed the work had helped management design that control earlier in the year (a self-review/objectivity threat that reperformance would not remove). Which planned use of internal audit work is most appropriate?
Hint

First decide whether the internal audit function is usable. Then analyze each area separately by assessed risk, degree of judgment, and any area-specific objectivity/self-review concerns.

Question 7

During planning of a nonissuer audit, the external auditor evaluates the client's internal audit function and concludes it is sufficiently objective, competent, and applies a systematic and disciplined approach. The auditor is considering using internal auditors' completed testing of controls over year-end revenue cutoff. The auditor has separately identified revenue cutoff as a significant risk because contracts signed near year-end often contain nonstandard acceptance and return terms that require substantial auditor judgment. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
Hint

First decide whether the internal audit function is usable at all. Then consider how higher risk and greater judgment affect the amount of work the external auditor should do personally.

Question 8

During planning for the 20X6 audit of North Pier Co., the external auditor determined that the internal audit function is sufficiently objective, competent, and applies a systematic and disciplined approach. Internal audit performed the following work: 1. Tests of routine three-way-match controls over cash disbursements, assessed by the external auditor as lower risk and involving little judgment. 2. Review of management's obsolete inventory reserve methodology and assumptions, assessed by the external auditor as higher risk and involving significant judgment. Which conclusion about where the external auditor may rely more heavily on the internal audit work, with minimal additional external testing, is best supported?
Hint

After concluding internal audit is usable, compare the two areas by assessed risk and how much auditor judgment is required; lower-risk, routine controls are more likely to be used with minimal extra testing.

Question 9

In planning the audit of a nonissuer, the engagement partner has determined that the client's internal audit function is sufficiently competent and objective to be considered. The auditor wants to use internal auditors' work to reduce some external audit procedures. Which planned use is the least appropriate because professional standards place the strongest limitation on relying on internal auditors in that situation?
Hint

Do not stop after competence and objectivity. Also ask which area requires the most direct auditor judgment and therefore permits the least reliance on internal auditors.

Drill all 128 Planning for and using the Work of Others questionsMixed across every rule in the topic, so you have to spot which one applies. That is how the exam does it.

Common questions

Can auditors use internal audit work for a significant risk under AU-C 610?

A significant risk does not automatically prohibit all use. For the allowance's routine data tests, reduce planned use and perform more direct procedures.

Can low assessed risk justify using internal audit conclusions about significant assumptions?

No. Even if the allowance's assessed risk remains low, evaluating significant forecast and markdown assumptions requires the external auditor's own judgment and direct procedures.

Are control tests always suitable for using internal audit work?

No. Testing the allowance-review control requires significant judgment about forecasts. That task calls for more direct auditor work than routine inventory data checks.

Watch it solved

A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Planning for and using the Work of Others, worked step by step.

Using the Work of Others | CPA AUD Simulation (TBS) on YouTube

Practice AUD like the real exam

The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.

Open the free simulator →

More on Planning for and using the Work of Others

All Planning for and using the Work of Others practice →

Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.