AUD · Performing Further Procedures and Obtaining Evidence · 9 practice questions
AU-C 265: Correcting Errors Does Not Fix Control Failures
An auditor must evaluate a control failure even if management later corrects the misstatement. Follow Noll's missed cutoff review from discovery through the correcting entry.
Try one first
Hint
A corrected misstatement can still matter for internal control. Focus on what the auditor's discovery says about the client's ability to prevent or detect a material error on a timely basis.
Answer D. A material misstatement that the entity's controls would not have prevented or detected on a timely basis is an indicator of a material weakness in internal control. Even though management corrected the financial statements before issuance, the underlying control failure remains and must be evaluated and communicated in writing during the current audit (per requirements for communicating significant deficiencies and material weaknesses).
Why not A: This is tempting because candidates may focus only on whether the financial statements were ultimately corrected. However, correction of the misstatement does not remove the fact that controls failed to prevent or detect the error on a timely basis, which creates an internal control implication that must be addressed.
Why not B: While an uncorrected misstatement raises additional audit concerns, the internal control assessment is about whether controls prevented or detected the misstatement on a timely basis. Even if management records the adjustment, the control failure itself can indicate a material weakness.
Why not C: This distractor appeals to the idea that recurrence is required before a deficiency matters. In fact, a current-year material misstatement that controls would not have prevented or detected already indicates a material weakness and triggers the auditor's evaluation and communication in the current audit.
The timeline
- Last week of 20X5Noll's required sales cutoff review is not performed.
The accounting manager should compare invoices with shipping documents before revenue is posted. No compensating control addresses the cutoff risk.
- 20X5 year-endNoll records $900,000 of revenue for goods shipped in 20X6.
Revenue is recorded too early. Management's controls do not identify the error.
- During the 20X5 auditSubstantive testing identifies the $900,000 cutoff error.
Discovery triggers evaluation of the related control failure, regardless of whether management later corrects revenue.
- At discoveryThe auditor evaluates the missed cutoff review.
The required review was not performed. Its existence in the control process does not establish that it operated.
- Before issuanceManagement records the auditor's proposed adjustment.
The entry corrects the revenue amount. It does not eliminate the need to evaluate the control failure.
Key points
- Remember: Correcting the amount does not prove the control worked.
- Substantive testing can reveal control problems, not just incorrect financial statement amounts.
- A control that exists on paper can still fail in operation.
How the exam traps you
- Waiting for management to refuse an adjustment before evaluating controls. Evaluate the control failure when the auditor identifies the cutoff error.
- Stopping the control evaluation once management records the correcting entry. Evaluate the missed review separately; correcting revenue does not show that the review occurred.
Question 2
Hint
Focus on which situation shows both a control failure and a reasonable possibility of a material misstatement not being prevented or detected on a timely basis.
Answer B. A material weakness exists when there is a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement will not be prevented, or detected and corrected, on a timely basis. Here, the absence of independent review over manual journal entries allowed a material revenue misstatement to be made and remain undetected by the company's controls, which strongly supports classification as a material weakness.
Why not A: This is tempting because any identified misstatement may suggest a control problem. However, a single, promptly corrected classification error, especially when the related supervisory review control otherwise operated effectively, does not by itself indicate a reasonable possibility of a material misstatement going undetected and therefore does not support a material weakness.
Why not C: Delayed performance of a control can indicate a deficiency, but the facts here are limited: the delay was only a few days and no cash misstatement was identified. Those facts point to a lesser deficiency rather than a material weakness.
Why not D: Multiple errors can signal control weaknesses, but when the errors are small and immaterial in the aggregate and were corrected, the situation is unlikely to rise to the level of a material weakness; it more likely reflects a less severe deficiency.
Question 3
Hint
Ask who detected the error, whether the entity's control detected and corrected it before issuance, and whether the auditor confirmed the control actually operated.
Answer B. When the entity's own control timely detects and corrects a misstatement before issuance and the auditor verifies the control operated effectively, the misstatement alone does not support inferring an internal control deficiency. Here the monthly review both detected the formula error and led to correction in the normal close before issuance, and the auditor's verification supports that the control functioned as designed.
Why not A: Tempting because an adjustment was ultimately recorded, suggesting correction. It is wrong because the auditor, not the entity's control, identified the issue and the approval control was bypassed; those facts indicate the entity's controls failed to prevent or detect the misstatement, supporting an inference of a deficiency.
Why not C: Tempting because cutoff errors can stem from control problems and are often revealed by substantive testing. It is wrong for this question because there is no evidence the entity's sales-cutoff control detected the misstatement, so the auditor's finding, absent evidence of control operation, supports inferring a control deficiency.
Why not D: Tempting because management ultimately discovered the error, which might suggest internal detection. It is wrong because the error led to a restatement and a required reconciliation was not performed, strong indicators that controls were ineffective during the period, so the misstatement supports an inference of a deficiency.
Question 4
Hint
Focus on whether Orion's own controls had already detected and corrected the misstatement before the auditor's testing began.
Answer B. The key question is whether the entity's controls would have detected and corrected the misstatement on a timely basis. If Orion's cutoff review control had already identified and documented correction of the specific transactions before auditor testing, that demonstrates the control operated timely and weakens the inference that the misstatement alone evidences a material weakness. The auditor would still evaluate the control, but this fact most limits the conclusion of a material weakness.
Why not A: This distractor is tempting because isolated human error often feels non-systemic. However, the pertinent issue is whether controls would have detected and corrected a material misstatement on a timely basis; an isolated error can still indicate a material weakness if controls failed to catch it.
Why not C: This option tempts because a correction before report issuance looks like remediation. It fails, though, because correction only after auditor notification does not show that the entity's internal controls detected and corrected the misstatement on their own and therefore does not limit the inference of a material weakness.
Why not D: This is attractive because atypical or one-off transactions can explain control exceptions. But the unusual nature alone does not limit the conclusion, if controls failed to detect and correct a material misstatement, that failure may still indicate a material weakness.
Question 5
Hint
Don’t treat each entry in isolation or rely solely on the fact corrections were posted; consider aggregation, the common cause, and whether the client's controls could have prevented or detected and corrected a material misstatement on a timely basis.
Answer A. The three errors aggregate to $1,170,000, which exceeds overall materiality, and they stem from the same control failure (manual overrides). By definition, a material weakness exists when there is a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement would not be prevented, or detected and corrected, on a timely basis. Here the entity's controls did not timely prevent or detect the aggregate misstatement; subsequent corrections recorded only after the auditor's identification do not, by themselves, eliminate the underlying control deficiency.
Why not B: Tempting because it points to the existence of a review control; incorrect because the mere presence of a control is insufficient if it did not operate effectively to prevent or detect a material aggregate misstatement.
Why not C: Tempting because it focuses on individual items and the fact adjustments were recorded; incorrect because materiality is assessed in the aggregate and the relevant question is whether controls timely prevented or detected and corrected a material misstatement, which failed here.
Why not D: Tempting because management posted corrections before issuance; incorrect because the auditor must still evaluate and, if appropriate, communicate control deficiencies when controls fail to prevent or timely detect material misstatements, even if amounts were later adjusted.
Question 6
Hint
Separate two issues: whether the misstatement amount is material, and whether the company's controls prevented or timely detected the error.
Answer C. Auditor-detected misstatements do not automatically establish a material weakness, but they can indicate that a control was missing or did not operate effectively to prevent or timely detect and correct the error. Here, the cutoff errors point to a possible deficiency because the gross margin review is too aggregated to detect these specific errors; the auditor should evaluate the severity of the deficiency and consider whether to change the nature, timing, or extent of further procedures.
Why not A: Tempting because the amount is below overall materiality and management will correct the books, but whether controls failed to prevent or timely detect the error is a separate evaluation; a correction does not eliminate a control deficiency.
Why not B: This is an overstatement: not all auditor-detected misstatements automatically equal a material weakness. The auditor must assess whether a deficiency exists and, if so, evaluate its severity before concluding it is a material weakness.
Why not D: The stem explicitly assumes the gross margin review is too aggregated to detect these cutoff errors on a timely basis, so it should not be treated as an effective compensating control; therefore the errors may still indicate a deficiency.
Question 7
Hint
Focus on whether the entity’s own controls, not the auditor, identified the material misstatement in time.
Answer C. An auditor-identified material misstatement arising under circumstances showing that entity controls would not have prevented or detected and corrected it on a timely basis is an indicator of a material weakness. Here, the change-management control was not performed, the monitoring control failed to detect the error, and no compensating controls existed; management's subsequent correction after auditor intervention does not eliminate the underlying control deficiency.
Why not A: Tempting because there was no misstatement in issued statements, but classification focuses on whether internal control prevented or detected and corrected the misstatement on a timely basis without auditor intervention. Management corrected only after the auditor identified the error.
Why not B: This distractor appeals to the incorrect notion that material weaknesses must be pervasive. A single-account, single-period failure can be a material weakness if it creates a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement would not be prevented or detected and corrected timely.
Why not D: Prior-period effects or a restatement can increase severity, but they are not required to classify the current-year deficiency. The current facts already show a material misstatement that the entity's controls failed to prevent or detect and correct in time.
Question 8
Hint
Focus on whether the entity's controls actually prevented or detected the completeness error and whether a later correction removes the underlying control failure.
Answer B. When an entity's controls fail to prevent or detect a misstatement that would be material if uncorrected, that failure is a strong indicator of a material weakness. Here, the controller's reconciliation compared totals to the ledger but did not address completeness of the customer population, and no other control compensated for that gap. Management's subsequent correction does not eliminate the underlying control deficiency.
Why not A: Tempting because the financial statements were corrected before issuance. However, a post-discovery correction does not negate that the company's controls failed to prevent or detect a material misstatement, so the deficiency still must be evaluated and communicated.
Why not C: Tempting because a reconciliation review existed. But that review did not verify completeness of the customer categories and therefore did not detect the material misstatement, which points to a material weakness rather than only a significant deficiency.
Why not D: Tempting because the engagement was a financial statement audit. Nonetheless, auditors performing GAAS audits still evaluate identified control deficiencies and must consider and communicate significant deficiencies and material weaknesses; the identified failure therefore does inform the conclusion about internal control.
Question 9
Hint
Focus on what the auditor's discovery implies about the design or operation of controls at year-end, not just on the fact that management later recorded an adjustment.
Answer D. A material weakness exists when there is a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement will not be prevented, or detected and corrected, on a timely basis. The auditor identified a material misstatement and found no control requiring knowledgeable review of nonroutine sales, so the absence of that control indicates the misstatement would not have been prevented or timely detected. Management's subsequent adjustment does not eliminate the year-end material weakness in internal control.
Why not A: This is tempting because the financial statements were corrected, but severity is determined by the effectiveness of controls at year-end to prevent or timely detect and correct material misstatements, not by later corrections made after the auditor discovered the issue.
Why not B: Finding a misstatement via substantive procedures does not reduce its severity when the underlying controls are absent or ineffective; a material misstatement combined with controls that would not have timely prevented or detected it meets the material weakness threshold rather than merely a significant deficiency.
Why not C: While a prior-period restatement is a clear indicator of a material weakness, it is not required before classifying a current-year deficiency. The current-year facts (a material misstatement and the absence of an appropriate control) are sufficient to support a material weakness.
Common questions
When should an auditor evaluate whether a cutoff error indicates a control deficiency?
When the error is identified and suggests a control failure. Do not wait for management's decision about the adjustment.
Does correcting a misstatement before issuance eliminate a control deficiency?
No. Noll's adjustment corrects revenue, but it does not change the fact that the required cutoff review was not performed.
Can substantive testing reveal an internal control deficiency?
Yes. Noll's substantive cutoff testing reveals an error that its controls missed, prompting evaluation of the related control failure.
Watch it solved
A full CPA AUD task-based simulation on Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies, worked step by step.
Uncorrected Misstatements & Control Deficiencies | CPA AUD TBS on YouTube
Practice AUD like the real exam
The free ChatCPA simulator: real exam layout, timed testlets, starting with a question on this topic. No account needed to start.
Open the free simulator →More on Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies
All Misstatements and Internal Control Deficiencies practice →
Questions from the ChatCPA bank of 17,658 CPA exam questions, each with a written reason for every wrong answer. ChatCPA is built by Nicholas Miller, CPA (Oregon #14907). How these pages are made. Spot an error? Tell us.